Good morning and welcome to this meeting of the Education Committee. We continue our consideration of the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill. I remind people to switch off mobile phones and anything else that makes a noise. I declare a possible interest in legal aid matters because of my membership of the Law Society of Scotland and my consultancy with Ross Harper Solicitors of Glasgow.
Official Report · Committee
Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Robert Brown LD 136
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 38
- Euan Robson LD 32
- Ken Macintosh Lab 17
- Elaine Murray Lab 10
- Rosemary Byrne SSP 7
- Adam Ingram SNP 4
- Rhona Brankin Lab 4
- Wendy Alexander Lab 2
- Martin Verity Clerk 1
- Brian Adam SNP 1
The record
448 contributions · showing 1–200Section 13—References to Tribunal in relation to co-ordinated support plan
Amendment 269, in my name, is grouped with amendments 258, 270, 261, 267 and 268.This group of amendments deals with the tribunal issue, with which amendments to earlier sections also dealt. I have tried to do two things with the amendments in the group. First, amendment 261 would give Scottish ministers powers to extend by statutory instrument at a later point, if they are so minded, the categories that can go to the tribunal. I am conscious that officials are worried that, if we go too far in that direction, there will be a flood of people coming into the tribunal and that that will mean that resources are diverted to it that should be spent on dealing with the major issues of substance. Nevertheless, I feel that the fears in this regard, particularly in relation to the efficacy of the mediation and advocacy arrangements that are proposed by the ministry and the arrangements at the school level, are overstated. Therefore, I want to give ministers the power to propose extensions if they are minded to do so in the light of the tribunal's experience.Secondly, amendments 269 and 258 are designed to deal with a particular source of difficulty that the committee has discussed a number of times; they seek to extend slightly the tribunal jurisdiction to deal with some of the people who would not have a co-ordinated support plan. Although it is fair to say that the co-ordination issue has been identified by the committee and ministers as crucial, it is also fair to say that the issue sits side-on to the complex situations that are the central point of the bill. I have always felt that, while co-ordination of services is important, it is not the only issue that we have to deal with in this context.Although amendment 269 is in a format of my own, it follows a suggestion by Children in Scotland and linked groups that we should deal with the cases involving a child who would require a co-ordinated support plan were it not for the fact that his or her additional support needs could be met by the education authority exercising its functions relating to education alone. The amendment relates to the arrangements for additional support in that particular situation and attempts to open them up, not hugely, but to a point at which additional support would be provided for children in situations in which co-ordination with services outwith the education department is not needed.Amendment 269 is slightly different from a similar amendment that I lodged earlier. I made that change because I wanted to put more focus on the system. The central part of the amendment is contained in the words:"failure by an education authority to make adequate or efficient provision".That is slightly more satisfactory than the original amendment.I am conscious that most of the cases that go to the tribunal relate to decisions on whether or not to have a plan. When people fall short of the requirements for the issue of a co-ordinated support plan, of course, there will be no plan as such, although there will be paperwork of various sorts that will back up the situation.While amendment 269 would open up the situation, amendment 258 attempts to control the flow through the tribunal in one of the many ways in which that could be done. It would give the president of the tribunal a sift power to identify whether a substantial issue is involved and give ministers the power to determine, by statutory instrument, what a substantial issue is. That is quite an important matter, as it would enable a debate on what "substantial" means in this context. Amendment 267 would allow the particular circumstances or factors that can give rise to a substantial issue to be identified.Amendment 269 would open up the situation to a modest extent and amendments 258 and 267 would create a power to control the tap. I know that all sorts of issues arise from my amendments, but the central matter is that the right to have a civil remedy—an application to a tribunal in certain limited situations—is extremely important. The inclusion of that right will reassure many people who might otherwise be concerned about the bill.This is a complex and difficult area with which the committee has grappled from the beginning. I hope that the amendments will commend themselves to the minister and the committee. I think that they provide a reasonable way of tackling people's concerns in this area without opening up the floodgates.I move amendment 269.
I wonder whether you could flesh out a little bit the reasoning behind amendment 261, which seems to suggest the weakening or watering down of the powers of the tribunal in favour of ministers in the first place and the president—who will have the powers to reject an application—in the second place. Will you explain that?
I am opposed to this group of amendments for a variety of reasons. The main reason for my opposition is that the amendments propose the extension of the tribunal system, which I think is fundamentally the wrong thing to do. We need to ensure that the bill does not over-legalise the system and I am very concerned about the fact that the amendments in question would do that.I disagree fundamentally with any change to the criteria that determine whether a young person is entitled to a co-ordinated support plan. That relates to the whole area of the involvement of agencies that are outside education. Changing that would fundamentally change, and in some ways undermine, what underpins the bill.I think that it would be very unwise to give the tribunal's president the sift powers, as that might serve to gum up and create a pinch point in the system, which would prevent it from working as effectively as it should for the very young people whom the tribunal is designed to help. There would be a negative effect on those young people.
I have quite a bit of sympathy with the substance of the amendments, in that we are well aware of the concerns of people whose children had a record of needs or would have qualified for a record of needs. They now do not have the comfort of having the piece of paper. I, too, had discussions with Children in Scotland about possible amendments, because it is very important that those issues, which are central to people's fears, are discussed and addressed in a way that gives people comfort. I have considerable sympathy with what this group of amendments tries to achieve.That said, I also have some niggling doubts. I feel that the definition of who will have a CSP and who will not is quite clear, because the bill says that another outside agency must be involved. If that clarity were taken away, as amendment 269 would do, there could be a lot of discussion about who would have had a CSP if they did not have support from outside. I am concerned about the fact that the proposed change would make it much more difficult to pinpoint who had the right of appeal.I am concerned about the wording of amendment 269. The phrase"failure … to make adequate or efficient provision"appears to be an either/or—it seems to be saying that the education authority can make adequate provision or it can make efficient provision. If provision were adequate, it would have to be efficient. I have a niggle about that wording.I am less keen on the idea of the president having a sift power; I have more sympathy for amendment 269's aim of giving comfort to those people whose children had a record of needs or would have had a record of needs. I am not terribly keen on the idea of the president having such a power for some of the reasons that Rhona Brankin outlined and because of the question of what would happen if a parent did not agree with the tribunal president's rejection. Would the parents take the president to judicial review over their decision making? There would be many problems associated with people who were unhappy with the president's decisions. I will be interested to hear what other members and the minister say on that.
