Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 12 May 2004 Education Committee Procedure 73 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Robert Brown only · show everyone

Robert Brown’s contributions

34 contributions
Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We were going to wait until 2 o'clock for the minister, but I would like to move on to agenda items 4 and 5 to consider the committee's work programme and the budget process this morning, if we have enough time. Agenda item 4 is on the committee's work programme. Members have a paper before them, which raises one or two issues. There is a gap in June in between the bits and pieces of legislation that we have been dealing with.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are not discussing the long-term work programme; we are discussing the programme only up to the summer recess. There may be limits on what we can do in that period because of the time that is available.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that they are on our list of issues to return to at some point.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not accept the suggestion that we are doing that. To a degree, the target is moving and developments happen, but I do not accept your interpretation of what we have agreed. However, we can resume the argument shortly.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am conscious of the need for the committee's work to add value to what is happening in the Executive and not just to tread in its footprints as if it were good King Wenceslas.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That links a little with the possibility that we talked about a while back of working with the Enterprise and Culture Committee on 14 to 16-year-olds going to college and other such matters. That has not progressed because of the difficulties of two committees working together.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is the problem with working on the early years. My strong view is that the committee should make a significant contribution to early-years learning, but that is a lengthy and involved matter. There are two reasons for not dealing with that subject at the moment. One is that Executive reports that we should have first will be published in the next few months. The second reason is that such an investigation would take longer than the gap of two or three weeks in June. Does the committee agree that early-years learning will be a key priority for us from the autumn onwards, that we need time to study it properly and that we should examine another matter now? Is that broadly the consensus? Fiona Hyslop had a different view.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I sense that the committee's feeling, however, has been to leave the early years until the autumn and to take advantage of the period between now and then to examine curriculum issues. Is that acceptable?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not think that the possibility of having an away day during the summer recess is raised in the briefing paper, but an away day would allow us to consider, among other things, our work programme for the following year. Is the committee minded to repeat the experience of having an away day during the summer recess, perhaps in September? That would allow us to consider the matter in more detail and take some of the suggestions on board.Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The second representative did not say very much.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not think that what we decide today will have implications, because we are dealing only with the short term. Those were useful points, which we should consider in more detail at the away day and in preparation for it. I am sure that we will be able to take account of all the points that we want to talk about.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Again, it is a question of timescale. We need to do some work first. We need our advisers to work with the Executive, in accordance with Wendy's suggestion, to go a bit deeper and give us something to get our teeth into.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I have no doubt that we can, but I am not sure that we can do it before June, because we have to do further work on quite a lot of stuff.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not dispute what you say, Rosemary, but the issue is whether we have enough information to go on with until the advisers and the Executive have worked together. What you suggest may be an issue for the away day and after the summer recess. Members have raised good points, but we must approach our work in a systematic way that will add value. I am not convinced that we are in a position to do that. If we had been able to do that, we would have been able to do it in the context of the budget discussions at this point.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Nevertheless, that is a good suggestion.Before we move on, I want to say that I am interested in some of the academic subject areas. I do not mean that I am interested in the subjects as such, but because they involve major issues that will affect the country. A while back, James Douglas-Hamilton had a members' business debate on science education. I and others were interested in that too. I am also interested in the teaching of languages, which is not done particularly well—not because of the teaching necessarily, but because of the structure. I wonder whether we want to look into that.Is there support for the idea of making targeted visits over the summer? Is that a useful idea?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We need some kind of background briefing paper to guide us in our approach.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is a slightly difficult approach to pin down in recommendations.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes, they could. The good thing about the curriculum is that it is so wide—it covers everything—and the whole of school life is under one review. We have to narrow that down perhaps and focus on something a bit more meaningful. The briefing paper has tried to make one or two suggestions about that: one is not necessarily any worse or better than the other; it is just a matter of making a choice and getting the approach right.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I was dubious about whether even three priorities were more than we could deal with. There is also a hidden agenda in the overcrowding of the curriculum and focusing it against all the demands that come in from across the board to do X, Y and Z and to add them to A, B, C, D and E.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are we getting towards achieving a focus on the points in paragraph 4? Are we finding a central point?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is there too much there or is it about right? Do we need to change the areas that are suggested?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think we have consensus on that. There were a number of suggestions about bodies and I am not unsympathetic to the idea of visits to schools. We must keep a balance between listening to the usual suspects and getting a flavour of what happens in the schools, which we do not always get once the information is evened out, qualified and modified by the official representatives.I wonder how many slots we have for fitting in something. Interruption. The clerk has brought our timetable to my attention. On 2 June we will consider our draft report on the School Education (Ministerial Powers and Independent Schools) (Scotland) Bill, which will take all morning. On 9 June, we will discuss the away day, which is a fairly minor matter and can go in anywhere. On 16 June, we will consider the draft report on the child protection inquiry, which will not take all day. I suppose that those items could be moved about slightly, although the clerks need proper time in which to complete the reports in reasonable time.I suppose that, effectively, we have from 2 June to 30 June, which is five meetings of one sort or another; we could adjust the timetable a bit. I do not want the committee to decide exactly how we do it. However, if we take the principle that there are five meetings, with a bit of input we can either shuffle things about and get a clear meeting for a visit or we can do something else. Would it be sensible to adopt the approach of perhaps having one meeting on visits to suitable schools and in the rest we can try to identity suitable witnesses to hear from in that context? Obviously, we have the beginnings of a remit for the inquiry there.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The final meeting before the recess is on 30 June.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Well—have we? Interruption. I am informed that the week of 28 June is the final week of the parliamentary term. The recess begins on 5 July. Perhaps we do not have a meeting scheduled for the final week—I do not know.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not think that we do.Okay. We have broad consensus on where we are going in terms of that period. There will be one meeting on visits and the rest will be on witnesses. Perhaps suggestions beyond what is in the paper will come in from people within a day or two. People can give a bit of thought to whom we should actually see or where we should go.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

One period—instead of having a meeting on a Wednesday or another day—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Not a bit of it.As we did before, we could divide the visits into two or three people going to different places. That worked well.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We can try and get about a bit in that regard.Okay. That should give the clerks enough to work with. We can talk that through. We will send an e-mail round, but can people put in suggestions within a day or two for consideration in the planning process—which is obviously quite tight—about where you want to go or witnesses that you want to see.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is a good point. I actually met with a group a while back. I will give you details on that particular issue.Is there anything else under that? Obviously, this is the short-term work programme. We will come back to the away day and all of that for the longer-term stuff.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. Thank you very much for that.We move on to item 5, which is on the budget process. In accordance with our earlier decision, the committee will move into private session. I ask members of the public to leave.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education Committee Wednesday 12 May 2004 Committee business · 2
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. School Education (Ministerial Powers and Independent Schools) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 175
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 73
  5. School Education (Ministerial Powers and Independent Schools) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 151

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.