Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

Wednesday 14 January 2004 Education Committee Bill scrutiny 494 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

494 contributions · showing 1–200
Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Item 4 on the agenda is the continuation of our stage 1 consideration of the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill, which will take place in public, as we decided.A letter has just been circulated to the committee from a number of groups, including the Equity Group. The letter emphasises the views that have already been put forward and suggests a number of detailed amendments to the bill. Of course, we are not dealing with amendments today and we cannot easily take on board the detail of what is suggested—or even read the letter, given that we have received it at such short notice. However, we are conscious of those witnesses' general views on the bill, as we are of other witnesses' views, and members will no doubt take those views on board in their deliberations.Members have a copy of our draft stage 1 report, which reflects the discussion that took place at our meeting last week and, of course, much of the evidence. I must say that I think that the report is extremely good. It takes up a lot of the issues in a sophisticated way and I thank the officials who are responsible for it—I am not sure who actually drafted it. The report forms the basis of our deliberations this morning.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Would it be possible to allow members to take a few minutes in which to read the two letters? We have received a letter from the Executive as well as one from the All for One/One for All group.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thought that members had received a copy of the Executive's letter earlier.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Martin Verity told me about the letter this morning, but I have not had a chance to digest it.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. I am happy to suspend the meeting for five minutes to allow people to read the letters and to get a cup of tea if they want one.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We return to item 4, which is the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill. I hope that members have had a chance to read the two letters before them. The primary matter for us to consider is the draft report. We had a general discussion last week, so I am not sure that we have to explore further the general issues except in so far as they relate to the detail of the report. Unless anyone disagrees, I propose to go through the report section by section.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

Peter Peacock's letter is hugely helpful and deals explicitly with some of the issues that we dealt with last week. I wonder whether we could take five minutes now to discuss the issues that he raises. That would expedite our page-by-page consideration of the report.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

It is slightly frustrating that civil service letters never include headings.The letter is helpful in dealing with four issues that we asked about. One of those issues was the eligibility criteria for co-ordinated support plans. There is absolute clarity about that and we might want to take a view on it—the response is helpful. The letter is also clear about the code of practice. The Executive says that it amended the draft bill to include an indication of what the code would cover. Obviously, there would also need to be consultation. That seems to strike the right balance. We asked about the relationship between personal learning plans, individualised educational programmes and co-ordinated support plans and the letter is helpful in that regard. The letter gives a helpful clarification of the code of practice, and lastly it is helpful with regard to funding.When I first read the letter I thought, "This is hugely helpful. We want to give visibility to the total amount of resource that is being committed." That is true not least because it is important that parents of children without a CSP and organisations with a special interest in the area have access to information on the total resource that is being committed. I wondered initially whether we should at least incorporate some of that detail into our report.There is another fundamental issue, although I am not absolutely sure of the position. Halfway through the final paragraph of the letter, Peter Peacock says:"A major strength of the Bill is the explicit duty on education authorities to provide for all children and young people with additional support needs … regardless of whether they have a CSP or not."That is the clarification that we sought and it answers Ken Macintosh's point about how we deal with the misperception that there will be a loss of rights. Given that the bill places that explicit duty on education authorities, the question arises whether the financial memorandum is too thin. It does not cover the moneys that are being devoted to those areas and it does not yet have the details that Peter Peacock has still to announce about how much money he is going to use specifically to support administration and implementation.The Executive's letter is hugely helpful. It answers a lot of what we asked. For clarification purposes, we might want to import some of it into our report. We might need to spend a minute or two thinking about how we give the funding visibility and whether we want to consider the scope of the financial memorandum in the light of that helpful clarification.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The point about the financial memorandum is already in our draft report.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

