To ask the First Minister who will make the final decision about whether genetically modified crops are grown commercially in Scotland. (S2F-655)
Official Report · Chamber
Genetically Modified Crops
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 4
- Alex Johnstone Con 2
- Mark Ruskell Green 1
- Marlyn Glen Lab 1
The record
10 contributionsThere are a number of hurdles that anyone wishing to commercialise a GM crop must overcome. First, European directive 2001/18/EC provides the legal framework regulating the importing and cultivation of GM crops. Decisions are taken by the member states and the European Commission on a collective basis. The Scottish Executive is fully involved in decisions to determine the UK position.
Secondly, it is necessary for a plant variety to be added to the national seeds list in the UK. That is a collective decision of the UK Government and the devolved Administrations. It is a reassurance measure for farmers—it is not a safety assessment. The crop must already have passed a rigorous assessment that it presents no increased risk to human health or the environment, under directive 2001/18/EC.
Thirdly, if, and only if, GM crops were proceeding to commercial growing, we would wish to have in place a co-existence regime that provided reassurance to both organic and conventional farmers and to the public. This is a devolved matter, but one where we might wish to take a common approach across the UK.
Secondly, it is necessary for a plant variety to be added to the national seeds list in the UK. That is a collective decision of the UK Government and the devolved Administrations. It is a reassurance measure for farmers—it is not a safety assessment. The crop must already have passed a rigorous assessment that it presents no increased risk to human health or the environment, under directive 2001/18/EC.
Thirdly, if, and only if, GM crops were proceeding to commercial growing, we would wish to have in place a co-existence regime that provided reassurance to both organic and conventional farmers and to the public. This is a devolved matter, but one where we might wish to take a common approach across the UK.
The First Minister might be aware that I am not personally opposed to this technology but have expressed grave concerns about the way in which public opinion was left behind long ago. Will he undertake that, if there is to be a separate Scottish decision, there will be a separate and comprehensive Scottish consultation in advance of that decision?
I have tried to explain to Alex Johnstone the complex network of decision making and the various legal layers at which decisions will be made. It is important that we actively participate in the process and take on board the outcome of the consultation processes that we have already had which, like almost every survey, demonstrate that there is genuine public concern about the consumption of foods containing GM ingredients and the release of those organisms into the wild. I believe that it is the job of Government and the industry to respond to those concerns and have regard to them. I give the member an absolute assurance that, if science shows that there would be harm to individuals or the environment, GM crops will not be grown in Scotland.
link
Is the First Minister aware that there have been no long-term studies of the effects of genetically modified organisms on human and animal health and that there is mounting evidence that GM maize causes increased mortality in the livestock that eat it? Who is liable for the harmful effects that might occur in Scotland once Chardon LL maize is commercialised? Does he agree that it is time that the Executive came off the fence, defended the precautionary principle in its partnership agreement and used its existing powers to block the addition of Chardon LL maize to the UK seeds list?
That decision is currently being discussed among all the devolved and national Governments in the UK. There are no current proposals, as far as I am aware, for GM maize to be grown in Scotland, but we have an interest in the decision and are involved in discussions.
Ultimately, we must have regard to the scientific evidence. If the scientific evidence shows that there will be harm to humans or the environment, we will not allow the crops to be grown in Scotland. If the scientific evidence shows otherwise, we will have to take that on board.
Ultimately, we must have regard to the scientific evidence. If the scientific evidence shows that there will be harm to humans or the environment, we will not allow the crops to be grown in Scotland. If the scientific evidence shows otherwise, we will have to take that on board.
I am pleased to hear the First Minister's assurances. Does he agree that Scotland should focus on producing premium crops in a GM-free environment?
One way in which we should do that is by supporting the organic sector in Scotland and our recent increases in funding for the sector and our strategy for organics are doing just that. That strategy has my full support and I am sure that, when Ross Finnie returns, he will be desperate to get on with it.
Meeting suspended until 14:30.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Feb 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 26 February 2004 Debate · 1
- Young People Debate · 103
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Young Offenders (Rehabilitation) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Affordable Housing (Rural Areas) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Random Drug Testing (Schools) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Genetically Modified Crops First Minister’s Questions · 10
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Asthma Questions · 10
- Schools (Edinburgh) Questions · 4
- Galleries and Museums (Fife) Questions · 10
- Skiing Questions · 8
- European Year of Education Through Sport Questions · 4
- Schools (Sustainable Energy) Questions · 6
- Area Tourist Boards Review Questions · 5
- Skin Cancer (Surgery) Questions · 4
- Road Traffic (Targets) Questions · 4
- Council Tax (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- National Health Service (Patient Transfer) Questions · 10
- Mobile Phone Theft Questions · 5
- National Health Service (Prescription Charges) Questions · 9
- National Health Service (Work Force) Debate · 86
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 45
- Co-operative Development Agency Members’ business · 18
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.