To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-427)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Wendy Alexander Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Alex Fergusson 3
The record
16 contributionsLater today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
Before coming to my substantive question, I begin by offering the First Minister the opportunity to comment to Parliament on the way in which his Government handled the sackings of Julia Bracewell and Dougie Donnelly this week.
Will the First Minister also tell us why his Government is delaying new youth courts in Dundee, Kilmarnock and Paisley when the evaluation of an existing youth court concluded:
"With its fast track procedures and additional resources it was regarded as a model to be aspired to in all summary court business"?
Youth courts have a proven record in taking young people causing chaos in our communities off the streets within a few days. Why is the First Minister denying the same protection to other communities across Scotland?
Will the First Minister also tell us why his Government is delaying new youth courts in Dundee, Kilmarnock and Paisley when the evaluation of an existing youth court concluded:
"With its fast track procedures and additional resources it was regarded as a model to be aspired to in all summary court business"?
Youth courts have a proven record in taking young people causing chaos in our communities off the streets within a few days. Why is the First Minister denying the same protection to other communities across Scotland?
As Wendy Alexander might remember, the previous Executive decided that there should be a review of the youth courts system, which I think has broad support and certainly has plenty of anecdotal evidence in its favour. The position was to be reviewed in spring next year in the light of the impact of the summary justice reforms. It is entirely sensible to follow that approach and then to consider the roll-out of further youth courts in the light of that review.
On her first question, given that we are establishing one body in charge of developing sport in Scotland, with one board and one chair, it is entirely understandable that the chairs of the two current bodies should stand down so that a new chair can be appointed.
On her first question, given that we are establishing one body in charge of developing sport in Scotland, with one board and one chair, it is entirely understandable that the chairs of the two current bodies should stand down so that a new chair can be appointed.
The previous Executive decided to open three more youth courts. There were no ifs or buts from Scottish National Party members when they saw the results of youth courts. Mr Kenny Gibson wanted a youth court in Ayrshire and Ms Sandra White wanted one in Glasgow. They were supported by 15 of the First Minister's colleagues, including Mr Neil, Ms Cunningham and two members who are now ministers—Mr Maxwell and Mr Mather. Have they all changed their minds overnight?
Youth courts are not the only issue on which there are concerns about the SNP failing to protect the public. This week, the SNP opposed an amendment to the budget to guarantee an additional 1,000 police officers on Scotland's streets. This week, Grampian Police also had to plunder its budget to meet the looming crisis in police pensions. What assurances will the First Minister offer to communities across Scotland that they will not lose police from their streets in order to fund the pensions shortfall?
Youth courts are not the only issue on which there are concerns about the SNP failing to protect the public. This week, the SNP opposed an amendment to the budget to guarantee an additional 1,000 police officers on Scotland's streets. This week, Grampian Police also had to plunder its budget to meet the looming crisis in police pensions. What assurances will the First Minister offer to communities across Scotland that they will not lose police from their streets in order to fund the pensions shortfall?
Given that at the election Wendy Alexander's party proposed no extra police officers in Scotland, I suppose that we should welcome that substantial conversion. I point the member to the Audit Scotland report that was published last year, which argued that the Government needed
"to develop an understanding of the cost-effectiveness of different service interventions to address the offending behaviour of young people".
Although the report was published in the autumn, Audit Scotland was reviewing the progress of the previous Executive.
It is entirely sensible for us to review the position, as was intended, in the spring of 2009, in the light of the summary justice reforms that have been introduced, so that roll-out of youth courts—which enjoy broad support—across the country can be considered. We are following the precepts of Audit Scotland in that matter and conducting the review that was planned by the previous Executive.
We now know the cost-effectiveness that the Labour Party intends for the people of Scotland. From the Finance Committee, we know the budgets that Labour intended to cut in order to finance the things that Wendy Alexander talks about at First Minister's question time: we know that it wanted to cut spending on road safety; we know that it wanted to stop work on the M8, the M80 and the M74; and we know that it wanted to cut road gritting and clearing—the winter maintenance budget. I repeat: Labour wanted to cut the winter maintenance budget. We know that it also wanted to cut the budget of the Scottish Crime and Drug Enforcement Agency and cut support for anti-terrorism measures. Given the list of cuts that the Labour Party took to the Finance Committee, is it surprising that it got the support of no other party in Parliament?