It is helpful to have the letter. It might have helped a large part of our evidence taking if we had had it earlier.We know where the Minister for Education and Young People stands on the CSP and what we say in the report will be about whether he is right. On IEPs and PLPs, one of our big concerns is how much experience we have with the PLPs, but we can understand the philosophy behind the minister's approach. On the code of practice, we have heard the minister's opinion and we must decide whether we want the code to be dealt with by means of an affirmative instrument. Those choices will be made during the drafting of our report.On the finances, there are basically two aspects. One is the disagreement or misunderstanding with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, which we will not be able to resolve until we meet next week—we will have to park that issue at one side. There is a fundamental point about whether it is implicit in the bill that authorities will have to provide for children who do not have CSPs. The general purpose is, quite explicitly, to provide additional support for children, which includes those without CSPs. The information that has been provided on that should be part of the financial memorandum. That would be extremely helpful and would ensure that people knew what resources were being allocated.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Can I ask a silly question? Is it possible for us to amend the financial memorandum? I am not certain about the procedure for that.

Martin Verity Clerk
link

It is not our financial memorandum.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

The end of the letter says:"You will appreciate also that I have yet to announce the additional funds I intend to provide to support implementation of this Bill. I shall do this shortly."That is our concern. The only additional moneys in the financial memorandum as it stands are for the administration of CSPs. If the minister expects to announce resources, they should be part of the financial memorandum. The bill cannot progress to stage 2 unless the financial memorandum is approved, which usually happens at the same time as the stage 1 report.There is an opportunity for us to say that we think that the memorandum should be revised. There is time for the Executive to introduce a revised memorandum before the stage 1 debate, which is scheduled for the end of January. What we recommend should be reflected in a revised memorandum; most explicitly, however, we should refer to the sentences that I have just quoted.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I ask the clerk for guidance on whether there is a procedure for revising the financial memorandum. I have not come across that before, but it may be quite normal.

Martin Verity Clerk
link

I am not really sure, to be honest. The financial memorandum is the Executive's, but I do not see why the committee cannot ask the Executive to amend it.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

It has been helpful to get some clarification, in particular that the final intention is that all pupils should have a personal learning plan. There was some confusion in the past about whether somebody who had a CSP would also have an IEP and a PLP.On the financial memorandum, there may be a technical issue. I do not know what should be in the financial memorandum. Large sums of money support the bill, but they also support previous education legislation and they will support a number of other Executive initiatives. If all that information was included in the financial memorandum for this bill, and possibly in the financial memorandums for other bills, there would be the possibility of a degree of double counting, about which the Executive has been criticised previously. The Executive has probably taken a narrow definition of what has to be in the financial memorandum in terms of the cost of implementation. The issue is how much we can disaggregate the larger figures that are in support of this financial memorandum, and the number of other Executive initiatives.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The trouble is that we are not starting with a clean sheet. There is provision in place. The bill will have implications for all that, but in itself will the substantive provision make a difference?

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

It is useful to have a rundown of the other areas where money is spent. My concern, however, which I have raised previously, is that much of that ring-fenced education funding often has no proper strategy around it. Considering the weaknesses in the financial memorandum, and the areas that we are not yet clear about, and given that it is two weeks before we debate the bill in the chamber, will we get clarification within that timescale that will satisfy us that the bill will have the resources to let it run properly? I do not think so. We should stop and take another look at the matter, and we should delay the bill until we have clarification. I feel a bit happier about what the minister has said about the code of practice, so why are we rushing the financial aspect, when it is crucial? Will we get any answers in two weeks?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am not entirely convinced that all the funding that is mentioned is ring fenced.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

