To ask the First Minister what progress is being made towards reducing class sizes in schools. (S2F-2736)
Official Report · Chamber
Schools (Class Sizes)
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 3
- Mary Mulligan Lab 2
- Fiona Hyslop SNP 1
The record
6 contributionsWe are making excellent progress towards reducing class sizes in schools. We are not only reducing class sizes to 20 in maths and English in secondary 1 and secondary 2 but reducing class sizes to 25 in primary 1.
The First Minister recognises that, to reduce class sizes, we need more accommodation and more teachers. When I met West Lothian Council education officials recently, they raised concerns about the difficulties that they face in providing additional classrooms, due to the area's increasing population and rising school rolls. Can the First Minister offer reassurance to local authorities such as West Lothian Council that they will be assisted to provide those additional classrooms? Can he also explain how he thinks that the Scottish National Party could deliver those class-size reductions, given that its policy makes a £1.1 billion gap in council revenues that would result in 167 fewer teachers in West Lothian schools?
I accept that this is First Minister's question time, but it would be of significant interest to the people of Scotland if we could occasionally ask questions of the SNP. I might just take that opportunity.
Under the school building programme, it is important that authorities plan for the reductions in class sizes that are set out in their obligations. In planning for those new facilities, the number of classrooms that will be available and the formation of the school need to take those obligations into account. It will also be important that we maintain the budgets that deliver those reduced class sizes and new school buildings. This Executive is absolutely committed to maintaining those budgets; it is a pity that the main Opposition party is not.
Under the school building programme, it is important that authorities plan for the reductions in class sizes that are set out in their obligations. In planning for those new facilities, the number of classrooms that will be available and the formation of the school need to take those obligations into account. It will also be important that we maintain the budgets that deliver those reduced class sizes and new school buildings. This Executive is absolutely committed to maintaining those budgets; it is a pity that the main Opposition party is not.
The First Minister clearly recalls my advice of five years ago that he should listen to head teachers and implement class size reductions. Is it not a shame that it has taken him five years to do so? Had he heeded an SNP pledge to cut class sizes to 18 in P1 to P3, is it not the case that he would not now have to take remedial action in S1 and S2? Is it not also the case that the gap between the top-performing and bottom-performing pupils in Scotland is getting wider? In which case, will he give us an idea of how many pupils are being left behind because of Labour's education policy?
I will happily give those pupils and their parents an idea of just how left behind they would be if the SNP had a chance to run Scottish education. Over the past six months, we have heard an absolute promise from Alex Salmond that, if he is able to return to this Parliament, he will cancel all unsigned contracts for school public-private partnerships, which would mean that all those school building projects that have not already begun would be stopped as of May this year. That would have a terrible effect on the education of pupils throughout Scotland who would be forced to stay in buildings that are now out of date and need to be replaced.
The SNP and Fiona Hyslop have been asked on several occasions to answer the questions that have been put to them about why they would cancel the PPPs and how they would replace that funding, but they have refused to answer. In addition, the SNP made it perfectly clear that it would take £1 billion out of local authority budgets in Scotland—Ms Sturgeon herself made that clear. We asked the SNP just seven weeks ago to answer questions about the number of teachers who would have to go as a result of that policy and yet again, we received no answers.
I am very happy to have a debate with Ms Hyslop and ensure that she has answers to her questions at any time. However, I ask the SNP to please answer our questions and look after pupils in Scotland.
The SNP and Fiona Hyslop have been asked on several occasions to answer the questions that have been put to them about why they would cancel the PPPs and how they would replace that funding, but they have refused to answer. In addition, the SNP made it perfectly clear that it would take £1 billion out of local authority budgets in Scotland—Ms Sturgeon herself made that clear. We asked the SNP just seven weeks ago to answer questions about the number of teachers who would have to go as a result of that policy and yet again, we received no answers.
I am very happy to have a debate with Ms Hyslop and ensure that she has answers to her questions at any time. However, I ask the SNP to please answer our questions and look after pupils in Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 22 Feb 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 22 February 2007 Debate · 1
- Road Tolling Debate · 99
- Criminal Law (Double Jeopardy) Debate · 49
- Child Protection Questions · 5
- Prisons Questions · 4
- Child Poverty Questions · 6
- Local Authority Roads (Maintenance and Repair) Questions · 8
- Trains (Controlled-emission Toilets) Questions · 6
- Sporting Facility Projects Questions · 6
- Music Industry (Ticket Touting) Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Schools (Class Sizes) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Blood Products (Public Inquiry) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Civil Legal Aid (Interdicts) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Homes (Grants Schemes) Questions · 7
- Scottish Water (Performance) Questions · 8
- Waste Management (Island Communities) Questions · 6
- Scottish Water (Status) Questions · 10
- Local Produce Questions · 4
- Carers (Strategy) Questions · 8
- Child Poverty Questions · 4
- Prescription Charges (Long-term Conditions) Questions · 6
- Elderly People (South Lochaber) Questions · 4
- Children's Health Questions · 4
- Myocardial Infarction (NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde) Questions · 4
- Health Protection (Vulnerable Groups) Questions · 4
- Nursing Home Places (Moray) Questions · 5
- Health Expenditure Questions · 4
- Affordable Housing Debate · 99
- Decision Time Decision time · 47
- Clyde Fishermen Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.