To ask the Scottish Executive what plans it has to modernise courtrooms, in particular by ending the wearing of wigs and gowns and the use of some formal forms of address. (S2O-3937)
Official Report · Chamber
Courts (Modernisation)
Finance and Public Services and Communities General
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Colin Fox SSP 2
- Hugh Henry Lab 2
The record
4 contributionsThe Scottish Executive has no current plans to specify court attire. It is our intention to improve the court environment for all users and there are already circumstances in which the wearing of gowns and wigs is dispensed with.
I am sure that the minister accepts the need for a modern judicial system that enjoys the full confidence of the public. Does he also accept that the wearing of wigs and gowns and the use of the terms m'lord and m'lady paint an antiquated and bizarre picture, which serves only to intimidate and bemuse people and reduces public confidence in the Scottish justice system? Since so many parts of the modern democratic world have managed to rid themselves of those ancient anachronisms and refer to participants as the judge and the people rather than m'lord and the Crown, will the minister tell us whether he has plans to reduce the number of those relics and replace them with modern counterparts, or would he rather extend the wearing of wigs and gowns to all arms of legal procedure, including the Parliament?
I am not sure that the precedent that has been set in Parliament by members who wear tee-shirts in inappropriate circumstances is what we would want to see in our courts. The attire that is worn in the courts is largely a matter for the bench and the bar, rather than for ministers.
Colin Fox makes the fundamental point that our courts need to be modernised. We must ensure that people feel comfortable when they are in court seeking justice. That is why we have put so much effort into modernising court procedures. We have examined the High Court system and we are examining the sheriff court system. We have also considered giving better support and protection to witnesses and to victims. Those, rather than what someone is wearing, are the fundamental issues that really matter. However, I am sure that the points that have been made will be taken into account by judges and by the legal profession. It would be wrong to suggest that no changes have been made to modernise our court systems.
Colin Fox makes the fundamental point that our courts need to be modernised. We must ensure that people feel comfortable when they are in court seeking justice. That is why we have put so much effort into modernising court procedures. We have examined the High Court system and we are examining the sheriff court system. We have also considered giving better support and protection to witnesses and to victims. Those, rather than what someone is wearing, are the fundamental issues that really matter. However, I am sure that the points that have been made will be taken into account by judges and by the legal profession. It would be wrong to suggest that no changes have been made to modernise our court systems.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Nov 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 11 November 2004 Debate · 1
- Fostering Debate · 28
- One Minute's Silence Debate · 1
- Fostering Debate · 22
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Prime Minister (Discussions) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Airport Rail Links First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Fresh Talent Initiative First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Convention of the Highlands and Islands First Minister’s Questions · 13
- VisitScotland (Funding) Questions · 5
- Outdoor Education Questions · 8
- Primary Schools (Free Fruit) Questions · 6
- Secondary Schools (Modernisation) Questions · 8
- Antisocial Behaviour (Schools) Questions · 6
- Tourism (Promotion) Questions · 6
- Sonar 2087 Questions · 4
- Supporting People Questions · 16
- Scotland Act 1998 (Powers) Questions · 6
- Open Space (New Developments) Questions · 8
- Second Homes Questions · 4
- Public Sector (Wages) Questions · 4
- Smoking Questions · 4
- Draft Sexual Health and Relationships Strategy (Consultation) Questions · 12
- Courts (Modernisation) Questions · 4
- Calman Report Questions · 4
- Small Claims Procedure Questions · 4
- Gambling Questions · 4
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Members' Bills Debate · 32
- Bills Debate · 16
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
- Dying with Dignity Members’ business · 18
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.