To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Executive plans to introduce legislation to amend the current law on rape. (S2F-911)
Official Report · Chamber
Rape (Legislative Plans)
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 4
- Alex Neil SNP 2
- Johann Lamont Lab 1
- Patrick Harvie Green 1
The record
8 contributionsThis is a serious matter and one that has recently received public attention. Let me make it clear that we want to see effective prosecution of rape and other sexual offences in Scotland. The time is right to consider clarification of Scotland's law on those matters, so I can announce today that the Minister for Justice has spoken with the chair of the Scottish Law Commission, who has agreed to consider the issues that surround the law on sexual offences, including rape, and to report to her in the near future.
I think that I speak on behalf of the whole Parliament in welcoming that announcement from the First Minister.
In the light of recent judgments, we are almost in a position from which it is very difficult to obtain successful convictions in rape cases in Scotland. Will the First Minister include two specific points in the remit of the Scottish Law Commission: first, the need to consider reform of the law with respect to intent to rape; and, secondly, the issue of whether we need a specific offence relating to male rape in Scotland? Finally, can he give us any indication of the timescale for the Scottish Law Commission's review?
In the light of recent judgments, we are almost in a position from which it is very difficult to obtain successful convictions in rape cases in Scotland. Will the First Minister include two specific points in the remit of the Scottish Law Commission: first, the need to consider reform of the law with respect to intent to rape; and, secondly, the issue of whether we need a specific offence relating to male rape in Scotland? Finally, can he give us any indication of the timescale for the Scottish Law Commission's review?
The timescale is a matter that I am sure the Minister for Justice will be able to clarify to Parliament following further discussions with the Scottish Law Commission.
On the specific points that Mr Neil made, it is important that the Scottish Law Commission review cover all aspects of definition and proof in relation to sexual offences, and to rape in particular. I believe that the review should include specifically the issue of male-on-male rape, which is a matter of concern to many members in the chamber and many members of the population of Scotland.
Recently, there has been publicity about any clarification of the law that might be required following the Scottish Law Commission's review. If clarification is required, we will look at further legislation. I do not want any woman in Scotland, however, to get a message here and now from the Scottish legal system or the Scottish Parliament that it would be inadvisable to report a rape or a sexual offence. It is very important that we maximise people's confidence not only in our courts—and in the sentences and prosecutions that are available to them—but in how the system deals with those who report such offences. That is one of the reasons why the Solicitor General for Scotland has made such a priority the improvement of how the system supports those who have reported such offences and who need support in order to appear in court to put their case.
On the specific points that Mr Neil made, it is important that the Scottish Law Commission review cover all aspects of definition and proof in relation to sexual offences, and to rape in particular. I believe that the review should include specifically the issue of male-on-male rape, which is a matter of concern to many members in the chamber and many members of the population of Scotland.
Recently, there has been publicity about any clarification of the law that might be required following the Scottish Law Commission's review. If clarification is required, we will look at further legislation. I do not want any woman in Scotland, however, to get a message here and now from the Scottish legal system or the Scottish Parliament that it would be inadvisable to report a rape or a sexual offence. It is very important that we maximise people's confidence not only in our courts—and in the sentences and prosecutions that are available to them—but in how the system deals with those who report such offences. That is one of the reasons why the Solicitor General for Scotland has made such a priority the improvement of how the system supports those who have reported such offences and who need support in order to appear in court to put their case.
I welcome what the First Minister has said. I seek his assurance, however, that recognition will be given to the need to clarify whether the problem arises from legislation or elsewhere. Does the First Minister agree that it is not enough to look at legislation alone?
Will the First Minister ensure that the action that is being taken by the Scottish Executive will make women less, rather than more, vulnerable and that it will encourage women to report rape and not deter them from coming forward? Finally, will the First Minister ensure that, in examining the issue, the Executive will work with organisations like Rape Crisis Scotland, which has an especially important perspective on how survivors of rape are treated in the legal system, and which also understands the nature of male violence against women?
Will the First Minister ensure that the action that is being taken by the Scottish Executive will make women less, rather than more, vulnerable and that it will encourage women to report rape and not deter them from coming forward? Finally, will the First Minister ensure that, in examining the issue, the Executive will work with organisations like Rape Crisis Scotland, which has an especially important perspective on how survivors of rape are treated in the legal system, and which also understands the nature of male violence against women?
Not only are we now involving directly organisations such as Rape Crisis and Scottish Women's Aid in a working group that the Solicitor General has established to examine handling of all cases in the system, but we are providing new financial support for Rape Crisis for its centres and the support that it gives to women in the community. Those are important measures that acknowledge the important role of the voluntary sector and of those who are committed to assisting women who are in such circumstances.
The outcome of the work of the Scottish Law Commission review might be that further legislation is required or that clarification by other means is needed. Whatever the outcome, it is important that we ensure that women have full confidence in the system, both in respect of how it treats them and how it prosecutes effectively those who are found to be guilty.
The outcome of the work of the Scottish Law Commission review might be that further legislation is required or that clarification by other means is needed. Whatever the outcome, it is important that we ensure that women have full confidence in the system, both in respect of how it treats them and how it prosecutes effectively those who are found to be guilty.
link
Like other members, I join in welcoming the First Minister's announcement. Does he agree that the specific—or potential—offence of male rape to which Alex Neil referred would be more usefully thought of in terms of actions, rather than in terms of the gender of the victim, given that the offence is one of anal and, indeed, oral rape as opposed to male rape?
That is a valid point. I am sure that it will be part of the remit for the considerations that will take place.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Jun 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 June 2004 Debate · 1
- Economy (Highlands and Islands) Debate · 155
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Rape (Legislative Plans) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Pensioner Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Heroin Use (Edinburgh) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Obesity First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Water Questions · 6
- Recycling (Edinburgh) Questions · 6
- Environmental Targets Questions · 9
- Landfill Targets Questions · 13
- Sheep Quality Questions · 8
- Waiting Times Questions · 6
- Elder Abuse Questions · 6
- Obesity Questions · 9
- Long-term Absence of Pupils Questions · 4
- Asthma Questions · 6
- General Practitioner Contracts (Quality of Service) Questions · 8
- New Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh (Food Hygiene) Questions · 8
- Electricity Generation (Renewables Technologies) Questions · 6
- Rail Services (Shotts Line) Questions · 6
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (Allocation of Funds) Questions · 5
- West Coast Main Line (Small Stations) Questions · 6
- Petrol Prices (Rural Scotland) Questions · 10
- Tenements (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 30
- Civil Partnership Bill Bill debate · 51
- Business Motion Business motions · 3
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 47
- Asbestos-related Illnesses Members’ business · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.