I have sympathy with the intention behind the amendments in the group, because I have a strong preference for widening access to the tribunal. It is important that Children in Scotland supports the principle of the amendments.
Amendments 269 and 258, which are the two substantial amendments in the group, would extend the powers of the tribunal to allow it to consider cases beyond those that qualify because a child has additional needs that require a co-ordinated support plan. As I suggested last week, I am sympathetic to both amendments.As all of us are aware, many parents and families, particularly those who have had to contest the opening of a record of needs for their children, believe that access to the tribunal is the only guarantee of their rights, or at least the only effective replacement of the record of needs system as a way of enforcing their rights. Although the Executive has done much to reassure all families who have children with additional support needs that their needs will be met, including the introduction of a dispute resolution process at local authority level, to my mind, it would be more efficient, more consistent throughout Scotland and more satisfactory if one tribunal system handled all cases that required dispute resolution.I hope that when the bill comes into force, it will succeed in reducing confrontation between families and local authorities and that the tribunal will be able to manage the number of cases in which disputes arise. If that happens, I see no difficulty in extending the powers of the tribunal at that stage to encompass more than just children who require a co-ordinated support plan. I am interested in hearing the minister's response, but I am minded to support amendment 261 and any consequential amendments.On the face of it, I am attracted to the idea behind amendments 269 and 258, that we should draw the line on access to the tribunal not at those who require co-ordinated support from different agencies but at those who have the most complex needs. I am also attracted to the idea that we should give powers to the president of the tribunal to use his or her discretion in granting leave to appeal. However, I have several worries about that approach. I am not keen on introducing more judgment or discretion into what will already be a relatively complex system. Although hard-and-fast rules on access to a tribunal can sometimes be harsh in their application, they have the advantage of transparency and simplicity. It would be wrong to encourage parents to think that they might be able to appeal, when that is unlikely to happen.There is no certainty about the numbers that might be involved. Although, as I said, I hope that disputes will be less common and that the tribunal system will be able to cope with them all, we do not know that that is what will happen. As the establishment of the new rights may have the perverse effect of increasing demand and the number of disputes, it is right that the tribunal should concentrate on the complex and co-ordinated needs of the most vulnerable and needy.I am anxious that we do not repeat the mistakes of the record of needs system. Despite the best intentions behind that system when it was introduced, for many people, the record of needs became a device to secure resources or to ensure that their child's needs were addressed. The bill will break that link by extending extensive new rights to all parents of children with additional needs, not just to a select few, even if they are the most vulnerable. The bill will also impose a range of new duties and responsibilities on local authorities and it will be backed up with substantial new resources, although that is not mentioned in the bill. The issue of resources is clearly a source of problems for many families.Fundamentally, we are trying to establish a new pattern of relationships between families and local authorities. I hope and believe that we will be successful, but we need to give the system a chance. I am concerned that if we agree to amendments 269 and 258, we will be the authors of our own misfortune by introducing an element of discretion and by almost encouraging parents to look to the tribunal, as they did with the record of needs system. I welcome the minister's comments on the matter, which is difficult and goes to the heart of many of the committee's anxieties about the bill.The committee should already be thinking about using its powers of post-legislative scrutiny to return to the matter after the bill has been enacted to find out whether it is having the desired effect. At that stage, we could use the powers that have been suggested in Robert Brown's amendment 261. That is the way in which to assuage parents' anxieties on the matter.
I have much sympathy with what Ken Macintosh said. I also have much sympathy with Robert Brown's amendments in this group, which I will probably support. However, I will be interested in hearing the minister's clarification of what the future holds for the tribunal system.Like Ken Macintosh, I believe that there should be a universal tribunal system to which everybody would have access. We should continue to seek to attain that ideal. What we have created so far is an adversarial system. We are tinkering around the edges to try to fix something that is fundamentally flawed, and it will be difficult for the tribunal system to work; there will be queues of people who will want to challenge it. If the system goes through as it is, I will be interested to see how it progresses. I hope that we can revisit the issue at stage 3 and try to do something more than just tinker around the edges. I intend to support amendment 269, because I believe that, although it does not go far enough, it is a step in the right direction.I gave examples at our previous meeting of the English tribunal system and its difficulties. Eighty-three per cent of those in England and Wales who take a case to a tribunal win their cases. The figure for cases that are settled at the last minute before a tribunal sits is an indication of how parents' concerns are not being addressed in England and Wales. I am concerned that the situation will be no better in Scotland.We must be aware that the issue of children with autistic spectrum disorder is going to get bigger. There is a growing population of such young people, but only patchy resources to deal with them. In England and Wales, more and more people are going to tribunals to get autism-specific education for their children instead of autism-friendly education and I believe that we will move in that direction in Scotland. I am aware of a number of cases here that are similar to those in England. I do not believe that the tribunal system will deal with such cases efficiently or effectively. Therefore, although I have grave concerns about the tribunal system, I will support Robert Brown's amendments.