A lot of it is, though. The problem with much of this kind of funding is that it comes into schools and has to be spent very quickly. There is no long-term strategy around it and much of it is wasted. I say that from experience. That kind of thing should be discussed and examined in much more detail than it has been. Perhaps that is a matter for another time, but the financial memorandum is current, and we are not clear enough about that at the moment to go forward.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I have quite some sympathy with what Rosemary Byrne said about the way that the money is going into schools, but there are two issues, and we are slightly rehearsing what is in the draft report. The minister's letter is welcome, as is the information on funding, but when it comes to the bill, we can take only the narrow view, in the sense that there is a wider issue about the resources that go into additional support for learning, which the bill does not address or even move forward on. The financial memorandum talks about the way in which we organise and approach additional support for learning and it even has implications for how we divide up the cake, but we can take only the narrow approach on it. There is a separate argument to be had as part of the budget scrutiny—or now—about trying to increase resources generally.One aspect of the bill with which I am not entirely happy is the fact that it might increase demand. I am unsure about that. When the minister gave evidence in December, he was clear that, even if the estimates are out quite wildly, he is confident that the figures will not be of a magnitude that will mean that his department will have any trouble making up the difference.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Tribunals are a different issue, but I think that the minister said that, as far as implementation is concerned, if the costs of the tribunals or the numbers of children with CSPs were out by a factor of as much as 50 per cent, he would be able to cope, although he would not want that situation.It is difficult to estimate how much the bill will increase demand, but there is every chance that, if we give people new rights and put new duties on local authorities, people will use those rights and demand new services. That is a difficult factor. What the costs will be is a stab in the dark.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is a difficult issue. We could end up with spurious accuracy—I think that that phrase was used earlier—without shedding much light on the matter. A lot of bills are like that. The Homelessness etc (Scotland) Act 2003, which we considered in the previous parliamentary session, had issues of the same sort. There might be opportunities for monitoring, which we might want to consider later and which might meet some of Rosemary Byrne's and others' concerns. The picture is developing, and we can keep a handle on it even once the bill has been passed. The situation will not change overnight, because it will no doubt take a couple of years to bring the bill into force.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

It is difficult to get precise figures, but I was reassured by the minister's approach, which Ken Macintosh outlined, and the wide range of services that he included and said that the Executive would fund. My understanding is that there is an absolute commitment to funding those services, and we are responsible for holding the Executive to account on that commitment.

link

The minister's letter says, on page 2:"As you know the PLP, which we propose ultimately for all children, is still in development stage".As the minister makes it clear that the PLP is proposed for all children, there is a case for its being in place in all Scotland before the bill is implemented. The minister says that the code of practice will be in place"prior to commencement of the legislation"and the same argument can be advanced for personal learning plans: only when they are in place will we have a realistic view of the numbers. What Ken Macintosh said about the demand probably being greater than anticipated was absolutely true. I am anxious to keep friction with parents to an absolute minimum and to avoid it wherever possible. However, the quicker that the bill is implemented, the greater the friction will be and that should be avoided.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The issue is surely the IEP rather than the PLP, because the PLP is not particularly linked to additional support needs.

link

There will inevitably be children on the borderline. If every child has a PLP, with additional support needs being covered by an IEP and the most severe learning difficulties by a CSP, we will not have an accurate picture of the precise numbers until all three systems are in place.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

I am not sure that I agree with that, because the intention of the CSP is to ensure the co-ordination of services when other agencies are involved. The CSP has a particular role and is not dependent on the development of the PLP.As we said last week, the concern for parents is what happens. If a child has additional support needs but does not have a CSP and the parents do not feel that adequate resources are being devoted to their child's additional support needs, what do they do and what power do they have to address that? Parents need reassurance on that, and how we address that issue is important. The minister refers in his letter to"the explicit duty on education authorities",but the issue is what parents should do if that duty is not being fulfilled. If we can make recommendations that reassure parents on that, the fact that PLPs are not in the bill will not be material.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We have had a fair thrash at all that, and perhaps we should move to the draft report, unless members are desperate to say anything in particular.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that everybody would agree that the letter is helpful, although it does not totally clear up the definitional issues—but we will come to that in a second.The introduction to the report is relatively straightforward. As there are no issues on that, we move to "Background and Consultation", which covers paragraphs 3 to 8.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I have two minor points to make. I want to ensure that we have quoted the Education, Culture and Sport Committee correctly. Under paragraph 5, the committee is quoted as saying that the record of needs"could be revised or replaced".We need to be tight on that.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I know. I am saying that we must respect that.It might be helpful, under paragraphs 7 and 8, to make the point that the Executive published a revised version of the bill and took longer to consult parents because of its recognition of parents' concerns. The convener might recall that I asked Jack McConnell at the Hub whether the Executive would delay the bill because of parents' concerns. He said, "Yes, we will." He said that the Executive had intended to launch the bill in May, but that it was delaying its introduction because the minister—who would be Peter Peacock—wanted to take more time over the summer to consult parents. It would be fair to include that.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Ministers should be given credit for that; we should note the sensible attitude that ministers took. Are you suggesting that we should include a reference to that?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

