To ask the Scottish Executive what criteria it will apply when assessing the business case produced to support a request for Executive funding of the Borders railway. (S2O-523)
Official Report · Chamber
Borders Railway
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicol Stephen LD 4
- David Mundell Con 2
- Jeremy Purvis LD 1
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
The record
8 contributionsThe business case will be assessed in accordance with the Scottish transport appraisal guidance.
Will the minister confirm that, in order to provide the funding, he will require a positive net present value, as he required in the case of all the roads that were approved under the strategic roads review?
The Scottish Executive is committed to supporting the construction of the Borders railway. We have already invested more than £2 million in the project by supporting the Waverley railway partnership. A bill is now before the Parliament and I hope that the project continues to make good progress. The Executive is committed to that.
The minister will be aware of the long-term strategic importance of the rail line to my constituents and I hope that a long-term view will be taken when the business case is considered.
The Tories' conversion to rail is rather novel. Can the minister tell the chamber how many rail projects were completed under 18 years of Tory rule compared with how many have been supported by the Executive?
The Tories' conversion to rail is rather novel. Can the minister tell the chamber how many rail projects were completed under 18 years of Tory rule compared with how many have been supported by the Executive?
"Very few" and "a lot" are the respective answers to those questions.
I have had a batch of written answers that tell me nothing about the criteria for assessing the business case for the Borders railway but are merely holding answers. Here is the minister's opportunity. I asked him which ScotRail routes would have passed the business case test that will be applied to the Waverley railway line, to which he answered:
"I shall reply to the member as soon as possible."—[Official Report, Written Answers, 1 October 2003.]
The time has come. Will the minister give me an answer?
"I shall reply to the member as soon as possible."—[Official Report, Written Answers, 1 October 2003.]
The time has come. Will the minister give me an answer?
It is obviously important—[Interruption.] I will give the written answer in due course. I still do not have the information that Christine Grahame requests, but I will give her a full and fair answer as soon as I have the information.
It is important that Christine Grahame realise that all projects now go to STAG appraisal, as it is called. It is important that we have a procedure for assessing a range of projects. [Interruption.] I am not sure whether she wants to hear the answer, because she continues to interrupt. It is important that we have a method of appraisal for all projects, whether they are road projects or public transport projects. We now have such a system. I hope that she will welcome that, and also the shift in emphasis that we are making towards public transport investment.
We are committed to supporting the Borders rail link. Christine Grahame should have been present in the chamber last night when her party's spokesperson on transport was less than whole-hearted in his commitment to the Borders rail link. I am confident that it will be this Executive rather than any SNP Administration that will deliver the Borders rail link for Scotland.
It is important that Christine Grahame realise that all projects now go to STAG appraisal, as it is called. It is important that we have a procedure for assessing a range of projects. [Interruption.] I am not sure whether she wants to hear the answer, because she continues to interrupt. It is important that we have a method of appraisal for all projects, whether they are road projects or public transport projects. We now have such a system. I hope that she will welcome that, and also the shift in emphasis that we are making towards public transport investment.
We are committed to supporting the Borders rail link. Christine Grahame should have been present in the chamber last night when her party's spokesperson on transport was less than whole-hearted in his commitment to the Borders rail link. I am confident that it will be this Executive rather than any SNP Administration that will deliver the Borders rail link for Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Oct 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 2 October 2003 Debate · 1
- Antisocial Behaviour Debate · 159
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet Sub-committee on Sustainable Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Digital Hearing Aids First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Hepatitis C First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Government Jobs (Dispersal) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Planning Questions · 10
- NFU Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Borders Railway Questions · 8
- Submarine Decommissioning Questions · 8
- European Union Justice and Home Affairs Council (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Respite Care Questions · 6
- Schools (Traffic Congestion) Questions · 6
- Electricity Generation (Renewable Sources) Questions · 6
- Strategic Rail Authority Funding Questions · 4
- Maybole Bypass Questions · 4
- Police Cover (Fife) Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Winter Pressures) Questions · 6
- Council Tax Questions · 4
- Emergency Contraception Questions · 7
- Antisocial Behaviour Debate · 82
- Business Motion Business motions · 8
- Private Escorting of Abnormal Loads Members’ business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.