First, I understand the concern that members have voiced and the genuine nature of the concern that members seek to address. The Executive has given a great deal of thought to the tribunal area, but we do not consider that it would be necessary to refer the matters under discussion to a tribunal in the way in which the amendments propose. In colloquial terms, amendment 269 appears to open the door wide and amendment 258 seems to close it again. In essence, amendments 269 and 258 seek to give a right of referral to a tribunal to a group of children and young persons who would not meet all the criteria for a CSP, who are those who do not need significant additional support to be provided from outwith the education authority.In a sense, we are returning to earlier debates on amendments that sought to remove the need for co-ordination, when it was accepted that co-ordination will be a central element in targeting those with the most extensive needs. The tribunal system fits into that particular pattern, if you like. Members will recall that, in response to the committee's concerns about those with additional support needs who would not qualify for a CSP, we made clearer with amendment 63 the explicit duty on education authorities to make additional and efficient provision for children's additional support needs. I believe that that amendment was generally welcomed.Members will note that we have lodged amendment 248, which is on specific transitional arrangements for those who have a record of needs. Those transitional arrangements are likely to cover a lot of the cases at which amendment 269 and related amendments are targeted. Amendment 248 will offer extra protection to safeguard the provision that is made for those particular children and young people.Amendments 269, 258, 267 and 270 would change fundamentally the role of the tribunals, because they imply that tribunals would monitor service delivery. We have been clear all along that we do not see the tribunals monitoring services at all.We have been through this before. As I explained last week, sufficient mechanisms are in place to allow parents and young people to raise concerns about the additional support that is provided: there is Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education, the powers of direction in the bill, the section 70 complaint route, and the mediation and dispute resolution arrangements. We could look at a system beyond dispute resolution arrangements, but that would add a level of cumbersome administration.As was the case with amendments last week, the problem with amendment 269 is that it is not clear what amounts to "failure". I know that that is described in other parts of the bill, but there may be difficulty in interpreting what is meant by a failure in this particular context. A further difficulty with amendment 269 is how the individuals who fall into the group that is mentioned in the amendment will know who they are, when there is no duty on the education authority to establish who they are. Likewise, with amendment 258, how will the president of the tribunal know who they are? How will the president conduct the sift, on which criteria will it be based, and what will happen if there is disagreement over the president's sift?The fundamental point is that we should focus on those who are most vulnerable and most in need, and we will do that through the mechanism of co-ordination, as I described. The amendments in the group would introduce a different element into the equation. That goes back to an argument that we have had already.On amendment 261 and consequential amendment 268, the committee has already raised the presentational difficulties that are involved in embarking on a new system. However, in effect, amendment 261 would send a message that the new system will not be sufficient to meet the needs and concerns of all its users. As I indicated, I do not believe that monitoring service delivery is a matter for tribunals, but there we are.Amendments 261 and 268 would perhaps undermine the safeguards that exist in the system to resolve disputes over service provision, such as mediation and dispute resolution and the other avenues that I mentioned. They could undermine parents' confidence in the new system, and lead to an element of confusion. Expectations could be raised that ministers would soon use the powers to extend the tribunals, but that is not ministers' intention. As I said when resisting similar amendments, I am not minded to extend the tribunals. I appreciate that giving ministers such powers may appear to offer flexibility in the longer term to avoid further primary legislation. However, if a system is to be radically altered, Parliament should have the opportunity to debate it fully, so primary legislation is probably the more appropriate route. I appreciate that consultation on regulations would provide such an opportunity, but if we were to make a fundamental change in some years' time, the primary legislative route would be more appropriate for it.I stand to be corrected, but I think that the Subordinate Legislation Committee has been generally concerned about granting powers to ministers. When such powers are necessary, they should be granted, but as I said, I see no need for the powers that amendment 261 would offer.The most important point is that amendment 261 would send out the wrong message about the system because it suggests that confidence in the system is lacking. If the system needs to be changed in years to come, it would be better to have another debate and further primary legislation, which would cover all the issues fully.We can consider those matters further before stage 3, but we ask the committee to reject all the amendments in the group.
I shall sum up the debate, which raised many complex issues. I thank everybody who spoke in the debate. Everyone has a genuine view and valid points were made from all parts of the spectrum. I will do my best to take account of those points.A difficulty arises because, way back at the beginning, the tribunal was named the additional support needs tribunal. It will deal only with co-ordinated support plans, so if confused messages are being sent out, that name sends out a big confused message from the Administration.I accept and welcome amendment 248, which deals to a significant extent with the record of needs position. Of course, that amendment relates to those who have records of needs now. The main issue concerns those who would have had records of needs and been in difficulty in the future, but who will not have co-ordinated support plans under the new system. I remain of the view that it is important to deal with that issue.The minister mentioned several administrative methods of dealing with matters, through the use of section 70 of the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 or through Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education, for example. There is often stress between administrative and bureaucratic methods and procedures that are stimulated by individual rights of reference or appeal. The general system that my amendments would create echoes what happens in the legal system when application is made to a sheriff for leave to appeal in some situations. I have tried to replicate that in the arrangement with the president of the tribunal—the equivalent of the court. I accept that the bill's intention is to avoid confrontation—I hope that it succeeds in doing that—and to deal with matters at school level, or, failing that, through mediation or advocacy, rather than people having to go anywhere near a tribunal. I am fairly confident that, under the bill, many cases will not go to tribunals.The minister made several points that I do not altogether accept. He asked what the word "failure" means. The bill uses the word "failure" in one or two categories of appeal, so I do not regard the minister's point as a substantial objection to the word's use in my amendments.The minister says that no duty is placed on the education authority to establish who falls short of the requirements for co-ordinated support plans. That is not really the case, because under section 3, every education authority is obliged to put in place arrangements for identifying people who have additional support needs. A process of assessment accompanies that. Although the formal plan that a CSP requires is not needed, the process still needs to be followed.The minister asked how the president of the tribunal would conduct the sift. I have tried to show in amendment 258 that only a substantial issue would be sufficient. In addition, ministers would be able to define "substantial" and determine the substantial issues that must be taken account of. In most respects, it would be in ministers' hands to try to make clear to the president of the tribunal exactly how that would work.I do not totally accept that the current arrangements are as clear-cut in practice as Ken Macintosh suggests. I understand what he is getting at and I entirely accept his point, but the question of who gets a co-ordinated support plan is linked to the question of who receives resources from outside the education authority—whether such resources are provided by the health board, the social work department, or another body, either for an educational purpose or for another purpose. That will clearly be a significant issue in relation to whether people take their cases to the tribunal in the context that we are talking about. There will be a lot of appeals anyway, simply because people with borderline cases who are dissatisfied might want to take their cases further. If anything, amendment 258 would give greater clarity about the circumstances in which appeals could go forward. Of course, there will be a settling-down period after the bill is passed, as there is with any bill, before we undertake any post-legislative scrutiny.I will try to deal with one or two of the additional points that members made. Rhona Brankin mentioned over-legalisation. The committee has worried about that from the start and I entirely accept her point. However, I do not think that the amendments would lead to over-legalisation; amendment 269, in particular, is an amended version of a proposal that I