We should recognise what the Executive did. The bill was introduced on 28 October 2003 and yet, as is noted in paragraph 5, the draft bill was published on 17 January 2003. Something happened when the new Executive came in and we should recognise that. It is background information rather than detail, but it should be included.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We agree to add a reference to that. Members have no further points on that section."Evidence Taken by the Committee" covers paragraphs 9 to 14. There should be a reference at the beginning of this section to the fact that we took some prelegislative evidence. Perhaps we should detail that evidence, given that it was part of our programme.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

We could include the fact that we had a helpful briefing from the Executive.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes."Issues Considered by the Committee" covers paragraphs 15 and 16. We may not want to get into the detail of this section just now, but I have a slight issue on the third bullet point, which talks about"replacing the Record of Need (RoN) process with a new Co-ordinated Support Plan (CSP)"In a sense, that is not a straight replacement but a sideways move. That is a nuance, but perhaps it should be reflected in the wording. Some children are going out of the system on one side—although they had records of needs, they will not get a CSP. Others are coming into the system from the other side—although they did not have a record of needs, they will get a CSP. The CSP is not a straight replacement for the record of needs. The whole ASL and CSP picture replaces the record of needs situation.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Perhaps we should say something along the lines of "abolishing the record of needs and introducing a new system."

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes; we need a slightly different wording. Perhaps the clerks could look at that."General Views on the Bill" covers paragraphs 17 to 31. As this is a lengthy section, perhaps we might take it in smaller chunks. Do members have any general observations to make?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I think that this is the appropriate place for me to make my point. From last week's discussion, I think that three main areas probably need to be emphasised; they are all covered in the report, but I wonder whether they are given enough emphasis. The first of those areas is the desirability for a single system. We acknowledged that a more pragmatic view is being taken of that issue. Some committee members and witnesses have said that we want to achieve a single system. The issue is whether the PLP, IEP and CSP will produce that, or whether something more fundamental will be required.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Much of that focuses on the paperwork.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Yes, but it also concerns the approach and whether it is possible to move that on quickly.The second area is the shift in the balance of power to parents to rebalance the partnership. Concern has been expressed about that at the committee—Elaine Murray addressed that point last week. It needs to be made clear up front that one of our general views is that we need to rebalance the power relationship, particularly if it is meant to be a partnership and we are to address the issues of trust, which we recognise.Thirdly, it is not necessarily the question who supplies the service that should be central, but the support needs of children. That point, which was raised last week, might be more controversial for members.All those areas are touched on in the report, but it might be helpful to emphasise them early on, in the section about our general view of the bill.In the third line of paragraph 17, we say that the bill"introduced much needed revision of the current provision of support for children with special educational needs."I think that we recognise that the bill revises the provision of the administration of support, which is a more specific point.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The bill does slightly more than that, because it widens the duty.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I want to concentrate on the three main themes. That is a practical point on the first of those themes.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is a point in what Fiona Hyslop has said, but not in the way in which she has put it.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The first of the three points has come out in the report.I do not think that the second point, which is a good one, has come out strongly enough. That was the point about rebalancing the relationship between parents and other partners in the provision of support for children with additional support needs; it was also about trying to re-establish trust and a positive relationship. I think that the Executive memorandum talks about reducing confrontation; that is certainly part of the policy. Perhaps we should flag that up by adding a paragraph at this point in our report. I am not sure how to do that.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The point about reducing confrontation is very important and it needs to be flagged up. We might be able to strengthen the wording in that direction.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am just not sure where we should add such points.I did not understand the third point.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

