To ask the Scottish Executive what its position is on protests on 29 May 2003 about the environmental effect of the testing of depleted uranium weapons at Dundrennan. (S2O-47)
Official Report · Chamber
Depleted Uranium Weapons Testing (Protests)
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 6
- Rosemary Byrne SSP 3
- George Reid 3
- Alex Fergusson Con 1
- Chris Ballance Green 1
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 1
The record
16 contributionsThe Scottish Executive respects the public's right to peaceful protest.
In the partnership agreement that they drew up, the two coalition party leaders stated that they would work
"to improve and sustain our environment",
to put
"environmental concerns at the heart of public policy"
and to secure
"environmental justice for all".
Given that the environment and health are devolved matters and in light of the Royal Society's 2002 report, which stated that there were areas of depleted uranium contamination that posed a risk to children and that there were areas that should be cleared of contamination—
"to improve and sustain our environment",
to put
"environmental concerns at the heart of public policy"
and to secure
"environmental justice for all".
Given that the environment and health are devolved matters and in light of the Royal Society's 2002 report, which stated that there were areas of depleted uranium contamination that posed a risk to children and that there were areas that should be cleared of contamination—
Members
link
Speech!
—will the minister give an undertaking to stop the test firing of depleted uranium shells at Dundrennan and will he initiate a clean-up project immediately?
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Before Mr Finnie replies, I should say that I will not allow questions of that length in future. I did so on this occasion because that was the member's first question.
The member is right to point to the substantial commitments to the environment that are contained in the partnership agreement—there is no way that we will renege on them. However, she makes a small error about the issue being wholly devolved. The legal framework relating to radioactive substances is the Radioactive Substances Act 1993, under which the Ministry of Defence—as the Crown—has an exemption. Therefore, the monitoring of the depleted uranium is conducted by the Secretary of State for Defence.
That is not entirely satisfactory for our being able to observe what happens in Scotland, but we have sought and obtained clear guidance that the Scottish Environment Protection Agency should satisfy itself that the procedures followed by the MOD are adequate—I am pleased to say that SEPA has done so. Furthermore, we recently received confirmation that the MOD will make arrangements for copies of its monitoring reports to be placed in the Scottish Parliament information centre. That will allow MSPs to arrive at an informed judgment about their contents.
That is not entirely satisfactory for our being able to observe what happens in Scotland, but we have sought and obtained clear guidance that the Scottish Environment Protection Agency should satisfy itself that the procedures followed by the MOD are adequate—I am pleased to say that SEPA has done so. Furthermore, we recently received confirmation that the MOD will make arrangements for copies of its monitoring reports to be placed in the Scottish Parliament information centre. That will allow MSPs to arrive at an informed judgment about their contents.
Although I would never want the right of an individual to demonstrate peacefully to be compromised, I refer the minister to an answer given by Dr Lewis Moonie in the House of Commons on 20 March 2002. He stated:
"Comprehensive environmental monitoring programmes have been in place at … Kirkcudbright ever since the beginning of the DU munitions trials announced in the House in 1979. These programmes have focused on the collection and analysis of samples of soil, vegetation, freshwater, seawater, seaweed, molluscs and seabed and shoreline sediments … This monitoring continues to show that DU does not pose a significant risk to members of the public or site personnel."—[Official Report, House of Commons, 20 March 2002; Vol 382, c 312W.]
Does the minister agree that, as no significant risk has been detected for 24 years, the Royal Society's assessment of the health effects of depleted uranium—that the risks are very low—is entirely correct and that that renders the need for demonstrations such as the one taking place in my constituency entirely unnecessary?
"Comprehensive environmental monitoring programmes have been in place at … Kirkcudbright ever since the beginning of the DU munitions trials announced in the House in 1979. These programmes have focused on the collection and analysis of samples of soil, vegetation, freshwater, seawater, seaweed, molluscs and seabed and shoreline sediments … This monitoring continues to show that DU does not pose a significant risk to members of the public or site personnel."—[Official Report, House of Commons, 20 March 2002; Vol 382, c 312W.]
Does the minister agree that, as no significant risk has been detected for 24 years, the Royal Society's assessment of the health effects of depleted uranium—that the risks are very low—is entirely correct and that that renders the need for demonstrations such as the one taking place in my constituency entirely unnecessary?
The questions are not getting any shorter, are they, Presiding Officer?
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Let us try with the answer.
I do not think that the state of play on any subject in any way detracts from an individual's civil-libertarian right to protest, so I will not change the original answer that I gave. However, the point that Alex Fergusson makes demonstrates that the exemption under the 1993 act does not remove the need for the Crown to carry out such monitoring, which I confirm is carried out by contractors for the defence science and technology laboratory. I also confirm that the results to which Alex Fergusson referred are in the public domain—he is also right about that.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
I call Chris Ballance. He must keep his question tight.
Will the minister ask SEPA to conduct an inquiry into radioactivity in the Solway to examine whether radioactive material has got into the food chain and whether our fish are safe to eat? The issue is not just about Dundrennan; it is also about Chapelcross and Windscale/Sellafield.
I can only repeat the advice that I have, which is that SEPA has confirmed that it is satisfied with the present monitoring programme. SEPA has not drawn my attention to any matters that would require it to instigate any such inquiry, but, if it does so, an inquiry will take place.
Given the Executive's stance on antisocial behaviour, would the minister think it right if somebody dumped 7,000 tin cans over the cliff at Dundrennan? If that would not be right, how much worse is it that the MOD has dumped 7,000-plus DU shells over the cliff there and continues to do so? Given that the MOD does not even know where the shells are and, a couple of years ago, managed to lose the test rig that was sent down to find them, how confident can we be in the reassurances that have been given?
That question should properly be answered by the Ministry of Defence.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 May 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 29 May 2003 Debate · 1
- Scottish Executive's Programme Debate · 108
- Business Motion Business motions · 40
- Depleted Uranium Weapons Testing (Protests) Questions · 16
- Area Tourist Boards Questions · 4
- A9 (Kessock Junction) Questions · 6
- Economic Growth Questions · 6
- Edinburgh Tram Network Questions · 6
- Scottish Ambulance Service Questions · 6
- Scottish Agricultural College Questions · 8
- Forth Road Bridge Questions · 4
- Homeless People (Edinburgh) Questions · 4
- Congestion Charging Questions · 4
- Economic Growth Questions · 6
- National Waste Strategy Questions · 4
- Borders Railway Questions · 9
- Scottish Agricultural College Questions · 6
- Charity Regulator Questions · 6
- National Health Service (Consultant Surgeons) Questions · 4
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet Sub-committee on Sustainable Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Antisocial Behaviour First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Nursery Nurses First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Scottish Executive's Programme Debate · 38
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 13
- Scottish Agricultural College Members’ business · 55
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.