Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

Wednesday 21 January 2004 Education Committee Bill scrutiny 840 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

840 contributions · showing 1–200
Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

With members' permission, we restart this meeting of the Education Committee.For the avoidance of doubt, I will explain how I propose to proceed. Members should have before them certain papers. Among those is the bill itself and an orange paper, which is the draft report. The report contains one or two suggestions—that is all that they currently are—for amendments, particularly on the area of the report that we did not reach last week. I propose that we start at the paragraphs on transitions, which is where we finished at the previous meeting, and move forward on those first. Secondly, there is a blue paper that was given out to members this morning. It contains a number of other suggested amendments to the draft report, which came in primarily in response to the clerk's later request for textual amendments. I do not propose to reopen the principled issues with which we dealt in the first part of the discussion last week. There may be issues on the borderline, but I do not want to be too heavy on that as this is the first bill that the committee has dealt with and we can perhaps learn from experience about the difficulties and ins and outs of the process.Members also have before them Rosemary Byrne's suggested amendments to certain sections of the report. Finally, there is the minister's letter and the letter from the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, which have been circulated before.I will start with the principled issues in the remaining part of the report from transitions onwards. I will then move back to the beginning of the report to address any textual changes that need to be considered at that point. I will leave the general principles of the bill until we have done all that, because what we do on the detail affects the proposals on the general principles, which is where the main area of controversy is.I suggest that the committee tries to reach a consensual view on the bill if it can. I do not want to hold anyone back from expressing their principled views, but a committee's consensual view on a bill has power that a report containing dissenting information and so on does not. I ask members to bear that in mind as an objective.I suggest that we start with transitions. I will refer to paragraph numbers and I ask members to do so, too—obviously the page numbers have been altered in the new paper but, as I understand it, the paragraph numbers have not. Is that okay?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will start with the paragraphs on transitions. Paragraph 163 of the report is where we finished at the previous meeting. Paragraphs 163 to 171 are on transitions. There are two suggestions for amendments to the draft report from Elaine Murray and myself. There is also a small suggestion from Fiona Hyslop in the new paper. Those are the changes from the previous draft. Are there any observations on those suggestions?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I have no problem with the amendments suggested by you and Elaine Murray. They both capture what we were discussing last week.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do members agree to those amendments?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Fiona Hyslop's amendment would come in at the end of Elaine Murray's amendment—it is a sort of addendum. What are members' views on that?

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I seek clarification. When we discussed the age at which planning should begin for transitions post-school, did we not discuss the possibility of the secondary 2 to secondary 3 transition point?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thought that that had been dealt with, although perhaps not the specific point about the change between S2 and S3.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Our report should state that the transition between S2 and S3 is critical for children who have additional support needs and that consideration of post-school transition should take place before the move to S3.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Consideration should specifically take place at that point—it is a trigger point.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

My amendment states that consideration could begin at that point.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Yes. The difficulty is that some children at that age are not as mature as others are. I would be reluctant to say that the process must begin at that stage, but I am trying to capture the point that a decision should be taken at that stage about when to start the process. In complex cases, the process might start at that point.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is a helpful suggestion. Where should we put that?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Perhaps it should go in the middle of Elaine Murray's amendment in paragraph 170.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

No; it is really an observation rather than a recommendation. What is it?

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

We should say that it is essential to have in the code of practice the fact that the transition between S2 and S3 is critical for all youngsters with additional support needs and that, for some of them, it might be appropriate for that point to be the start of the process.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Right. I suggest that we put that after Elaine Murray's amendment, which is the logical place for it. The more I think about it, the more I think that it is really a recommendation. The initial wording that you gave seemed to me to pretty much encapsulate the idea, subject to tidying up.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I thought that the point should go in the middle of paragraph 170, before the last sentence. The paragraph should state: "The committee therefore notes that, under the legislation, planning for transitions could begin at the age of 14 and, in particular, notes the importance of the transitional stage from S2 to S3. It therefore suggests that this information should be included in the Code of Practice."