brought forward and then changed to deal with that very point. Amendment 269 refers to the"failure by an education authority to make adequate or efficient provision for such additional support".In other words, the focus would be on provision, not on support.Although I accept that an issue of resources always lurks behind such amendments—and behind the bill's wording about who will or will not get a CSP—that issue is, as the bill is currently phrased, at second hand. The tribunal will not deal directly with resource issues, and nor would it if amendment 269 were agreed to, given the way in which the amendment is phrased.Elaine Murray questioned the use of "or" in the phrase "adequate or efficient" in amendment 269. Oddly enough, the wording in my original version of amendment 269 was "adequate and efficient", because I was trying to reflect the wording of section 3(1)(b), but I was advised by the clerks that the amendment would be clearer if the wording was "adequate or efficient". If the wording was "adequate and efficient", there might be no appeals at all, because both requirements would have to come into play. There is a considerable degree of overlap, as we know from earlier debates, but I think that "adequate or efficient" is probably the right phrase.Ken Macintosh made a number of important points, some of which I have dealt with, about the need to reduce confrontation and about the tribunal system. Like him, I confess that I have qualms about whether the dispute resolution mechanism will be effective or just cumbersome. In lodging the amendments, I am trying to make the references to the tribunal clearer in limited and key areas, to prevent people from becoming entrammelled in what might be a confrontation-producing system, which might be the case if references were made to the tribunal at an earlier stage in some sort of local authority system. I am conscious that it is important not to increase demand, so I have tried to put in place a number of locks, so that the general principle that would be set out would apply only to the very limited number of people who would not have a co-ordinated support plan but who had some element of complex or multiple needs. The principle would be in place and ministers would have the power to define "substantial" issues.I know that ministers are concerned that judicial review actions might be raised by people who were dissatisfied with decisions of the president of the tribunal. However, such actions could also be raised in relation to, for example, the local authority's earlier decisions and to ministers' decisions. Judicial review is not a catch-all that anyone can initiate; the number of judicial reviews is not huge across the board of all the matters in relation to which such actions can be raised. There must be substance to the case and petitioners must be able to point out an administrative deficiency or other cause for raising the action. In practice, most people would probably need legal aid to do that and legal aid would not be granted to pursue an issue unless there was a probable or substantial cause.Adam Ingram raised some points about amendment 261, which seeks to extend the tribunal's powers. I did not quite follow his argument that such a provision would weaken the tribunal's powers; indeed, it would not affect the tribunal's existing powers at all, unless ministers decided to exercise it. However, if experience showed that there was a need to fill gaps, the provision would allow ministers to extend the tribunal's powers without having to come back to Parliament with further legislation on the matter. In any case, that would be unlikely to happen. Unlike some arrangements for giving ministers additional powers, these powers would extend civil rights, which means that they contain less of an element that could be criticised.As any proposal to extend the powers in question would have to be the subject of consultation with the committee under the usual subordinate legislation arrangements, there would be a debate about the matter. The closest parallel that I can think of is the provision in the Homelessness etc (Scotland) Bill, which I dealt with as a member of the Social Justice Committee in the previous parliamentary session, to give ministers the power to extend the categories of people who had priority. Although similar concerns were raised about that provision, the Social Justice Committee felt that it was the appropriate way of dealing with the matter. For all those reasons, I feel that the ministerial objections to my amendments are not well founded.I want to raise a broader point about the substance of the bill. I am well aware that, as our consideration of the bill has continued, we have struggled to keep our focus on the people with the greatest needs. I do not think that my amendments go against that intention; they simply widen very slightly the categories of such people and try to address the fact that the co-ordination element of the bill, although central and important, is not the only way of defining the areas in which people might have major problems and might be in conflict with the system.I have listened to other members' arguments on their amendments that seek to widen the tribunal's jurisdiction. However, I want to find the fulcrum that ensures that committee members' views and the views that we have heard in evidence on both sides of the argument are taken into account. As a result, I am suggesting a modest extension of powers that will not overwhelm the system or add hugely to the numbers of people who go to the tribunal. Inserting such a provision into the bill would give some comfort to quite a number of people who would be affected not so much by the legislation itself but by the very difficult circumstances in which they find themselves. As a result, I intend to press amendment 269, to move the associated amendments and to move amendment 261, on the extension of the tribunal's powers.The question is, that amendment 269 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 5, Against 4, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 269 agreed to.
Amendment 34 not moved.
Amendments 87 and 88 moved—Euan Robson—and agreed to.
Amendment 228 moved—Ms Rosemary Byrne.
The question is, that amendment 228 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 228 disagreed to.
Amendment 35 not moved.
Amendment 138 moved—Ms Rosemary Byrne.
The question is, that amendment 138 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 138 disagreed to.
Amendment 89 moved—Euan Robson—and agreed to.
Amendment 107, in the name of Fiona Hyslop, has already been debated with amendment 225. I should have said at the beginning of the meeting that we have received apologies from Fiona Hyslop and that we are pleased to welcome Brian Adam.
Amendment 107 moved—Mr Adam Ingram.
The question is, that amendment 107 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
Division list (how members voted)
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)The Convener: The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 107 disagreed to.
Donald Gorrie cannot be with us, but I think that he said that he would not press amendment 139.
Amendment 139 not moved.
Amendment 258 moved—Robert Brown.
The question is, that amendment 258 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
Division list (how members voted)
ForBrown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)AgainstAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Alexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)The Convener: The result of the division is: For 3, Against 6, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 258 disagreed to.
Amendment 36 not moved.
Amendment 237 moved—Euan Robson—and agreed to.
Amendment 259, which is in my name, is in a group on its own.Amendment 259 is designed to deal with the awkward issue of the anomaly that we identified in respect of legal aid and placement requests. To put matters simply, with ordinary placement requests for children who are not involved with additional support needs or anything of that sort, legal aid is available to take the reference to the sheriff, who will eventually make the decision. In respect of people applying with an additional support needs issue, the bill provides for that issue to go to the tribunal, where, of course, there is no legal aid. I think that the committee supported there being no legal aid in that area, but the consequence is an anomaly, in that people with perhaps a simpler and more straightforward placement request would get legal aid whereas people in more complex situations would not. I think that the minister and the committee have recognised the difficulty.The amendment is an attempt—and I put it no higher than that—to try to deal with the matter, put such cases back to the sheriff and therefore open up the provision of legal aid where a complex or substantial legal issue arises. To some extent, the amendment is a probing amendment. I would be interested in the views of the minister and committee members as to whether there is a way of resolving the paradox, whether we must live with it, whether the format is acceptable for dealing with matters or whether members can suggest other mechanisms to progress the issue. There is a difficulty and I do not think that any arrangement is entirely satisfactory.I move amendment 259.
I welcome the convener's comments and whole-heartedly endorse the intentions behind amendment 259. However, like him, I am not sure whether the amendment introduces further weaknesses or anomalies. We have repeatedly raised the issue in the committee and I hope that the Executive will find a way out of the problem for us.We have the possibility of an uneven system in which families will have to balance the more sympathetic approach that a tribunal will offer with the harshness of the court system, under which they might be granted legal aid. I would be concerned if that choice encouraged parents to choose one route over the other—that would unnecessarily and unfairly increase expense and it might produce different results in different cases. I would welcome the minister's comments on whether the issue is resolvable and whether amendment 259 is the way to resolve it.
