To ask the First Minister what information the Scottish Government has concerning the possible use of Scottish airports as staging posts for rendition flights. (S3F-547)
Official Report · Chamber
Rendition Flights
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Ian McKee SNP 3
- Alex Fergusson 1
- Robin Harper Green 1
- Robert Brown LD 1
- John Scott Con 1
The record
12 contributionsThe information that we have was supplied by civil liberty groups and it has been passed to Strathclyde Police. The Scottish Government is strongly opposed to rendition flights, and the people of Scotland are entitled to know whether a Scottish airport has ever been used for such activities.
The announcement last week by the Foreign Secretary relates only to Diego Garcia, and the information held by the United Kingdom Government does not indicate that any rendition flights have used Scottish airports. Obviously, we are now deeply concerned about the reliability of the assurances that previously were received from the United States authorities.
It is a matter of regret that the UK Government did not see fit to forewarn the Scottish Government prior to the Foreign Secretary's statement in the House of Commons. Accordingly, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice has written to the Foreign Secretary to express our concerns and to seek confirmation that Scotland will be covered by the further assurances that are to be sought from the US authorities about past practice and, even more important, a guarantee from the Government that it will be made crystal clear that Scottish airports should not and cannot be used for rendition flights.
The announcement last week by the Foreign Secretary relates only to Diego Garcia, and the information held by the United Kingdom Government does not indicate that any rendition flights have used Scottish airports. Obviously, we are now deeply concerned about the reliability of the assurances that previously were received from the United States authorities.
It is a matter of regret that the UK Government did not see fit to forewarn the Scottish Government prior to the Foreign Secretary's statement in the House of Commons. Accordingly, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice has written to the Foreign Secretary to express our concerns and to seek confirmation that Scotland will be covered by the further assurances that are to be sought from the US authorities about past practice and, even more important, a guarantee from the Government that it will be made crystal clear that Scottish airports should not and cannot be used for rendition flights.
I am sure that the First Minister will agree that there are strong bonds of friendship and respect between the United States of America and Scotland. Indeed, almost half the signatories to the declaration of independence were of Scottish ancestry and two were graduates of Edinburgh medical school. However, does the First Minister agree that the statement by UK Foreign Secretary David Miliband in the House of Commons on 21 February that, contrary to earlier assurances, the US has used British territory for rendition flights is of deep concern? Aviation policy is a reserved matter, but justice is not.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Briefly please, Dr McKee.
Rendition is illegal under international law. Will the First Minister take firm measures to follow the issue up?
There can be no country in the world that has a warmer relationship with the United States than Ireland, but the Irish Government has banned rendition flights from using any Irish airport. I suggest that we have the same, correct attitude in Scotland.
Civil aviation is a reserved matter, as is the information that United States authorities give to the Foreign Secretary. However, if an individual was unlawfully transitted through Scotland to facilitate torture, that would constitute a crime under Scots law. It would be for the police to investigate any such allegations and to report the results of their investigation to the procurator fiscal.
Civil aviation is a reserved matter, as is the information that United States authorities give to the Foreign Secretary. However, if an individual was unlawfully transitted through Scotland to facilitate torture, that would constitute a crime under Scots law. It would be for the police to investigate any such allegations and to report the results of their investigation to the procurator fiscal.
I hope that the First Minister has been furnished by Amnesty International with the details of three aircraft that are known to be possibly associated with the Central Intelligence Agency and which between them have made 87 stops in Scottish airports. Will the First Minister seek specific assurances that those three aircraft have not been and will not be used for rendition flights?
The Cabinet Secretary for Justice is seeking such assurances from the Foreign Secretary. The cabinet secretary met civil liberties groups, including Amnesty International, in August 2007. Following that, information from the groups was submitted to the Crown Office for consideration of whether there was sufficient evidence to justify criminal proceedings. The information was subsequently passed to Strathclyde Police, where it is still under consideration. All members should have confidence in the criminal authorities in Scotland when they have the opportunity to investigate cases.
