To ask the Scottish Executive what study it has made of the use of the single transferable vote in the recent Northern Ireland Assembly elections and what lessons can be learned for future Scottish elections. (S2O-945)
Official Report · Chamber
Single Transferable Vote
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tavish Scott LD 5
- Phil Gallie Con 2
- Tricia Marwick SNP 1
- Bristow Muldoon Lab 1
- Iain Smith LD 1
The record
10 contributionsWe have established an independent working group to consider the implementation of the single transferable vote in Scotland. That group is considering the experience of STV in other countries, including Northern Ireland.
I welcome the study in Northern Ireland. Is the minister aware of the huge number of spoiled ballots recorded in the Northern Ireland election? Does he recognise the confusion that seems to exist among the electorate, given the fact that the system has been used in the past? Will he take that on board and does he acknowledge the dissatisfaction registered in Northern Ireland? Does he agree that simplicity in electoral reform is the key?
Although I agree with Mr Gallie, there is a lot of simplicity about making a direct correlation between Northern Ireland politics and Scottish politics. It is important to reflect on why STV was introduced in Northern Ireland: the political situation there is different and the desire is to reflect the balance of the community in any outcome. Mr Gallie might also be aware that the turnout in Northern Ireland was 63 per cent, which was higher than the turnout in the Scottish elections in May. That shows more interest—perhaps worryingly—in the Northern Irish elections that have just taken place. The STV working group will consider these matters; that is why ministers have established it. Perhaps Mr Gallie will reflect on the fact that he is here because of proportional representation and if he wishes to be a convert to that cause we will welcome him.
Does the minister agree that it is vital that elections are conducted in a way that reduces voter confusion to a minimum? Does he agree with the unanimous view of the Society for Returning Officers in Scotland that if STV is introduced for local government elections, Scottish Parliament and council elections should not be held on the same day?
I understand the member's point and the points that have been made in evidence to the Local Government and Transport Committee in recent weeks. Ministers are aware of the issues but, at this moment, we have no plans to change the proposals to have the elections on the same day.
I am sure that the minister is aware that the chair of the STV working group advised the Local Government and Transport Committee this week that he did not expect to provide his final report to ministers until September next year. Does the minister share my concern that that could mean that final consideration of the bill could take place before members of this Parliament are able to see a copy of that report?
Mr Muldoon raises an important point. I advise the chamber that the STV working group has been asked to report to ministers on issues relating to the practical implementation of STV by—as Mr Muldoon says—September next year. However, the group's chairman, David Green, will make an interim report to ministers in January, before ministers give evidence to Mr Muldoon's committee later in the year. That will be done to deal with the very point that Mr Muldoon raises.
Does the minister agree that evidence from Northern Ireland shows that the number of spoiled votes varies greatly from election to election? The use of STV is not the sole reason for people spoiling their ballot papers. Will he agree to examine fully next year's local elections in southern Ireland, which are being conducted using STV and electronic voting?
Mr Smith makes important points about electronic voting and about considering the experience of other countries. That is why we have the STV working group, which is considering and taking advice on these matters. Executive officials working on local government issues are considering these matters closely and will be studying practical examples so as to inform our considerations.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Dec 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 11 December 2003 Debate · 1
- Public Services Debate · 175
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Air Travel First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Emergency Workers (Protection) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Drink Driving First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Scottish Enterprise First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Biodiversity Action Plan Questions · 6
- Postwatch Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Animal Transport Regulations Questions · 9
- Central Heating Scheme Questions · 10
- Draft Nuclear Sites and Radioactive Substances Bill Questions · 6
- Single Transferable Vote Questions · 10
- Transport Links (Ayrshire) Questions · 4
- Shop Workers (Christmas Day Working) Questions · 4
- Teachers' Pay and Conditions Questions · 6
- Corporate Culpable Homicide Questions · 4
- M74 Extension (Public Inquiry) Questions · 4
- Maternity Care Questions · 9
- Renfrewshire Schools (Public-private Partnership Project) Questions · 6
- Area Tourist Boards Questions · 5
- Debt Recovery (Bank Arrestment) Questions · 4
- Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill: Preliminary Stage Bill debate · 44
- Decision Time Decision time · 17
- Speed Limits around Schools Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.