To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will provide an update on the future of the Forth road bridge. (S2O-8428)
Official Report · Chamber
Forth Road Bridge
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Enterprise, Lifelong Learning and Transport
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tavish Scott LD 5
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 2
- Scott Barrie Lab 1
- Bruce Crawford SNP 1
- Helen Eadie Lab 1
The record
10 contributionsAt present, we are examining several issues in relation to the Forth road bridge: the operation and management arrangements in terms of the tolled bridges review; the Forth Estuary Transport Authority's plans to introduce a road user charging scheme; and the implications of the cable corrosion findings. That work is evolving and I will keep the Parliament advised of progress at the appropriate time.
The Forth Estuary Transport Authority has suggested that the current road bridge should be closed or torn down in 2019 on safety grounds. Bearing it in mind that building a new road bridge will take at least 11 years and will cause major disruption at Queensferry, will urgent consideration be given to appropriate planning for the future? Something should be done now.
I assure Lord James Douglas-Hamilton that urgent consideration is being given to emerging findings from the bridge master and FETA. I have commissioned an independent analysis from the Flint and Neill Partnership, which is one of the United Kingdom's leading consultants on bridges and cable-supported bridges. It is inappropriate to prejudge that analysis. It is important that we obtain that analysis and then assess the exact position. It is important to look at every issue. No motorist would forgive us if we got it wrong, so we should wait until the analysis is complete before we make any final decisions. I assure the member that we will ensure that Parliament is fully involved in that process.
The minister will be aware of last month's members' business debate on the subject, which I initiated. Given the strategic importance of the Forth road bridge not just to the east of Scotland but to the wider Scottish economy, will he assure us that he is taking seriously the suggestion that heavy goods vehicles may be banned from using the bridge from 2013? Is he also taking seriously the devastating effect that that would have on the economy not only in Fife but in Scotland as a whole?
I was sorry not to have participated in that debate. I acknowledge Scott Barrie's point about heavy goods vehicles. I am sure that he is aware that the prediction that has come from FETA and the bridge master is the worst-case scenario. That is why we commissioned the independent study, which we hope will report to us by the end of January 2007. I assure Scott Barrie that his point about the importance of the bridge and the Firth of Forth as a strategic corridor in Scotland is well recognised. That is why we will proceed with this issue.
Obviously, the minister is aware that, by 2013, heavy goods traffic will be an issue and that, by 2019, we face the closure of the bridge unless remedial action is taken. In those circumstances, I hope that he accepts that the window for doing anything is closing fast. Indeed, some might say that the window has closed already, as some commentators say that it would take 13 years to build a new bridge. Given that the window is closing, what is the latest date by which a decision to build a new bridge has to be made to ensure that it opens by 2019?
I have yet to see in the public domain the independent analysis of the position of FETA and the bridge master, but we know what their emerging findings are. As Mr Crawford has also looked at the matter in detail, I am sure that he knows that those findings were based on a 5 per cent analysis of cables. I am sure that we agree that a fundamental decision on strategic investment in Scotland's road and rail network could not be made on such an analysis. That is why we are doing independent work. I do not wish Parliament to think that we had already accepted those dates. As I said to Lord James Douglas-Hamilton and Scott Barrie, we will be in a better position to inform our decision-making process when the independent work has been completed. I assure Bruce Crawford that I am acutely aware of the planning and construction horizons for this project. It is self-evident that it is important that we get it right.
Has the minister seen the presentation by the Forth Estuary Transport Authority? If not, will he make arrangements to do so? If he does that, will he make sure that all the MSPs for the constituencies surrounding the Forth bridgehead are invited to that presentation, which is quite alarming? I share the views of my colleagues who have said that the lead time for a new bridge will be at least 20 years, if we take into account how long it took from the drawing board to the opening of the Forth road bridge and the Kincardine bridge. The minister is correct to say that we should be well informed, but we should be informed about all the studies. I thank the minister for his interest in the matter.
I would be happy to make sure that the presentation that I saw towards the end of November—I forget the exact date—is available to all members. It has rightly been made available to the board of FETA and I am sure that the bridge master will be more than happy for it to be made available to members. I will ensure that that happens.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Dec 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 15 December 2005 Debate · 1
- Family Law (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 159
- Schools (Co-operative Principles) Questions · 4
- NHS Western Isles Questions · 10
- Green-belt Land Questions · 6
- Racial Discrimination (Public Sector Agencies) Questions · 6
- Schools (Truancy) Questions · 8
- Social Rented Housing (Overcrowding) Questions · 4
- Osteoporosis Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Fresh Talent Initiative First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Childhood Obesity and Social Deprivation First Minister’s Questions · 4
- G8 Summit (Security Costs) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Excess Winter Deaths (Greater Glasgow) Debate · 20
- Forth Road Bridge Questions · 10
- Tertiary Education (Links with China) Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Tram Scheme (Costs) Questions · 8
- Regional Transport Partnerships Questions · 7
- Bus Compliance Officers Questions · 4
- Concessionary Fares (Mature Students) Questions · 4
- High Court (Reforms) Questions · 4
- District Courts (Clerking) Questions · 4
- Class A Drug Offences Questions · 4
- Her Majesty's Prison Inverness (Female Unit) Questions · 5
- Antisocial Behaviour Questions · 10
- Transportation of Prisoners (Reliance) Questions · 4
- Chief Constable of Dumfries and Galloway Constabulary (Meetings) Questions · 10
- Family Law (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 199
- Family Law (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 21
- Animal Welfare Bill Bill debate · 6
- Business Motions Business motions · 6
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 9
- Decision Time Decision time · 24
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.