To ask the First Minister—with whom we share ambitions for higher economic growth—what steps the Scottish Executive will take to address the fall in Scotland's rating in the table of economic performance in the latest IMD "World Competitiveness Yearbook" from 40th to 51st—of 61 nations—and why he considers that these steps will improve Scotland's rating. (S2F-2314)
Official Report · Chamber
Economic Competitiveness
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 3
- Jim Mather SNP 2
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
The record
6 contributionsTo correct the impression that is created regularly by Mr Mather, I inform members that Scotland's overall position in the IMD "World Competitiveness Yearbook" in 2006 has improved from 36th in 2004 to 30th in 2006. That is a positive improvement in anybody's book.
However, we wish to continually improve Scotland's economic performance and that is why we are investing in infrastructure, in Scotland's universities and in skills.
However, we wish to continually improve Scotland's economic performance and that is why we are investing in infrastructure, in Scotland's universities and in skills.
I give the First Minister 10 out of 10 for bravado. He will note in that same yearbook that the gap between the United Kingdom and Scotland remains wide—there is no level playing field. The First Minister has often offered to debate with us that level playing field and I now return the offer to debate it with him anywhere, any time, in front of a representative audience—although perhaps he heard that Bristow Muldoon lost a similar debate by 23 votes to two last April. Is that why he will not debate the matter? When can we have that debate?
I hesitate to say it again, but Jim Mather has two options when he gets up out of bed in the morning. He can either celebrate Scotland's successes and feel good about the country that he lives in, or he can talk them down, denigrate and misrepresent them. Unfortunately, he chooses the latter option far too often.
Jim Mather asked about a world competitiveness survey, but he did not mention that that survey contains four aspects. On Government efficiency, we have improved from 39th place to 30th. On business efficiency, we have improved from 36th to 26th. On infrastructure, we have improved from 28th to 26th. Given the impression that we sometimes have of Barcelona and Catalonia, it is perhaps surprising that our overall performance placement is better than theirs.
Mr Mather does not come to the chamber and quote those positive statistics. He does not quote the Financial Times FDi magazine, which recently named Scotland the best region in the whole of Europe for human resources. He does not mention that in a recent worldwide survey of scientists, Glasgow and Dundee were both placed in the top five universities in the world for science. This Parliament should be about celebrating Scotland's successes, recognising our weaknesses and then investing in the right areas to ensure that Scotland succeeds in the future. I only hope that some day Jim Mather will help us to do that.
Jim Mather asked about a world competitiveness survey, but he did not mention that that survey contains four aspects. On Government efficiency, we have improved from 39th place to 30th. On business efficiency, we have improved from 36th to 26th. On infrastructure, we have improved from 28th to 26th. Given the impression that we sometimes have of Barcelona and Catalonia, it is perhaps surprising that our overall performance placement is better than theirs.
Mr Mather does not come to the chamber and quote those positive statistics. He does not quote the Financial Times FDi magazine, which recently named Scotland the best region in the whole of Europe for human resources. He does not mention that in a recent worldwide survey of scientists, Glasgow and Dundee were both placed in the top five universities in the world for science. This Parliament should be about celebrating Scotland's successes, recognising our weaknesses and then investing in the right areas to ensure that Scotland succeeds in the future. I only hope that some day Jim Mather will help us to do that.
link
Given the figures published yesterday that showed that foreign investment in Scotland has fallen by 95 per cent since Labour came to power, does the First Minister believe that that is his fault or the fault of his Liberal Democrat deputy?
Again, that is not true, but we would of course expect no more from the Tories. The reality is that, for the five years for which investment is judged, Scotland is holding its share despite the problems that we had in electronics between 1999 and 2001, and we are now growing our share again. When we are attracting investment and jobs into this country and making the incentives work, it does not help for the Tories, who would be quick to criticise if we were not offering incentives for companies to come to Scotland, or other members of the Opposition to describe them as bribes, as Mr Neil did recently when Morgan Stanley agreed to bring hundreds of jobs to Glasgow.
Let us get a bit of consistency from the Opposition. Let us support investment in Scotland, give people the right incentives and, when they come, tell them that they are welcome and celebrate the fact that they are here.
Let us get a bit of consistency from the Opposition. Let us support investment in Scotland, give people the right incentives and, when they come, tell them that they are welcome and celebrate the fact that they are here.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 May 2006 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 25 May 2006 Debate · 1
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 11
- Police, Public Order and Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 189
- Acute Hospital Services Questions · 6
- Partnership Agreement (Education) Questions · 6
- National Health Service (Costs for Treatment Abroad) Questions · 8
- Alcohol Questions · 4
- Long-acting Reversible Contraception Questions · 6
- Glasgow Housing Association (Stock Transfer) Questions · 7
- Glasgow Housing Association (Evaluation) Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Renewable Energy First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Economic Competitiveness First Minister’s Questions · 6
- E Coli First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Ferry Services (Tendering Process) Questions · 8
- Tramline (Funding) Questions · 4
- Modern Apprenticeships Questions · 4
- Bus Transport (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Environmental Sustainability Questions · 8
- Life Sciences (Inverness) Questions · 4
- Road Safety (A82) Questions · 4
- Tayside Police (Retirals) Questions · 4
- Rape (Conviction Rate) Questions · 4
- Mesothelioma (Legislation) Questions · 4
- Knife Crime Questions · 4
- Dundee Families Project Questions · 4
- Domestic Abuse Questions · 4
- Football Fans (Behaviour) Questions · 4
- Knife Crime Questions · 4
- Substance Abusers (Contraception) Questions · 5
- Police, Public Order and Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 163
- Police, Public Order and Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 24
- Motion without Notice Business motions · 4
- Business Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 8
- Human Trafficking (Prostitution) Members’ business · 37
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.