Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Additional Support for Learning (Co-ordinated Support Plan) (Scotland) Regulations 2005 (SSI 2005/266) Additional Support for Learning (Publication of Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2005 (SSI 2005/267)

Wednesday 1 June 2005 Education Committee Subordinate legislation 74 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

74 contributions
Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Item 2 is consideration of four sets of regulations under the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004, which is a piece of legislation that the committee considered last year.The purposes of the instruments, which are subject to the negative procedure, are to specify a period within which a request for help by an education authority from an appropriate agency must be complied with; to make provision for education authorities to take action in connection with changes that occur in the school education of children and young people with additional support needs; to make provision in respect of the co-ordinated support plan; and to add to the information to be published by education authorities, to set timescales for publication and to prescribe the form and manner of publication.I am pleased to welcome from the Scottish Executive Robin McKendrick, the team leader of the additional support for learning division; Shona Pittilo, the policy officer in the additional support for learning division; and Louise Donnelly, a solicitor with Legal and Parliamentary Services. Would Mr McKendrick like to make some introductory comments? We will take all the regulations together.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

I will take the Additional Support for Learning (Appropriate Agency Request Period and Exceptions) (Scotland) Regulations 2005 first. The instrument applies only when the education authority requests help from an appropriate agency under section 23(1) of the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004. That is definite. Also, the instrument does not list the appropriate agencies that are covered. Those will be included in a separate order made under section 23(2)(c) of the act, which will be laid in due course.The focus of the instrument is to set the request period and the exceptions to that period. It is worth pointing out that we started out by suggesting that appropriate agencies should have a six-week window in which to respond to requests. However, during our consultation exercise, many of the agencies stated that that period was not long enough and was too tight. Therefore, we have increased the period that appropriate agencies have to respond to a request from six to 10 weeks. I emphasise that the clock starts ticking when the request is made—when it is communicated to the appropriate agency. There is no requirement in the regulations that the request be signed, because requests might be made by e-mail or at a videoconference. The important thing is that the request should be in a form that is capable of being used for subsequent reference. The regulations also cover exceptions to the period. If an appropriate agency becomes aware that it will not be able to meet the 10-week deadline, it must inform the education authority that alternative provision will have to be made. To safeguard children with additional support needs, the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004 makes provision, subject to certain definitions, for certain actions to be taken when there is or is likely to be a specified change in a child's school education. The Additional Support for Learning (Changes in School Education) (Scotland) Regulations 2005 define what those changes are. They apply to a child starting pre-school education, primary education or secondary education, to transfers from one school to another and to other situations involving school closures or exclusions. To ensure that changes happen as smoothly as possible, education authorities will require to have in place appropriate arrangements for all children, not just those with additional support needs. To ensure that the arrangements are appropriate for a child or young person who has additional support needs, the regulations specify the action that an education authority must take at various transition points in the school career of that child or young person. When authorities consider it appropriate, they should involve other agencies to ensure that the transition is as effective as possible. A number of issues arise. It was thought that 12 months was an appropriate period in which to arrange for a move from primary school to secondary school. However, in relation to children entering pre-school education, the consultation suggested to us that the timescale should be changed and, given the rapid development of children at that age, a six-month timescale was judged to be more appropriate. I stress that, if the education authority considers it appropriate to seek relevant advice and information from an appropriate agency or another person, it is also required to take account of the views of the child and their parents or of the young person when making arrangements, before the change takes place.The regulations require education authorities, within specified periods, to consider which agencies might require information to make arrangements to meet the additional support needs of a child prior to a change in their school education. Once identified, the education authority must provide such information with a minimum of six months' notice. The period of six months applies in all cases apart from when a child is entering pre-school education, when the consultation suggested that a three-month period would be more appropriate. Again, that is because of the rapid development of children at that age. I turn now to the Additional Support for Learning (Co-ordinated Support Plan) (Scotland) Regulations 2005. As the committee will be aware, the co-ordinated support plan is a statutory strategic planning document, which will be subject to regular monitoring and review for those children and young people who meet the criteria set out under section 2 of the 2004 act. Section 9(2) of the act sets out certain information that a CSP must contain, but under section 11(8), we are allowed to develop the criteria. Therefore, the regulations prescribe the form and content of the co-ordinated support plan, the time limits that must be complied with when preparing and reviewing the plan, the exceptions to those limits and provisions in connection with the keeping, transfer, disclosure and discontinuance of the plan. The additional information that a CSP will now have to contain as a result of the regulations includes the biographical and contact details of the child or young person, the contact details of the parents or of the adults who have responsibility for the child, the pupil profile, the comments of the parent, child or young person on any aspects of the plan and a review timetable. The schedule, which is on page 8 of the regulations, sets out what the co-ordinated support plan should look like. I stress that the template is the result of extensive consultation by our development officers with front-line professionals, who think that it is a reasonable way to set out a co-ordinated support plan. The code of practice provides further information about the content of the plan and about the detail of the regulations. Separate guidance will be produced on how to complete a plan. That will operate in conjunction with the training materials that will be available shortly. I undertake to copy any information that the committee wants to receive. Indeed, we would be happy to provide training for the committee. I do not intend to go through the details under all the main headings in the regulations, but I will say that provision is made for the time limit for preparation of the plan, the time limit for the review of the plan, time limit exceptions, arrangements for keeping the plan, the transfer of the plan between authorities, the disclosure of the plan and the discontinuance, retention or destruction of the plan. The committee might be interested to know that we are currently developing an electronic version of the co-ordinated support plan. A feasibility study that was carried out towards the end of last year concluded that it would be possible to run with the idea and we have created a working group to examine the concept.The Subordinate Legislation Committee had some questions about the drafting of regulation 5. We found those comments helpful and have undertaken to come back with an amendment to the regulation prior to the commencement of the legislation on 14 November.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is an unusual thing to do. Will it not get a bit confusing if a regulation is followed by an amendment? Is that a satisfactory and transparent way of handling the problem?