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We could go with that. Are members happy with that addition?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

What about Fiona Hyslop's amendment about moving things on to the face of the bill?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Elaine Murray's suggestion will help to clarify matters. However, given that everybody who gave evidence during the process was confused by the measure, we have a duty to try to ensure that the bill is as clear as possible. Ministers have an opportunity to try to find a form of words that would make clear what Elaine Murray is saying.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

I accept that there has been confusion because the duty is actually that an education authority must comply with the duty in section 10(6) no later than 12 months before a child leaves school. I am not sure whether that needs to be clarified in the bill, but perhaps it needs to be clearer in the accompanying policy documents, which are intended to clarify the bill's intention.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

The issue was raised by many individuals and organisations. Putting the point in the bill may help to clarify the situation.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am trying to work out how we would put that point in the bill, because we are talking about interpreting what is in the bill. In other words, the point is already in the bill but it has not been interpreted properly.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Fiona Hyslop's amendment uses the word "clarify". There is a sense in the committee that the issue is important and that it should be clarified in the bill. Would it be acceptable to make a slight alteration and suggest that the minister should consider clarifying the wording in the bill?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do members have any more comments about the section on transitions? It is a very important section and I think that we have reached unanimity on it.We move on to consider paragraphs 172 to 177, on the code of practice and directions. I have suggested three amendments and Fiona Hyslop and Lord James Douglas-Hamilton have suggested a small change to paragraph 175, to recommend that the statutory instrument on the duty to issue the code of practice should be subject to the affirmative procedure.Does the committee agree to make that change to paragraph 175?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

My amendments relate to consultation with the civic community and my first suggestion is that the requirement to consult should be in the bill. I make the suggestion for the committee's consideration and I would not want to go to the wall on the issue, but it seems so important and so many issues are arising about the code of practice that I do not think that we should ignore the matter.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I do not think that the committee would disagree that consultation will be needed. In his letter—I think in the letter that we received the week before last—the minister gave a specific assurance that he was committed to consulting on the code of practice. Indeed, I think that the minister said this week that he had started to set up an advisory committee. Are there any examples from legislation in the past that might lead us to expect that consultation would not take place?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Obviously I accept the minister's assurances, but the difficulty is that ministers can change, Governments can change and all sorts of issues can arise. Because of the importance and the extent of the code of practice, consultation will be important.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I support Robert Brown's proposed amendments. To answer Kenneth Macintosh's question, the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 provides a good example of legislation in relation to which there was an issue about consultation on a code of practice that was an integral part of the legislation.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Was the requirement to consult included in the legislation?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I understand that it was. Our report should certainly mention the minister's commitment to consultation and I think that it would be helpful if the requirement to consult were in the bill. Members might want to check the 2003 act to establish what it says, as I cannot say whether consultation on the code of practice was an integral part of the bill, but I know that the question of consultation was essential to the passing of that legislation, so in that context the 2003 act is probably the piece of legislation that is the most similar to the one that we are considering.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suppose that our report could recommend that the minister consider including the matter in the bill—or words to that effect.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

I am not convinced that the bill is the appropriate place for that. The bill should direct the statutory process after the legislation is passed.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

You might argue about that both ways—

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

I am not sure that the question of whether there is consultation on the code of practice should be dealt with in that part of the legislative process.

link

I support the convener's amendments. Would it please everyone to change the wording, so that we recommend that the commitment to consult on the code of practice should be "considered for inclusion in the bill"?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

We are recommending that the code of practice should be subject to the affirmative procedure. Does that mean that consultation would automatically take place?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am not sure. That is a good point. Can we have advice on that?

Martin Verity Clerk
link

If the power is exercised under a statutory instrument, consultation would inevitably form part of the process.

Martin Verity Clerk
link

Yes—consultation with interested parties.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

In that case, I withdraw my amendment, as the question of consultation would be covered by the recommendation to use the affirmative procedure. Do members agree?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Apparently someone's mobile phone is switched on and is interfering with the equipment. Could everyone check their phones and ensure that they are switched off?The second amendment that I suggest is in paragraph 176 and relates to the slightly different issue of the involvement of other agencies. The point was made in evidence—I cannot remember by whom—that if co-ordination is to be effective, other agencies need to know exactly what they should be doing. I am not sure whether there should be a separate code of practice, or whether it could be included in the code of practice for which the bill currently provides, but it is an important point and I wonder what the committee thinks.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I agreed with the idea in the previous draft that the Executive should clarify how it expects other authorities to abide by tribunal decisions and work with education authorities. The code of practice is probably a good place to do that.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Perhaps that should be our suggestion.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

However, I am slightly worried that the code of practice might become an unwieldy document. Perhaps the considerations that we are discussing could be dealt with in Executive health circulars instead of in education circulars. I do not have a firm view that the Executive's clarification should be in the code of practice.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Perhaps we should suggest the wording "Code of Practice or other guidance."

