To ask the Scottish Executive whether it supports the Environment Agency's plans to introduce rod-licensing charges on the Scottish section of the River Esk. (S2O-5388)
Official Report · Chamber
Rod-licensing Charges
Justice and Law Officers General Questions
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Lewis Macdonald Lab 5
- David Mundell Con 2
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- Elaine Murray Lab 1
- Jeremy Purvis LD 1
The record
10 contributionsThe Scottish Executive supports the introduction of the fisheries management plan for the border Esk that is proposed by the Environment Agency. The duty to introduce rod licences is imposed on the Environment Agency under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries Act 1975.
I thank the minister for his very careful answer. Does he agree that, in effect, the Environment Agency has reneged on the commitments that Lord Sewel gave to Lord Monro of Langholm when the Scotland Act 1998 was being passed that those powers would not be used? Will the minister tell the chamber why if rod-licence charges are not a good idea on any other river in Scotland, they are a good idea on the Esk?
David Mundell should understand that primary legislation is primary legislation and that the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries Act 1975 does not provide the Environment Agency with discretion over whether to introduce rod licensing for salmon and trout. The member should also understand that the Scotland Act 1998 did not transfer responsibility for the issuing of rod licences from ministers of the Crown to Scottish ministers because the issuing of such licences was never a ministerial function but one that was imposed on the Environment Agency under primary legislation. Therefore, transferring that role to Scottish ministers was simply not an option.
Does the minister agree that it is an historical anomaly that the River Esk is designated as an English river, unlike the Tweed, which has been a Scottish river since the 1850s act of Parliament that bears its name? Does he share the concerns of the Gala angling association, whose members will have to pay for all 200 of the rod licences? Would a solution not be to devolve the Esk back to Scotland?
The Environment Agency's management of the River Esk in the Borders is no more an historical anomaly than the management under Scottish law of the River Tweed's last 10 miles, which are in English territory, or the management of the River Till, which is a tributary of the River Tweed that the Tweed acts placed under Scottish law even though the river is entirely within the county of Northumberland. Those are not historical anomalies but demonstrations of the fact that river catchment areas are managed as river catchment areas, not divided by administrative boundaries.
Will the minister confirm my understanding that the Tweed fishery is regulated under schedule 6 to the Water Resources Act 1991, which enables Scottish ministers to agree to the byelaws that regulate the fishery, but the introduction of the rod licences comes under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries Act 1975, which is a separate piece of legislation? Is he aware that Dumfries and Galloway Council believes that there is some dubiety about the legislation? Will he join Dumfries and Galloway Council in requesting the Environment Agency to defer the introduction of the rod licences by one year so that those legal issues can be further examined?
I agree with Elaine Murray's description of the legislative basis of the regulations. The Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries Act 1975 requires the imposition of rod licensing, although the conservation, management and exploitation of fisheries are regulated under other legislation. Consequently, although it might be possible to defer the management plan for the river—I see no particular advantage in doing so, but it would be possible—it would not be possible to defer the introduction of rod licences on the same basis because those are imposed under a different piece of legislation. In law, the Environment Agency is required to proceed with the introduction of rod licences.
As one who was born on the north bank of the River Tweed in Berwick-upon-Tweed, I ask the minister to confirm that one of the benefits of devolution is that the Scottish Parliament and Scottish Executive can work closely with the Westminster Parliament and Westminster Government when such cross-border interests arise. Does it not prove the insanity of the nationalists' desires for independence that they would divide communities and, bizarrely, seek to divide rivers?
As Jeremy Purvis will know given his origins on the north bank of the Tweed, on certain sections of the River Esk, the north bank is in Scottish territory and the south bank is in English territory. The idea that it would somehow make more sense to manage the two banks of the same river under entirely separate legislation does not seem very sensible to me.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Feb 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 10 February 2005 Debate · 1
- Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service Debate · 72
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Fresh Talent Initiative First Minister’s Questions · 8
- European Development Funding First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Economic Success First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Manufacturing Questions · 4
- A80 Questions · 6
- Biomass Energy Group Report Questions · 11
- Economic Development Questions · 6
- Wave Power Questions · 8
- Developing World Markets Questions · 4
- Youth Offending Questions · 4
- Communication with Victims Questions · 6
- Sex Offenders Questions · 6
- Procurator Fiscal Service (Dumbarton) Questions · 7
- Scottish Human Rights Commission Questions · 9
- Firearms Crime Questions · 6
- Prisons (Rehabilitation) Questions · 4
- Land Register Questions · 5
- Sexual Health Strategy Questions · 8
- Rod-licensing Charges Questions · 10
- Pressured Area Status Questions · 5
- National Sexual Health Advisory Committee Questions · 6
- Jobs Relocation (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 6
- Anti-racism Strategy Debate · 69
- Business Motion Business motions · 8
- Decision Time Decision time · 25
- Cancer Patients (Benefit Entitlements) Members’ business · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.