There is a point of principle here. My understanding is that, under the present system, a considerable number of people can get legal aid if they apply to the sheriff in relation to placing requests. Under the provisions of the bill, if all such matters went to a tribunal, those people would not be able to get legal aid. Therefore, there is a problem with the bill's withdrawal of the right to legal aid. People who are entitled to legal aid should not be deprived of it. The matter should be addressed and I look forward to hearing what the minister has to say. Amendment 259 gives the tribunal the power to refer cases to the sheriff if the tribunal believes that to be the right course of action.
I agree that this is a complicated area and, again, it is an area to which the Executive has given consideration. I am afraid that amendment is technically defective. I appreciate that it is a probing amendment and I am happy to continue to consider the perceived difficulty before stage 3—I make those two points before saying anything else.During stage 1, Peter Peacock said that there is a perceived anomaly regarding the arrangements for appeals on refused placing requests, as a small number of them will be referred to the tribunal rather than to education authority appeal committees and then to the sheriff court. Consequently, for that small number, the possibility of legal aid for legal representation will not be available.The Executive's view is that because the school that the pupil with the CSP will attend is so intrinsically linked to the learning objectives and to the additional support provision required to achieve them, appeals on refused placing requests where there is a CSP—or a reference to the need for a CSP—are better dealt with by the tribunal. There is provision in section 14(5)(c) for a tribunal to refer such appeals to an education authority appeal committee in certain circumstances. That would be appropriate when there has been a dispute about whether a pupil requires a CSP and the tribunal finds that a CSP is not required. In other words, the placing request can be dealt with through the current appeal route for refused placing requests.Amendment 259, however, would allow the tribunal to refer any such appeal on a refused placing request direct to the sheriff where the tribunal considers there to be a likelihood of substantial legal or other complex issues and where the assistance of a solicitor or advocate would be in the best interests of the child or young person. The intention appears to be for the tribunal to consider that as a preliminary matter, and to consider the best interests of the child or young person irrespective of where the appeal rights lie and without any apparent consideration of how that will link into eligibility for legal aid. Frankly, it is not clear on what basis the tribunal would consider that substantial legal or complex issues could not be dealt with adequately by the tribunal itself. It is important to consider that the chair of the tribunal will be legally qualified—that is made clear—and that the complexities may well relate to the CSP.It appears that each proposed solution to rectify the perceived anomaly produces further anomalies, and Ken Macintosh has suggested that there may not be a way out of this particular situation. In amendment 259, the anomaly is that cases that are believed to raise complex matters requiring legal assistance will be referred to the sheriff court, yet the parties may not actually qualify for legal aid. They will be required to go directly to the sheriff court, missing the opportunity of going to the education authority appeal committee, which has the power to overturn the authority's decision and direct the child to be placed according to the request. The parties' right to have the matter decided by an expert tribunal will also be removed. So, in dealing with one anomaly, another appears to have been created.As I say, a technical issue also arises with amendment 259. It refers to"section 28F of the 1980 Act",which, in fact, will be disapplied under this bill in regard to those with additional support needs. The correct reference would be to schedule 2 to this bill.I appreciate both the intention behind amendment 259 and the convener's point that it is a probing amendment. However, the amendment is technically flawed and it does not, in the Executive's view, address the anomaly without creating a further anomaly. It is therefore not the appropriate solution.With those comments, and with the undertaking that we will continue to look into this matter—because I appreciate, as Peter Peacock said during stage 1, that there is a perceived anomaly—I finish by saying that we will try to address the matter for stage 3. However, as Ken Macintosh says, it might be a conundrum with no answer.
I am not sure that I accept that the reference in amendment 259 is technically wrong. The amendment intends that "the reference shall proceed as if it were an appeal to the sheriff under section 28F of the 1980 Act".That, of course, will continue to apply for non-additional support needs cases anyway.
Well—
However, I will not go into that particular technical issue.I am aware of the complexities and I am not entirely satisfied that amendment 259 is the way forward. It may be that advocacy provision is the key that will, as far as possible, square the circle. I had thought that the amendment was quite an elegant solution but I accept that it does not do the trick, so I will not press it.
Amendment 259, by agreement, withdrawn.
Amendments 37 to 40 not moved.
Section 13, as amended, agreed to.
Section 14—Powers of Tribunal in relation to reference
Amendment 41 moved—Lord James Douglas-Hamilton.
The question is, that amendment 41 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 41 disagreed to.
Amendment 270, in my name, has already been debated with amendment 269. I think that amendment 270 is consequential.
Is it consequential on amendment 269, amendment 258 or amendment 261?
Let me get this right. It is consequential on amendment 269.The question is, that amendment 270 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 5, Against 4, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 270 agreed to.
Amendment 108 not moved.
Amendment 53 moved—Mr Adam Ingram.
The question is, that amendment 53 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 53 disagreed to.
Amendments 42 and 43 not moved.
Amendment 140 moved—Ms Rosemary Byrne.
The question is, that amendment 140 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 140 disagreed to.
Amendment 260, in my name, is in a group on its own. The amendment is a probing amendment and suggests that a tribunal might have wider powers to order an education authority to arrange for an assessment or examination to be carried out, if appropriate, on such terms as the tribunal considered appropriate. The amendment is intended to deal with what I thought was a lacuna in the bill, but I would be interested to hear the minister's views on it. Clearly, tribunals will have to have powers—whether widened or not—to establish the basis on which they form their view. The issue is straightforward.I move amendment 260.
I support the amendment. I believe strongly that tribunals should have teeth. The amendment would give tribunals the option of ordering an education authority to arrange assessment or examinations, which in practice would give more rights to parents.
I sympathise with the intention behind the amendment, but I am not entirely sure whether it is necessary and whether such a specific provision needs to be made in the bill, rather than in a code of practice or regulations. I would welcome comments from the minister. I assume that tribunals have the powers to which the amendment refers and that those do not need to be stated here.
I want to make a similar point. The amendment is not necessary, because parents and professionals already have the right to request an assessment. I see the purpose of the amendment, but I doubt that it is necessary.
The amendment would tighten up an area about which there is much concern. The appearance at a tribunal of a child or young person may be due to the fact that what the local authority has put in place is not appropriate. Identification of the needs of the child through assessment may be necessary. The amendment is sensible and I support it.