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I do not think that that would be strong enough. We need something more than the code of practice for other bodies. We should ask the minister to consider how other bodies can be tied in. I do not know whether that is the best way to describe it.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you mean in terms of tribunal orders? Or do you mean in some other way?

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Tribunal orders might be a possibility, but I am not sure how that would be done. Perhaps using the code of practice to clarify the situation for other bodies is okay. However, I am not sure whether using the code of practice for other aspects is a sufficiently strong approach.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

My problem is slightly different. There is an issue about tribunal orders that are made in relation to other agencies, but there is also an issue about the procedure in terms of identification, assessments and, indeed, the whole ball game in so far as it involves outside agencies. That is not a matter of instructions but of procedures, guidance, orders or an arrangement that ensures that other agencies know how they fit into the set-up. That is the kind of thing that I have been trying to get at.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I appreciate Rhona Brankin's concerns, but suggesting using the code of practice for clarification in this instance does not preclude us from suggesting other steps elsewhere in the document.

link

I support the convener's suggested amendment. Including the clarification in the code of practice rather than having endless, different pieces of paper would make it simpler for practitioners. The convener's amendment does not prevent Rhona Brankin from suggesting a strengthening amendment.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

It would be stronger to say that there should be one code of practice that would include advice to other agencies.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes, there should be a paragraph in the code of practice that is headed "Health service" or whatever.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Keeping everything in the one document is a stronger suggestion.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is that all right? Does Rhona Brankin have a further suggestion?

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

No. We discussed the wording with regard to outside agencies at last week's meeting. When I initially considered the convener's suggested amendment, I could not remember what we had said on the matter at our previous meeting, so I felt that we must ensure that we had more than a code of practice. However, having remembered last week's discussion, I think that we probably have an adequate form of words to ensure that the minister considers ways in which the health service, colleges of education and higher education can be tied in. We dealt with that issue adequately in our previous discussion.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Fiona Hyslop has suggested a slight amendment to that that might resolve the problem.Do we agree paragraph 176, with the slight change that Lord James suggested?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

A further, relatively minor amendment is suggested in paragraph 177. I do not think that we got a full explanation of the timescales for the code of practice and I think that we should have that. Is that fair?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We move on to implementation issues, which are dealt with in paragraphs 178 to 183. I am sorry to take up members' time with this, but I have suggested three amendments towards the end of the section. I do not think that anyone else has suggested amendments. I also suggest an amendment to my own amendment—if I can put it that way—in paragraph 184, where it says:"to make the necessary resources available". The words "to ensure that the necessary resources are available" might be slightly better.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I have no concerns about the amendment, except about the wording of paragraph 184. I do not remember the Executive saying that it was making resources available only for "best practice schools". I am not quite sure why you have—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

No, the Executive did not say that; however, we visited lots of best-practice situations. My concern—which I have expressed once or twice—is whether that reflects the position in all schools, the majority of schools, or what have you. I cannot remember whether it was a comment that was made to me personally or evidence that the committee received, but somebody certainly said that in about 50 per cent of schools there were issues about the adequacy of the resources going into the proposals, although obviously that would improve over time.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that it was something that we picked up in discussion, rather than in formal evidence.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

We got it from the unions. My point is that the training is not just for all schools, but for all teachers. We heard that training is required not just for traditional special needs teachers, but for all teachers, so that they will have an awareness of personal learning plans and individualised educational programmes and be able to help. My concern is about the breadth of coverage rather than the specifics. We heard about that from the unions and on our visits. We heard from the directors of education about initial teacher training, which is an obvious issue; however, my concern is the continuous training of existing teachers and how they will relate to the new system.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Would it help if we left out the phrase"not just ‘best practice schools'"?

