To ask the Scottish Executive what steps are being taken to measure the impact of the decline in Scotland's population. (S2O-843)
Official Report · Chamber
Population Decline
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Andy Kerr Lab 5
- Richard Lochhead SNP 2
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
- Mike Watson Lab 1
- Jamie Stone LD 1
- George Reid 1
The record
11 contributionsThe Executive is considering the challenges that population decline poses for Scottish society and we are analysing the impact of the long-term demographic trends on public service delivery and the economy. That means that we are looking at the projections that the General Register Office for Scotland has made and their implications for service delivery to different age groups, the spatial impact of population change and what will happen to the skills base of the economy.
I am delighted to hear that the minister has read the explosive and worrying document that the Registrar General for Scotland issued earlier this year. The document states:
"Scotland, unlike other countries in the European Union, is currently experiencing overall population decline."
Does the minister agree with the Registrar General that population decline is
"often regarded as being symptomatic of poor economic performance".
Will the minister tell the chamber and Scotland why, in a devolved Scotland, young people and young families continue to emigrate overseas?
"Scotland, unlike other countries in the European Union, is currently experiencing overall population decline."
Does the minister agree with the Registrar General that population decline is
"often regarded as being symptomatic of poor economic performance".
Will the minister tell the chamber and Scotland why, in a devolved Scotland, young people and young families continue to emigrate overseas?
As per normal, the facts and the statistics are all astray. Most advanced economies in Europe suffer from population decline. The First Minister launched the fresh talent initiative, which welcomes and attracts to Scotland people of talent who come here to study or people of talent who want to relocate their families and businesses to Scotland. The fresh talent initiative is supported by the business community and by the Scottish Council for Development and Industry, the Confederation of British Industry, the Federation of Small Businesses and many other organisations.
In addition, the European Commission's director general for justice and home affairs, who is perhaps a more astute observer of these matters, said:
"The Fresh Talent initiative announced earlier this year by the First Minister, Jack McConnell, is a good example of the kind of initiative which will help to attract and retain the new talent we need."
We should recognise the problem, but the report is not explosive. The problem will take 20-odd years to impact. The SNP's planning horizons may be different from everyone else's, but we have time to plan and to assess the impact on our economy and our communities. The spatial dimension of the issue means that we should include communities in the Highlands and more remote communities. The Executive knows about the issue and it will act to deal with the problem.
In addition, the European Commission's director general for justice and home affairs, who is perhaps a more astute observer of these matters, said:
"The Fresh Talent initiative announced earlier this year by the First Minister, Jack McConnell, is a good example of the kind of initiative which will help to attract and retain the new talent we need."
We should recognise the problem, but the report is not explosive. The problem will take 20-odd years to impact. The SNP's planning horizons may be different from everyone else's, but we have time to plan and to assess the impact on our economy and our communities. The spatial dimension of the issue means that we should include communities in the Highlands and more remote communities. The Executive knows about the issue and it will act to deal with the problem.
link
Given all the international evidence that points to a clear link between a low-tax, lightly regulated economy and a growing population—witness the examples of the United States of America, New Zealand and Singapore—will the minister outline what steps the Scottish Executive is taking to create a more business-friendly environment in Scotland?
In the environment that the Tories want to create, people who came to Scotland could not access health services because the Tories would have shut them all down; they could not access nursery places because the Tories would have closed them down; and they could not access proper education because the Tories would have closed that down. The £20 billion of cuts that the Tories said they would introduce as a result of their taxation policies would have no attraction for families who come to locate in Scotland or for students who come to study in Scotland. They would look around the horizon and see a Tory environment in which there were no public services for them and their families. That is not the way to attract new talent to Scotland.
Rather than dwell on the doom and gloom comments that Richard Lochhead makes on behalf of the SNP, about people flooding out of Scotland, I ask the minister to turn his attention to something rather more positive.