The bill's proposals, particularly those on the CSP, are supply led. The definition of a CSP means that an integral part of consideration of who will get a CSP is who provides the service; health or social work provision is necessary. Of all the points, that is probably the most controversial. The "Rights of the child" section of the report might be the most appropriate point at which to ask whether we have been strong enough on that. We might be able to redress the balance by including something about the needs of the child. The CSP, which is a central part of the bill, is defined by consideration of whether a child requires health or social work involvement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

The trouble with your general statement of the point is that it relates to the definition of the CSP, which is based on the key point that, as the minister put it, where things break down is where co-ordinated support fails.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

We as a committee have to decide whether we agree that the CSP is the most important aspect of the bill or whether we want there to be greater emphasis on the needs of the child, which are implicit throughout the rest of the bill. We are talking about our general views on the bill at this stage.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I think that we need to be explicit—just as the bill should be explicit—in saying that the bill is intended to meet the needs of children and young people and their families. That intention should underpin the bill and I think that it does.I have a difficulty with paragraph 31; in a sense, my difficulty touches on what Fiona Hyslop said although I disagree with her. I do not agree with the statement:"the Committee is concerned that the legislation does not fully eliminate the existing three tier system of provision."The trouble is that we all seem to be talking about different things. We all have concerns about integrating the PLP, the IEP and the CSP, but that is a case of paperwork and bureaucracy. I welcome what Peter Peacock has said about youngsters who have CSPs not requiring IEPs. In a sense, therefore, we are moving towards a more integrated system. Our report should say that we welcome that, but that we recommend that a single system would be the most inclusive way, which could also, almost as a by-product, help to reduce bureaucracy.In a sense, the three-tier system has been linked to the evidence that we heard from some people that a system that contains PLPs, CSPs and IEPs is not inclusive and will not move us forward. I am of the view that we do not currently live in a world without barriers to learning, so it is necessary to have a system that has built-in additional support. I accept the need for the legislation and a system whereby parents and pupils will have additional support. We do not live in an ideal world in which we can say that all pupils should be treated the same because, sadly, that world does not exist. We should take that sentence out.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are there not two points there? We are not actually eliminating an existing three-tier system; that is not correct. There is quite a lot of stuff about the need within a more inclusive framework to concentrate on the children who have had particular difficulties and whose needs have had to be focused by the system. If focus is lost, those children will also lose the resources that go along with it.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Yes. My point is that the new system is more inclusive. The definition of additional support needs is wider and it covers youngsters who were not included previously.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

I would like paragraph 31 to be altered to reflect the fact that not the whole committee is in favour of going down the road of a two-tier system. I talked about that last week and I point it out again.I know that Rhona Brankin has said that the ideal would be to move to a single-tier system, but I feel very strongly that such a system, which covers every child, would be more appropriate. There should be no adversarial approach at all, because every child would have the right to access appropriate resources and an appropriate education for them as an individual. There should be one format for planning and co-ordinating where necessary.I went into the subject during last week's meeting. I would like paragraph 31 to reflect the fact that there is a view that we should at least aim for a single-tier system and that some members of the committee would have preferred that.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are you suggesting that there should be no tribunals and appeals mechanisms?

