To ask the First Minister what measures the Scottish Executive is taking to support the fish farm industry. (S2F-515)
Official Report · Chamber
Fish Farming
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 5
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 2
- Fergus Ewing SNP 1
- George Lyon LD 1
- Mark Ruskell Green 1
The record
10 contributionsThe Food Standards Agency has said that Scottish salmon is within internationally recognised safety limits and its advice is that people should consume at least two portions of fish a week, one of which should be an oily fish such as Scottish salmon. [Interruption.] I have to say that the future of the Scottish salmon industry is a serious matter, not a laughing matter as the Scottish nationalists seem to think. It is a matter that deserves the united support of the Parliament in the face of research elsewhere that is at best doubtful and which is unnecessarily damaging to our industry. Through the implementation of the strategic framework developed with the industry we support the sustainable growth of Scottish aquaculture, ensuring that it is both diverse and competitive.
I welcome the First Minister's response. Does he share my concern about the impact of illegal dumping in the European market of cheap, inferior salmon by non-European Union countries? Does he agree that it is essential that the European Commission puts in place safeguards to protect Scottish salmon producers? Will the First Minister join me in condemning the politicians and organisations that aligned themselves so cynically with the conclusions that were published last week in a report on salmon farming? The report was based firmly on bogus science and has been denounced by all credible international and local health monitors.
My constituents—although I did not live in the area at the time—probably know as well as anybody else in Scotland how important food standards are, given the deaths that took place in Wishaw back in the mid-1990s, which were one of the reasons why the Food Standards Agency was established.
The Food Standards Agency is an independent agency here in Scotland. It was set up to give us advice on such matters. Not only does it recommend that Scottish salmon is safe, but the European Commission does so too. We should go out there and promote our industry, both freshwater and farmed. I hope that in the years to come we can ensure that we are able to deal with anti-competitive practices elsewhere and can ensure that the European Commission gives Scottish salmon the special status that it deserves, so that we see it on more plates in more countries throughout the world.
The Food Standards Agency is an independent agency here in Scotland. It was set up to give us advice on such matters. Not only does it recommend that Scottish salmon is safe, but the European Commission does so too. We should go out there and promote our industry, both freshwater and farmed. I hope that in the years to come we can ensure that we are able to deal with anti-competitive practices elsewhere and can ensure that the European Commission gives Scottish salmon the special status that it deserves, so that we see it on more plates in more countries throughout the world.
Does the First Minister agree that salmon farming is absolutely essential to the economy of the Highlands, and the west Highlands in particular, sustaining as it does more than 6,000 jobs where there are no alternatives? Does he agree that the recent so-called scientific research that has attracted so much publicity is wholly flawed, and was funded by the massively wealthy Pew Charitable Trusts, which is a body that is prepared to pursue direct intervention to achieve its so-called objectives? Does he also agree that the sample used did not include any wild Atlantic salmon, that the salmon used was bought before the compulsory labelling laws were introduced and that there is, therefore, no basis or foundation to this unreliable so-called research, which has done immense damage as an act of sabotage to this vital Scottish industry?
I will say three things. First, the importance of the industry to communities, in particular in the north-west of Scotland, should not be underestimated. Secondly, the quality of the industry has been affirmed by independent agencies—not by politicians—and we should back those independent agencies in what they say. Thirdly, I appeal to everybody in the chamber to unite behind the industry and to promote what is good about it, Scottish salmon and eating fish in general, instead of prolonging the advertising of the research, which is what the people who published it clearly want. I hope that that will ensure that not only Scottish jobs but Scottish diet and health improve in the years to come.
I am delighted to hear that. Does the First Minister agree that the American research actually confirms that Scottish salmon is safe to eat? It confirms that Scottish salmon meets the United States Food and Drug Administration guidelines and confirms that Scottish salmon meets the World Health Organisation standards. The facts in the report confirm that Scottish salmon is safe to eat. I hope that the First Minister agrees with the Food Standards Agency—which, after all, was set up as an independent organisation to give advice to consumers on food safety matters—which has said categorically that Scottish salmon should be part of Scotland's diet.
I am happy to agree with those remarks.
link
Given the clear inconsistencies between the positions of the Government's own Central Science Laboratory and the Food Standards Agency on the toxicity of farmed salmon, will the First Minister convene an independent inquiry into the issue, for the sake not just of consumers, but of the Scottish salmon farming industry?
I agree that it is very important that we verify what we say and that it is of benefit to the industry as well as to consumers that we are able to justify and promote Scottish salmon with some confidence. My understanding is that the report by the Central Science Laboratory was considered by the Food Standards Agency. Based on WHO calculations, it was found that there was an element of double counting in the report's assessment of tolerable daily intake and the report was seen to be questionable. The Food Standards Agency—which I repeat is an independent body that was set up for this purpose—has said that Scottish salmon is safe to eat. That message should go from this chamber throughout the world.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Jan 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 15 January 2004 Debate · 1
- European Commission (Work Programme) Debate · 70
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Fish Farming First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Financial Services First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Higher Education Bill First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Oil and Gas Industry First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Council Tax (Second Homes) Questions · 4
- Drink Driving Questions · 10
- Prescriptions (Terminally Ill People) Questions · 6
- High Court (Appeals) Questions · 6
- Council Tax (Second Homes) Questions · 6
- ScotRail (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Council Tax (Second Homes) Questions · 5
- Haymarket Station Questions · 6
- Skills Councils Questions · 6
- Teachers (Qualifications) Questions · 4
- East Lothian (Schools) Questions · 8
- Glasgow School of Art Questions · 4
- Fisheries Agreement Questions · 10
- Eco-tourism (Northern Highlands) Questions · 4
- Points of Order Procedure · 7
- Emergency Workers (Protection) Debate · 41
- Business Motion Business motions · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 15
- Medical Services (West Highlands) Members’ business · 32
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.