To ask the Scottish Executive what powers the Scottish Environment Protection Agency has over sewage pollution. (S2O-6029)
Official Report · Chamber
Sewage Pollution
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE General Questions
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Lewis Macdonald Lab 5
- Rosemary Byrne SSP 2
- Adam Ingram SNP 1
- Mark Ruskell Green 1
- Phil Gallie Con 1
The record
10 contributionsSEPA has statutory powers to regulate water pollution under the Control of Pollution Act 1974, as amended. The entry or discharge of sewage effluent to controlled waters is illegal, unless it is authorised by a consent that is issued by SEPA. Consent standards are established from the requirements of a range of legislation. SEPA also has statutory powers to issue notices to prevent, minimise, remedy or mitigate the effects of polluting discharges on the environment, and powers to report offences under the Control of Pollution Act 1974 and other legislation to the procurator fiscal, with a recommendation for prosecution.
In the light of the non-stop flow of e-mails and letters that I receive that highlight continued instances of sewage pollution, and in the light of the number of pollution incidents with which SEPA must deal, does the minister agree that SEPA's current powers are insufficient to deal with a problem that is increasing? As a result, will he increase SEPA's powers to deal with such problems? Will he increase the level of monitoring and regulation of sewage pollution? Will he increase the levels of fines for companies that have been found to cause sewage pollution?
I do not agree with the fundamental proposition that SEPA lacks adequate powers. Rosemary Byrne will know that under the provisions of the Water Environment and Water Services (Scotland) Act 2003, SEPA has an overview of the pollution of waters. That is clearly significant, as is the act to which I referred earlier. The water investment programme that we outlined in Parliament last month provides for significant investment in improving the standard of waters around Scotland's coastline and of its internal waters.
The solution is to maintain activity in the way that SEPA has done. SEPA maintains a close watching brief and is effective in dealing with issues when they arise.
The solution is to maintain activity in the way that SEPA has done. SEPA maintains a close watching brief and is effective in dealing with issues when they arise.
As the minister is aware, I have proposed to his colleague Ross Finnie that pollution prevention and control regulations should be amended to require a specific waste recovery licence that would allow SEPA to conduct much more rigorous control over sewage sludge disposal on land and which would be paid for by the operators under the polluter pays principle. What consideration has he given to that proposal?
Adam Ingram should be aware that waste management licence exemptions are required for the kind of spreading that has been discussed. It is worth restating that when it comes to how we deal with sewage, recycling it and using it for constructive purposes, such as on land or for burning for energy, are far preferable options to landfill and other forms of disposal. Rather than seeking to inhibit the proper use of sewage sludge for recycling, we should seek to enable it to happen in a way that is controlled and monitored—as it is by SEPA—but which allows that waste to be disposed of in as environmentally beneficial a way as possible.
link
SEPA has identified more than 2,000km of rivers and coastal waters that are being affected by sewage or contaminated surface water discharges and some 600km of our rivers and coasts as an absolute must for investment. SEPA is already set to be underfunded to the tune of £20 million for meeting the water framework directive requirements. Why is the Executive, through its under-resourcing of SEPA, undermining its own Water Environment and Water Services (Scotland) Act 2003, to which the minister referred in his answer to Ms Byrne?
The simple answer is that we are not underfunding SEPA; we are making provision for SEPA to carry out its statutory duties, in relation to the Water Environment and Water Services (Scotland) Act 2003 as well as its other statutory duties. As I said in my earlier answer, the provision that we have indicated for Scottish Water over the coming investment programme period will allow the investment of significant sums to improve water quality in our rivers and around our coasts.
The minister referred to the burning of waste products. He will be aware that a block has been put on burning at Longannet power station, which produces a pelletised, treated sewage product. The alternative method is to bury untreated sewage around the country. Surely the minister must take a stand on that matter and address it promptly.
I am glad that Phil Gallie agrees that landfilling of sewage sludge is not a preferable option. That is why we support other forms of disposal, including its proper use on land and in burning for energy. The decision to which Phil Gallie referred has been made in court and it is not for me to comment on the merits of judicial decisions. However, that decision does not prevent Scottish Power from burning sewage sludge at Longannet. Although it puts new regulatory requirements on that process, it does not prevent disposal of sewage sludge by that method.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Apr 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 14 April 2005 Debate · 1
- Council Tax Debate · 88
- Nuclear Power Debate · 52
- State Hospital, Carstairs Questions · 4
- Sewage Pollution Questions · 10
- Institutional Child Abuse Questions · 4
- Outdoor Education Questions · 4
- Eco-schools Questions · 8
- Infected Cadavers (Handling Guidelines) Questions · 5
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Economic Strategy (Employment) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Fresh Talent Initiative First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Trade and Industry First Minister’s Questions · 11
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Workplace Skills (Young People) Questions · 4
- M74 (Economic Benefits) Questions · 8
- Bus Services Questions · 6
- A8000 Questions · 8
- Hydro-electric Power Questions · 4
- Competitiveness Questions · 8
- Fatal Accident Inquiries Questions · 6
- Home Detention Curfews Questions · 5
- Her Majesty's Prison Kilmarnock Questions · 4
- Prisons (Drug Rehabilitation) Questions · 6
- Civil Law Review Questions · 4
- Offending on Bail Questions · 4
- Crimestoppers Questions · 4
- Skills Debate · 67
- Decision Time Decision time · 47
- Hannah Research Institute Members’ business · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.