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

The Subordinate Legislation Committee was quite content with that procedure.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. We might come back to that later.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Last, but by no means least, we have the Additional Support for Learning (Publication of Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2005. The 2004 act specifies that education authorities must publish information about the range of matters that are specified in the act at section 26(2).During the consultation exercise on the code of practice and the regulations, we asked what else it might be useful for education authorities to publish. As a result, we are now adding to the list of issues in the act and are amending section 26(2) of the act to the effect that there is now a requirement to provide details of any health board for the education authority area, or any part of it, where advice, information and support can be obtained. That change recognises the important role that health boards can play in the provision of information, advice and support. Further, there will now be a requirement to provide details of any other person who the education authority thinks appropriate from whom parents and so on can get advice, information and support, including support for advocacy. That is in recognition of the important role that voluntary organisations can play in supporting parents, providing advocacy and so on. Education authorities must publish that information within three months of the commencement of section 26 of the act. It must be available free of charge either at the authority's headquarters or at public libraries. It must also be available in electronic form, for example, on the authority's website. It must also be made available free of charge to such other persons as might reasonably require it. If the parents of a child with additional support needs were moving from one authority to another, it would be reasonable for them to ask what the authority's policies were and to access the information that could be provided. It would also be reasonable for a researcher to be able to access the information free of charge in any form that would be considered to be reasonable. The act stipulates at section 26(1) that authorities must keep that information up to date and under review. I can confirm that Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education's review of the implementation of the act will also examine that issue to ensure that, in the early stages, authorities are keeping that information as up to date and relevant as possible.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

For clarity, we will now deal with the regulations separately, starting with the Additional Support for Learning (Appropriate Agency Request Period and Exceptions) (Scotland) Regulations 2005. Regulation 3 concerns exceptions and paragraph (1)(a)(i) talks about a situation in which a process of assessment "cannot take place". That seems quite stark and I wonder whether there is any definition of what "cannot" means in those circumstances.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

There are a number of reasons why an assessment could not take place. For example, the parents of the child might not turn up for the interview—that would be the principal reason. Alternatively, the agency might not have received information that it has requested from another agency.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I think that the principal reason is covered by regulation 3(1)(b). I share the convener's concern about regulation 3(1)(a)(i). I suspect that in effect what it means is that if an assessment by a health professional was needed but could not be provided because of staff shortages, for example, the request period could be extended. One of parents' key concerns is that any delay will be due not necessarily to the request for help and support but because they have to get an assessment from another authority. There are shortages all over the place so, regardless of everything in the act, if professional support was needed, that one line in regulation 3(1)(a)(i) could provide a get-out from providing a co-ordinated support plan.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

