To ask the Scottish Executive, in circumstances where a general practitioner partnership is dissolved, whether there is a statutory requirement for the national health service board to seek to tender the services provided openly to non-general practitioners. (S2O-11742)
Official Report · Chamber
GP Partnerships (Dissolution)
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE General Questions
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Andy Kerr Lab 4
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 3
- George Reid 1
- Karen Whitefield Lab 1
- Fiona Hyslop SNP 1
The record
10 contributionsNHS boards have a statutory duty to ensure that all patients have access to GPs and primary medical services.
Again, we do not get a straight answer from the minister. Perhaps I can help him. The minister was responsible for introducing the Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Act 2004, which the Scottish Socialist Party was the only party to oppose. Section 4 of the act inserted new section 17L into the National Health Service (Scotland) Act 1978, under which
"A Health Board may, subject to such conditions as may be prescribed, enter into a general medical services contract with … a medical practitioner … a partnership, where"
at least one partner is a GP, or
"a company limited by shares,"
where the only condition is that
"at least one share in the company is … owned by a medical practitioner".
That is the crucial difference—
"A Health Board may, subject to such conditions as may be prescribed, enter into a general medical services contract with … a medical practitioner … a partnership, where"
at least one partner is a GP, or
"a company limited by shares,"
where the only condition is that
"at least one share in the company is … owned by a medical practitioner".
That is the crucial difference—
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
And your question?
My question is: will the minister finally refute the statements that his department made to the media that NHS Lanarkshire had no option other than to tender openly, including to non-GPs? Will he confirm that, according to the legislation, the board may not have had to do that?
The actions of NHS Lanarkshire are entirely appropriate in terms of the provisions in the legislation. A very rare set of circumstances are involved, which is that two GPs cannot agree on the future of their practice. We offered a partnership split that would have allowed them to work as single-handed GPs, but they would not agree even on that proposal. We therefore find ourselves in this situation.
What is important in all this is that the people of Harthill who are patients of that practice are given access to GP services. That is exactly what the board will do. As I have said many times, there is no reason why the traditional model of GP provision should not continue. The circumstances in which we find ourselves are very rare. I understand that the board is looking at the matter today and that it will shortly make known its views on the future of the practice.
What is important in all this is that the people of Harthill who are patients of that practice are given access to GP services. That is exactly what the board will do. As I have said many times, there is no reason why the traditional model of GP provision should not continue. The circumstances in which we find ourselves are very rare. I understand that the board is looking at the matter today and that it will shortly make known its views on the future of the practice.
Does the minister agree that it is vital that patients of the Harthill medical practice should be represented on the decision-making panel? Does he also agree that the approach that NHS Lanarkshire has taken in this regard has not been as inclusive as it should have been? Does the minister further agree that the primary focus in the process must be on providing the best possible GP services, in which the health care needs of the people of Harthill, Greenrigg and Blackridge are recognised?
Of course, patient need is at the heart of what we do in the NHS in Scotland. The work of GPs in our communities is absolutely vital.
With regard to the consultation process, I understand that all people in the area were lettered, public meetings were held and patients are represented on the panel. Nonetheless, if the member has specific concerns on the way in which the process was conducted, I am happy to look at them. The matter is the responsibility of NHS Lanarkshire, but I want to learn any lessons that should be learned from the process that was undertaken.
I repeat that we are dealing with a very rare set of circumstances. I see no reason why the traditional model of GP provision should not continue in Lanarkshire. It comes down to the fact that two independent GPs—who are not employees of the national health service—could not continue to agree on the way in which the partnership should operate in the future. They could not even agree on the proposal to run the practice as a two single-handed GP set-up. We therefore find ourselves in this very rare situation. The board is doing the right thing: it is ensuring that the community gets access to good-quality GP provision.
With regard to the consultation process, I understand that all people in the area were lettered, public meetings were held and patients are represented on the panel. Nonetheless, if the member has specific concerns on the way in which the process was conducted, I am happy to look at them. The matter is the responsibility of NHS Lanarkshire, but I want to learn any lessons that should be learned from the process that was undertaken.
I repeat that we are dealing with a very rare set of circumstances. I see no reason why the traditional model of GP provision should not continue in Lanarkshire. It comes down to the fact that two independent GPs—who are not employees of the national health service—could not continue to agree on the way in which the partnership should operate in the future. They could not even agree on the proposal to run the practice as a two single-handed GP set-up. We therefore find ourselves in this very rare situation. The board is doing the right thing: it is ensuring that the community gets access to good-quality GP provision.
Will the minister confirm on the record that NHS Lanarkshire could have chosen not to invite a tender from a non-GP company limited by shares? The 2004 act says that such tenders "may" be invited, not that they must be invited. If it is difficult for the minister to answer that question now, will he send a letter to interested members that provides an interpretation of the law?
The member has chosen to ignore what I have said. Given the circumstances at Harthill, NHS Lanarkshire has acted entirely appropriately. The provisions of the legislation in question and the National Health Service (Scotland) Act 1978 ensure that boards have sufficient flexibility to discharge their duties to provide primary medical services. How they do so in accordance with the needs of local populations and local circumstances is a matter for each NHS board. I repeat: what the board has done is entirely appropriate and in accordance with the legislation.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Jan 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 25 January 2007 Debate · 1
- Business Motion Business motions · 7
- Crofting Reform etc Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 139
- Crofting Reform etc Bill Bill debate · 28
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- MSSA Infection Questions · 6
- Post Office Network (UK Consultation) Questions · 4
- Prisons (Private Sector) Questions · 6
- GP Partnerships (Dissolution) Questions · 10
- Ministerial Attendance at Constituency Events (Guidelines) Questions · 4
- Aberdeen Dental School (Consultation) Questions · 7
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Senior Citizens (Poverty) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- European Union First Minister’s Questions · 4
- One Plus First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Broadband First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Employer Levy Questions · 4
- Central Heating Programme Questions · 10
- Housing Stock Transfer Questions · 6
- Relocation Policy (Small Units) Questions · 6
- Council Tenants' Right to Buy (Suspension) Questions · 4
- Local Government Funding (Inverclyde) Questions · 6
- Local Income Tax Questions · 8
- Flooding (Financial Assistance to Local Authorities) Questions · 4
- Relocation Policy (UK Civil Service Jobs) Questions · 4
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Reliance Questions · 4
- Speech and Language Therapy Questions · 6
- Minister for Tourism, Culture and Sport (Visit to Inverness) Questions · 10
- Schools (Health Promotion and Nutrition) (Scotland) Bill Questions · 6
- Children in Care (Education Champion) Questions · 4
- Nursery Education (Funding) Questions · 4
- Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament Act 2006 (Determinations) Debate · 14
- Budget (Scotland) (No 4) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 68
- Scottish Local Government Elections Order 2007 (Draft) Debate · 56
- Decision Time Decision time · 28
- Royal Hospital for Sick Children Edinburgh (Fair Parking) Members’ business · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.