To ask the Scottish Executive what evidence it has on the effect of Roman Catholic schools on sectarian behaviour by adults. (S1O-6130)
Official Report · Chamber
Sectarianism
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Cathy Jamieson Lab 5
- Michael Russell SNP 2
- Donald Gorrie LD 1
- Brian Fitzpatrick Lab 1
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
The record
10 contributionsWe are not aware of any evidence of a causal link between Roman Catholic schools and sectarian behaviour by adults.
May I then suggest to the minister that, in those circumstances, she should tell the First Minister, who is sitting next to her, that he would be wise not to seek a cheap headline in the Sunday newspapers by suggesting such a link? He would also be wise to ensure that the debate on the future of education in Scotland is not conducted in those terms.
Of course, Mr Russell has never sought a headline.
I am at one with the First Minister when I say that I believe that there is value in a Catholic education. The examples that have been given of shared campuses—for example Annbank and St Ann's Roman Catholic primary in my constituency, and Pirniehall and St David's Roman Catholic primary, where I recently opened the new school—give a positive example of how we can work together.
Children and schools are not the root cause of sectarianism, which is caused by the outdated behaviour of adults.
I am at one with the First Minister when I say that I believe that there is value in a Catholic education. The examples that have been given of shared campuses—for example Annbank and St Ann's Roman Catholic primary in my constituency, and Pirniehall and St David's Roman Catholic primary, where I recently opened the new school—give a positive example of how we can work together.
Children and schools are not the root cause of sectarianism, which is caused by the outdated behaviour of adults.
The Executive set up an all-party working group to examine aspects of sectarian behaviour and the group produced a lot of very sensible recommendations. Will the minister and her colleagues consider pushing ahead with those recommendations that have wide support while they wait for the results of consultation on further steps, and not halting the sensible measures that they could take quickly?
The short answer is that we will. I will, of course, work with my colleagues in education and with young people. We are keen to ensure that we promote an education system that promotes fairness and tolerance of the variety of cultures in Scotland. We will continue to do that.
Does the minister accept that her repeated words on denominational schools—Catholic, Jewish and Episcopalian—will receive a warm welcome, as did the comments that the First Minister made earlier in the year? Such schools make a valuable contribution to a diverse education system and, we hope, to a diverse and tolerant Scotland. Will the minister consider the many examples of good working between denominational and non-denominational schools such as Turnbull High School, Thomas Muir High School and Bishopbriggs High School and their feeder primaries? Will she consider how such instances of good practice might be supported and promoted throughout the country?
I am always keen to hear about examples of good practice and I am aware that much good practice in Scottish schools is unrecognised. I would be delighted to hear more about the examples that Brian Fitzpatrick has mentioned.
link
The minister is aware that there is some concern in the Roman Catholic community about shared campuses. Will she assure us that there will be no move to introduce shared campuses unless they have the full support of the parents of children at both schools involved?
The member is aware that that is primarily a matter for the local authorities. I am aware that, in some instances, consultation is currently taking place. In my first-hand experience of some of the benefits of shared campuses, I am sure that some of the fears of parents can be overcome. I have offered to meet the Catholic Education Commission in the new year to discuss some of those issues.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Dec 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 19 December 2002 Debate · 1
- Budget Process 2003-04: Stage 2 Debate · 107
- Standing Orders (Changes) Debate · 6
- National Health Service (Pay and Conditions) Questions · 8
- Industrial Fishing (North Sea) Questions · 12
- Wildlife (Smuggling) Questions · 5
- Bereavement Counselling (Children) Questions · 5
- School Education (National Priorities) Questions · 4
- Sport (International Events) Questions · 10
- Renewable Energy Questions · 8
- Air Traffic Control Questions · 4
- Sectarianism Questions · 10
- Fisheries Council Questions · 8
- Civil Service Jobs (Dispersal) Questions · 4
- Carers (Support) Questions · 5
- Intermediate Technology Institutes Questions · 9
- Audiology Services (Funding) Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- ScotRail (Subsidy) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Schoolchildren (Filming) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Bain Review First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Argyll and Clyde NHS Board First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Agricultural Holdings (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 65
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 38
- Firefighters and Fire Control Staff (Pay) Members’ business · 44
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.