Does the First Minister agree that the possible use of Scottish airports for rendition flights has caused considerable disquiet and outrage across Scotland? Given the highly political nature of the issue, the independence of the Scottish prosecution system and, indeed, the operational independence of chief constables, is the First Minister in a position to raise with the Lord Advocate the possibility of her appointing an independent investigator—perhaps a senior or retired procurator fiscal—to examine the allegations, the information that is available and the evidence of the possible use of Prestwick or other airports for illegal purposes in connection with rendition flights, and to report back to her? Does the First Minister agree that the extraordinary background to the matter might require extraordinary measures to be taken to address the public's concern?
I agree about the general public concern.
There is a missing link in this matter, which is that we need to have positive and comprehensive assurances in response to the various allegations that have been made. That is why the Cabinet Secretary for Justice has written to the Foreign Secretary, following on from the fact that the Foreign Secretary had to accept that information that he had given to the House of Commons was not correct.
On the provision of strong information to show that the allegations are not substantiated, we should have confidence in the processes of the Scottish judicial system. Following the meeting in August 2007, exactly the right thing was done. The information that was supplied by the various groups was submitted to the Crown Office and passed to Strathclyde Police, where it is still under consideration. We should have confidence in the processes of Scottish law and Scottish justice.
There is a missing link in this matter, which is that we need to have positive and comprehensive assurances in response to the various allegations that have been made. That is why the Cabinet Secretary for Justice has written to the Foreign Secretary, following on from the fact that the Foreign Secretary had to accept that information that he had given to the House of Commons was not correct.
On the provision of strong information to show that the allegations are not substantiated, we should have confidence in the processes of the Scottish judicial system. Following the meeting in August 2007, exactly the right thing was done. The information that was supplied by the various groups was submitted to the Crown Office and passed to Strathclyde Police, where it is still under consideration. We should have confidence in the processes of Scottish law and Scottish justice.
The First Minister will be aware of my interest in Prestwick airport. Can he assure Parliament that the Government will take all necessary steps to ensure that, whatever might or might not have happened in the past, Prestwick is not used for rendition flights in future? Further, will he outline what specific measures he can take to ensure that that happens?
I refer John Scott to the answer that I gave to Ian McKee. In the information that we are seeking from the Foreign Secretary, we are dealing with the past, in terms of looking for information and explicit denials from the United States Government, but even more important we are also asking that it be made crystal clear that Scottish airports, including Prestwick, cannot be used for this illegal activity.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Feb 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 28 February 2008 Debate · 1
- Improving Accountability Debate · 92
- Protecting Scotland's Children Debate · 50
- Voluntary Sector (Partnership Working) Questions · 10
- Blind and Partially Sighted People Questions · 4
- Sure Start Questions · 6
- National Concessionary Travel Scheme Questions · 6
- Alcohol Support Services (Designated Place) Questions · 4
- Domestic Energy Consumption Questions · 6
- Biodiesel Plant (Grangemouth) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Rendition Flights First Minister’s Questions · 12
- DNA Retention First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Planning System First Minister’s Questions · 10
- European Regional Development Funding 2007-2013 Questions · 6
- Food Supplies Questions · 8
- Scottish Rural Development Programme (Agri-environment Schemes) Questions · 6
- Biodiversity (West of Scotland) Questions · 4
- Food (Affordability and Accessibility) Questions · 6
- Energy-from-waste Plants Questions · 6
- Zero Waste Fund Questions · 4
- Strathclyde Police Questions · 10
- Police Pensions Questions · 4
- Sentencing (Non-violent Offenders) Questions · 6
- Clear-up Fund Questions · 5
- Prisons (Drugs) Questions · 4
- Designated Places (Police Support) Questions · 4
- Safety (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- Business Motion Business motions · 3
- Graduate Endowment Abolition (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 22
- Graduate Endowment Abolition (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 180
- Business Motion Business motions · 9
- Decision Time Decision time · 72
- Rural Schools (Closure) Members’ business · 25
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.