To ask the Scottish Executive what progress is being made on achieving an improved nephrops total allowable catch for next year. (S2O-4459)
Official Report · Chamber
Nephrops (Total Allowable Catch)
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Environment and Rural Development
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 3
- Iain Smith LD 2
- Fergus Ewing SNP 1
The record
6 contributionsInitial proposals from the Commission are positive and suggest a potential increase of 12 per cent to 21,350 tonnes in the North sea—to reflect full availability of the 28 per cent increase that was conditionally agreed but only partially released in 2004—and an increase of 12 per cent to 12,700 tonnes in the west of Scotland. A final proposal on nephrops, which is linked to the wider management arrangements for cod, will be agreed at the December council.
I thank the minister for that encouraging answer. He will be aware of the importance of the nephrops fishery to my constituency and to the fishermen of Pittenweem. In last year's negotiations, 2,300 tonnes of nephrops quota were withheld pending the development of the management plan to minimise incidental cod mortality. The plan was submitted by the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department in the summer. Has the Commission accepted that plan? Will the minister give an assurance that none of the 2005 quota will be withheld?
The member is right to say that we put the proposal to the Commission but, unfortunately, its consideration overran the appointment of Commissioner Borg. That was very unhelpful. We continue to make it clear that the management arrangements that we have proposed are sound and that they justify an increased take-up of the quota. We hope to emerge from the December council with agreement on the United Kingdom getting its full quota allocations and on whatever management measures on effort or bycatch might be required. If that is settled in December, it will be of great benefit to fishermen, especially those in Pittenweem.
Does the minister agree that, although a 12 per cent increase in the nephrops quota for the west coast is welcome, prawns are in even more plentiful supply? In the negotiations that he is shortly to undertake, there are two crucial aspects of a technical nature, on which I have written to him. First, there is camera evidence, which has been disregarded for west coast prawns, but which has been accepted for Fladden previously. Will he argue for the acceptance of that evidence? Secondly, does he agree that the so-called cod association formula is a misinterpretation, is misleading and should not play any part in informing the important negotiations?
On the latter point, the answer is no. When I met west of Scotland fishermen, which I think was two weeks ago, we discussed the report that had been prepared on the cod-associated bycatch. Although it is completely true to say that, at certain times, the cod bycatch is as low as 2.1 per cent—a level that would indicate that measures were not necessary—I regret to say that the report also refers to much more substantial cod bycatches. That cannot be ignored. One cannot simply pick and choose which parts of the scientific evidence to base one's arguments on. The cod bycatch remains a problem.
As regards our advocation of an increase in the quota on the basis of the latest advice that has come from the helpful co-operation of the fishermen and the use of the technical data, that forms part of the submission that we have already made to the Commission and it is part of the case that we will be prosecuting in the next three weeks before we get to the December council and during the council itself.
As regards our advocation of an increase in the quota on the basis of the latest advice that has come from the helpful co-operation of the fishermen and the use of the technical data, that forms part of the submission that we have already made to the Commission and it is part of the case that we will be prosecuting in the next three weeks before we get to the December council and during the council itself.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Dec 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 9 December 2004 Debate · 1
- Iraq Debate · 153
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Scottish Executive (Priorities) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- National Parks First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Fresh Talent Initiative First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Reoffending First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Global Warming Questions · 10
- Water Meters Questions · 4
- Scottish Water (Development Constraints) Questions · 6
- Beef Cattle (Over-30-months Scheme) Questions · 4
- Waste Reduction (Packaging) Questions · 4
- Nephrops (Total Allowable Catch) Questions · 6
- Core Path Network Questions · 4
- Agenda for Change Questions · 8
- Care Assessments (Parental Input) Questions · 6
- Children's Services (Perth Royal Infirmary) Questions · 6
- Prescription Charges Questions · 4
- Health Care (North of Scotland) Questions · 8
- Medical Training (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- Rail Electrification Questions · 4
- European and External Relations Questions · 12
- Criminal Justice Social Work (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Police (Use of Weapons) Questions · 4
- Edinburgh-Shotts-Glasgow Rail Line Questions · 4
- Proposed Christmas and New Year's Day Trading Bill (Consultation) Questions · 6
- Schools (Budget Management) Questions · 7
- Antisocial Behaviour (Private Housing) Questions · 4
- Fisheries Debate · 117
- Business Motion Business motions · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 39
- Excess Winter Deaths Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.