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

No. I am saying that the legislation should be there for every child equally.

link

I have two reservations about the final sentence. First, current rights are not diminished and the needs of the most vulnerable in the community will continue to receive top priority. I raised my second reservation when I said that personal learning plans should be in place before the bill is implemented. I might not have the support of the majority but, on the basis of social inclusion, I think that all children should have a CSP or IEP or PLP. Some of the many children who are on the borderline are left out of the system and that is unfair to them. The system should be properly in place before the bill is implemented.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is clearly an issue about what will happen under the bill to people who have records of needs at present, but we will come to that later. However, I am not sure that you are factually correct that the PLP must be linked in—I am not convinced about that. PLPs are an on-going development with many resource implications—the IEP is the key point for the bill.

link

My contention is that the letter from the minister suggests that he does not know who is in and who is not in for CSPs. Therefore, it is probable that he does not know who is in and who is not in for IEPs. If a large number of children do not have a PLP or any other document, we simply will not know what their needs are and whether they should come into the system. On the basis of social inclusion, every child throughout the education system should be properly catered for.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

As I understand it, one of the general principles of the bill is to provide for all children who have additional support needs. The minister's letter mentions"the explicit duty on education authorities to provide for all children and young people with additional support needs, for whose school education they are responsible for, regardless of whether they have a CSP or not."Like others, we are in danger of getting too hung up on the CSP, which addresses a specific need, and not recognising that the bill places a duty on education authorities to provide for all children with additional support needs.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

While we are discussing the point, I suggest that we put up front in paragraph 17 or thereabouts a specific reference to the general duty in section 2, which would help to clarify some of the issues.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I suggest an amendment to the phraseology in paragraph 31 that might bring all members on board. In paragraph 31, we should leave out the first sentence and start the paragraph with: "The committee accepts the minister's point that it is the Executive's intention to meet the duty imposed by the 2000 act to ensure that children receive the education they require."

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Sorry, I do not quite follow you.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I suggest that we take out the stuff about the three-tier system and put in the following: "We welcome the steps to inclusion within the bill but recognise that the success of the new system will depend critically on the integration and quality of the relationships between the CSP, the IEP and the PLP, while supporting all children within an inclusive framework." We should continue with: "The committee recognises that the Executive has taken a pragmatic position to create a system that balances the needs of all children, while co-ordinating support for those with complex and multiple factors."My suggestion could potentially bring all members on board by acknowledging that some people fear that the bill could lead to a three-tier system, but that the minister wants to ensure that all children receive the provision that they require. We could then state that, while we welcome the steps towards inclusion, the success of the measures will depend critically on the integration of the IEP and the PLP and the quality of relationships that exist. In advance of the system being set up, we cannot judge whether the outcome will be a three-tier system, albeit a better-quality one, or—as is the bill's intention—a single framework that provides inclusively for all children while recognising that not all children's needs are the same.My proposal is an attempt to bring all committee members on board. We do not dispute the intention of the bill, but some members have anxieties about what will happen when the bill is implemented. I was trying to capture that point. I will submit my proposal in written form.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I have two points. I draw to members' attention the fact that a unanimous view on the bill has advantages and gives us power, although I would not deny any member the right to press a different view. Perhaps you will give the clerk a detailed written suggestion, Wendy, but it seems to me that you are suggesting that we need a timescale objective for the bill, rather than saying that its implementation is going to happen now. You are saying that the Executive has taken the aspiration on board and that this is where the Executive wants to head, but that that cannot be done overnight.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

What I am really saying is that, until the bill is implemented, we cannot judge whether it will succeed in its ambition, which is to create an inclusive system. The committee is considering a caveat that says explicitly that we want an inclusive system. Whether that is achieved by the bill will depend on the quality of relationships and the integration of the three elements. Obviously, some people are sceptical about whether the bill will meet its objectives, and some are more optimistic. I do not think that the committee needs to take a view on what will happen in practice. We will know that only post hoc.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

