Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 13 March 2008 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 17 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-588)

I also welcome our visitors to the Parliament today and pass on the chamber's congratulations to Frank Hadden and the Scottish rugby team, following their Calcutta cup victory last Saturday. I look forward to seeing them later.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Later today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland. I will also meet Frank Hadden and will pass on everyone's congratulations.

I think that the chamber will want to join me in congratulating young Nathan Thomson who, at nine years old, intervened to protect his mother from a vicious assault and agree with the Solicitor General's remark that there should be an award for bravery for that exceptional young man.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link
I associate myself with the remarks that the First Minister has just made.

Two weeks ago, I asked the First Minister to publish his local income tax plans. Finally, the ever obliging Mr Swinney is shoved out to present the First Minister's flagship policy. The nat tax got an even worse reception than Thatcher's poll tax. [Laughter.]

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link
For the most basic of accountancy purposes, can the First Minister tell the chamber how much 1p on income tax would raise in the first year of the tax?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I can tell Wendy Alexander that 432,000 pensioners across Scotland will welcome the change in taxation.

I notice that Wendy Alexander said that this tax is unpopular. She is a professor at the University of Strathclyde, whose election survey showed that 88 per cent of people supported income tax based on the ability to pay and 12 per cent supported Labour's council tax rises. I think that that is a sign of popularity, and I hope that, at some point, Wendy Alexander will welcome the introduction of a fair tax based on the ability to pay.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link
Pre-rehearsed, pre-cooked. I asked a fair question—what does 1p on income tax raise in the first year? I will try another question, with the assistance of one of Scotland's top accountancy firms. Yesterday, I asked PricewaterhouseCoopers for its analysis of the Government's plans. It said that it was at a total loss to explain why the most basic numbers were missing from the document. How much council tax cash has to be replaced? Which year do the plans refer to? How much will 3p on income tax raise? What is the size of the resulting black hole and how might it be filled?

It is strange that, although this time last year, in its scramble for votes, the Scottish National Party was willing to answer all of those basic questions, none of those numbers appeared in this week's document.

Does the First Minister agree that he is duty bound to publish the basic numbers and then let the people of Scotland decide?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I saw Margaret Curran shaking her head again. I think that Wendy Alexander is in trouble. [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I can only imagine that the new consultation with PricewaterhouseCoopers means that Professor Arthur Midwinter is getting the sack. [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
What Wendy Alexander describes as a black hole is a £281 million tax cut for working families throughout Scotland, which, as she has said, represents less than 1 per cent of Scottish Government expenditure. She thinks that that sort of efficiency gain is easily affordable, as she told us in her famous hungry caterpillar speech. Will she at some point join me in acknowledging the fact that single pensioners, pensioner couples, couples with children and one-parent families will welcome a taxation system that is based on the ability to pay as opposed to Labour's regressive council tax? [Interruption.]

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link
If the First Minister's Government is unwilling to publish the basic numbers or even tell us which year is being talked about, any talk of winners or losers is simply meaningless. It is no accident that the basic numbers appear nowhere in the Government's document. Even worse than that, they are being denied to parliamentary officials. When the Scottish Parliament information centre asked the Government for details on how the money would be raised, it was told:

"the figure was deemed to be internal advice to ministers only."

Scotland deserves answers. In three years' time, the council tax will raise £2.5 billion. That means that there will be a 5p local income tax and a 25 per cent tax hike. Is it the case that, at a rate of 5p, a single person in an average house will start to lose at £23,000 and a couple will start to lose at £34,000?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Wendy Alexander has, unfortunately, forgotten the tax cut of £281 million. She also seems to support the United Kingdom Government's attempt to withhold Scotland's money by withholding its council tax rebate.

Wendy Alexander asked for detailed numbers. I will give her detailed numbers. Under the proposals, single pensioners will be better off by £7.30 a week; pensioner couples will be better off by £13.80 a week; couples without children will be better off by £3.40 a week; couples with children will be better off by £3.10 a week; one-parent families will be better off by £5.40 a week; and single people will be better off by £3.30 a week. That is why the proposals have been widely welcomed by people in society who are concerned that taxation should be based on people's ability to pay.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link
Attempts to talk about winners and losers are meaningless if the First Minister will not tell us which year the plans refer to, how much council tax cash has to be replaced and the size of the black hole. Of course everybody will pay less if there is a 40 per cent cut in the cash to local services, but that will not make everybody a winner. Three pence on income tax would lead to a huge hole in local finances. The truth is that families cannot afford what has been proposed, businesses do not want it, local government does not like it and—by the way—the rich will not even pay it. Is it not time that the First Minister admitted that he is trying to con the people of Scotland?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I tried to explain that a £281 million cut in taxation will be widely welcomed by the people of Scotland.

Let us take some quotations from the people to whom I listen—as opposed to Wendy Alexander's MSPs, who must accept that they will pay a bit more under an income tax, which is probably why they are so against it. The Child Poverty Action Group says:

"The poorest pay proportionately more tax than the rich. Regressive taxes include council tax … Government must ensure the burden of taxation is proportional to the ability to pay."

This morning, the Age Concern website commented on yesterday's budget announcement:

"Many pensioners will be disappointed that the government hasn't offered any help with their Council Tax bills. Council Tax should be replaced by a fairer system that reflects people's ability to pay."

Those groups, which are concerned about the poorest in society, are part of the 88 per cent of people who support the introduction of a local income tax. Wendy Alexander and her MSPs are part of the 12 per cent who want to hang on to the unfair council tax.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 13 March 2008 Debate · 1
  2. Borders Railway Debate · 81
  3. Fuel Poverty Debate · 62
  4. Mayfield Community Regeneration Project (Funding) Questions · 4
  5. Young People (Disabilities) Questions · 8
  6. Underage Drinking Questions · 8
  7. Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route Questions · 10
  8. Community Planning Partnerships (Housing and Regeneration) Questions · 4
  9. Rape and Sexual Assault Questions · 4
  10. Tourism (Scottish Borders) Questions · 5
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 17
  12. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  14. United Kingdom Budget (Scottish Industry) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  15. Smoking Cessation First Minister’s Questions · 6
  16. Local Government Services (Income Tax) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Schools (Deprived Areas) Questions · 8
  18. Advanced Highers (Access) Questions · 8
  19. Skills Development Scotland Questions · 4
  20. Class Size Reductions Questions · 8
  21. School Buildings (Access) Questions · 6
  22. Rural Primary Schools Questions · 4
  23. Gaelic Questions · 4
  24. Performing Arts Questions · 10
  25. Scotland's Reputation Questions · 9
  26. Lisbon Treaty Questions · 4
  27. The Lemon Tree Questions · 6
  28. National Theatre of Scotland Questions · 4
  29. National Parks Debate · 87
  30. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 6
  31. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  32. Decision Time Decision time · 71
  33. Iraq War Members’ business · 16

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.