I appreciate that amendment 260 is a probing amendment. I do not know the technical term for the absence of a lacuna, but we think that the amendment is unnecessary. We have already agreed to amendment 63, which makes it absolutely clear that an education authority has a duty to provide support and to meet the needs of each and every child and young person who has additional support needs. Education authorities will be required to have effective assessment and monitoring arrangements in place.In some referrals, tribunals may consider the evidence that was acquired through the assessment process by which education authorities reached their conclusions to be insufficient or flawed—for example, if a decision that a CSP is not required is not supported by the available evidence. In such circumstances, tribunals could overturn decisions and direct education authorities to carry out further assessments.I refer members to paragraph 11(2)(p) of schedule 1, on the rules of procedure, which will allow tribunals to commission medical and other reports in specified circumstances. We will set out those circumstances in the rules on procedure for tribunals. Amendment 260 is thus unnecessary, as the powers that it seeks are already provided for in schedule 1.
I accept what the minister has said. One should perhaps read the schedules with a fine-toothed comb, but I did not manage to do that. I will not press amendment 260.
Amendment 260, by agreement, withdrawn.
Amendment 238, in the name of the minister, is grouped with amendments 240, 241, 245, 246 and 247.
We lodged the amendments in this group to meet the Subordinate Legislation Committee's concerns that the code would be partly legislative in character rather than concerned with matters that are of a purely administrative or explanatory nature. The Subordinate Legislation Committee wanted the Executive to publish the code in such a way as to allow for parliamentary scrutiny, rather than merely issuing it to education authorities. Amendment 238 and the Executive amendments to section 23 will address that concern. I hope that the Education Committee will accept that we have tried to meet the Subordinate Legislation Committee's request.I move amendment 238.
I welcome the amendments, as they will help to clarify the duties of local authorities.
Amendment 238 agreed to.
Section 14, as amended, agreed to.
After section 14
Amendment 261 moved—Robert Brown.
The question is, that amendment 261 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 6, Against 3, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 261 agreed to.
Amendment 262 not moved.
Section 15—Appeal to Court of Session against Tribunal decision
Amendment 229, in the name of Lord James Douglas-Hamilton, is in a group on its own.
I should perhaps mention that I am a non-practising Queen's counsel.I lodged amendment 229 on behalf of a parent, but it deals with a matter of common sense. If the Court of Session is minded to allow an appeal, it should have the right to make interim provisions having regard to the best interests of the child. Such appeals should be dealt with speedily, but amendment 229 would clarify the position and put it beyond doubt.I move amendment 229.
We will resist amendment 229. If my understanding of what it seeks to achieve is correct, the amendment is unnecessary because the bill already makes provision for ancillary orders.As Lord James Douglas-Hamilton has explained, amendment 229 proposes to give the Court of Session the power to make such interim orders as it considers appropriate in cases in which it has decided the appeal in favour of the appellant. The amendment proposes that the criterion to be applied in exercising that power is what is in the best interests of the child or young person.However, an interim order is an order that the court makes pending the rights of parties being determined by the court, whereas amendment 229 wants that power to be available after the court has made its decision on the appeal. Frankly, that does not appear to be appropriate. The intention of the amendment may be to allow the court to make orders connected with its decision, but the bill already provides for the court to make ancillary orders.A further difficulty with the amendment is that it would give the Court of Session the power to make an interim order based on the interests of the child. However, how can the court know the best interests of the child when it is considering a legal argument on the question of law that is at issue?I hope that Lord James Douglas-Hamilton will withdraw his amendment on the basis that his concerns about ancillary orders are covered in the bill.
Does "ancillary" include "interim"? I inquire on behalf of the members of the committee.
I will need to take advice on the matter. With the indulgence of the convener, perhaps I can arrange for a civil servant to answer that technical question. It would be better for it to be answered at first hand.
I understand that the official is not allowed to speak. I am sorry.
Interim orders can be sought by the parties at the start of the appeal process.
Can I clarify a procedural point? I have never before encountered a case of a civil servant not being allowed to speak in committee.
I have to say that it seems very sensible that officials should be allowed to speak, but I have been advised otherwise.
I would like my civil servant to speak purely on the technical aspects of the matter, in case I get the legal position incorrect. I do not want to mislead the committee.
Only members can take part in a debate. The officials accompanying the minister are not present as witnesses as they would be if this were an inquiry or a stage 1 consideration. That does not prevent officials from giving advice to the minister.
I accept that the practice is not considered normal, but I suggest that we send a brief note to the Procedures Committee suggesting that it should examine the possibility of facilitating members' requests for clarification from an official at stage 2.
I agree. It seems nonsensical that we cannot receive guidance on technical issues at stage 2.
It may be appropriate to take a short break in proceedings at this point.
My officials have given me advice and I will try to explain it accurately, bearing in mind the procedural position. I understand that the parties can seek an interim order at the start of proceedings to maintain the status quo, in effect. Nothing in the bill suggests that that could not be the case. Would it be helpful for us to write to the committee on that point so that accurate advice can be put down in black and white? I am not familiar with the interim order procedure.
I do not want to press the minister unduly, as it is obvious that the matter is technical. Amendment 229 has been proposed because appeals may take some time to determine. There may be an urgent need in a particular case to get a preliminary decision to put in place interim measures to deal with a situation as it stands at that moment, before the case is determined. Complicated cases can sometimes take a long time. I want reassurance that the court can pass interim orders to ensure that the situation can be properly covered before the case is fully determined. The cases may be determined quickly, but I think that they are likely to take some time, as some of them will be complicated. I ask for a similar amendment to be lodged at stage 3.
I think that we have an undertaking from the minister to write to the committee about the issue. If I understand the matter correctly, we have considered the points that were raised. I am sorry to have caused devastation by asking the question.
The minister should issue his response before members have concluded their preparations for stage 3. The issue needs to be dealt with.
Forgive me. The situation is straightforward—I am not expert in that area of the law, so I would not want to say on the record anything that misled the committee or was inaccurate.
I am grateful. On that basis, Lord James, would you be prepared to withdraw amendment 229?
I think that it would be unworthy of me to press the amendment when the minister was in a state of possible confusion.
That slightly overstates the point, but thank you.
Amendment 229, by agreement, withdrawn.
Before we move on, I will take up Wendy Alexander's point. If the committee is so minded, I shall write to the Procedures Committee along the lines that she suggested. Is that agreed?
Members indicated agreement.
Section 15 agreed to.
After section 15
Amendment 255 moved—Ms Rosemary Byrne.
The question is, that amendment 255 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForByrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)AgainstAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Alexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 1, Against 8, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 255 disagreed to.
Before section 16
Amendment 90, in the name of Lord James Douglas-Hamilton, is in a group on its own.