"to develop an understanding of the cost-effectiveness of different service interventions to address the offending behaviour of young people".
Although the report was published in the autumn, Audit Scotland was reviewing the progress of the previous Executive.
It is entirely sensible for us to review the position, as was intended, in the spring of 2009, in the light of the summary justice reforms that have been introduced, so that roll-out of youth courts—which enjoy broad support—across the country can be considered. We are following the precepts of Audit Scotland in that matter and conducting the review that was planned by the previous Executive.
We now know the cost-effectiveness that the Labour Party intends for the people of Scotland. From the Finance Committee, we know the budgets that Labour intended to cut in order to finance the things that Wendy Alexander talks about at First Minister's question time: we know that it wanted to cut spending on road safety; we know that it wanted to stop work on the M8, the M80 and the M74; and we know that it wanted to cut road gritting and clearing—the winter maintenance budget. I repeat: Labour wanted to cut the winter maintenance budget. We know that it also wanted to cut the budget of the Scottish Crime and Drug Enforcement Agency and cut support for anti-terrorism measures. Given the list of cuts that the Labour Party took to the Finance Committee, is it surprising that it got the support of no other party in Parliament?
Let me deal with the two factual points that preceded that rant. Labour created not 500 or 1,000 new police officers, but 1,500, as the First Minister well knows. He also knows full well that Audit Scotland did not evaluate youth courts in its review of youth justice.
The country knows that the constitutional purpose of First Minister's question time is for the First Minister to account for his decisions and not simply to rant. Let me use it for the purpose for which it was intended.
A week ago, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice told Parliament that in Grampian an additional 230 police officers would be recruited by 2009. How does that square with the view of the convener of Grampian police authority, who said that
"money which should be spent on policing in the Grampian area will have to be spent on police pensions"?
The question is clear: will the Cabinet Secretary for Justice's guarantee on police numbers in Grampian be met or not?
The country knows that the constitutional purpose of First Minister's question time is for the First Minister to account for his decisions and not simply to rant. Let me use it for the purpose for which it was intended.
A week ago, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice told Parliament that in Grampian an additional 230 police officers would be recruited by 2009. How does that square with the view of the convener of Grampian police authority, who said that
"money which should be spent on policing in the Grampian area will have to be spent on police pensions"?
The question is clear: will the Cabinet Secretary for Justice's guarantee on police numbers in Grampian be met or not?
Wendy Alexander should extend her reading. The latest information on Grampian police numbers is set out in an article of 9 January in The Press and Journal, which is headed "Boost to give north-east ‘record level' of officers". [Interruption.] I hear the comment that that is not what Martin Greig said. Unfortunately, the article goes on to say:
"Councillor Martin Greig last night welcomed the extra resources, which he said will see an additional 60 officers join the force during the next financial year".
Martin Greig continued:
"We are definitely moving in the right direction".
He also said:
"It is good to see we are well on course to reaching record levels of officers."
In the most recent article on the subject, Martin Greig said that Grampian is on track to have an unprecedented number of officers. Given that he is the very person whom Wendy Alexander mentioned, perhaps I should offer her a subscription to The Press and Journal of Aberdeen.
"Councillor Martin Greig last night welcomed the extra resources, which he said will see an additional 60 officers join the force during the next financial year".
Martin Greig continued:
"We are definitely moving in the right direction".
He also said:
"It is good to see we are well on course to reaching record levels of officers."
In the most recent article on the subject, Martin Greig said that Grampian is on track to have an unprecedented number of officers. Given that he is the very person whom Wendy Alexander mentioned, perhaps I should offer her a subscription to The Press and Journal of Aberdeen.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Ms Alexander, your final question.
The First Minister knows well that there has been a rise in police budgets, which we welcome. However, he also knows that police budgets all over Scotland are being plundered to deal with the pensions shortfall that is forecast.
