To ask the Scottish Executive what proposals it has to reduce class sizes. (S1O-6701)
Official Report · Chamber
Schools (Class Sizes)
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Cathy Jamieson Lab 5
- Michael Russell SNP 2
- Johann Lamont Lab 1
- Tommy Sheridan SSP 1
- Brian Monteith Con 1
The record
10 contributionsIn response to the national debate on education, we indicated that we would bring forward proposals to reduce class sizes and to improve pupil-teacher ratios at critical stages such as primary 7, secondary 1 and secondary 2, particularly in maths and English.
How? How much will it cost? Where will the Executive get the money from?
When this Administration comes back in May, we will introduce fully costed proposals. Those proposals will stand up to scrutiny, unlike the SNP's proposals, which crumbled at the first hard question.
Does the minister acknowledge that the size of classes is not the sole factor in determining educational achievement in our schools? In my constituency, the schools with the biggest classes are often those that are highest achieving. Given the minister's commitment to addressing the central issue of inequality in education, will she support initiatives such as the nurture initiative in my constituency, which allows for intensive and close support for some of our most vulnerable children whose broader social needs have to be addressed so that they can access education?
I take on board the point that Johann Lamont has raised. Of course class sizes are important, but we also need to ensure that resources and support are provided so that we can close the opportunity gap. Many schools have used their resources creatively and have worked hard to overcome the barriers that exist for disadvantaged pupils. I always welcome examples of good practice and like to see it spreading throughout Scotland.
Three months ago, I asked the minister how much she estimated it would cost to lower class sizes to a maximum of 20 in the primary and secondary sectors. Three months ago, she said that she was working on it. Does she know yet how much that would cost?
I refer the member to the answer that I gave to Mr Russell. We will not make proposals that are not properly costed. We will make proposals that stand up to scrutiny and we will deliver in the same way as we have delivered on reducing class sizes for the first three years of primary education.
If I may say so, Presiding Officer, you are wearing a rather fetching purple tie—rather like Hibernian Football Club's second colours.
Further to Tommy Sheridan's question, is the minister aware that, when class sizes were reduced to 20 in California, the results included many classrooms with 40 or more children and two teachers, patchy attainment and the hiring of teachers without proper qualifications to meet the demand for additional teachers? Is that what the minister wants? Does she agree that what matters most is teaching quality in Scotland?
Further to Tommy Sheridan's question, is the minister aware that, when class sizes were reduced to 20 in California, the results included many classrooms with 40 or more children and two teachers, patchy attainment and the hiring of teachers without proper qualifications to meet the demand for additional teachers? Is that what the minister wants? Does she agree that what matters most is teaching quality in Scotland?
Teaching quality is very important and I am aware of the research to which Mr Monteith refers. It showed that, in some areas, there were advantages in reducing class sizes, particularly for the kind of pupils that Johann Lamont referred to. However, it also highlighted some of the dangers. We have to ensure that we do not fall into the trap of doing the wrong thing in an attempt to raise standards. That is why we will make proposals for those critical stages where we know that there are problems. We will focus on maths and English because we are committed to raising standards of literacy and numeracy. I am sure that Mr Monteith in his very fetching tie will agree with that.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Mar 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 27 March 2003 Debate · 1
- Closing the Opportunity Gap for Older People Debate · 123
- Great Northern Partnership Members’ business · 28
- Agriculture Questions · 8
- Police (Fife) Questions · 8
- Housing Questions · 8
- European Maritime Safety Agency Questions · 6
- Nursery Schools (Consultation) Questions · 6
- Adoption Questions · 6
- Ferry (Ballycastle to Campbeltown) Questions · 6
- Air Services (Glasgow to Barra) Questions · 4
- Less Favoured Areas Support (Crofting) Questions · 8
- Scottish Borders (Economy) Questions · 17
- Schools (Class Sizes) Questions · 10
- A82 (Tarbet to Inverarnan) Questions · 6
- Racial Prejudice Questions · 6
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Entitlement Cards First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Forth Estuary Transport Authority First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Schools (British History) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- British Sign Language (Interpreters) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Motion of Thanks Debate · 13
- Decision Time Decision time · 21
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.