Wendy is trying to get us a bit further along the road, for which I thank her. However, we can have an inclusive system only if everyone has the same access to it and if there is equality in it. I do not think that we should tie ourselves in knots about PLPs and IEPs because IEPs will be there in the interim until the development of PLPs, and things will eventually be broadened to cover more children. However, the system will not be inclusive when we have CSPs and IEPs/PLPs. I said all this last week and I do not want to go back over the same argument, but people will be chasing resources by asking for a CSP and we will have an adversarial situation in which people will go through tribunals and so on. There is absolutely no need for a two-tier system. With good practice, we can plan, and co-ordinate the planning, within an IEP system for all children. That happens at present. I would like something further to be put into the paragraph. The main aim should be to have one inclusive system for all young people, with one format for planning. The system should cater for the needs of each individual child because, remember, education in the 21st century really is about the individual pupil. I can see why James Douglas-Hamilton is so concerned that children may be left out of the loop in the planning process. That process will not be inclusive. We should be aiming for every child to have a plan, but we are pushing a two-tier system at the moment with CSPs and IEPs/PLPs. We have to be aware of the fact that we will simply be rewriting the record of needs. I said all that last week and I cannot say more.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We get the point. My difficulty with that approach is that it would be fine if infinite resources were readily available right across the country. It is not so easy otherwise.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

What Rosemary Bryne says does not represent the majority view from the evidence that we received. A few organisations took that view, but the vast majority accepted that the bill was a step forward and would lead to a more inclusive system. Our report must represent that. Many parents would be appalled if the committee reflected the view that children with additional support needs were not going to have additional resources and time at their disposal.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Some children face more barriers than others. As a parent of a daughter with special educational needs, I very much welcomed the reassurance that the barriers that she faced in her education were being specifically addressed and that there was a requirement to remove them. Not all children are the same.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

To some extent, what we put in will depend on what we say about the detail in later sections. The issue is as much how the bill ends up as how it is at the moment.Would it be sensible for Wendy Alexander to provide her wording to the clerks so that the section can be redrafted in light of the other comments that have been made, and perhaps for us to examine the general point about the approach to the bill at next week's meeting, when we are looking at the final version? Is that a workable suggestion?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will then be able—for example, with regard to Lord James Douglas-Hamilton's point on the link between records of needs and the new system—to see what we are proposing on the rest of it and to take an overall view, which I hope will be balanced against what we decide on the rest of it. Is that helpful?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I seek comments on the definition of additional support needs, which is addressed in paragraphs 32 to 40 and which, I suspect, will raise some of the same issues.

link

Paragraph 40 states:"it is vital that the Code of Practice provides sufficient clarity for the people who have to work within the system."There is a case for the code of practice being approved by the Education Committee or the Parliament under the affirmative procedure.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is proposed later. We will come to your point when we reach that section.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I do not agree with the second sentence in paragraph 40, which begins:"Overall, the Committee welcomes the broadening of the definition of additional support needs",but goes on to state:"However, it notes that the definition is complex and was potentially confusing for those working in the system."Does paragraph 40 deal with the and/or provisions?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is not just the and/or provisions, as we received a lot of evidence from various points of view—from the COSLA end and the parent end—that people did not know what the implications would be.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I think that the definition of additional support needs is much simpler, which I welcome. It should make it much easier to decide which youngsters have additional support needs.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

You are right. I was thinking about CSPs.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Should we make the point that although the definition is clearer, it will still require the interpretation of professionals, teachers or families? In other words, it will still need to be decided where a child falls on the spectrum of needs, in terms of a CSP or an IEP, which is why the code of practice is vital. The report could state, "The committee welcomes the broadening of the definition, however it notes that the definition will still require interpretation by professionals", or something to that effect.My second point is on paragraph 34. It should be in bold, because it contains a recommendation.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes, it should. As we go through the draft report we should confirm the committee recommendations, so that we have a clear decision for the clerks.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The paragraph addresses the concern, but we have not come up with a positive recommendation. That is probably asking too much.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is up to the Executive to do that. I made the recommendation in paragraph 34 at the beginning. Does anyone have a problem with it? It was tactical, to a degree.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

It would be reasonably straightforward to make an amendment that said, "to fully benefit from school education", or, "to achieve their potential in school education." That would be a relatively minor amendment.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

