To ask the Scottish Executive when it intends to make a statement on its plans for the future of genetically modified crops. (S2O-663)
Official Report · Chamber
Genetically Modified Crops
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Allan Wilson Lab 4
- Iain Smith LD 2
- Mr Rob Gibson Highlands and Islands) (SNP 1
- Mark Ballard Green 1
The record
8 contributionsA statement will be made when we have had the opportunity to evaluate both the outcome of the dialogue on genetically modified crops and the advice from the Advisory Committee on Releases to the Environment on the implications of the farm-scale evaluation results.
Will the minister assure me that when decisions are being reached on the future of GM crops the precautionary principle will be rigorously applied? Will he take full account of the failure of the seed companies to provide pure samples for the recent trials in north-east Fife and elsewhere, which cast doubt on their ability to maintain separation of GM and non-GM materials? Will he also take full account of the recently published reports on the field trials, which suggest that farming methods associated with GM oil-seed rape are damaging to biodiversity?
I am pleased to give Iain Smith the assurances that he seeks. I go further and say that development of our future policy will be based on all the relevant information, including the outcome of the public debate to which he refers, the science review, the study on costs and benefits, and the results of the farm-scale evaluations, on which we will of course seek additional expert advice from ACRE prior to making any response. I suspect that a response will be made towards the end of the year or at the beginning of the new year.
Mr Rob Gibson
Highlands and Islands) (SNP
link
Does the minister agree that the delay and indecision that have followed the discussions on the GM issue during the summer are damaging to the clean image of food in Scotland? Will he make it possible for a case to be made to the European Union for a GM moratorium in Scotland as soon as possible, so that we can end the indecision?
No. I do not agree with any of that. Last night, I was in discussion with colleagues in the ministries in Wales, Northern Ireland and Westminster about the development of the policy, which will continue to be science based and will continue to constitute responsible policy making. I have had this conversation with Mr Gibson in the past. He knows that it would be contrary to the EU single market for any member state or any part of any member state to impose the type of restrictions that he would seek to impose on the development of GM technology in this country.
I remind the minister of EU directive 2001/18/EC, on the deliberate release into the environment of genetically modified organisms, which states:
"The competent authority should give its consent only after it has been satisfied that the release will be safe for human health and the environment."
Given the results of the science, will the Scottish Executive now state that it, as the competent authority, will follow that directive and not give consent for the release of genetically modified organisms?
"The competent authority should give its consent only after it has been satisfied that the release will be safe for human health and the environment."
Given the results of the science, will the Scottish Executive now state that it, as the competent authority, will follow that directive and not give consent for the release of genetically modified organisms?
That is an unproven case as yet. I said to Mr Smith and repeat to Mr Ballard that we will take expert advice from the scientific community on the outcome of the farm-scale evaluations. I make one observation in advance of that: given that, in coming to our decision, we will apply the European regulatory framework to which Mr Ballard refers, any decision that we take will protect human health and our environment. However, the outcome of the farm-scale evaluations demonstrated clearly that the worst as well as the best result for biodiversity was from conventional farming.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Oct 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 30 October 2003 Debate · 1
- Integrated Rural Development Debate · 79
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 24
- Local Government Finance Review First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Fireworks First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Concorde First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Cod Fishery (Closure) Questions · 8
- Maternity Services (Glasgow) Questions · 10
- Audiology Graduates Questions · 8
- Genetically Modified Crops Questions · 8
- East Lothian Schools Public-Private Partnership Questions · 8
- Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill (Remote Areas) Questions · 6
- Healthy Eating Questions · 6
- European Constitution Questions · 8
- Housing Grants (Water Supply) Questions · 4
- Maternity Services Questions · 4
- Police (Racism and Sectarianism) Questions · 4
- Scottish Forests (Support) Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Royal Infirmary (Generators) Questions · 5
- Point of Order Procedure · 8
- “Building Better Cities” Debate · 94
- Business Motion Business motions · 4
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 34
- European Week for Safety and Health Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.