Let me make this very simple for all of us. Will the First Minister undertake to publish the best estimates of the police pensions bill for the next three years, so that forces can plan ahead and deal with the pensions hole, which has been forecast to be as much as £50 million next year? Will he reassure communities throughout Scotland that he will publish that estimate and that the pensions crisis will not be paid for out of operational police budgets, or will he simply admit that when the rhetoric is put to one side, we will not have the reality of the numbers on the police pensions crisis?
Let me make this very simple for all of us. Will the First Minister undertake to publish the best estimates of the police pensions bill for the next three years, so that forces can plan ahead and deal with the pensions hole, which has been forecast to be as much as £50 million next year? Will he reassure communities throughout Scotland that he will publish that estimate and that the pensions crisis will not be paid for out of operational police budgets, or will he simply admit that when the rhetoric is put to one side, we will not have the reality of the numbers on the police pensions crisis?
The crisis that Wendy Alexander describes might have been developing over the past eight years while the Labour Party was in government. The figures that she asks for are already with the police boards and local authorities, and discussions are under way on how we can address the pensions issue, which has built up over a substantial period.
The difference between this Government and the previous Executive in addressing such issues lies in the historic concordat between local and national Government in Scotland. I see that a number of Labour group leaders have joined the ring-fence rebellion: David O'Neill of North Ayrshire, Kevin Keenan of Dundee, Jim McCabe of North Lanarkshire and Eddie McAvoy of South Lanarkshire. Given the support of local authorities for financial flexibility and the end of ring fencing, what did Wendy Alexander do to face down that rebellion? She gave an interview at the weekend, in which she said:
"Well, I think there should be a big reduction in ring-fencing … I am all in favour of local discretion … I think lots of the changes are a good idea … I do think we need to give people discretion to make the right decisions locally."
Wendy—welcome to the big tent against ring fencing.
The difference between this Government and the previous Executive in addressing such issues lies in the historic concordat between local and national Government in Scotland. I see that a number of Labour group leaders have joined the ring-fence rebellion: David O'Neill of North Ayrshire, Kevin Keenan of Dundee, Jim McCabe of North Lanarkshire and Eddie McAvoy of South Lanarkshire. Given the support of local authorities for financial flexibility and the end of ring fencing, what did Wendy Alexander do to face down that rebellion? She gave an interview at the weekend, in which she said:
"Well, I think there should be a big reduction in ring-fencing … I am all in favour of local discretion … I think lots of the changes are a good idea … I do think we need to give people discretion to make the right decisions locally."
Wendy—welcome to the big tent against ring fencing.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
A final question from Ms Alexander.
Members
link
No!
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. It is totally within order to offer a final question to Ms Alexander.
For the third time, I ask the First Minister whether he will publish the best estimates of the police pensions bill for the next three years. Yes or no?
If Wendy Alexander had not started on sportscotland, she would have had more opportunity to produce police numbers. We are in discussions with local authorities and police boards. Because of the new historic concordat and our new relationship with local authorities, we intend to deal with such difficult issues, as the previous Executive singularly failed to do.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Jan 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 17 January 2008 Debate · 1
- Energy Debate · 67
- Burns Night Questions · 10
- A77 (Symington and Bogend Toll) Questions · 4
- Glasgow City Council (Discussions) Questions · 4
- Council Tax Freeze Questions · 4
- Tourism (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 9
- Village Halls Questions · 6
- Train Services (Europe) Questions · 6
- Scottish Literature (Reclassification) Questions · 5
- Scottish Parliament Elections Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Locally Sourced Food First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Organ Donation First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Nuclear Power (Job Losses) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Healthy Living Centres (Remote and Islands Communities) Questions · 7
- National Health Service (Fire Safety) Questions · 4
- NHS Fife (Meetings) Questions · 18
- Children's Cancer Services (Aberdeen) Questions · 8
- Obesity Questions · 9
- National Health Service (Low-paid Workers) Questions · 10
- Glasgow Housing Association Questions · 6
- Older People (Lifestyles) Questions · 6
- Policy Priorities Questions · 4
- Norovirus Questions · 4
- Firearms Debate · 78
- Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill Bill debate · 30
- Presiding Officer's Ruling Procedure · 29
- Decision Time Decision time · 45
- Defence Aviation Repair Agency (Almondbank) Members’ business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.