That said, regulation 3(2)(a) says: "The appropriate agency must, when it becomes aware that the time limit under regulation 2 cannot be met, inform the education authority which made the request of-(a) the reason why the time limit cannot be complied with; and(b) a new date",which "in any event must be not later than 16 weeks starting on the date when the request was made by the authority."We are talking about only a slight extension. There is still a back-stop at 16 weeks.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I take the point about the 16 weeks, but that is quite a long time. The practical issue is whether the regulation will be used to provide an automatic exemption. I am conscious of what often happens in court procedures, in which exemptions can become the norm rather than the exception. I cannot remember whether there is anything in the guidance or elsewhere about a push towards 10 weeks, not 16 weeks, being the norm.

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

The code of practice makes it clear that there is an expectation that education authorities and other appropriate agencies will meet requests for help or assessment—or whatever the request is—within the 10-week timescale. However, it is recognised that there will be situations in which that is not possible. Perhaps an assessment cannot take place because a therapist is not available, possibly due to staff shortages. However, as soon as the appropriate agency becomes aware that the 10-week timescale cannot be complied with—for whatever reason—it must notify the education authority of that, with the reasons, then set a new date. As Robin McKendrick said, the regulations make it clear that that new date cannot extend beyond a further six weeks.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Will that be monitored in some way?

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

That would be part of the HMIE review. If authorities are making requests for help and those requests are not being met within the timescale, that would have to be considered. Originally, as Robin McKendrick said in the introduction, the timescale was six weeks. You commented that 16 weeks is quite a long time. It was extended mainly because of concerns from the Health Department that it would find a six-week limit difficult to meet, partly because of shortages and so on. Where a child is already known to the service, it would be possible, but where a child was new to it, the department felt that longer would be needed, so the timescale was extended to 10 weeks, and then to 16 weeks, to take account of those more exceptional circumstances in which a child is coming new to a service and requires a more in-depth assessment, because information is not already there to help to draw conclusions.

link

I can perfectly understand the reasons for the extension, but I wonder why the timescale has been extended so much, from six weeks to 10, then from 10 to 16. The extension seems considerable. Might a lesser figure have been more appropriate?

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Initially, the period was shorter, but we had to take account of the concerns that were raised in the consultation, not just from those in health but from those in social work, who felt that if the timescale could not be met, they would be led into unnecessary disputes.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

The judgment was born of the results of our consultation. If a request cannot be met because of the reasons that have been pointed out, such as a staff shortage, would it be possible to address that problem in one, two or three weeks? The regulations state that it is reasonable for an agency to be able to carry out any review and respond to the education authority in 16 weeks. That is a final limit past which the process cannot go.We have listened to what respondents to our consultation said in their written responses. Some wanted to go back to 20 weeks and 24 weeks, but we think that we are on reasonable ground by saying 10 weeks and, where there is a problem with that, 16 weeks, although, as Shona Pittilo pointed out, we say in the code of practice that that is an exception.

link

Obviously it is a question of balance and judgment but, if in the light of experience it is found that 16 weeks is longer than is strictly necessary, will you amend the regulations?

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

As the minister made clear when he spoke to the committee about the code of practice last week, nothing is written in tablets of stone. We will examine all aspects of the act and the code and, if we believe that we can safely develop anything that is in the regulations, we will certainly do that when we have sufficient information on which to base a judgment.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

Under regulation 3(2), an agency that cannot carry out an assessment must make the education authority aware that the time limit has been broken. What provision has been made for the recording of the timescale and the delay in assessment? If HMIE is going to monitor that, it will have to have that information. What provision has been made to ensure that a record is made of the fact that a request was made at a certain time, that it was not complied with for whatever reason and that measures are being taken to ensure that it is complied with within the extended timescale?