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I did not understand. I was trying to clarify what you meant by that.A couple of points that I have made in the past have not been included in the draft report. It is vital that there is training for senior management in schools. Managing the new system is going to be important. There are more youngsters coming under the umbrella of additional support needs and a significant number of changes are being made. There will be more youngsters with IEPs, and CSPs will be a new type of documentation. There are significant management challenges in schools and it is vital that a senior member of staff manages the system adequately.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you have a phraseology to suggest? It would probably come after the first sentence of my amendment.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

We could add, "This should include senior management training and training for all staff." It is not just a question of support staff.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We could say, "The committee also noted the particular importance of training and support for management staff within schools."

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Managing the new system adequately also has a resource implication and we need to recognise that it will take time to manage the system properly. That was one of the problems with the previous system.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Right. So is the point that you are making that there should be additional wording after"to provide the necessary training and staffing",to say "including the management resource"—

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Or, "the management resource required to adequately manage the system."

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

It is the management time that is the issue, is it not? It is about managers having the time aside from their other remits.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not think that we have a clear view on that, have we?

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

It is about how we word that to protect their position.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suggest that, for the avoidance of doubt, when we are finished with this, the clerks e-mail round to members the final versions of the amendments—not so much the detail of the paragraphs but the recommendations—for agreement within 24 hours or whatever? Would that be doable?

Martin Verity Clerk
link

It would have to be done today.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

Given the fact that the financial memorandum seems to concentrate only on the costs of the production of CSPs and so on, we might also ask the Executive how that resource is to be provided. The supporting resource is not really clear in the financial memorandum.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes, okay. There seems to be agreement to that.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Let me clarify this, so that I understand what is happening. We are saying that, as well as the training of specialist staff, there should be a requirement for all staff to be given training in the importance of identifying and assessing additional support needs.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is covered by the current wording. I do not want to over-complicate matters.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are talking specifically about management staff and about their having time for that training. We are saying that the financial memorandum—

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

It does not necessarily have to be in the financial memorandum. The argument could be that the financial memorandum is about only the administrative costs of the bill. Although the resources that will be made available for the training of staff have to be identified, the financial memorandum might not be the appropriate place to do that.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

So we are asking for clarification from ministers.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

It is about people knowing where the money to do some of these things is coming from.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I do not want to make any assumption about the management of the support system in schools. The system will be managed by a senior member of staff but, more important, it will be managed at principal teacher level as well. Quite often, that is where the time is needed for managing—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that "management" can cover both those areas, if the recommendation is phrased correctly. I am slightly doubtful whether the clerks have a clear view of what we have agreed.

Martin Verity Clerk
link

I think that we understand what is meant. We will circulate the agreed wording to members and get comments back before the end of the day, if that is okay.

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

My next point is on paragraph 185 and is linked to the previous issue. I propose that new paragraph 185 should read: "The Committee calls on the Executive to undertake a survey of councils on the adequacy of staff resources." I do not know whether that is appropriate, but it seems reasonable to think about it. Members will remember that we took evidence on child therapy reports. I think that it is important that we get an update on where we are at with that.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I do not think that we should prescribe that the way in which the adequacy of staff resources should be assessed is necessarily a survey. We could ask the Executive to assess the adequacy of staff resources and leave the method to the Executive.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes, that is fair enough. We will call on the Executive to assess the adequacy of staff resources. I think that we have reached agreement on that. Are there any other implementation issues?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. The next section is on transitional arrangements and includes paragraphs 187 to 189. An amendment has been suggested by Lord James Douglas-Hamilton, which is a reference back to an earlier part of the report.

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Does anyone have any other comments on that section?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. The next section is on "Provisions within the Disability Discrimination Act 1995" and includes paragraphs 191 to 196. There are one or two suggested amendments, which we will address in the order in which they come. The first has been suggested by Fiona Hyslop and is a textual amendment rather than an amendment to the recommendation.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Yes, it is just technical and designed to leave more options open to the ministers regarding how they execute the bill's provisions. There are different ways in which services can be provided; for example, we have had orders in council on about 40 previous occasions. I am suggesting a more general wording that would allow the Executive more options.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is there any disagreement to that?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Are we talking about paragraph 192 or paragraph 195?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Paragraph 192—the textual bit. It is additional text to give a bit of context, perhaps.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Is that the one that I just said? Paragraph 192 seemed to imply that only one witness said that, but it was said by lots of witnesses. I wanted to strengthen the point that it was a central point that was made by a number of witnesses. My amendment is just background.

