To ask the Scottish Executive what its position is on recent research that suggests a link between fluoridation of water and bone disease in children. (S1O-5771)
Official Report · Chamber
Fluoridation (Research)
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Mary Mulligan Lab 3
- Robin Harper Green 2
- Mary Scanlon Con 1
The record
6 contributionsThe University of York's "A Systematic Review of Public Water Fluoridation" took account of 254 relevant studies on fluoridation. No conclusive evidence was produced linking water fluoridation and bone disease. If there had been conclusive evidence, the Executive would not have included fluoridation as an option in its consultation document "Towards Better Oral Health in Children: A Consultation Document on Children's Oral Health in Scotland".
The minister is no doubt aware that, last month, a Medical Research Council working group on fluoride recommended further research into the health effects of water fluoridation. The group is concerned about the fact that research from Mexico has shown that fluoride can cause bone disease in children, but we do not know whether adding fluoride to our water will cause similar bone disease. Does the minister agree that, given that unknown, it is vital that proposals to fluoridate water should not go ahead until research into the health effects of fluoride has at least been completed, and will she guarantee that?
In Mexico, the example that Mr Harper uses, fluoride is found naturally. In those instances, there have been examples of fluoride causing health problems because of the high concentration. However, when fluoride is added to water supplies, it is added at much lower levels. None of those levels has shown instances of health problems. However, the Executive is willing, as ever, to listen to the relevant information that is provided and to consider the research. We will continue to do that.
The current consultation document on fluoridation of the water supply states that the Executive is impartial on the issue. How does the minister square that statement with a contribution of £26,000 to the British Fluoridation Society—a society that exists solely to promote fluoridation of the water supply?
The Executive has said consistently that it remains open minded on fluoridation of the water supply. The consultation document on children's oral health includes a number of aspects, and Mary Scanlon should ensure that the debate on children's oral health is not only on fluoridation, but covers all the other measures that would be needed to improve a poor record of oral health throughout Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 31 Oct 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 31 October 2002 Debate · 1
- Broadcasting and the Print Media Debate · 49
- Fishing Debate · 106
- Affordable Housing Questions · 8
- Youth Crime Action Plan Questions · 8
- Fluoridation (Research) Questions · 6
- Secretary of State for Education and Skills (Meetings) Questions · 12
- Seagulls Questions · 7
- Veterinary Teaching and Research (Funding) Questions · 5
- South-west Scotland (Jobs) Questions · 6
- Scottish Fishermen's Federation (Meetings) Questions · 12
- Fireworks Task Group Questions · 8
- Cancer Strategy Questions · 6
- Rail Industry (Report) Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cities Review First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Construction Industry First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 77
- Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 40
- Edinburgh Waverley Station Members’ business · 30
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.