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

The act and the regulations make it clear that any request that is made under the act must be made in a form that is capable of being used for subsequent reference. They do so without being specific about how the request should be made—for example, it could be made in writing, by e-mail or by video—but the fact that we say that the request must be capable of being used for subsequent reference means that it is a matter of fact that the communication took place on a certain date. Therefore, as I said in my introduction, the clock starts ticking on that date and, in any review of a specific case, HMIE would be able to refer to that date as the date on which an authority asked an appropriate agency to comply with a request that had been made under section 23(1) of the act.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

For many children with additional support needs, the clock actually starts ticking when the parents ask the education authorities for an assessment, which could include an assessment by a health professional. The problem is that the legislation means that the official clock starts ticking only when the education authority makes the request. We have still to report on the code of practice, on which we took evidence last week, but some evidence that we have had on it suggests that the clock should start to tick when parents ask for the assessment. My concern is that an education authority could end up delaying making a request to a health authority until it knows that the request can be complied with. Perhaps, if we have concerns about the timescale and we want HMIE to track how long it takes for a request to be complied with but accept the timescales that are in the regulations, the code of practice needs to be amended to include reference to the point at which parents request the involvement of health professionals. That might be a more effective way of monitoring progress and reflecting the reality that, for the child, the clock often starts ticking not when the education authority asks for the health assessment, but when the family asks for it.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

It is reasonable that the code of practice should make those matters absolutely clear.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will leave those regulations for the moment and come back to what we want to do about them later. The second set of regulations is the Additional Support for Learning (Changes in School Education) (Scotland) Regulations 2005. I have a question about what happens when a school closes with the result that people make a transition. How do the regulations relate to general regulations on school closures? Are they interrelated?

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

The regulations set no relationship. I used a school's closure as an example of when the regulations would kick in. If a school were to close, an education authority would have to take action more than 12 months before that happened or as soon as possible if the closure were less than 12 months away. Nothing in the instrument contradicts or clashes with anything in other regulations.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The third instrument is the Additional Support for Learning (Co-ordinated Support Plan) (Scotland) Regulations 2005, which has a technical issue to which the Subordinate Legislation Committee adverted. When I interrupted you to ask my initial question, I was getting at the fact that the regulations are to be amended before they come into force. Why do you not just make further regulations that contain the amended aspect?

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

The amendment will make the regulations clearer. One of the Subordinate Legislation Committee's comments was that regulation 5 made five cross-references to the parent act. We have taken on board that drafting point. The committee's other point was about making absolutely clear, when regulation 5(a) refers to"subsection (5)(a) of that section",whether "that section" is section 10 or section 11 of the act.The redraft will not change the policy content. Given the importance that parents, education authorities and others attach to having early sight of the co-ordinated support plan, which is a new concept, it is better to enact the regulations now, if the committee agrees. After that, we will amend those small matters to make the regulations clearer. The amendment will not change the policy. As I said, the code of practice will make absolutely clear the policy content of the co-ordinated support plan.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

So it is a matter of distributing the regulations to people, even though they will not come into force yet.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Absolutely. The Subordinate Legislation Committee made helpful points on the drafting.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

When we discussed the code, a point was made about the form of the document in the schedule and the interrelation with individualised educational programmes. We were told that, rather than bureaucracy being created by a requirement for the same information to be conveyed in two formats, the relevant sections of a CSP might say, "See IEP". Will that happen? If so, should there be a reference to that in the form, which will be a working document for teachers and other education professionals?

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

We can consider the schedule in conjunction with the template in the code of practice. The way in which the regulations and the schedule are drafted is quite bald. The template in the code of practice gives more information about the content of sections of the plan. The IEP question probably relates to the profile, which provides the possibility of including information about other plans that a child or young person may have. That will be made clear in the code and in the guidance that is to be produced on completing co-ordinated support plans and the information that will be held in plans.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

As people fill in plans, they would read the code and other guidance rather than the schedule to the regulations.

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes. That is in response to the consultation, in which people said that they needed separate guidance.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

How does SSI 2005/266 interact with SSI 2005/264? An education authority has 16 weeks to produce a CSP and 12 weeks for a review. If, while doing that, an education authority must ask an agency for information or advice, that agency may have up to 16 weeks' grace in which to reply. If SSI 2005/264 gives agencies as long as that to reply, could that not create considerable pressure in relation to the preparation of a CSP?

