Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Medium Secure Care Unit (Site Selection)

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 18 December 2003 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link
To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Executive will intervene to ensure that the selection process for a site for a medium secure care unit for the west of Scotland is fair, transparent and robust. (S2F-465)

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
The Minister for Health and Community Care will consider carefully the report on that particular site selection process, which he expects to receive soon from the committee responsible. On today of all days, the need to ensure public safety is uppermost in people's minds. I reassure the Parliament that I take my responsibilities as First Minister in relation to applications to move mental health patients around Scotland with the utmost seriousness. In every case that crosses my desk, I err on the side of caution.

Every party represented in the Parliament is committed to care in the community; every party represented in the Parliament supported the principles of the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003. There was a consensus in the chamber that if people no longer pose a threat, they should have the chance of gradual rehabilitation in the community. That means medium secure units. By definition, each medium secure unit will be sited in someone's community and in someone's constituency. It is the responsibility of those of us who are elected to the Scottish Parliament to show leadership, principle and backbone on the issue, and not to put ourselves at the head of ill-informed local scaremongering campaigns.

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link
I thank the First Minister for that predictably inadequate answer. He will by now have received from the Paisley and Barrhead community action group a dossier that details the catalogue of inaccurate and out-of-date information, omissions, incorrect applications of weightings and benefits criteria and numerous inconsistencies in information that were used throughout the whole process. Not only the Paisley and Barrhead action group but East Renfrewshire Council, councillors of different parties, the Lanarkshire action groups, community councils, MPs of different parties and the Deputy Minister for Justice consider the process to be fundamentally flawed.

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link
Is the First Minister aware of Mr Hugh Henry's letter of 10 December to John Ross, who is the chair of Dumfries and Galloway NHS Board? In that letter, Mr Henry says:

"I have been concerned for some time about the process of reaching the short leet of three. I am not convinced that the Steering Group has been able to demonstrate to the satisfaction"—

George Reid The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
You must come to the point.

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link
The letter calls for an independent review of the process. The Executive started the process—

George Reid The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
You must put your question now.

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link
When will the Executive take its obligations seriously and intervene in the process, which has been a shambles from start to finish?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
I recognise that these are sensitive issues. In my days both as a councillor and as an MSP, I have taken such issues very seriously and I hope that everybody will do so. Where processes need to be improved, they should be improved. However, improving the process is not the same issue as some of the scaremongering that is going on.

All parties in the chamber have been united about the need for medium secure units. In March, when she was SNP health spokesperson, Nicola Sturgeon said:

"we know that the problem is a lack of medium secure places."—[Official Report, Health and Community Care Committee, 4 March 2003; c 3915.]

Shona Robison backed up the case for changing the right of admission to the state hospital so that people can be transferred to medium secure units.

These units are needed across Scotland and that will be uncomfortable for some local representatives in some situations. However, we have a duty and a responsibility to take the issue seriously. This kind of scaremongering by raising the issue in the way that Mr McFee has done does the issue no justice whatever. I hope that, in the weeks ahead, he will tone down his language and the way in which he approaches the issue.

Michael McMahon Lab Hamilton North and Bellshill
link
As member for Hamilton North and Bellshill, I have two of the proposed locations in my constituency, but I participated in the scoring event last week, unlike Mr McFee, who would rather grandstand and talk to the press than participate in the process. Does the First Minister agree that any perception by the public of a haphazard decision-making process would undermine the ability of professionals to deliver the services that the public expect, especially services for those with mental health issues? Does he therefore agree that an independent review should be a requirement in any NHS consultation process so that the public can have confidence in it?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
As I said at the beginning, I do not want to pre-empt the due consideration by the Minister for Health and Community Care of the report that he expects to receive from the group that is dealing with the matter in the west of Scotland. However, where there is stalemate or difficulty in reaching a decision, I believe that some independent element to the final decision would be helpful. I hope that that is being considered.

I also believe strongly that the need to resolve any difficulties with the process should not allow us to move away from the principled position that people should not be in the Carstairs state hospital if they can be dealt with closer to the community. No one should be in the community or in any secure unit in the community if that is unsafe for the public who live nearby, but nobody should be in Carstairs unless they absolutely have to be.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 18 December 2003 Debate · 1
  2. Variant CJD Statement · 23
  3. Business Motion Business motions · 6
  4. Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 110
  5. Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 19
  6. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  7. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  8. Nursery Nurses (Salaries) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  9. Public-private Partnerships First Minister’s Questions · 6
  10. Medium Secure Care Unit (Site Selection) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  11. Pre-budget Statement Allocation First Minister’s Questions · 10
  12. Head Lice Infection Questions · 8
  13. Household Income (Definition) Questions · 4
  14. Adoption (Support) Questions · 6
  15. Edinburgh Royal Infirmary (Ambulance Services) Questions · 8
  16. Minister for Transport (Maybole Visit) Questions · 4
  17. Senior Citizens (Energy Charges) Questions · 4
  18. Marine Environment (Radioactive Releases) Questions · 6
  19. Strathclyde Police (Funding) Questions · 6
  20. Drug-assisted Sexual Assault Questions · 6
  21. United Kingdom Energy Bill Questions · 10
  22. Green Jobs Strategy Questions · 6
  23. Drugs Courts Questions · 4
  24. Calf Trade Questions · 4
  25. Contemporary Visual Arts Questions · 6
  26. General Practice Out-of-hours Cover (Remote Areas) Questions · 4
  27. Myalgic Encephalomyelitis Questions · 4
  28. Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 28
  29. Motion without Notice Business motions · 4
  30. Decision Time Decision time · 19
  31. Congestion Charging in Edinburgh Members’ business · 71

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.