Given that a turnaround in the birth rate—even if we could achieve that—is a long-term objective that will take a few years to have effect, we should focus on short-term action. The minister mentioned the fresh talent initiative. Can he say where that initiative is going? Has he had any talks about it with the Home Office or other agencies? Given that the initiative will mean not only keeping Scots but bringing in people with skills and talents from other countries, how will he manage to decouple it from the hysteria that surrounds the issue of asylum seekers and refugees, which we have seen today?
Given that a turnaround in the birth rate—even if we could achieve that—is a long-term objective that will take a few years to have effect, we should focus on short-term action. The minister mentioned the fresh talent initiative. Can he say where that initiative is going? Has he had any talks about it with the Home Office or other agencies? Given that the initiative will mean not only keeping Scots but bringing in people with skills and talents from other countries, how will he manage to decouple it from the hysteria that surrounds the issue of asylum seekers and refugees, which we have seen today?
That is absolutely the point. The fresh talent initiative seeks to ensure that there is a one-stop shop for people who wish to come with their families to live in Scotland and for those who study in Scotland and wish to stay on in Scotland. That one-stop shop approach will operate throughout the public services and across devolved and reserved issues, such as visas and immigration. That will provide a benchmark for other nations to consider. They will see how Scotland is doing its job to ensure that we attract people from overseas.
In addition, I welcome the initiatives in the health service. For example, Glasgow Caledonian University has a Glasgow overseas professional in practice project, which will secure 50 people for the health service here in Scotland, who otherwise may not have chosen to settle in Scotland. That makes a real difference in enabling us to provide the first-class public services that we seek to provide.
In addition, I welcome the initiatives in the health service. For example, Glasgow Caledonian University has a Glasgow overseas professional in practice project, which will secure 50 people for the health service here in Scotland, who otherwise may not have chosen to settle in Scotland. That makes a real difference in enabling us to provide the first-class public services that we seek to provide.
The minister will realise that in remote areas in Scotland—including my constituency—we have huge problems getting health service professionals. He will also understand that the role played by immigrants from other countries has underpinned the health service in the past. Does he agree that targeting those people to work in rural areas would not only help to arrest the population decline, but would bring professionals to where they are needed in remote parts of Scotland?
First, I highlight the Executive's rural initiative policy and strategy, which reflects some of the population problems that Mr Stone mentions. Those problems clearly have an effect on sustainability issues within our communities.
On the member's second point, about attracting professionals, it is clear that the work of the fresh talent initiative and the Grampian NHS trusts is vital. The trusts are out there in the marketplace encouraging people from overseas to come to work in Scotland and people who are studying in Scotland to stay and rear their families in Scotland. We must make Scotland a welcoming place for those people and their families to ensure that they stay with us and provide much-needed public services.
On the member's second point, about attracting professionals, it is clear that the work of the fresh talent initiative and the Grampian NHS trusts is vital. The trusts are out there in the marketplace encouraging people from overseas to come to work in Scotland and people who are studying in Scotland to stay and rear their families in Scotland. We must make Scotland a welcoming place for those people and their families to ensure that they stay with us and provide much-needed public services.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Question 7 has been withdrawn.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Nov 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 27 November 2003 Debate · 1
- Violence Against Women Debate · 64
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Terrorism (Contingency Plans) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Objective 1 Funding (Highlands and Islands) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Fisheries First Minister’s Questions · 8
- M74 First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Renewable Energy (Targets) Questions · 4
- Animal Welfare Questions · 6
- Planning (Right of Appeal) Questions · 10
- Barrier-free Transport Questions · 6
- Dermatology Services Questions · 4
- Population Decline Questions · 11
- Acute Health Services (West Highlands) Questions · 10
- Equine Passports Questions · 4
- Scottish Opportunities Fund Questions · 8
- Transport Accessibility Audits Questions · 4
- Domestic Abuse Questions · 4
- Elections (Turnout) Questions · 6
- National Health Service (Dentists) Questions · 4
- Road Infrastructure (Funding) Questions · 8
- Renewable Energy (Targets) Questions · 9
- Physical Activity: The Need for Improvement and the Cost of Failure Debate · 48
- Business Motion Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 37
- World AIDS Day 2003 Members’ business · 21
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.