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

One of the exceptions in the CSP timescale would apply if another agency that had been asked for help was unable to comply within the required timescale. If the other agency required an extension to its timescale, that might have a knock-on effect on the education authority, which might need to extend its timescale as well.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

So the overall timescale could, I think, be up to 24 weeks.

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

The code is clear about the interrelation between the time at which an authority asks for help and the timescale for those requests. As the authority must be mindful of that timescale, the sooner that the requests are made, the better. The code recommends that, when the authority gives notice of its intention to perform an assessment, it should notify the parents which agencies it will contact and it should contact those agencies at that point. The sooner that the authority does that, the better, because the clock will start ticking from the minute that that intention is made known.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

I presume that HMIE will monitor the timescales. Will its findings be published? Will that information be made public? For example, will HMIE say how many authorities have exceeded the 16-week limit?

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

There will also be monitoring through the tribunal, to which parents will have a right to appeal if the authority does not comply within the 16-week timescale and if no reasonable exceptions apply. Therefore, there will be dual monitoring, I suppose.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

How will the co-ordinated support plan work with the individualised educational programme? Many IEPs give more information than will be given under the proposed format for the CSP, because many IEPs include both the young person's profile and the different agencies that will work with him or her. Could the IEP format be used for a CSP? I am concerned about the paper chase that is developing, which we talked about last week. Some teachers will look at the CSP form and think, "I have more information on the IEP, so why do I need to fill out this form as well?" What is the position on that? Must there be a piece of paper for the co-ordinated support plan to which the child is entitled?

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

As a result of that discussion last week, the code of practice will make it absolutely clear to professionals, including teachers, what the relationship is between an individualised educational programme and a co-ordinated support plan. Whereas an IEP has educational targets for a school term, the CSP is about the broader context of how health, social work and so on will contribute towards educational objectives on a slightly longer scale. IEPs have individual objectives on a weekly or monthly basis for a school term, but CSPs will deal with a longer, more sustained period. Given the risk of confusion, the code will make clear the precise relationship between the IEP and CSP. The last thing that we want is a paper chase.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Rosemary Byrne asked whether the CSP must be a document. I think that there will need to be a document to comply with the regulations.

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

The CSP will be a statutory document.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

If the child has an IEP, can the CSP refer to the IEP so that it is not necessary for all the details to be written out again?

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes, indeed.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

My point is that many IEPs already set out the co-ordination of the different agencies, so the CSP could simply repeat what is already documented. Will the format of the CSP be piloted to see whether it works before it is pushed out to all schools? Will we be able to review the format of the CSP? I think that there will be difficulties with it.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

As I said in response to Lord James Douglas-Hamilton, nothing is set in tablets of stone. Obviously, we will want to review things in the light of our experience of implementing the act. However, the CSP template has not been arrived at as a result of bureaucratic decisions within Victoria Quay. The development officers who worked with the Scottish Executive met front-line professionals and they piloted the proposal in schools. As a result, we feel confident that the regulations provide a reasonable first stab at a co-ordinated support plan. The code will make clear the relationship between the IEP and the CSP and we will take things from there.A group of parents and professionals advised us on the development of the act, and an advisory group will continue to work, alongside the HMIE review, as part of the review process. We can use that group as a sounding board on how people are finding the implementation of CSPs and other aspects of the act. As a result of that dual approach, as well as officials going out and speaking to parents groups and professionals alike, we think that at the end of the two-year period we will have a sound knowledge of what is going on. As a result of that, we can make any necessary changes.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

Is any feedback available on the pilot that has been done? That information would be helpful to the committee.

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Two of the development officers visited schools and authorities throughout the country and spoke to teachers and officers. I am not sure whether a report was drawn up on that, but if you would like that information to be shared, I can certainly find out. If there is no report, we could draw some conclusions from that work.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Presumably, you incorporated the results of that work into the format of the CSP.

Robin McKendrick Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Absolutely. I am not aware whether a formal report was drawn up on the pilot, but the results were fed into the development of the co-ordinated support plan and they form part of the CSP as we see it now.

