To ask the First Minister what penalties will be paid by Reliance Secure Task Management Ltd in respect of any breach of its contract to escort prisoners. (S2F-807)
Official Report · Chamber
Prison Escort Services
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 4
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 2
- Annabel Goldie Con 1
- Margaret Smith LD 1
The record
8 contributionsThe contract provides for penalties for failure to meet agreed performance standards. The Scottish Prison Service will calculate penalties on a monthly basis following the investigation of all alleged incidents.
Does the First Minister accept that, whatever additional penalties Reliance might have to pay in relation to the delays and general incompetence that it has been responsible for during the past two weeks, the public want and have a right to know the specific price that the company will pay for allowing a convicted murderer to saunter out of a courtroom and disappear into thin air? Will he tell the Parliament today the value of the fine that Reliance will have to pay for letting James McCormick go? If he will not do so, will he outline what possible reason there can be for keeping such information under wraps?
The Minister for Justice made it clear yesterday that, subject to important provisions in relation to public safety and some provisions that are inevitable in relation to commercial confidentiality, we will publish the contract. We will also publish performance information that will not only allow the Parliament to criticise, rightly, the way in which the contract has been implemented in the past three weeks, but ensure that we can guarantee that performance is improving and monitor that against the contract. That information will be agreed between the Scottish Prison Service and Reliance during the coming weeks. It will be published and it will give the Government and the Parliament an indication of whether performance is improving before we get to the stage of extending Reliance's responsibilities elsewhere in Scotland.
It is common knowledge that the negotiation and placing of the contract were accompanied by ministerial detachment. In so far as the Minister for Justice has alluded to the contract, she has sought to hide behind issues of commercial and operational sensitivity. I listened to the First Minister's response, but does he accept that, if public confidence is to be restored not just in our justice system but in the political process in Scotland, ministerial disclosure to the Parliament of how the penalty provisions of the contract operate is critical? Does he accept that it is not enough for the contract to be published and that it is essential that we have manifest ministerial acceptance of responsibility and appropriate and regular statements in the chamber about how the penalty provisions are applied?
I do not think that Annabel Goldie can say that responsibility has been shirked in any way. The first thing that happened when the Parliament returned to a full plenary meeting yesterday was that the Minister for Justice gave a parliamentary statement accepting her responsibility for sorting out the situation. During the past three weeks, the minister has been pursuing not just the Scottish Prison Service, the Scottish Court Service and the police service, but Reliance, to ensure that this debacle is sorted out. That is exactly the right thing for her to do and that is why she is in her position. She is the kind of person who takes such tough decisions and is prepared to knock heads together to ensure that the service works in the interests of victims and witnesses. She is not the kind of person who sits on the Tory or nationalist benches, shirks reform and is not prepared to put victims and witnesses first in the system.
No doubt the contract includes details of vetting and licensing. Guards who escort prisoners in England and Wales face the tough licensing and vetting procedures of the Security Industry Authority, which was set up under legislation that was passed in 2001. The Executive has stated its intention to extend that protection to Scotland. Will the First Minister confirm whether the Executive is still seeking a legislative slot at Westminster to do just that?
That is one of the issues that the Minister for Justice dealt with yesterday. She said quite clearly—I hope that everyone in the chamber heard her comment and I hope that some members of the media heard it, too, because unfortunately the position has been misrepresented to the public—that the people who work for Reliance in the service have been subject to additional security checks under the supervision of the Scottish Prison Service, which makes sure that those checks are in place. That is a reassurance for members of the public. Although Reliance has been unable to operate the contract successfully during the past three weeks, the individuals who are involved have had the appropriate checks, which have been applied under the supervision of the Scottish Prison Service. That is part of the agreement. We wanted to make sure that those who are involved in the service are able, properly trained and—
My apologies, Presiding Officer, I started waffling there. I will drop it at that.
My apologies, Presiding Officer, I started waffling there. I will drop it at that.
In this meeting
Everything on 22 Apr 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 22 April 2004 Debate · 1
- Cultural Review Statement · 25
- Mental Health Debate · 31
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Local Taxation First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Draft European Constitution First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prison Escort Services First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Seals First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Presiding Officer's Statement Procedure · 7
- Sport (Lottery Funding) Questions · 4
- Outdoor Education (Safety) Questions · 8
- Looked-after Children (Mental Health Services) Questions · 7
- Schools (Local Authority Spending) Questions · 6
- Local Tourism Hubs Questions · 8
- Miss X Case Questions · 7
- School Education (Sustainable Development) Questions · 5
- Arbroath Supermarkets (Planning Inquiry) Questions · 6
- Debt Advice Questions · 4
- Access to Credit Questions · 6
- Planning Applications (Protection of Communities) Questions · 4
- Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Bill Questions · 9
- Planning Reform (Consultation) Questions · 8
- Borders Railway (Funding) Questions · 12
- Tolled Bridges (Review) Questions · 6
- Motorists (Assistance) Questions · 4
- Prison Escort Services Questions · 4
- Rail Services (Fife, Perth and Edinburgh) Questions · 7
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
- Energy Debate · 106
- Decision Time Decision time · 46
- Multiple Sclerosis Awareness Week Members’ business · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.