To ask the Scottish Executive what recent discussions it has had about reducing class sizes. (S2O-4313)
Official Report · Chamber
Schools (Class Sizes)
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Education and Young People, Tourism, Culture and Sport
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Peter Peacock Lab 4
- Dennis Canavan Ind 2
- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 1
- Adam Ingram SNP 1
The record
8 contributionsI have regular discussions with local authority and teacher representatives on several educational issues, including class sizes.
Does the minister agree that many classes are far too big? For example, is he aware that according to the Executive's latest figures, in secondary schools in the Falkirk area, 47 per cent of first-year maths classes and 55 per cent of second-year maths classes have 30 or more pupils? Instead of allowing head teachers to dilute the partnership commitment to reduce such class sizes to a maximum of 20, will he fulfil the commitment by increasing teacher recruitment and giving local authorities additional resources to employ more teachers, to improve educational opportunities for pupils in our schools?
I am glad to be able to satisfy Dennis Canavan on all those counts. The Executive is firmly committed to reducing class sizes in secondary 1 and 2 maths and English in particular, precisely because we think that classes are too big. That is part of our commitment to have 53,000 teachers in our schools, even though school rolls are falling. We are on track to meet that commitment.
We have increased teacher training places by 700 this year and in the subject to which Dennis Canavan referred—maths—we are training 80 per cent more teachers this year than we did last year. In the past two weeks, I have given education authorities an extra £60 million to build extra classrooms to house extra teachers. We have in place the budget to train those teachers and to pay their salaries. Everything is in place to meet the targets by 2007. Far from being given latitude to dilute that commitment, head teachers will have latitude to go further and to cut class sizes more, provided that that is in the educational interests of pupils.
We have increased teacher training places by 700 this year and in the subject to which Dennis Canavan referred—maths—we are training 80 per cent more teachers this year than we did last year. In the past two weeks, I have given education authorities an extra £60 million to build extra classrooms to house extra teachers. We have in place the budget to train those teachers and to pay their salaries. Everything is in place to meet the targets by 2007. Far from being given latitude to dilute that commitment, head teachers will have latitude to go further and to cut class sizes more, provided that that is in the educational interests of pupils.
I was pleased to hear what the minister said. In allowing head teachers more flexibility over class sizes and providing on-going information, will he undertake always to keep teachers informed, particularly through the Educational Institute of Scotland and other trade unions?
Not only will teachers be kept informed, but I hope they will play an active part in national and local discussions about how we provide the flexibility for which head teachers and schools have asked. It is good professional practice for head teachers to seek to involve teachers in the discussion of potential changes to class sizes in their schools. That is very much the spirit in which I want progress to be made.
Once we have in place all the resources that I outlined to Dennis Canavan, we want to ensure that head teachers can on occasion consider cutting some class sizes further, provided that doing so does not disadvantage other pupils. That ought to be a professional judgment made by the head teacher and the class teachers to do the right thing by the kids in a school. I therefore hope that teachers will be actively involved in the process.
Once we have in place all the resources that I outlined to Dennis Canavan, we want to ensure that head teachers can on occasion consider cutting some class sizes further, provided that doing so does not disadvantage other pupils. That ought to be a professional judgment made by the head teacher and the class teachers to do the right thing by the kids in a school. I therefore hope that teachers will be actively involved in the process.
Are falling school rolls not having more impact on class sizes than are Executive policies to boost the number of teachers? Several news stories in the past few weeks have suggested that a shortage of teachers persists, not least in Glasgow. Given that driving down class sizes is the key to improvements in attainment and discipline in school education, will the minister undertake to review the measures that he is taking to increase teacher supply, rather than twisting and turning on matters of flexibility?
I do not for one minute think that I am "twisting and turning on matters of flexibility". Our policy is clear and I will reiterate it. We have given the extra cash to build the extra classrooms to house the extra teachers whom we are recruiting. We have in position all the places in our universities to train those extra teachers and we have all the money to pay their salaries. Given that everything is on track, it is right that we should examine how we might advance our policy even further with some local flexibility. Indeed, last week the First Minister quoted the SNP spokesperson speaking in support of that policy rather than opposing it. I hope that we will get support from the SNP.
Fewer than 1 per cent of all teacher posts in Scotland are still advertised after three months, so we do not have a big national problem with teacher shortages. Mechanisms have been put in place to plan the type of teacher we require and what type of subject we require to be taught, in advance of any shortage that we see coming.
I accept that there are localised shortages, but local authorities are working hard to resolve that through their supply provision. However, not only do we not have an overall problem, we are supplying extra teachers to make sure that with the combination of falling school rolls and extra teachers, we can make use of an unprecedented opportunity to reduce class sizes more than we had planned.
Fewer than 1 per cent of all teacher posts in Scotland are still advertised after three months, so we do not have a big national problem with teacher shortages. Mechanisms have been put in place to plan the type of teacher we require and what type of subject we require to be taught, in advance of any shortage that we see coming.
I accept that there are localised shortages, but local authorities are working hard to resolve that through their supply provision. However, not only do we not have an overall problem, we are supplying extra teachers to make sure that with the combination of falling school rolls and extra teachers, we can make use of an unprecedented opportunity to reduce class sizes more than we had planned.
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Dec 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 2 December 2004 Debate · 1
- Aquaculture Debate · 98
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Parole Board for Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Public Sector Jobs (Cuts) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Sectarianism First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Schools (Class Sizes) Questions · 8
- Foreign Languages (Primary Schools) Questions · 8
- Modern Languages Questions · 4
- Marine National Parks Questions · 4
- VisitScotland (Marketing Strategy) Questions · 6
- Land-value Taxation Questions · 9
- Domestic Abuse (Prevention) Questions · 8
- Scottish Borders Questions · 8
- Housing (Local Authorities) Questions · 8
- Local Authority Services (One-stop Shops) Questions · 4
- Local Government Finance Review Questions · 4
- Housing Support Services Questions · 4
- Health Services Funding (Grampian) Questions · 8
- Road Safety Questions · 13
- Drugs (Legislation) Questions · 6
- Strategic Road Projects Review Questions · 8
- Racism Questions · 4
- Efficient Government Debate · 96
- Business Motion Business motions · 7
- Decision Time Decision time · 46
- Domestic Abuse Services Members’ business · 27
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.