Shona Pittilo Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Initially, we considered that the IEP could be incorporated into the CSP, but during the development we found that that would not be practical. As Robin McKendrick said, the CSP is a strategic document. The CSP includes educational objectives for a year, whereas the IEP drills down further, with termly targets. We envisage that the IEP will be used in conjunction with the CSP. The CSP informs the IEP and vice versa. As Robin McKendrick said, we are looking into the CSP being an electronic document, which will make the transfer of information from the IEP to the CSP much easier. That will reduce the burden that teachers might feel they are under in the record-keeping process.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

I do not want to labour the point, but I have a final comment on the matter. A school may well choose not to continue to develop a child's IEP because of the CSP. At the moment, many young people have reviews every three months or even more frequently, but that good practice might be set back by the yearly reviews. I am concerned that schools will not continue to give young people the opportunity of more frequent reviews. If those issues are taken on board by HMIE and the situation is monitored and recorded so that there is evidence and we can look at the matter again, I will be reassured. However, there are issues of concern and we need to ensure that we consider them carefully.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are there any questions on the Additional Support for Learning (Publication of Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2005?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We move on to discuss what we want to do with the regulations. On the first instrument—the Additional Support for Learning (Appropriate Agency Request Period and Exceptions) (Scotland) Regulations 2005—there was concern about timescales. Although we would not want to make recommendations about that, given the assurances that the regulations are under review, would it be appropriate for us to note in our report to the Parliament that we have concerns? That might reflect the committee's view. Would that be possible?

Martin Verity Clerk
link

Yes.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That would not annul the instrument or interfere with the legalities of it, but it would indicate that the committee attaches importance to the timescales and thinks that some attempt should be made to keep on top of them. Is that acceptable?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Yes, but our report should also refer to the code of practice and we should state that we would like a record to be made about the initial date for assessment from parents.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes. We can include that. Is the committee agreed that it does not want to make any recommendation on the Additional Support for Learning (Appropriate Agency Request Period and Exceptions) (Scotland) Regulations 2005 in its report to the Parliament, other than as noted?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not think that there were any particular issues on the Additional Support for Learning (Changes in School Education) (Scotland) Regulations 2005. Is the committee agreed that it does not want to make any recommendation to the Parliament on the regulations?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

On the Additional Support for Learning (Co-ordinated Support Plan) (Scotland) Regulations 2005, the only remaining issue concerns the amendment of the regulations. We have received an explanation of what will happen in that regard. Are members broadly prepared to go along with the instrument?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I find this a bizarre way in which to proceed. Bearing in mind that the instrument was laid only on 19 May and that it does not come into force until 14 November, would it not be better if it were redrafted, submitted and approved instead of it having to come back to the Parliament? I understand and respect the explanation that has been given, but I find the process a bit odd. The convener might want to advise the Subordinate Legislation Committee of our concern that this should not become a common occurrence.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am given to understand that the Subordinate Legislation Committee is satisfied with the explanation. We have not seen its report formally, but that is the advice that we have.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The Subordinate Legislation Committee is the expert committee on these procedures. However, in the light of the complexities that were referred to when we first saw the instrument, the transparency of the legal process is helped if regulations are introduced in one document and not in several. Given the undertakings that the officials have given today and the Subordinate Legislation Committee's view, I am inclined to stick with what we have and not to get into other procedures. To require the instrument to go before the Parliament in another shape or form is probably disproportionate to the issue. I am sure that the officials will take on board what has been said.

link

It can be confusing for parents if a later draft, about which they may not be aware, comes through and is approved. I ask the officials to note that, in terms of transparency and of parents knowing what is going on, this is not an example of good practice.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I would be surprised if any parents were to read the documents. There is a limit to how far we can take the point.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are we agreed that we do not want to make any recommendation in our report to the Parliament on the Additional Support for Learning (Co-ordinated Support Plan) (Scotland) Regulations 2005?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Finally, are we agreed likewise on the Additional Support for Learning (Publication of Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2005?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank the committee and officials.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education Committee Wednesday 1 June 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 74
  4. Pupil Motivation Inquiry Committee business · 249

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.