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is a joint suggestion on paragraph 195, although I do not think that Fiona Hyslop's amendment totally echoes my amendment. Let me just read it.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

You have suggested that Westminster should legislate and Fiona Hyslop has suggested that it does not have to be Westminster legislation.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is the point, yes. I have some wording that I would like to add to that, which I can give to the clerks: "Alternatively, the Minister might consider whether this objective could be achieved by parallel provisions within the current Bill." I do not know whether it can, but if it can, that is probably simpler.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Yes, I think that we can do that. Euan Robson talked about reverse Sewel motions.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The central point is that we want to have the matter dealt with. The question of how it is dealt with is for the minister. Is that fair?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

If you could widen the wording of your amendment, I would be happy with that.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I hear mutterings from the sidelines.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am suggesting that my amendment should be agreed to but that we should add the sentence, "Alternatively, the Minister might consider whether this objective could be achieved by parallel provisions within the current Bill." That is all about the aids and adaptations and things of that sort.

link

I am happy with what you suggest. The Disability Rights Commission was emphatic in its written submissions that a change would be required at Westminster. It may be right or wrong, but if all these paragraphs could be included, that would help.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

It may be one of the things on which we asked for legal guidelines, along with anything that we asked of the minister—was it?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

All that I am saying is that the report should not be prescriptive, but should leave it open for the minister to decide.

link

It is also a matter for the Presiding Officer, as he is not entitled to submit a bill for royal assent on a reserved matter.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

What was the minister's view when we discussed the issue with him? Did he say that it was covered?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

He was sympathetic. Euan Robson said that there might be the opportunity of using a reverse Sewel motion, for example. There is the order in council idea. I am simply saying that we should not be prescriptive. I am happy. We can move on. If we agree to Robert Brown's amendment and add what he suggests, the scope will be widened.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are members happy with that suggestion?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Fiona Hyslop suggested another amendment.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Has the amendment to paragraph 196 been included? That should not have been highlighted. Lord James Douglas-Hamilton has suggested an addition to paragraph 196, which is fairly straightforward. Do members agree to it?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

As members have nothing further to add about that section, we will consider paragraphs 197 to 212, which concern financial issues. There do not seem to be any suggested changes until paragraph 206. The amendment to paragraph 206, which Fiona Hyslop proposed, relates to the NHS Confederation. We will take a moment to consider it.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

There is a central issue about whether we should acknowledge that the only financial implications of the bill are administrative and will concern CSPs and tribunals. I have read the Official Report, which showed that the minister's assurances relate to the number of CSPs and tribunals. If members agree to my proposals, paragraph 208 will be moved up to refer to CSPs and tribunals only. Witnesses have said that there might be greater demands on services. If we accept that, it should be reflected in the financial memorandum.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suggest that we deal with the matter in two parts. First, there might be general agreement in the committee for including paragraph 206 as a statement of a problem.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

So we agree to that.Paragraph 207 suggests that there should be an amendment to the financial memorandum—there might or might not be broad agreement in the committee about that. There is a difficulty relating to background trends and what is done by the bill.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

We have discussed the matter at various stages and there is no doubt that the bill could create additional demands. It is not simply that there is unmet demand out there—therapists, the NHS Confederation, Argyll and Bute Council, COSLA and various bodies have made that point. I do not think that limiting what is said to therapists implies that there will not be consideration across the range.Wendy Alexander has continually raised the issue of spurious accuracy. I think that the minister said that the bill does not pretend to assess demand and cost it. The minister has made it clear that the bill should be considered in the context of increasing resources throughout Scotland for additional support for learning, which is welcome. Whether those are sufficient is an on-going matter for the Executive and the Parliament to decide. The matter is really part of our budget discussions and other discussions. I am not saying that that issue is not important—indeed, it is crucial. Parents who make known their views on the bill always start with the argument about resources before they deal with the bill, so the matter is crucial. We will not do anybody any favours by including such things in the bill, as I do not think that doing so would be possible. We would end up in the same situation that we ended up in with the Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Act 2000 and we would get things wrong.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

