I am not sure whether to answer Mike Pringle or Bruce Crawford.
The Scottish Executive is taking action to address both the symptoms and the causes of antisocial behaviour. As well as introducing new legislation and improving antisocial behaviour services, we are continuing our long-term investment to deal with the causes of antisocial behaviour through our programmes to tackle poverty and promote social inclusion.
Has the minister had a chance to read the recent Joseph Rowntree Foundation report "Anti-social Behaviour Strategies: Finding a balance"? The report contains an interesting small paragraph, which states:
"In areas most beset by ASB, ways have to be found of countering the sense of powerlessness and accompanying entrenched pessimism among residents. There is a need to break the vicious circle whereby fears and expectations of ASB"
and
"lack of faith in the authorities' capacity to do anything … reinforce each other."
What strategies might be introduced to break that vicious circle, which is a difficult issue that besets many communities in Scotland?
Hugh HenryLabThe Deputy Minister for Justice · Paisley South
I have not read the report from which Bruce Crawford quoted, but I am sure that our officials will have done so. Over many years, successive Governments, as well as many local authorities, have tried to do exactly what that report suggests. In many communities in different parts of Scotland, initiative after initiative has tried to empower communities. I know that attempts to do so have certainly been made in some communities in Renfrewshire, where I live.
As well as attempting to tackle the immediate problems of antisocial behaviour and its impact, we recognise that, if such attempts are to be successful, we must also address the long-term issues by tackling problems of poverty—as this Administration, across its different departments, is attempting to do—and by looking at the fundamental health problems that beset many communities. Of course, we also need to examine the educational opportunities that are available to young people. That is why we have made the largest-ever investment in school building in this country, why we are investing so significantly in early years and why we have provided more teachers. By doing that, we hope that we will improve young people's education and, slowly but surely, their confidence.
Empowering and enabling people are the means through which we can give them the confidence to stand up and challenge and to take decisions for their own communities. The problem is very deep—it cannot be answered quickly in a response to a parliamentary question—but empowerment is important. The fundamental long-term strategy of the Administration is very much in accord with what Bruce Crawford has suggested.
Does the minister agree that it is for the police to decide operational matters in response to antisocial behaviour? Does he agree that it is disgraceful for local councillors to accuse police of being soft on antisocial behaviour when the police are tackling it in the way that they feel is suitable? Should we trust the police or councillors on this one?
Hugh HenryLabThe Deputy Minister for Justice · Paisley South
That is a valid point. From some of the recent discussion about what has been happening on Beach Boulevard in Aberdeen, I know that the police are taking effective action and that that action is supported by the local community. I also know that some politicians—including councillors and members of the Scottish Parliament—have criticised the action that the police have taken in that respect. The police are doing their job, using the new powers that were given to them by the Scottish Parliament. We should support the police where they take steps to tackle antisocial behaviour. We should also hope that councillors will take their duties and responsibilities seriously and that they will ensure that officials in council departments play their part in ensuring that co-ordinated and integrated action has an effect on local communities.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.