To ask the Scottish Executive what measures it is using to help to resolve disputes without recourse to court proceedings. (S2O-7426)
Official Report · Chamber
Dispute Resolution
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Justice and Law Officers
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Hugh Henry Lab 4
- Bill Butler Lab 2
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- Jeremy Purvis LD 1
The record
8 contributionsWe support and encourage the use of alternative methods of dispute resolution where that is appropriate. We have published guidance for the public on how to resolve disputes without going to court and we are providing support and funding for a range of mediation and advice services. That includes funding that was recently announced for two new in-court mediation pilot schemes and for the Scottish Mediation Network.
I note the encouraging news that there are to be two further in-court mediation pilot schemes to follow the one in Edinburgh. Has the ministerial team considered taking the opportunity to build on the success of the Edinburgh pilot scheme by using the Glasgow pilot scheme to go beyond merely dealing with the settlement of small claims?
Bill Butler is right to refer to the success of the Edinburgh project. When I visited it recently to open the new mediation rooms, I was impressed not only with the dedication of the volunteers who were there, but with the effectiveness of the scheme. It is in everyone's interest for people to achieve an early and amicable resolution to a dispute without having to go through the full rigours—with the associated time demands and cost—of a court hearing.
Although the Edinburgh project deals mainly with small claims, Bill Butler's suggestion is useful and I would like the projects in Aberdeen and Glasgow to deal with summary cause and ordinary cause. If we can help to establish that such a mediation service works for more complicated claims, we can give everyone confidence in seeking resolution without having to resort to a full court hearing.
Although the Edinburgh project deals mainly with small claims, Bill Butler's suggestion is useful and I would like the projects in Aberdeen and Glasgow to deal with summary cause and ordinary cause. If we can help to establish that such a mediation service works for more complicated claims, we can give everyone confidence in seeking resolution without having to resort to a full court hearing.
I am sure that the minister will agree that family mediation services have played a crucial—indeed, integral—role in matrimonial disputes and disputes over children. Is he therefore considering granting additional funding to family mediation services, whose role will increase under the Family Law (Scotland) Bill?
The funding of local projects should be a matter for responsible local agencies. There is an historical anomaly in the fact that the Executive funds 10 or 11 local mediation services throughout Scotland. We are seeking to rectify the situation by transferring the funding to a more appropriate local agency. I do not think that it would be right for the Executive to determine all decisions about funding for local projects. Taking that approach to its logical conclusion, we would not stop at funding family mediation; we would fund every local voluntary project through the Executive, which clearly would not work.
On the other hand, it is right that the Executive should look to support the national bodies that help to develop, promote and establish the wide variety of services that exist across the country. We are doing that. We have invested substantially in that and we are working with those national bodies, which are going through a change programme to make them more effective. Additional funding has been allocated and we remain committed to that.
On the other hand, it is right that the Executive should look to support the national bodies that help to develop, promote and establish the wide variety of services that exist across the country. We are doing that. We have invested substantially in that and we are working with those national bodies, which are going through a change programme to make them more effective. Additional funding has been allocated and we remain committed to that.
The family mediation and other mediation services are very effective and complement both criminal and civil law in Scotland. When is the minister likely to come to the conclusion of his review? What role will local authorities and, crucially, the voluntary sector play in helping him to reach his conclusions?
We have been in discussions with local government to establish an effective mechanism for the disbursement of funds for local bodies. I hope to reach a resolution in the near future. However, that does not take away from the pertinent point raised by Jeremy Purvis. There is a need for local government across Scotland—this reflects Christine Grahame's concerns—to recognise the value of such services. It is not for the Executive to dictate to local government what it should do with its funds. However, I encourage those in local government to look carefully at what is being delivered and achieved in their areas. I commend to them the value that is delivered by family mediation services and I exhort them not to underestimate the harm that would be caused if those services were not supported.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Sep 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Wednesday 7 September 2005 Debate · 1
- Scottish Executive's Programme Debate · 88
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 3
- Rural Schools (Presumption Against Closure) Questions · 8
- School Public-Private Partnership Projects (Renewable Energy) Questions · 6
- Sustainable Development (Planning) Questions · 4
- Tourism (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 5
- National Health Service (Availability Status Codes) Questions · 6
- Dental Services (Fife) Questions · 7
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Terrorism First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Single-status Agreement First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Parliament (Powers) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Careers Scotland (Pay) Questions · 4
- Modern Apprenticeships (Application Criteria) Questions · 13
- Traffic Congestion (West Edinburgh) Questions · 4
- Marine Energy Questions · 9
- Oil Tanker Accidents (The Minches) Questions · 6
- Lifeline Air Links (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 6
- East Coast Rail Line (Electrification) Questions · 4
- Violent or Abusive Pornographic Material (Legislation) Questions · 4
- High Court Reforms (Monitoring) Questions · 4
- Shoot to Kill (Police Authorisation) Questions · 4
- Dispute Resolution Questions · 8
- Procurator Fiscal Service (Cupar) Questions · 7
- Crime and Young People (Diversionary Courses) Questions · 4
- Family Law (Scotland) Bill (Scottish Women's Aid) Questions · 4
- Electronic Tagging (Children) Questions · 4
- Scottish Executive's Programme Debate · 70
- Paisley Choral Festival Debate · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.