There are two problems. One is that although this is an education bill, it is making provision for health services, and I do not know whether that is competent. Secondly, although we noted that there would be increased demand for a whole range of services, there is no evidence on the extent of that demand, so even if it is competent to put the relevant figures in the financial memorandum, what figures should be attached to that need? It is more an issue of recognising that significant additional resources will be required to meet the intention of the bill in a number of areas, but they cannot be categorised numerically at the moment.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I agree. We should find a form of words that recognises that there may be greater demand on health services. That cannot be put in the financial memorandum to an education bill, but maybe we should recommend that ministers consult other ministerial colleagues on the financial implications for their budgets. I do not know how that should be stated. Somebody on the Finance Committee might be able to give us advice on that.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I will suggest an amendment that I hope meets our objective. We know that it is difficult to say, "You must put in the financial memorandum how much extra this is going to cost," because local authorities and health services have told us that they do not want us to hypothecate tiny sums of money for them and tell them what they should spend it on. That is a dilemma that we will struggle with for the next four years, because if we demand that the figures go in the financial memorandum, the implication is that that sum is hypothecated but, as we have heard, that is not how local authorities and health services want to proceed on the ground. Nevertheless, I take the point that we cannot make legislation that has financial implications without acknowledging them.In that context, I suggest the following amendment to paragraph 207. It should state, "The Committee believes that education authorities and the health service in their planning need to ensure that they make provision, through the additional resources available to them, for the increased service demand, and the Executive needs to consider whether the scoping of the Financial Memorandum meets all the requirements upon it."That amendment covers the fact that local authorities and the health service will get the extra money that they need. There is an issue—which we will not resolve with this bill, but we are right to flag it up—about how to address the need for a financial memorandum to acknowledge all the costs without tying the hands of local authorities and health authorities. I am happy to write out that amendment, which I propose in the spirit of getting everybody on board.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is helpful. Have you written it out?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I am happy with that amendment in that context. Similar points about the financial memorandum arise on the following page.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Does that have the agreement of the committee?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

There may be a slight ordering issue, to do with paragraph 208 coming before paragraph 205, which Fiona Hyslop touched on. It is fair to say that the minister regarded the financial memorandum as being narrow in scope and related to the administrative costs of the bill rather than to the service demands. We need to ensure that the ordering is correct. Paragraph 208 logically should go back in the ordering. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Let us move on to Fiona Hyslop's proposed amendment to paragraph 209. Fiona, given the agreement on the other amendment, is your amendment needed?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

It emphasises the point that the long title of the bill refers to widening support and improving support services. It emphasises why it is relevant.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is a good debating point, but I do not think that it adds anything to the sense of what we are saying, does it?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I am not saying that it does; I am saying that it reinforces our point of concern about the bill's wider implications, whether or not it is needed to describe that concern.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I might be wrong, but I detect that there is not agreement on that amendment. Can we leave it out?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Should the monitoring of financial demands as the bill is implemented be reflected in this section? I do not know whether Wendy Alexander's amendment covered that. The committee should obviously consider it in its budget scrutiny.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Perhaps the amendments that we have just agreed—the amendment to paragraph 206 plus Wendy Alexander's amendment to paragraph 207—should follow paragraphs 208 and 209. Paragraph 209 strikes me as being the transitional paragraph.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes. I agree with that. Let me be clear that we have recorded that correctly: we have paragraphs 205, 208, 209 and then the changes.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That makes logical sense. I raised the issue of monitoring. Do we need to make an observation that we will take it up in our budget scrutiny or that the Executive should monitor the expenditure demands?

link

Wendy Alexander's amendment covered that, but she was going faster than some of us could write, as not all of us can do shorthand.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Her amendment focuses on local authorities and the Executive. It does not give the Parliament, this committee or the Finance Committee responsibility to monitor.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is fair to say that it does not deal with monitoring.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

It might be possible to add that the committee might want to write to the Finance Committee highlighting the difficult issue of the scoping of financial memoranda when we want to avoid hypothecating all the resources that go to other bodies, such as health services and local government. We will not resolve it, because it is a wider issue. I could write an amendment saying that the committee will write to the Finance Committee asking it to consider the issue.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is a different point, but it is also relevant. Do we agree Wendy Alexander's additional point?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Secondly, should there be some reference in the report to the issue needing to be monitored further and the committee returning to it in its budget scrutiny?

