To ask the First Minister what action the Scottish Government proposes to take to review the number of quangos. (S3F-129)
Official Report · Chamber
Quangos
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- John Wilson SNP 2
- Rhona Brankin Lab 1
- Robert Brown LD 1
- Derek Brownlee Con 1
The record
10 contributionsThat matter is under review at the present moment. We inherited a situation of having nine Government departments and 160 quangos. As John Wilson knows, we have already taken action to reduce the number of Government departments from nine to six. As the review proceeds, we will certainly also take action to reduce the number of quangos in Scotland. We have too many quangos and we should have fewer.
Does the First Minister agree that greater transparency is required in the making of appointments to public bodies? According to research that was undertaken in 2005, 60 per cent of those who were appointed and who declared a political allegiance did so to one particular political party in Scotland. Does the First Minister agree that an examination is needed into the number of appointments that are made to quangos?
John Wilson is being quite coy, but the figure of 60 per cent related to the number of people who declared allegiance to the Labour Party. That is a remarkable fact. My comment has upset Labour members, but facts are chiels that winna ding, and 60 per cent seems to be a very high percentage. In fairness, I should point out that the number of people in quangos who identify themselves with a political party is low when compared with the total number. It should also be said that many people on quangos and other bodies contribute selflessly to public service.
However, John Wilson raises a fair point. I will ask officials to investigate and I will bring comments on the matter back to Parliament.
However, John Wilson raises a fair point. I will ask officials to investigate and I will bring comments on the matter back to Parliament.
I am rather confused by Mr Salmond's response. His colleague Richard Lochhead seems to think that quangos are rather a good thing. In June, he said that making Quality Meat Scotland a quango would
"give increased leadership, not just to the benefit of the livestock sector, but the food industry as a whole."
Does Mr Salmond agree that Scottish Natural Heritage and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency give strong leadership on the environment, and that SNH and SEPA should be maintained as separate bodies? If quango status is good enough for red meat, surely it is good enough for the environment. Is he going to go ahead with their merger, as stated in his manifesto? Yes or no?
"give increased leadership, not just to the benefit of the livestock sector, but the food industry as a whole."
Does Mr Salmond agree that Scottish Natural Heritage and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency give strong leadership on the environment, and that SNH and SEPA should be maintained as separate bodies? If quango status is good enough for red meat, surely it is good enough for the environment. Is he going to go ahead with their merger, as stated in his manifesto? Yes or no?
If Rhona Brankin had been paying attention to announcements that have been made over the past few days—in the Government's programme and elsewhere—she would know that we are already drawing things together into a single rural service, so that people who use the quangos and are supervised by them will not have the miasma of confusion that they complain about at present. On the issue that Rhona Brankin mentioned, and on other issues, she really should consult her constituents more widely, who find being supervised and examined by several bodies—at the same time and on the same issue—hugely confusing. She will find that rural Scotland will welcome the idea of a single entry point and a single service. That idea has already been introduced by this Administration.
I was intrigued when the First Minister mentioned the existence of "160 quangos", because in a speech on 17 May he referred to 152. That is perhaps one of the hidden aspects of the first 100 days of the new Administration.
More seriously, I want to ask the First Minister whether he has a target for how many quangos he seeks to cut. A major campaign is under way on the challenge of providing affordable housing, so can the First Minister clarify the position of Communities Scotland and the timescale for any changes that may be made?
More seriously, I want to ask the First Minister whether he has a target for how many quangos he seeks to cut. A major campaign is under way on the challenge of providing affordable housing, so can the First Minister clarify the position of Communities Scotland and the timescale for any changes that may be made?
We have discovered that there were hidden quangos as well as hidden waiting lists under the previous Administration. However, to answer Mr Brown's question more specifically, apparently the Scottish definition of quango includes not only non-departmental public bodies but executive agencies. That is the reason for the difference between the two numbers. However, whether the number is 152 or even more, as it is now, I am sure that Robert Brown will agree that there are too many. The number has increased but it ought to be diminished.
Given that ministers in all departments are keen to talk about decluttering the landscape, can the First Minister confirm that in four years' time there will be fewer quangos, that they will employ fewer people and that they will control a smaller budget than they control today?
Everything we do in this area is aimed at decluttering the landscape of quangos and non-departmental public bodies in Scotland. I am certain that Derek Brownlee will see substantial progress towards that end. That is not to diminish the role of the public sector or public servants, but it is an unassailable law of administration that if one body regulates an issue we are likely to get better results than from many bodies trying to regulate the same issue, especially when they spend a good deal of time consulting one another.
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 13 September 2007 Debate · 1
- Education Debate · 120
- Council Tax Questions · 8
- National Health Service Dental Services (Fife) Questions · 4
- Regeneration (Levenmouth) Questions · 10
- Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route Questions · 6
- Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Questions · 6
- Local Enterprise Companies Questions · 11
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Quangos First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Primary School Class Sizes First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Flooding First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
- Public Libraries (Investment) Questions · 6
- Culture (Meetings) Questions · 10
- St Andrew's Day Questions · 5
- European Treaty (Discussions) Questions · 4
- Tartan Day Questions · 10
- Roman Heritage Questions · 8
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Primary Schools (Modern Languages) Questions · 4
- Teachers Questions · 12
- Gaelic Education Questions · 13
- Young People Questions · 6
- Angus Sinclair Case Statement · 25
- Planning Statement · 29
- Smoking, Health and Social Care (Scotland) Act 2005 (Variation of Age Limit for Sale of Tobacco etc and Consequential Modifications) Order 2007 (Draft) Debate · 14
- Decision Time Decision time · 24
- Points of Order Procedure · 6
- Recovered But Not Covered Campaign Members’ business · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.