To ask the Scottish Executive what progress it is making in reducing class sizes. (S2O-8316)
Official Report · Chamber
Class Sizes
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Education And Young People, Tourism, Culture And Sport
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Peter Peacock Lab 5
- Mary Mulligan Lab 2
- Dennis Canavan Ind 1
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 1
- Fiona Hyslop SNP 1
The record
10 contributionsVery good progress is being made in training the teachers who are required to meet our 2007 class size commitments by then.
I welcome the progress that the minister has outlined, but I am sure that he is aware that there are particular challenges for local authorities—such as West Lothian, which covers my constituency—in which school rolls are increasing and additional classes may be needed. What additional finance, over and above school fund moneys, has been provided for authorities that have increasing rolls? Will the minister confirm that sufficient resources have been provided for each such local authority to achieve class size reductions in good time?
We are in the process of concluding the discussions that we have been having with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. In fact, Tom McCabe referred to those discussions last week in his statement to the Parliament on the local government settlement. Part of the thinking behind that is to ensure that we have clear ideas about how many extra teachers each local authority needs to employ. We are working hard on a distribution mechanism that will support that and additional cash is sitting in my budget waiting to go out to local authorities to employ those teachers.
Mary Mulligan referred to a particular problem, which is the fact that, in areas of increasing population, it can take a couple of years before the grant-aided expenditure allocations catch up with the population growth. That remains a feature of the way in which resources are distributed, but we are examining ways in which we can ensure that all our class size commitments can be fulfilled throughout Scotland.
Mary Mulligan referred to a particular problem, which is the fact that, in areas of increasing population, it can take a couple of years before the grant-aided expenditure allocations catch up with the population growth. That remains a feature of the way in which resources are distributed, but we are examining ways in which we can ensure that all our class size commitments can be fulfilled throughout Scotland.
How can the minister possibly claim that the Executive is making good progress towards hitting its targets of reducing S1 and S2 class sizes in maths and English by 2007 when the truth is that it does not even know the up-to-date number of classes that are above or below the target? Will the minister contact all local education authorities to ask for up-to-date figures? The last figures that the Executive published were for 2003.
An annual census of teacher numbers is taken, which reveals to us a lot of the detail to which Mr Canavan refers. The reason that I can claim that we are making progress is that we are making progress. There was a 45 per cent increase in the number of primary teachers coming into our schools in August 2005 from those who started training in 2004. There has been an 85 per cent increase in teaching graduates in maths and a 52 per cent increase in English in 2005. There has also been an increase of more than 200 per cent in the number of chemistry teachers who have been recruited into our schools.
Beyond what we are doing to train our own teachers in universities, we are recruiting teachers from outside Scotland. That is why there has been a huge increase in the number of registered teachers coming to Scotland and registering here. Such registrations are up by more than 100 per cent in maths and, in English, they are up by more than 118 per cent.
That is real progress and we will hit our targets.
Beyond what we are doing to train our own teachers in universities, we are recruiting teachers from outside Scotland. That is why there has been a huge increase in the number of registered teachers coming to Scotland and registering here. Such registrations are up by more than 100 per cent in maths and, in English, they are up by more than 118 per cent.
That is real progress and we will hit our targets.
Does the minister agree that expanding the number of available teacher training places is not enough on its own to secure our next generation of teachers? Does he agree that there must be an adequate supply of high-quality school placements and mentors for trainee teachers and that those mentors must be properly supported so that they have enough time to mentor the large number of student teachers who are in their care?
Lord James makes a good point. One of the pressures that we are putting on the university sector because we are recruiting so many teachers is the difficulty—although the universities have solved the problem—of getting enough student placements. We are mindful of the impact that that has on schools. We have learned a huge amount in the past three years from how new probationer teachers are supported in their schools with proper mentoring and a reduction in class contact time. They get full, proper support to ease their transition into school.
We want to apply those lessons in turn to student teachers when they are training in schools before graduation. Much further thinking is being done on that, and we hope to make progress on it in due course.
We want to apply those lessons in turn to student teachers when they are training in schools before graduation. Much further thinking is being done on that, and we hope to make progress on it in due course.
Will the minister confirm that it is not the numbers of teachers in training or on the register that matter, but the numbers of teachers in the classrooms? The minister should bear in mind that head teachers told him that meeting the target of 20 pupils per class in S1 and S2 for English and maths is not achievable. Will the minister admit that that target is no longer a target but an aspiration—a welcome one, but an aspiration nonetheless? The minister cannot realistically hope to meet the target and he knows it.
No, I do not accept that. We are well on the way to meeting the target. As I have said many times in the chamber, we will provide the resources to local authorities to ensure that the targets can be met.
Equally, we have said to head teachers that we will provide an element of discretion at local level when head teachers judge that they can have class sizes even smaller than 20 if that can be done to the advantage of particular groups of pupils without disadvantage to the remainder. We will provide that flexibility.
Be in no doubt, however: we will put in place the resources to allow the targets that we set to be met—and met in full.
Equally, we have said to head teachers that we will provide an element of discretion at local level when head teachers judge that they can have class sizes even smaller than 20 if that can be done to the advantage of particular groups of pupils without disadvantage to the remainder. We will provide that flexibility.
Be in no doubt, however: we will put in place the resources to allow the targets that we set to be met—and met in full.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Dec 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 1 December 2005 Debate · 1
- Schools Debate · 78
- Bus Services (Scottish Borders) Questions · 6
- Ship-to-ship Oil Transfers (Firth of Forth) Questions · 6
- Care of the Elderly Questions · 4
- Free Concessionary Travel (Publicity) Questions · 5
- National Health Service (Self-management) Questions · 4
- Traffic-flow Monitoring (South of Scotland) Questions · 6
- Roads (Haudagain Roundabout Upgrade) Questions · 6
- Scottish Water (Brownfield Developments) Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Army Recruitment First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Water and Sewerage Infrastructure First Minister’s Questions · 6
- AIDS First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Public Services (Environmental Impact) Questions · 10
- Digital Inclusion Questions · 6
- Local Government (Equal Pay) Questions · 14
- Council Tax Questions · 4
- Grant-aided Expenditure (Funding Formula) Questions · 4
- Non-departmental Public Bodies Questions · 4
- Efficient Government Targets Questions · 4
- Curriculum (History) Questions · 4
- Safe Play Questions · 4
- Class Sizes Questions · 10
- Teachers (Abuse Allegations) Questions · 7
- Sex Education (Parental Consultation) Questions · 4
- Rural School Closures Questions · 6
- Curriculum (History) Questions · 4
- Fisheries Debate · 89
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 48
- Council Tax (Very Sheltered Housing) Members’ business · 21
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.