To ask the First Minister what meetings he will have today. (S3F-149)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Wendy Alexander Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributionsLater today, among other engagements, I will meet the chairman of the Office of Gas and Electricity Markets to discuss charges for electricity transmission that discriminate against generators in Scotland.
I warmly welcome Wendy Alexander to her place. Let me also now welcome all 27 appointments that she has made as it would take too long to welcome them individually.
I warmly welcome Wendy Alexander to her place. Let me also now welcome all 27 appointments that she has made as it would take too long to welcome them individually.
I thank the First Minister for his warm words of welcome.
On the subject of warmth, yesterday was the seventh anniversary of Labour announcing our scheme to give free central heating systems to pensioners. More than 80,000 Scottish pensioners have already benefited. Why, then, did the Minister for Communities and Sport admit yesterday that the Scottish National Party Government is now reviewing the scheme, with targeting or means testing the likely outcome? Can the First Minister assure Scotland's pensioners that the scheme will not be cut back and that all Scottish pensioners without central heating will still qualify?
On the subject of warmth, yesterday was the seventh anniversary of Labour announcing our scheme to give free central heating systems to pensioners. More than 80,000 Scottish pensioners have already benefited. Why, then, did the Minister for Communities and Sport admit yesterday that the Scottish National Party Government is now reviewing the scheme, with targeting or means testing the likely outcome? Can the First Minister assure Scotland's pensioners that the scheme will not be cut back and that all Scottish pensioners without central heating will still qualify?
We are entirely committed to the statutory target to eradicate fuel poverty. That point was made by the minister yesterday. I am afraid that Wendy Alexander's description of what he said at yesterday's committee meeting is not accurate. Nonetheless, the important point for people around Scotland is that we are reviewing the scheme as a means to improving it. As I am sure she will know from her knowledge of housing, the scheme and many other aspects of housing in Scotland are badly in need of improvement.
Yesterday, the Minister for Communities and Sport told the Local Government and Communities Committee that free central heating for pensioners was now under review and that targeting was planned. The truth is that we extended the scheme whereas he has spoken about restricting it. Is that review under way, or has it simply been ditched because, once again, a minister has been rumbled? Winter deaths shamed Scotland; the central heating scheme cut those deaths by a massive 70 per cent in just five years. Why is the Minister for Communities and Sport now proposing to cut that lifeline?
Perhaps Wendy Alexander should have adjusted her second question after she heard the first answer. The Minister for Communities and Sport said clearly yesterday that we are reviewing the scheme with the purpose of improving it. Clearly, we could not improve the scheme unless we reviewed it. Given that I have now said that twice, Wendy Alexander should accept the fact that there are deficiencies in the scheme and that we are hoping to improve on them. I think that that will be widely welcomed by people in Scotland who suffer from poor heating in their houses and who are looking forward to improvements under an SNP Government.
The First Minister is ducking the question. His minister yesterday talked of targeting. At the moment, every single pensioner in Scotland who is without a central heating system qualifies for the scheme. Where does targeting fit if every single pensioner in Scotland currently qualifies? This week, pensioners all over Scotland are turning on their heating. Under Labour, the scheme was available to every pensioner, whether they had money or not. Why is the First Minister now targeting it?
I am answering Wendy Alexander's questions very precisely. It is not my fault that she cannot think of the right questions.
The minister said that we were targeting improvements in the scheme. For the third time, I say that the Government's purpose is an enhanced and improved scheme. Wendy Alexander should reflect on the fact that there are substantial waiting lists in the scheme, as in so many areas of Labour policy. Our purpose is to target improvements, which will be widely welcomed by the people of Scotland.
The minister said that we were targeting improvements in the scheme. For the third time, I say that the Government's purpose is an enhanced and improved scheme. Wendy Alexander should reflect on the fact that there are substantial waiting lists in the scheme, as in so many areas of Labour policy. Our purpose is to target improvements, which will be widely welcomed by the people of Scotland.
We made it clear that the scheme was available to all pensioners. The First Minister has refused to repeat that commitment today. Last week, the First Minister ditched a review because what one of his ministers said was brought to light. It speaks volumes about the SNP's priorities that some pensioners will be targeted and left out in the cold, when cash is being made available for new signs and new embassies, and when £500,000 is being made available for a broadcasting commission. We would like a First Minister who stops using Scotland and starts serving Scotland.
Wendy Alexander should have adjusted her fourth question after the first three answers. Can we focus on the fact that we have made it clear that we are reviewing the scheme to enhance and improve it? Since this is her first outing, I gently remind her that the number of people in fuel poverty rose under the previous Administration.
Wendy Alexander has made 27 appointments, involving more than half the Labour group in the Parliament. A number of people are beginning to wonder whether she appointed the wrong half.
Wendy Alexander has made 27 appointments, involving more than half the Labour group in the Parliament. A number of people are beginning to wonder whether she appointed the wrong half.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 20 September 2007 Debate · 1
- Flood Risk Management Debate · 90
- Post Office Network Change Programme Questions · 6
- Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route Questions · 12
- Court Services (North-east) Questions · 4
- Strategic Spending Review (Efficiency Savings) Questions · 8
- Energy Policy Questions · 6
- Disability Discrimination Act 2005 (Guidance) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Scottish Assigned Budget First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Renewable Energy First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Agenda for Change First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Primary Health Care (Lanarkshire) Questions · 20
- Midlothian Community Hospital Questions · 4
- Old Age (Dignity and Well-being) Questions · 4
- Community First Responders (Borders) Questions · 5
- Cardiac Rehabilitation Centres Questions · 4
- Housing Stock Transfer (Glasgow) Questions · 12
- Flood Prevention Questions · 6
- Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (Meetings) Questions · 7
- Rural Development Questions · 11
- Recycling Targets Questions · 4
- Recycling Targets (Glasgow City Council) Questions · 4
- Farm Produce (Prices) Questions · 4
- Water and Sewerage Infrastructure (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Penal Policy Debate · 73
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 29
- Points of Order Procedure · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 52
- ICL Factory Explosion (Public Inquiry) Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.