Amendment 90 was lodged on behalf of the Scottish Human Services Trust and is supported by Children in Scotland, Barnardo's and Capability Scotland. There are four subsections to the section that amendment 90 proposes to introduce. The new section would give every child with additional support needs for whom school education is provided by the education authority the right of access to independent advocacy services. The amendment makes it clear that the service is independent from the involvement of the authority in question. Independent advocacy is important, as a Dutch uncle is needed to help to guide parents through the process of identifying whether their child requires additional support. The new section would help parents in an ever-increasing and daunting legalistic and burdensome process. Amendment 90 is a parent-friendly means of getting a balanced and happy agreement between parents and the local authority. It has widespread support—when lodging the amendment, I received words of encouragement from parents and from groups such as Barnardo's and Capability Scotland. In cost terms, it could save money, as it may resolve issues before they escalate to tribunals or mediation. I hope that the Executive will have the good will to accept this worthwhile amendment, which has widespread support and is based on nothing more than common sense and a desire for fair play. I move amendment 90.
I never thought of Lord James Douglas-Hamilton as somebody who went Dutch, but I am impressed by his reference. I have spoken several times about the need for independent advocacy and for general support services, at tribunals and throughout the system, to help parents and families in what has in the past been a confrontational system in which they have often been outnumbered and in need of such advice and support. I am not sure, but I believe that amendment 90 may be modelled on the section that was included in the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003, and I certainly have some sympathy with its intention. However, as I said at a previous meeting, I am slightly concerned that resources might be diverted into advocacy and away from front-line and direct services for children with additional support needs. That would make advocacy services extremely well funded, perhaps to the detriment of the support services. The minister offered us extensive reassurances, either last week or the week before, and undertook to consider various sections of the bill that could be amended at stage 3. I am certainly looking to the minister or to other members to lodge amendments to secure those rights without having to put in place the structure that Lord James Douglas-Hamilton is suggesting, despite my sympathy for his intentions.
I, too, have sympathy with the intentions of amendment 90, but I also have some concerns. The amendment seems almost as if it would regulate the independent advocacy services. Children with a spectrum of different needs could desire advocacy from a wide range of different providers, including people who specialise in certain support needs. The duties that the amendment would place on the providers of services could frighten people off or prevent the provision of other advocacy support, because it might be felt that providers would fall foul of the provisions in the new section. Although I have sympathy with the intention behind the amendment, I believe that, because of the way in which the new section is written, it could work to the detriment of the provision of advocacy.
The amendment is important for reassuring parents in particular about the bill. I cannot see how resources will be sucked away as Ken Macintosh suggests, but perhaps we can include some form of words to ensure that that does not happen. In restoring a balance between education authorities and parents, the introduction of independent advocacy, along the lines that the amendment proposes, is very much to be welcomed.
I agree. The amendment would in many ways minimise the adversarial approach that I was talking about earlier. If we are giving parents the right to ask for assessment, it makes a great deal of sense to enable them to access advocacy to help them to understand the process and what type of assessments they should seek. That could also prevent people from having to go to a tribunal. The amendment is very sensible and I hope that we can support it.
I do not support the amendment, although I understand where it is coming from. We have had quite a lot of reassurance from the minister on this tricky issue, which we will continue to discuss at stage 3. Subsection (4) of the proposed new section attempts to define what "independent" means. I am not sure that that is an entirely satisfactory definition or way forward. There is a view that advocacy services should be provided only outwith the local authority, but the amendment tries, not entirely successfully, to provide a more complex definition, which recognises that some advocacy services will be provided by the local authority. The matter should probably be dealt with in the code or in subordinate legislation, where we want a nod in favour of independence or Chinese walls. However, I do not think that the amendment is the solution and, for that technical reason, if nothing else, the amendment should not be supported.
I agree with the convener on the technical point that he has just made and I accept Ken Macintosh's important point about the desirability of putting resources into front-line services rather than into advocacy. I also agree with what Elaine Murray said. The Executive has said that it will lodge amendments at stage 3 for the purposes that I think I described at the previous meeting of the committee. Those amendments will make the position clearer. The amendment raises serious resource issues. There is nothing in the bill to prevent parents from contacting and seeking advice and assistance from a voluntary organisation that provides advocacy services. As members know, the Executive has indicated that it will put more money into supporting such organisations. With regard to the tribunal, it has always been the policy intent for parents to be able to have a supporter of their choice with them—that may indeed be somebody from an advocacy organisation, who may act as their representative. The committee ought to be very clear about the costing of the amendment. The right to advocacy that the amendment seeks to introduce is not targeted, so there is no limitation on its use. We must be realistic about the money involved. An unqualified right to advocacy effectively establishes a demand-led service rather than one driven by need. When the bill is amended at stage 3, it will be made perfectly clear that there is an adequate balance.
Is the minister saying that he will introduce an amendment at stage 3 in this regard?
To some extent, we have had this debate. I think that assurances—
Assurances were given in the context of the debate that we had earlier, although not in relation to this amendment.
In that case, I would like to go a little further, as it is necessary or highly desirable to have a provision in the bill that will reassure parents. I do not altogether accept the line of argument about costs, because I believe that resolving issues before they escalate to mediation and tribunals would save funds. I think that tribunals should be avoided wherever possible.
The question is, that amendment 90 be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForAdam, Brian (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Byrne, Ms Rosemary (South of Scotland) (SSP)Douglas-Hamilton, Lord James (Lothians) (Con)Ingram, Mr Adam (South of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstAlexander, Ms Wendy (Paisley North) (Lab)Brankin, Rhona (Midlothian) (Lab)Brown, Robert (Glasgow) (LD)Macintosh, Mr Kenneth (Eastwood) (Lab)Murray, Dr Elaine (Dumfries) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Amendment 90 disagreed to.
Section 16—Mediation services
Amendment 141, in the name of Donald Gorrie, is grouped with amendments 143, 146 and 148. I believe that amendment 141 relates to the issue of the interrelation between the education authority and the other agencies.As Donald Gorrie is not here today, I move amendment 141 on his behalf.
I am slightly unclear about this group of amendments. I believe that they are related to the next group of amendments, which is led by amendment 144, and that their aim is to prevent local authorities from being bodies that can provide mediation services, but I am not entirely sure that that is the case. We discussed the matter in committee and concluded that, although independence is an important concept and it is important that we maintain independence, local authorities should be able to provide independent services. I am not sure whether I am reading the amendments correctly, however.
