To ask the Scottish Executive how many responses it has received to the consultation on the recommendations of the McInnes review. (S2O-3012)
Official Report · Chamber
McInnes Review
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Justice and Law Officers
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Cathy Jamieson Lab 4
- Mike Pringle LD 2
- John Home Robertson Lab 1
- Michael Matheson SNP 1
The record
8 contributionsThe consultation on the review of summary justice ran from 16 March to 16 July, during which time 239 responses were received. One hundred and fourteen responses from individuals and 125 responses from organisations were submitted.
Can the minister tell me whether a majority of the responses are in favour of retaining an element of lay justice in the new system? Can she give me an assurance that if the majority of responses come out in favour of the dissenting voice on the McInnes report she will listen to that?
I always take very seriously any consultation that the Executive undertakes. One of the fundamental principles of the Parliament is that we consult and, despite the fact that we are sometimes criticised for the amount of consultation that we do, I make no apologies for that.
We will, of course, give due weight to the comments that have been made during the consultation, but it is important to recognise that it is not simply a numerical exercise in terms of the number of responses that are submitted to the consultation. I have received an analysis of the responses, which have been put together, and I am considering that very carefully. I can say that a number of issues have been raised about lay justice, unification of the court system and a whole range of other issues that were included in the McInnes review. I want to consider the responses carefully and I will come back to Parliament to respond in due course.
We will, of course, give due weight to the comments that have been made during the consultation, but it is important to recognise that it is not simply a numerical exercise in terms of the number of responses that are submitted to the consultation. I have received an analysis of the responses, which have been put together, and I am considering that very carefully. I can say that a number of issues have been raised about lay justice, unification of the court system and a whole range of other issues that were included in the McInnes review. I want to consider the responses carefully and I will come back to Parliament to respond in due course.
I hope that the minister will conclude that there is an overwhelming case for retaining lay justices as a feature of the justice system in Scotland. However, does she share my concerns about establishment control over the selection and appointment of justices of the peace in Scotland? Does she agree that lords lieutenant are not necessarily the most appropriate people to have the lead role in the selection and appointment of JPs?
It is important to recognise that the reason why we consulted on the issue in the first place is that we want to consider speeding up the process of summary justice and making it connect better with our local communities. As we heard in the debate this morning, many people are concerned to ensure that that feature of the system continues. Many members who spoke in the debate this morning outlined the valuable work that JPs have done in the past, but it is also fair to say that concerns have been expressed to me that the system is not always as representative of local communities as it might be. However we take the matter forward, my priority will be to have an effective system that speeds up the process and connects with local communities.
In the light of the Criminal Procedure (Amendment) (Scotland) Act 2004, which will see some 20 per cent of High Court work moved down to the sheriff court system, and given that McInnes has recommended that district court work should be moved up to the summary sheriff courts, there is a danger that our summary sheriff courts may not be able to cope with the demands that are being placed upon them. Can the minister therefore give an assurance that before any of the proposed changes in McInnes are made there will be a detailed assessment of their impact on the summary sheriff court system in Scotland?
I am sure that the member is aware that the McInnes report proposes a unified court system and a new system of summary sheriff courts. It is not fair to say that it will simply be a case of moving cases up in the existing system. Of course I will carefully consider all the contributions that have been made. I reiterate that the review is about speeding up the system and giving communities a better opportunity to be connected to their local courts system, so that what happens in relation to the justice system is visible and communities can be confident that when people are detected, put through the prosecution system into the courts and sentenced, there will be something to prevent them from reoffending. The courts system has a great contribution to make to that.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Sep 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Wednesday 8 September 2004 Debate · 1
- Motions without Notice Business motions · 10
- Scottish Executive's Programme Debate · 88
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Civil Service (Reform and Modernisation) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Smoking Ban First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Sport First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Demographic Change Questions · 4
- English Language Teaching (Immigrants) Questions · 6
- Corporate Social Responsibility Questions · 8
- Security Questions · 6
- A9 Questions · 10
- Road Safety (Sheltered Housing) Questions · 4
- Aggressive Driving Questions · 6
- Prison Governors Association Questions · 4
- McInnes Review Questions · 8
- Peterhead Prison Questions · 6
- Pollution Cases Questions · 6
- Offences Aggravated by Religious Hatred Questions · 4
- Royal Family (Protection) Questions · 4
- Scottish Ambulance Service Questions · 10
- Diabetes Questions · 8
- Children's Hearings System Questions · 4
- Vaccines (Advice to General Practitioners) Questions · 4
- Tourism (Fife and Central Scotland) Questions · 8
- Architectural Heritage Questions · 4
- Point of Order Procedure · 6
- Scottish Executive's Programme Debate · 94
- Business Motions Business motions · 13
- International Suicide Prevention Week Members’ business · 13
- Sports Facilities (North-east Scotland) Members’ business · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.