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am sorry that I am going back slightly, but there is a slight phraseology issue in paragraph 209, where it says in the second sentence—

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Can I make an additional point? I do not know whether it is necessary to add something about monitoring. It takes us back to the point about how we scrutinise the resourcing that will go into the bill's successful implementation. We can return to it in our budget scrutiny, but the Health Committee would have to consider it as part of its budget scrutiny as well. Perhaps we should make that point in the report.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We could draw it to the attention of other appropriate committees.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Yes, I suppose that is right, because what we said about post-school transitions concerns the Enterprise and Culture Committee. That committee and the Health Committee would be the other two committees with responsibility.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. I think that that is agreed. I suggest that the second sentence of paragraph 209 might read, "However, the Committee is concerned that the provision of services for children with additional support needs stimulated by the bill is not quantified by the Financial Memorandum." That is slightly more sensible.

Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We move on to paragraph 211. Bear in mind that we have not agreed the original wording of that, so it is all up for grabs.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

When we considered the original draft, we had not had COSLA's letter or the minister's latest letter. There are two issues. One is the general point about recognising that cost implications will come with the general duty, even if those are sourced from mainstream budgets. The question is whether those costs ought to be in the financial memorandum or otherwise included, noted or appended. The second issue is that of the narrower administrative costs on which the minister is focusing, and which have been the subject of discussion with COSLA. Are we satisfied that we have sufficient information on those costs?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Let us return to the COSLA issues in a moment. We need to ensure that the report's wording reflects our new position, but let us put that to one side for the moment and examine Fiona Hyslop's suggested amendments to paragraph 211. I suggest that her first amendment has been dealt with by Wendy Alexander's earlier amendment.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I still feel strongly that a revised financial memorandum would be helpful in progressing the bill. Wendy was considering the bill's longer-term implementation; my amendment is about the progress of the legal provisions over the next few weeks. It would be extremely helpful if the Executive could make that revision. We know that the Executive has the information, which we have seen. Having reflected on COSLA's evidence, but in any case on both counts that we have mentioned, I think that there should be a revised financial memorandum. Bearing in mind the criticism from the Auditor General about an amendment on mainstreaming that was made at the last minute on a previous occasion and which caused financial concerns on which he reported, we have a duty and responsibility to allow sufficient time and space for all the information to be available to Parliament before it makes its decision.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

We need to think about the need for more debate by the Finance Committee on the purpose of the financial memorandum and on what should and should not be included in it. That touches on Wendy Alexander's point. There are two particular issues to do with the financial memorandum before us. One is whether the number of CSPs is correctly identified. Should the financial memorandum reflect the fact that the minister has stated that additional moneys will be made available if more CSPs are required than are currently detailed in the memorandum? That would be an appropriate revision. The additional information that the minister has given with regard to the resources that are available for additional support needs more generally is not necessarily included in the financial memorandum in an appropriate way. If that information is included, that runs the risk of double counting. If figures turn up in lots of pieces of legislation, the Executive could be strongly criticised for making several announcements of the same thing. The information should perhaps be produced somewhere in the policy documents or explanatory notes other than in the financial memorandum. The Executive should be making clear the totality of resources that are being made available for additional support needs, while noting that those relate not just to the bill but to a number of measures.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The minister said that he was going to announce additional resources for that general area. We could ask him to clarify what those are in the context of the bill.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

If the minister said that in a letter, then those additional resources should be included.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I suggest an amendment to Fiona Hyslop's amendment to paragraph 211 to capture that point. We could stop Fiona Hyslop's amendment after "general duty" and then add: "the itemisation of these additional resources should be available to the Parliament in advance of Stage 2 consideration and, if it is appropriate, a revised Financial Memorandum should be made available." That would cover both points, and it does not lock the Executive into making the financial memorandum the appropriate vehicle for that, although it requires information on the totality of the global resources to be made available before stage 2.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education Committee Wednesday 21 January 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 30
  4. Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 840

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.