Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

New Forth Crossing

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Enterprise, Lifelong Learning and Transport

Thursday 2 November 2006 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 15 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link
To ask the Scottish Executive what progress has been made in the decision-making process about a new crossing for the Forth at North Queensferry. (S2O-10902)

Tavish Scott LD The Minister for Transport · Shetland
link
We are taking forward the planning work that must be done if a replacement crossing of the Forth is needed. Therefore, planning is under way through the strategic transport projects review. Five detailed reports have been commissioned and will be completed by next May. The reports will be submitted on 3 November, 30 November, 31 December, 30 April 2007 and 31 May 2007.

That work will allow ministers to take any necessary decision next summer as part of the spending review 2007. At that point, ministers will have an analysis of the condition of the current bridge, options for a replacement crossing—which will include type, form and location—funding and procurement options and legislative requirements. Ministers' possession of the fullest possible information will allow them to make a decision that is based on a comprehensive analysis of options, risks and costs. Full details of the reports will be placed in the Scottish Parliament information centre.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link
I thank the minister for that answer and for the exchange of correspondence in which he has engaged with me. However, I must express genuine frustration and concern on behalf of the people of east-central Scotland, who believe that the minister has done very little work on the matter since he first gave an assurance to Parliament in the spring of this year. The public perception is that he has been dragging his feet and the perception of those who are closest to the coalface is that he has done little or nothing, especially on environmental impact assessment issues and a variety of technical matters. For the well-being of the Scottish economy, it is imperative that a new crossing is considered urgently and with haste.

Tavish Scott LD The Minister for Transport · Shetland
link
I gave a full answer on what we are doing. It is now on the record that five reports will be submitted later this year and next year. The work that must be done, regardless of when the decision is taken, is being done. That is what businesses and local people expect. We are talking about a decision that will be of great significance for the Government of the day. In my view, it would be wrong to take a decision now, without doing all the necessary work. Ministers must have the full analysis when they make their decision. As I said in my initial answer, the fact that that analysis is being provided will ensure that the ministers of the day have the full information.

George Reid The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
As it is unlikely that we will reach question 9, any member who wished to ask a follow-up to question 9 should do so now.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link
Does Mr Scott recall that almost a year ago, the First Minister told me that it would be particularly stupid to carry out the work that he has just announced? Does the minister agree that if that work had been carried out a year ago, the decision could have been made this summer instead of next summer? Will he give a commitment that, regardless of which design is chosen, the Executive agrees in principle to the building of a new Forth crossing, thereby ending once and for all the uncertainty for businesses in Fife and the north?

Tavish Scott LD The Minister for Transport · Shetland
link
Governments must take decisions on the basis of full information and we are ensuring that the work is being done to allow that to happen. I would have thought that any responsible Opposition would agree with that approach and I am disappointed that the Scottish National Party does not.

I finish by quoting at Tricia Marwick Mr Salmond, who said on 5 September:

"Certainly the planning should be done now because you've got to plan for the eventuality. You don't build something unless you have to."

Margaret Smith LD Edinburgh West
link
I thank the minister for his response to Helen Eadie. It is clear that on both sides of the Forth there is frustration and concern that we should make progress as quickly as possible. I would like an assurance that the report that is being prepared for the minister not only considers the general issues but goes a step further, so that if a decision is taken that a new Forth crossing is required, some of the practical work to address engineering issues—whether for a bridge, a tunnel or whatever—that forms part of the planning that the minister talked about will have been done. There are concerns that we might get another general report, rather than a report that covers some of the hard practical planning to which the minister alluded.

Tavish Scott LD The Minister for Transport · Shetland
link
As I said in my answer to Helen Eadie's initial question, one of the pieces of work that is being done, on which a report will be produced before next May, is on the options for a replacement crossing, covering type, form and location. I assure Margaret Smith that that will include the kind of detail that she is looking for. I repeat the somewhat obvious point that no minister or Government could take a decision without the fullest possible analysis of such issues, which is what will be produced.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link
Does the minister accept that damage is already being done to the Fife economy due to the uncertainty that is being created about the Forth crossing? Although I appreciate that work on the detail needs to continue, businesses throughout Fife and the east of Scotland are looking for a commitment in principle to replace the Forth crossing to ensure that we do not see a meltdown in the east of Scotland economy.

Tavish Scott LD The Minister for Transport · Shetland
link
Let us try to keep to a rational, objective assessment of the situation. The difficulty with that argument is that it suggests that Governments should always take a decision in principle and then consider the evidence to see whether the decision should stand. We are doing it the right way round. We are ensuring that the work and planning in all these areas—which members in all parties will acknowledge must be done—is done, to ensure that we take a decision at the right time with the right information. That is what we will do.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab The Ministerial Parliamentary Aide to the First Minister · Kirkcaldy
link
I hear what the minister says, but I have to agree with my colleagues that for people in my constituency, the whole of Fife and the wider east of Scotland, the issue is the uncertainty. The reports from the bridgemasters have said that there are issues with the bridge. People, in particular those who rely on haulage going across the bridge, are talking about relocating businesses outwith the Fife economy, which must be a worry for us. If the issues with the bridge remain, I do not see why we cannot have a decision in principle to have a new crossing.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab The Ministerial Parliamentary Aide to the First Minister · Kirkcaldy
link
What can the minister do to reassure companies in Fife that the situation is being addressed as a matter of urgency and that a decision will be made quickly?

Tavish Scott LD The Minister for Transport · Shetland
link
I am not sure what more I can add to the answers that I have already given without repeating exactly what I have said. I appreciate the points about the haulage industry; indeed, we had a fair airing of those points during the Local Government and Transport Committee's debate on these matters a week or so ago. That debate was helpful in allowing us to understand those points fully.

I assure Marilyn Livingstone that we are taking these matters forward and that we are doing the work. I have detailed what the work packages will be. Further information on them will be placed in SPICe, as I said a moment or so ago. We will continue that work and will take the right decision at the right time.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 2 November 2006 Debate · 1
  2. Scottish Executive Budget Review Debate · 101
  3. Financial Powers (Scottish Parliament) Debate · 90
  4. Housing Stock Transfer Questions · 10
  5. Health Centres (Renfrew and Barrhead) Questions · 6
  6. Smoking Ban (Bar Workers) Questions · 4
  7. School Facilities Questions · 10
  8. St Andrews Agreement Questions · 4
  9. Scoliosis Questions · 5
  10. Children's Sports Glasses (National Health Service Provision) Questions · 5
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  12. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
  13. Winter-related Deaths First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Methadone Programme First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. English Language Courses (Immigrants) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  16. Safety at Sea (Meridian) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  17. Cumbernauld (A80 Upgrade) Questions · 6
  18. National Transport Strategy Questions · 10
  19. Rail Fares (North-east Scotland) Questions · 4
  20. Age Discrimination Questions · 4
  21. New Forth Crossing Questions · 15
  22. Economic Development (North Ayrshire) Questions · 4
  23. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  24. Antisocial Behaviour Questions · 4
  25. Fireworks Act 2003 Questions · 4
  26. Alcohol (Sales to Intoxicated People) Questions · 6
  27. Drink and Drug-driving Arrests (Hamilton and Bellshill) Questions · 4
  28. Reliance Questions · 4
  29. Youth Courts Questions · 6
  30. Operation Triplicate Questions · 5
  31. Confiscation of Assets Questions · 4
  32. Business Motion Business motions · 8
  33. Scottish Commissioner for Human Rights Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 238
  34. Scottish Commission for Human Rights Bill Bill debate · 29
  35. Decision Time Decision time · 45
  36. Clydesdale Parks Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.