To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-698)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Wendy Alexander Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
12 contributionsImmediately after First Minister's questions, I will attend a meeting of SEER, the Scottish Government's response unit, to ensure that all the consequences of the Grangemouth industrial action are considered so that the impact on the economy and people of Scotland is minimised.
I think that we will all welcome the statement that will be made in the chamber later this afternoon, after relevant meetings have taken place during the day.
Under the First Minister's Government, some people seem to matter more than others: the Trump Organization, Macdonald Hotels and Mr Brian Souter seem to have a special pass to the corridors of power. Is the First Minister running a special access Government?
Under the First Minister's Government, some people seem to matter more than others: the Trump Organization, Macdonald Hotels and Mr Brian Souter seem to have a special pass to the corridors of power. Is the First Minister running a special access Government?
It is not for me to determine the subject matter of the leader of the Opposition's questions, but just occasionally Wendy Alexander would be wise to rise to the event and occasion that is occupying the interest of the people of Scotland. Perhaps she will get to asking about the Grangemouth dispute in her fourth question, if she bothers to ask one today.
The people Wendy Alexander mentioned have no special access to the Government; the Government operates in the best interests of the Scottish people. In the speech that I made to the Scottish Trades Union Congress on Tuesday—a speech that I think was pretty well received—I could have mentioned that I have met the Scottish Trades Union Congress and its representatives on more occasions than I have met all the organisations that she mentioned put together.
The people Wendy Alexander mentioned have no special access to the Government; the Government operates in the best interests of the Scottish people. In the speech that I made to the Scottish Trades Union Congress on Tuesday—a speech that I think was pretty well received—I could have mentioned that I have met the Scottish Trades Union Congress and its representatives on more occasions than I have met all the organisations that she mentioned put together.
I am not surprised that the First Minister dodged the question. As he knows, the chamber will return to these matters this afternoon, but he has chosen not to speak.
New concerns emerge all the time about what is happening behind closed doors. The recent extension of the contract for the ScotRail franchise involves more than £800 million of taxpayers' money, yet the most basic levels of transparency, scrutiny and accountability were ignored, as was Audit Scotland. This is one of the largest contracts that the First Minister's Government will let, so does he now regret how it was done? Yes or no?
New concerns emerge all the time about what is happening behind closed doors. The recent extension of the contract for the ScotRail franchise involves more than £800 million of taxpayers' money, yet the most basic levels of transparency, scrutiny and accountability were ignored, as was Audit Scotland. This is one of the largest contracts that the First Minister's Government will let, so does he now regret how it was done? Yes or no?
I do not know whether Wendy Alexander was a member of the previous Administration when it negotiated the contract, within which was the means of extension. That extension clause was invoked. As she will be well aware, it was both price and market sensitive, and ministers acted on the basis of advice. I am certain that if they had not operated on the basis of advice, Wendy Alexander would have been the first to come to the chamber and find yet another thing to gripe about.
This week, John Swinney told the unions that he regrets how it was done, but it appears that the First Minister does not. What troubles people is that ministers' justification for the secrecy was that it was to protect FirstGroup's share price. The word that the First Minister just used was "price", but the term that he used last week was "share price".
I know that the First Minister is not a regular user of ScotRail services, as many of the rest of us are, but does he agree—[Interruption.]
I know that the First Minister is not a regular user of ScotRail services, as many of the rest of us are, but does he agree—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
—that the relevant consideration, when £800 million of taxpayers' money is at stake, is the service to passengers, not the return to shareholders?
Wendy Alexander might travel first class, but that wisnae a first-class question.
Does Wendy Alexander regret the clear passenger benefits that the additional £70 million of additional investment in Scotland's rail network will bring, the ability to cap profits and the ability to extend the franchise on much better terms, in the public interest, than those that were negotiated by the previous Administration? Did it ever occur to Wendy Alexander that if her colleagues had done their job when the contract was negotiated, there would have been no need to renegotiate the terms?
Does Wendy Alexander regret the clear passenger benefits that the additional £70 million of additional investment in Scotland's rail network will bring, the ability to cap profits and the ability to extend the franchise on much better terms, in the public interest, than those that were negotiated by the previous Administration? Did it ever occur to Wendy Alexander that if her colleagues had done their job when the contract was negotiated, there would have been no need to renegotiate the terms?
We are used to the First Minister going for the insult when all else fails. He knows that the extension of the franchise does not start until November 2011, which is after the next Scottish Parliament elections. Some £800 million of taxpayers' money has been handed over and still we have none of the data that would allow a proper assessment of whether that represents a good deal for the taxpayer. That brings us to the heart of the matter, which involves the unacceptability of the First Minister's cavalier attitude to government. Under his stewardship, we are getting used to the special access, the lack of data, the superficial consultations and the refusal to answer questions.
Scotland does not want a special access Government in which the First Minister is his own judge and jury. The proper mechanism for reviewing ministerial conduct is the ministerial code. It is a necessity for good government. Parliament had demanded a review of the code, which the behaviour of this Administration makes urgent. Why, then, one year after the First Minister came to office, are we still waiting for a review?
Scotland does not want a special access Government in which the First Minister is his own judge and jury. The proper mechanism for reviewing ministerial conduct is the ministerial code. It is a necessity for good government. Parliament had demanded a review of the code, which the behaviour of this Administration makes urgent. Why, then, one year after the First Minister came to office, are we still waiting for a review?
I was going to congratulate Wendy Alexander on getting to her fourth question, but, given the nature of it, I do not think that I will bother.
The ministerial code under which we are operating is the code that we inherited from our predecessor Administration. When, in the eight years in which Labour and the Liberal Democrats formed that Administration and Wendy Alexander was a member of the Scottish Parliament, did she make any suggestions about changes to the ministerial code? Not once.
When it comes to obeying terms of reference and codes of conduct, I think that my track record is a lot better than Wendy Alexander's.
The ministerial code under which we are operating is the code that we inherited from our predecessor Administration. When, in the eight years in which Labour and the Liberal Democrats formed that Administration and Wendy Alexander was a member of the Scottish Parliament, did she make any suggestions about changes to the ministerial code? Not once.
When it comes to obeying terms of reference and codes of conduct, I think that my track record is a lot better than Wendy Alexander's.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Apr 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 24 April 2008 Debate · 1
- National Qualifications Statement · 35
- International Education Debate · 50
- Scottish Ambulance Service Questions · 8
- Scottish Ambulance Service (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Private Rented Accommodation (Students and Young People) Questions · 6
- Hydro Power Questions · 6
- Criminal Justice System (Child Protection) Questions · 4
- Family Contact Centres (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Scottish Business in the Community (Funding) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Grangemouth Oil Refinery First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Student Hardship First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Energy Strategy First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Summer Time Questions · 11
- Zambia (Sustainable Development) Questions · 6
- Music and Drama Questions · 12
- Creative Scotland Questions · 8
- Cuba (Links) Questions · 5
- Community Music Festivals (Support) Questions · 4
- National Industrial Museums (Investment) Questions · 4
- Scots Language (Promotion) Questions · 6
- Education (Aberdeen) Questions · 8
- Local Government Concordat (Education) Questions · 5
- Modern Apprenticeships Questions · 7
- School Building Programme Questions · 6
- School Building Programme Questions · 8
- Primary School Teacher Places Questions · 8
- Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama (Reorganisation) Questions · 4
- Planning Application Processes (Menie Estate) Debate · 168
- Grangemouth Refinery (Industrial Action) Statement · 39
- Decision Time Decision time · 23
- Leven to Thornton Rail Link Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.