To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-567)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Wendy Alexander Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
13 contributionsLater today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland. Can I say how delighted I am to be answering Wendy Alexander's questions, given that it appears that if her boss had had his way, she would have been asking questions of Annabel Goldie or Nicol Stephen?
We all saw the headlines this week about Scotland's booze and blade culture, and we all know that it is now even more uncomfortable to walk down the street on a Friday or a Saturday night—not just in the small hours but in the early evening. Does the First Minister agree that we need new approaches to tackle drink-fuelled violence in Scotland?
Yes, I do. That is why I am sure that Wendy Alexander will want to join me in congratulating the Cabinet Secretary for Justice on raising the issue so high on the public agenda and on introducing so many new initiatives.
I welcome what the First Minister has just said, but I have concerns about the mixed messages that are coming from the heart of his Government. Given the reality of drink-fuelled violence, is the First Minister on the side of his justice secretary, who said on the BBC's "Wasted Nation" that he wants to double the cost of drink, or is he on the side of his Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth, who told the weekend's papers that he wanted to cut it?
Wendy Alexander should probably acknowledge that when we talk about drink being cheaper than water, we are talking not about 10-year-old Glenmorangie being cheaper than water, but about high-strength cider and beer, and about the heavy discounting by supermarkets and retailers aimed at promoting a binge culture. I hope that, in her joint enthusiasm for tackling what is a real social problem in Scotland, Wendy Alexander is not suggesting that we continue the discrimination against one of Scotland's most famous exports—discrimination that might hamper us in terms of jobs and exports around the world.
There the First Minister goes again—no answer. It is time for a straight answer to a straight question. The finance minister is lobbying for a tax cut on all spirits. Like it or not, cutting tax means cutting the price of the vodka and alcopops that are causing much of the trouble on our streets. Meanwhile, the justice secretary wants to double the cost of alcohol. Which side of the bar is the First Minister on?
I am only responsible for the answers and not for Wendy Alexander's questions. If she had listened to my previous answer, she would know that I tried to make what I thought was a perfectly valid distinction, which would be well understood by the people of Scotland, between 10-year-old malt whisky and the cheap drink that is available in so many areas and that is causing us such great concern.
I do not know whether Wendy Alexander has been following the television programmes on the matter, because I remember seeing Pauline McNeill on "Newsnight" just last week, when she refused to say that she did not think that excise duty on whisky should be cut. Before Wendy Alexander asks the justice secretary or me about contradictions, she should ask her own MSPs.
I do not know whether Wendy Alexander has been following the television programmes on the matter, because I remember seeing Pauline McNeill on "Newsnight" just last week, when she refused to say that she did not think that excise duty on whisky should be cut. Before Wendy Alexander asks the justice secretary or me about contradictions, she should ask her own MSPs.
We have still not heard whether the First Minister is in favour of cutting the price of alcohol, as his finance minister suggests, or doubling it, as his justice secretary suggests. The First Minister knows full well that excise duty is also charged on vodka and alcopops and the like. We believe that the alcohol epidemic is too serious to play politics with.
Members
link
Oh!
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
Even the Scotch Whisky Association is arguing only for a tax freeze. However, the Scottish National Party is busy stoking up a budget battle and calling for a cut. Why is the Government more interested in starting fights with London than in stopping the fights on Scotland's streets?
Over the past 10 years, I have been delighted to work on a cross-party basis with members of Parliament who have been calling on Chancellors of the Exchequer for a cut—with considerable success—based on the recognition that one of Scotland's great industries should not be discriminated against by taxing the alcohol content of drink.
If we are to address deep discounting and the binge-drinking culture, surely we should support the justice secretary in bringing forward his key proposals for how Scotland can address the problem. I do not agree with Wendy Alexander that addressing the problem means continuing to discriminate, through the tax on alcohol content, against one of Scotland's great industries, and I do not think that many of her own members will seriously support that absurd position.
If we are to address deep discounting and the binge-drinking culture, surely we should support the justice secretary in bringing forward his key proposals for how Scotland can address the problem. I do not agree with Wendy Alexander that addressing the problem means continuing to discriminate, through the tax on alcohol content, against one of Scotland's great industries, and I do not think that many of her own members will seriously support that absurd position.
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Mar 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 6 March 2008 Debate · 1
- State Hospital (Redevelopment) Statement · 23
- Rape and Sexual Offences Debate · 37
- Midwife-led Maternity Units Questions · 6
- Delayed Discharge Questions · 4
- Inequalities Questions · 9
- Free Nursery Places Questions · 6
- Wick High School Questions · 13
- Oil and Gas Exploration (Moray Firth) Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Firearms Legislation First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Domestic Violence First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Airports First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Economic Development (Borders) Questions · 10
- Young People (Education and Training) Questions · 4
- Tidal Energy (Pentland Firth) Questions · 11
- Road Equivalent Tariff (Mull and Islay) Questions · 17
- Scottish Enterprise (Meetings) Questions · 12
- Clyde Fastlink Questions · 4
- Sheriffhall Junction Questions · 10
- visitscotland.com Questions · 4
- Council Tax Freeze Questions · 4
- Economic Growth (Slowdown) Questions · 4
- Offenders (Rehabilitation) Questions · 4
- Rural Policy Debate · 52
- Public Appointments (Draft Equalities Strategy) Debate · 12
- Decision Time Decision time · 27
- Eating Disorders Members’ business · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.