Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Schools (Discipline)

Health and Community Care General Questions

Thursday 3 March 2005 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab Hamilton North and Bellshill
link
To ask the Scottish Executive what action is being taken to improve discipline in schools. (S2O-5653)

Peter Peacock Lab The Minister for Education and Young People · Highlands and Islands
link
As yesterday's report of Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education on behaviour in schools said,

"most schools are succeeding well in maintaining good discipline".

However, I will continue to work in partnership with education authorities and other stakeholders to ensure that the approaches and resources that are making a difference in most schools extend to all schools over time.

Michael McMahon Lab Hamilton North and Bellshill
link
As the minister will know, recently published figures show that the number of exclusions in schools has risen by 7 per cent and that male pupils account for nearly 80 per cent of exclusions. Does he think that that is a result of teaching styles in schools that alienate boys and increase boredom and confusion, or of the invisibility of bullying among girls, which tends to be less physical and less immediately noticeable? What steps, if any, have been taken to address the issue?

Peter Peacock Lab The Minister for Education and Young People · Highlands and Islands
link
The immediate reason for the rise in the number of exclusions is that I have made it clear to head teachers that we will not have artificial targets to reduce exclusions and that, if they believe that a pupil should be excluded, they should exclude that pupil. The authority is vested in head teachers: if they believe that a child should be excluded, that is their decision and I will back it. That said, we know that there are challenging issues in our schools, particularly among boys, who are disengaging from learning in a way that we do not want, primarily between years 1 and 3 in secondary school and principally because our curriculum has not been challenging or engaging enough for those young people. Everything that we are doing about curriculum reform in our schools is designed to ensure that boys and girls engage much more actively in education, feel enthused and motivated by it and gain something from it. As a consequence, discipline will improve.

link
Is the minister aware that the HMIE review that was published yesterday stated that the guidance that the Executive had issued on procedures for monitoring exclusions and attendance

"had yet to be fully and rigorously implemented"?

As the Executive has ceased to publish the statistical bulletin on incidents of violence and anti-social behaviour against local authority school staff, and as schools are not recording such incidents consistently, how does the minister propose to monitor the incidence of indiscipline in Scotland's schools?

Peter Peacock Lab The Minister for Education and Young People · Highlands and Islands
link
I have made it clear that I intend to monitor that closely. I will do so by talking to teachers and directly surveying teacher opinion and experience regularly so that we can adjust and adapt policy. That is the right way to monitor indiscipline, but we will also interview pupils to find out their daily experience. That way, we can ensure that our policy approaches are tailored to suit the circumstances in our schools.

Lord James Douglas-Hamilton must have been reading The Daily Mail version of the HMIE report, not the report itself, because the report points to the fact that

"The great majority of pupils took pride in their schools and … were open, courteous and well behaved"

and that

"most schools are succeeding well in maintaining good discipline".

Contrary to what Lord James implies, although we will collect teacher opinion on those matters, when the Tories were in office not so many years ago, they declined to do so. They would not fund a survey in the mid 1990s and it was left to the teacher unions to expose what was happening. We have rectified that problem. We will not hide from the issues that confront our schools; we will face them straight on and provide the resources and support that schools need to be able to tackle challenging situations.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link
Will the minister take the opportunity to pay tribute to the vast majority of pupils, who behave well in school? Will he also acknowledge the low-level, constant, daily disruption that many teachers experience? Does he acknowledge that, like it or not, the Executive's social inclusion and mainstreaming policy, however desirable it is, is having a negative impact? Will he face up to that fact and listen to the teachers' concerns about that issue?

Peter Peacock Lab The Minister for Education and Young People · Highlands and Islands
link
Of course I applaud the vast majority of pupils, who are well-behaved, and the vast majority of teachers, who do a stunningly good job day in, day out in contending with the difficult pupils who cause particular problems in our schools.

Social inclusion is a challenge, but we must dispel the myth that we are somehow importing children from another planet and depositing them in local schools, because the children concerned are local children who are going to their local schools. We want to keep those kids in those schools for as long as we can, because we know that, if we can do that, their life chances will be much greater. If we do not do that effectively, those kids will be condemned to a life in which they are less likely to be in employment, are in poorer health and have poorer housing conditions. That is why social inclusion is important. However, it should not be at any price, which is why we have empowered head teachers to exclude pupils from school whenever that is appropriate. It is also why we are investing in special units in and just beyond our schools so that we can keep our classrooms freer from disruption and our young people learning.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 March 2005 Debate · 1
  2. School Meals Debate · 66
  3. G8 Summit (Right to Protest) Debate · 40
  4. First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  5. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  6. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 23
  7. Identity Card Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 10
  8. Sectarianism First Minister’s Questions · 9
  9. Fresh Talent Initiative First Minister’s Questions · 16
  10. Food Self-sufficiency Questions · 10
  11. Waste Services (Efficiencies) Questions · 6
  12. Waste Water Treatment (Odours) Questions · 6
  13. Calf Registration Questions · 4
  14. Climate Change Programme Questions · 8
  15. Climate Change (Energy Saving) Questions · 4
  16. Terrestrial Trunked Radio (Health Effects) Questions · 6
  17. Accident and Emergency Services (Glasgow) Questions · 6
  18. Dental Services (Grampian) Questions · 6
  19. National Health Service (Technology) Questions · 4
  20. NHS 24 Questions · 8
  21. European Union Constitutional Treaty Questions · 12
  22. Sale of Sports Facilities Questions · 10
  23. Workplace Segregation Questions · 4
  24. G8 Summit (Tourism) Questions · 4
  25. Schools (Discipline) Questions · 8
  26. Energy-related Jobs (Transfer) Questions · 4
  27. Prohibition of Female Genital Mutilation (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 24
  28. Edinburgh Tram (Line One) Bill: Financial Resolution Edinburgh Tram (Line Two) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 8
  29. Points of Order Procedure · 7
  30. Business Motion Business motions · 4
  31. Motion without Notice Business motions · 5
  32. Decision Time Decision time · 52
  33. Lapwing Lodge Members’ business · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.