I think that what you are saying applies to amendment 144, but I am not entirely sure how the other amendments fit in.
I believe that amendments 141, 143, 146 and 148 are, in effect, consequent on amendment 144, but I could be misreading them.
That was not how I read them. I thought that they were to do with widening powers in a slightly different way; however, you might be right. I do not support Donald Gorrie's amendment; I moved it purely for the purposes of debate.
I agree that there is confusion about the amendments, but I appreciate the intention behind them, which is to avoid or to resolve disagreements between parents and young people and agencies such as health boards. My difficulty with the amendments is that education authorities are responsible for establishing which young people have additional support needs and for making the necessary provision to meet those needs, either directly or with help from others and that, therefore, parents and young people will be concerned with education authorities' compliance with their obligations under the bill.It would be inappropriate for mediation arrangements that were made by an education authority to allow for resolution of disputes between parents and young persons and other agencies. Any agreement that was reached through mediation might conflict with, or be irrelevant to, the arrangements that education authorities make for complying with their statutory obligations. It will be for authorities to determine what arrangements for mediation they put in place. Where a disagreement with an education authority involves another agency, it will be in the authority's best interests to have a relevant officer or professional from that agency take part in the mediation discussions. Indeed, section 19 of the bill will allow the authority to request the help of other agencies in exercising any of its functions under the bill, and section 22 will place on education authorities a requirement to publish information about their mediation services, which will allow them the opportunity to set out how they would involve other agencies in situations in which their input was required.The amendments would introduce an element of confusion. It is not helpful or appropriate to be prescriptive in this regard and the bill has—in sections 19 and 22—the means by which to involve other agencies. For those reasons, the amendments are unnecessary, and I hope that they will not be pressed.
I am reassured by what the minister has said—provisions are in place to deal with the issue adequately. I am grateful to Donald Gorrie for raising the issue but, on his behalf, I seek to withdraw amendment 141.
Amendment 141, by agreement, withdrawn.
Amendments 142 and 143 not moved.
Amendment 144, in the name of Donald Gorrie, is grouped with amendment 57. Agreement to amendment 144 will pre-empt amendment 57.Ken Macintosh was right to say that amendment 144 seeks to avoid a local authority's being involved in providing mediation services. However, the committee and I took the view that that would be going too far, although we sympathised with the direction of the amendment. Therefore, although I will move amendment 144 for the purpose of debate, I do not altogether agree with its intention. I move amendment 144.
Amendment 57 seeks to strengthen the duty on local authorities by stating that they must carry out "any of their functions", and not just"their functions under this Act".Additional support needs will come under not just the bill, but under acts such as the Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Act 2000, therefore amendment 57 is appropriate.Amendment 144 returns to the familiar theme of placing duties on other agencies.
I have already argued against the measures in the wrong discussion.
On amendment 144, the bill is clear that if mediators are employed by an education authority, they must not be involved in identifying provision for children and young persons who have additional support needs. That requirement will provide the necessary safeguard for users while offering flexibility to authorities to purchase services from existing organisations, including those in the voluntary sector, or to provide the service directly.The requirement will also offer the opportunity for the service to fit in with existing services, and possibly to develop the service beyond the terms of the bill, for example to include children's services within the authority area. An authority will also be required to publish details of its arrangements; the code of practice will set out good practice in that area. For those general reasons, amendment 144 is not necessary.Lord James's amendment 57 seeks to ensure the independence of an education authority's mediation service. It is similar to amendment 144 and I resist it on the same basis. Its provisions would be unduly restrictive. It seeks to exclude from involvement in mediation services any staff who are employed by an authority, not just those who are involved in education. For example, a chief trading-standards officer or a surveyor who had nothing to do with the process would be excluded as a result of amendment 57, when they might be perfectly capable of providing mediation. In small authorities, where employment by the local authority accounts for a large proportion of employment in the area, it would be unnecessarily restrictive to exclude people who work in the local authority but have absolutely nothing to do with the education department. The code of practice will set out guidance in that area. I ask Lord James not to move amendment 57.
On Donald Gorrie's behalf, I will seek to withdraw amendment 144. However, it is important that there be adequate provision in the non-council or voluntary sector for the provision of assistance. There is an issue about the confidence of parents. Behind amendment 144 is a substantial issue, but the amendment would be the wrong way to deal with that issue because it is too prescriptive. On that basis, I will with the committee's agreement withdraw amendment 144.
Amendment 144, by agreement, withdrawn.
I do not wish to move amendment 57 at this stage, but we may need to return to the issue of firewalls at stage 3.
Amendment 57 not moved.
Amendments 145 to 147 not moved.
Amendment 239 moved—Euan Robson—and agreed to.
I was going to have a short break at this point, but as the coffee will arrive soon, I will delay the break for a while.Amendment 221, in the name of Lord James Douglas-Hamilton, is in a group on its own.
Amendment 221, which I lodged on behalf of Independent Special Education Advice, would introduce new subsections in section 16. If mediation is to be successful, we must have a binding agreement with a built-in termination clause that either party can access by giving sound reasons. If not, the system could easily be meaningless to many parents.Under amendment 221, if an agreement has been reached on conclusion of mediation, the agreement would be in writing—signed by both parties—and would be upheld by both parties until a written statement of discontinuation of the agreement and the reasons for that decision by either party had been sent to the other party.I move amendment 221.
I agree that, in most processes, agreements should be written down for the benefit of all to avoid misunderstanding, but I am not sure whether that is necessary in this case or whether it is normal procedure. I am not sure whether we should put such specific measures in legislation, as opposed to in the code of practice or in good-practice regulations.
I agree—the point is not unimportant, but it could be dealt with in the code of practice or regulations.
I am a little concerned about the idea that the agreement would be legally binding on the parents of the child in question.
To make the outcome of mediation legally binding is to turn mediation into arbitration, which is different. If the idea is to draw a conclusion to something, amendment 221 defeats its own purpose because it says:"but any party may revoke the agreement by notice in writing".In any event, we resist amendment 221 because we do not think that the concept of making the outcome of mediation legally binding is correct as it would alter the spirit of mediation per se.
I will not press amendment 221 at this stage. I will study what the minister has said with a view to deciding whether an amendment would be appropriate at stage 3.
Amendment 221, by agreement, withdrawn.
Amendment 148 not moved.
Section 16, as amended, agreed to.
I suspend the meeting for a 10-minute break.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Mar 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Education Committee Wednesday 10 March 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 448
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.