Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Consultation

Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 11 September 2003 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link
To ask the Scottish Executive what plans it has for a review of public consultation processes. (S2O-362)

Margaret Curran Lab The Minister for Communities · Glasgow Baillieston
link
The promotion of civic participation is a priority for the Scottish Executive. Reviews of Scottish Executive practice were carried out in 2000 and 2002. We have a programme of action to improve consultation practice within our changing to deliver programme of continuing organisational improvement and cultural change.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link
Will the minister take on board the views of organisations such as the Aberdeen Chamber of Commerce and voluntary groups such as pensioners forums and the Princess Royal Trust for Carers? Those organisations complain that consultation is becoming an increasingly intolerable burden on their limited financial resources. They feel that, in many instances, not enough time is given for them to make adequate submissions. They call for some degree of standardisation of consultation documents and, most important, they indicate that, in order to be meaningful, consultation by public bodies should be less frequent and more focused on issues of real importance to decision making.

Margaret Curran Lab The Minister for Communities · Glasgow Baillieston
link
If there were opportunities to standardise consultation processes so as to make them more efficient and effective, we would all very much welcome that and try to focus on it. It seems from my perspective, however, that we are sometimes damned if we do and damned if we don't. If we do not consult thoroughly and effectively, people will say that we are not consulting properly; if we consult thoroughly, people will say that we are consulting too much.

I understand that there is no magic or perfect solution, but we must always work to improve consultation processes to make them as effective as possible. That means listening to the voluntary sector, to groups of people such as pensioners, to the private sector, to industry and to local communities, which is important for getting things right in relation to health, for example. It also means accepting that we might have to customise consultation for those various groups' needs. From her question, I think that Mrs Milne appreciates that the matter is complex and that we must attempt to make steady progress.

Des McNulty Lab Clydebank and Milngavie
link
The minister will be aware of my concern about Scottish Water's past failures in consultation on planning matters. Scottish Water now has to produce a consultation code to cover consultation on major developments. Could that practice be adopted by other public organisations? Would not getting decisions right in the first place be a better route forward for planning matters than having to employ expensive methods of appeal?

Margaret Curran Lab The Minister for Communities · Glasgow Baillieston
link
I thank Des McNulty for that question. We should of course get all planning decisions right and, as I am sure I can convince him, we make every effort to do so. The proper mechanisms need to be in place to ensure that the decisions are right.

As Des McNulty knows, my colleague Ross Finnie has responsibility for Scottish Water. However, on the general point—and this answers Nanette Milne's point—we seek to examine different models of consultation and to remain open minded about the different possibilities. We are not wedded to one practice because it has been used in the past. We listen to complaints and criticism, so we can implement steady progress. I am sure that Ross Finnie will keep me up to date on progress with Scottish Water in that regard.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link
After the most extensive public consultation that it ever conducted, Forth Valley NHS Board reached a unanimous decision in favour of a new hospital at Larbert. However, some parochial politicians are now trying to intervene to overturn the result of that public consultation. Will the Scottish Executive resist those efforts and ensure that approval is granted as soon as possible for the building of the new hospital?

Margaret Curran Lab The Minister for Communities · Glasgow Baillieston
link
It would not be appropriate for me to comment on a health decision, but the member's question clearly demonstrates that consultation is not the answer to all ills; it can be conducted properly only when people appreciate that it is not entirely a substitute for policy decision making and assessment. Consultation must be viewed appropriately and in context at the time.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 11 September 2003 Debate · 1
  2. Asylum Seekers Debate · 168
  3. First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  4. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  5. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  6. Local Authorities (Facilities for Young People) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  7. Scottish Enterprise First Minister’s Questions · 6
  8. Holyrood Building Project (Inquiry) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  9. Borders Railway First Minister’s Questions · 14
  10. Drug Users (Treatment and Rehabilitation) Questions · 10
  11. Fireworks Questions · 6
  12. Edinburgh South Suburban Railway Questions · 6
  13. Physical Education (Students) Questions · 6
  14. Consultation Questions · 8
  15. Dentists Questions · 11
  16. Fire Service (Trade Unions) Questions · 8
  17. Scottish Opera Questions · 6
  18. Road Maintenance Questions · 4
  19. Health Funding (Orkney and Western Isles) Questions · 4
  20. Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department Questions · 4
  21. Sport and the Arts (Reducing Antisocial Behaviour) Questions · 6
  22. Economic Policies (North-east Scotland) Questions · 5
  23. Clyde Shipyards (Apprentices) Questions · 5
  24. Partnership Agreement (Funding) Statement · 94
  25. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  26. Legal Deposit Libraries Bill Bill debate · 8
  27. Business Motion Business motions · 36
  28. Decision Time Decision time · 23
  29. Obesity Members’ business · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.