To ask the Scottish Executive whether it has examined the advantages of the Irish model of staff relocation policy when considering its own policy. (S2O-1607)
Official Report · Chamber
Staff Relocation
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Finance and Communities
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tavish Scott LD 4
- Fergus Ewing SNP 2
- Elaine Murray Lab 1
- Mike Pringle LD 1
The record
8 contributionsThe Executive will watch with interest the development of policy in Ireland and, indeed, in Whitehall following the Chancellor of the Exchequer's announcement yesterday on the implementation of the Lyons review.
I would have thanked the minister if that had been an answer.
Is the minister aware that the Minister for Finance in Ireland, Mr Charles McCreevy, announced in December a fully detailed programme for the proposed relocation within three years of 10,000 jobs to the parts of Ireland that need investment? Does the minister agree that, although we should not replicate completely the policy of another country, a national strategy with the principle of having volunteers not conscripts and a national spatial policy through which relocated jobs go to the parts where economic development is needed are the model policies to which Scotland should aspire?
Is the minister aware that the Minister for Finance in Ireland, Mr Charles McCreevy, announced in December a fully detailed programme for the proposed relocation within three years of 10,000 jobs to the parts of Ireland that need investment? Does the minister agree that, although we should not replicate completely the policy of another country, a national strategy with the principle of having volunteers not conscripts and a national spatial policy through which relocated jobs go to the parts where economic development is needed are the model policies to which Scotland should aspire?
I am never clear whether Mr Ewing backs the Executive's decision to relocate Scottish Natural Heritage to Inverness. He should not suggest that the Irish example is directly comparable with Scotland because there are many differences between the approach in Scotland and the Irish model, as I understand it. The Irish system is not without its controversies. I understand that there is controversy over the fact that relocation costs are not paid to staff, who are being asked to relocate to different parts of Ireland in a short time order. However, such costs are being met as part of the relocation of Scottish Natural Heritage. I wonder whether Fergus Ewing agrees with that Irish policy.
Fergus Ewing and I often disagree but, in this case, I ask the minister to consider the merits of the system in Ireland, which uses a regional regeneration strategy to determine where the jobs ought to go. Will the minister consider seriously such a system of relocation, given that, sadly, the application of the Executive's present criteria results in areas such as Dumfries and Galloway never being shortlisted for serious consideration for civil service job relocation?
I appreciate Elaine Murray's concerns and I sympathise with her for having to go to Dublin with Fergus Ewing. She raises important issues. I have said that we will consider the Irish model with interest. We will develop, through discussion, any aspect from which we can learn. However, as I said, there are differences between the Irish model and the approach that we take in Scotland. That is not to say that Dumfries and Galloway, like every other part of Scotland, should not benefit from our policy.
Now that the Executive has decided to relocate SNH out of the heart of my constituency, will the minister assure the people of Edinburgh South that another large employer, NHS Scotland—the offices of which are only half a mile away from the Parliament—will not be relocated?
I am afraid that I can give no such assurance. I am sure that Mr Pringle understands the Scottish Executive's relocation policy and knows about the role that the triggers play in ensuring that particular decisions are consistent with the overall policy. Decisions must be consistent with the need to balance the different needs of the economy, the different aspects of the trigger levels and the frequently raised issues about the Edinburgh economy and the economies around it.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Mar 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 18 March 2004 Debate · 1
- Genetically Modified Crops Debate · 132
- Council Tax Debate · 122
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Priorities) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Health and Well-being First Minister’s Questions · 8
- White-fish Industry First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Security Review First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Tourism (Cunninghame South) Questions · 9
- Schools (Non-traditional Sports) Questions · 8
- Schools (Standard Grade Examinations) Questions · 6
- Shinty Questions · 6
- Tourism (Environment Quality) Questions · 6
- Enterprise in Schools Questions · 6
- Ratho Adventure Centre Questions · 4
- Olympic Games 2012 Questions · 4
- Council Tax Rebates (Second Homes) Questions · 10
- Voter Education Questions · 4
- Asylum Seekers Questions · 8
- Staff Relocation Questions · 8
- Victims of Trafficking Questions · 4
- Housing Developments (Infrastructure) Questions · 5
- Affordable Housing Questions · 6
- Scottish Drug Enforcement Agency Questions · 8
- Scottish Agricultural College Questions · 6
- Bankvale Associates Ltd Questions · 4
- Swing Bridges Questions · 4
- Dispute Resolution (Mediation) Questions · 6
- Concessionary Travel Questions · 4
- Landfill (Aucheninnes Moss) Questions · 8
- Action to Promote Women Debate · 88
- Justice (Northern Ireland) Bill Bill debate · 16
- Decision Time Decision time · 48
- Bone and Joint Decade Members’ business · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.