To ask the Scottish Executive whether, now that it has published separate Scottish data for some of the indicators on the World Health Organisation's European health for all database, it will submit a separate return for Scotland to the database to enable Scottish statistics on health to be compared on a like-for-like basis with those of other European countries; and the reasons for its position on this matter. (S2O-6487)
Official Report · Chamber
Scottish Statistics
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Health and Community Care
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stewart Maxwell SNP 2
- Andy Kerr Lab 2
The record
4 contributionsI need a towel wrapped round my head in a darkened room after that question, but that is another matter.
The Scottish Executive considers that comparisons with health information for other countries is a vital part of understanding the health issues facing Scotland. It uses the WHO databases, along with other sources, for a range of analysis to inform relevant policy and decision making. Having invested in the new analysis for Scotland, the Executive is committed to ensuring that the maximum value and benefit can be derived from all possible international uses and comparisons. As a result, the Executive is discussing whether Scotland could be separately identified in the WHO's health for all database.
The Scottish Executive considers that comparisons with health information for other countries is a vital part of understanding the health issues facing Scotland. It uses the WHO databases, along with other sources, for a range of analysis to inform relevant policy and decision making. Having invested in the new analysis for Scotland, the Executive is committed to ensuring that the maximum value and benefit can be derived from all possible international uses and comparisons. As a result, the Executive is discussing whether Scotland could be separately identified in the WHO's health for all database.
I thank the minister for that charming answer.
Given that the published figures are now in the public domain but only 306 of the indicators have so far been published, is it the minister's intention to publish the rest of the indicators, up to the total number of 517? Why do we not have a direct input into the WHO's European database, which gives a like-for-like comparison? The question is particularly pertinent given that the figures that he has published show that the death rate for trachea, bronchus and lung cancer among Scottish women is almost 50 per cent higher than the rate in the rest of the United Kingdom, and that the standardised death rate for cirrhosis of the liver in Scotland is 116 per cent higher than the rate in the rest of the UK. Is it not vital for the Parliament to have that direct comparison, not just with the rest of the UK but with the rest of Europe? We could also use that database for internal comparisons between the different regions of Scotland, using the software that is available.
Given that the published figures are now in the public domain but only 306 of the indicators have so far been published, is it the minister's intention to publish the rest of the indicators, up to the total number of 517? Why do we not have a direct input into the WHO's European database, which gives a like-for-like comparison? The question is particularly pertinent given that the figures that he has published show that the death rate for trachea, bronchus and lung cancer among Scottish women is almost 50 per cent higher than the rate in the rest of the United Kingdom, and that the standardised death rate for cirrhosis of the liver in Scotland is 116 per cent higher than the rate in the rest of the UK. Is it not vital for the Parliament to have that direct comparison, not just with the rest of the UK but with the rest of Europe? We could also use that database for internal comparisons between the different regions of Scotland, using the software that is available.
Care must be taken when comparing Scottish health information with results derived from other sources, such as the WHO. Different classifications, definitions and methodologies mean that results must be interpreted very carefully.
The Scottish National Party, as it always does, looks to the figures that show that Scottish health is at its worst. I could quote other figures, such as those on life expectancy of males and females born today or infant deaths per 1,000 of live births, which show strong improvements. The database gives us mixed information, which the Executive is well aware of in the context of its strategy on coronary heart disease, stroke and cancer and the priorities that it has set in regard to the hungry for success programme, the physical activity task force in our schools and the attempt to improve health and well-being in Scotland. It is very unfair, but typical of the SNP, to talk Scotland down and pick the negative statistics.
The substantive part of the question—[Interruption.] Well, the member chose to use the statistical database to talk down Scotland, so I wanted to use the opportunity to talk up Scotland's health and create some confidence in our Scottish health service. If SNP members had listened to the Royal College of Nursing conference this week, they would know that the RCN asked politicians to speak about the positive aspects of health as well as those that cause them concern—the SNP singularly fails to do that in its questions.
The member asked why we had managed to provide only 306 of the 599 WHO health indicators. Providing those indicators is a considerable effort and a lot of work that has significant resource implications for the information and statistics division and which delays other ISD activity on its work programme. Therefore, we need to balance the pressures in Scotland around the well-recorded improvements that we want to make in the ISD and in the information that it provides to the Executive and the wider public. We must manage our resources effectively to ensure that we deliver that wider programme of work while celebrating the fact that we now have 306 of those indicators in our database. I suggest that good progress has been made and that we try to understand the resource implications for the ISD and its wider work programme.
The Scottish National Party, as it always does, looks to the figures that show that Scottish health is at its worst. I could quote other figures, such as those on life expectancy of males and females born today or infant deaths per 1,000 of live births, which show strong improvements. The database gives us mixed information, which the Executive is well aware of in the context of its strategy on coronary heart disease, stroke and cancer and the priorities that it has set in regard to the hungry for success programme, the physical activity task force in our schools and the attempt to improve health and well-being in Scotland. It is very unfair, but typical of the SNP, to talk Scotland down and pick the negative statistics.
The substantive part of the question—[Interruption.] Well, the member chose to use the statistical database to talk down Scotland, so I wanted to use the opportunity to talk up Scotland's health and create some confidence in our Scottish health service. If SNP members had listened to the Royal College of Nursing conference this week, they would know that the RCN asked politicians to speak about the positive aspects of health as well as those that cause them concern—the SNP singularly fails to do that in its questions.
The member asked why we had managed to provide only 306 of the 599 WHO health indicators. Providing those indicators is a considerable effort and a lot of work that has significant resource implications for the information and statistics division and which delays other ISD activity on its work programme. Therefore, we need to balance the pressures in Scotland around the well-recorded improvements that we want to make in the ISD and in the information that it provides to the Executive and the wider public. We must manage our resources effectively to ensure that we deliver that wider programme of work while celebrating the fact that we now have 306 of those indicators in our database. I suggest that good progress has been made and that we try to understand the resource implications for the ISD and its wider work programme.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Apr 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 28 April 2005 Debate · 1
- Smoking, Health and Social Care (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 128
- New Deal (Fife) Questions · 6
- Unemployment (East Lothian) Questions · 4
- Supporting People Charges Questions · 6
- Attacks on Firefighters (Tayside) Questions · 8
- Strategic Rail Development Plan Questions · 8
- Europe Day Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Economy (Access to Broadband) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Capital Equipment (NHS Greater Glasgow) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Wind Farms First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Special Protection Areas Questions · 4
- Mountainous Area Status Questions · 6
- Horse Strategy Questions · 6
- Domestic Waste Recycling Questions · 4
- Demolition Activity Questions · 4
- Developers (Environmental Damage) Questions · 7
- Subsidies (Information) Questions · 4
- Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park (Byelaws) Questions · 6
- Flood Prevention Questions · 4
- Scottish Statistics Questions · 4
- Community Hospitals Questions · 6
- Sexual Health Questions · 6
- National Health Demonstration Projects Questions · 4
- NHS 24 Questions · 11
- Criminal Justice Services Debate · 75
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 6
- Smoking, Health and Social Care (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
- Presiding Officer's Ruling Procedure · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 42
- Managing Sex Offenders Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.