On paragraph 40, we need to welcome the new definition of additional support needs as being inclusive and helping to clarify what in the past has led to confusion. Of course, we still recognise some of the difficulties around the definition of a CSP.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

This may echo some of the points in the last section, but is it fair to say that that is the central duty in the bill? It would be helpful to stress that again.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

That helps us to move away from the pejorative interpretation of special educational needs. I was going to talk about new rights, but that is a different point as it does not come under this section. There would be a danger if we were to replace the legislation in 20 years' time but, at the moment, the definition is more inclusive—

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

That is an important point. Because of the discussions about who gets a CSP and who does not get one, the focus has not been on the new duties. If we restated that at this point in the report, that would help to focus attention on the matter. I am with Rhona Brankin on this. I am not sure that I like the second sentence about the definition being complex. I do not think that the definitions are all that complex. However, there has been difficulty with people's interpretation of them. That might need to be made more explicit.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Some of the definitions are spread across a number of sections and are in various forms. I agree that the definition of additional support needs is not particularly complicated. Is that the view of the committee?

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

The definition is a welcome clarification—or simplification.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is that the view of the committee?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We had written and oral evidence that indicated that provision is very variable in the area of English as an additional language. It has not always been dealt with correctly, and the potential of bilingualism as an asset has not been recognised. There has been a call for national standards to be developed in the area. Might it be relevant to say that the committee supports the call made by the Scottish Association for the Teaching of English as an Additional Language for national standards to be developed for the teaching of English as an additional language?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

It would come at the end of paragraph 38.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I have forgotten who spoke about this, but the evidence on the positive steps that have been made was quite good. Less impressive was the interpretation of how the bill would affect—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I accept that entirely, but the central point was that there were no national standards in that area. That featured in written correspondence from various people with an interest.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Perhaps we could just flag up that view, rather than endorse it explicitly. That point was put to us during a half-hour or one-hour evidence session. We could flag up the fact that the committee was rather worried by the matter. It would not be the committee's wish to reverse two decades of advancement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We could put in something like "The Executive might consider whether there is a need for national standards in the area of English as an additional language." Is that a valid suggestion?

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

The witness was trying to say that, in many cases, bilingual children who come into the system without much English to start with might be labelled as needing learning support in the sense that they are poor at the work that they are doing, rather than in the sense that they do not have a grasp of the English language. People have worked for years to diminish that perception. It would be good if we could try to counteract that perception. The convener's suggestion might help.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Sheila Roberts made another point, which was that people can have a superficial knowledge of English on which they can get by socially although they might not be able to pick up more elaborate ideas, such as mathematical concepts, that they might pick up better in their home language, if that is the right way to put it—I am sure that that is the wrong way to put it, but members know what I am getting at.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I fundamentally disagree with Sheila Roberts, who, as it is put in the draft report, "was concerned that these children should not be identified as having additional support needs."I absolutely agree with what Rosemary Byrne has said about those children being identified out of ignorance as having—

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

That is right: people do not understand what those children's needs are. However, they very much come under the broad definition of children who require additional support.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

Those children face significant barriers. There is an issue here about training. The wider definition of additional support needs has to be addressed by training the practitioners. I fundamentally disagreed with Sheila Roberts when she said that that area should not be included in the definition.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is right. There are two points: training and national standards.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

My point is similar to the point that was made by Rhona Brankin. I disagree with the use in paragraph 38 of the quotation from Sheila Roberts. We should concentrate on what could be done to improve support for bilingual people. She equates bilingualism with learning difficulties and says that"Increasing numbers of bilingual pupils will be inappropriately placed in low achieving groups"as a result of the bill, but there is no evidence for that.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

That may be past practice, but that does not mean that—

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

No, but I must say that that attitude is still out there. The point that Sheila Roberts made is relevant if we can word it so that—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Should we say that the committee does not accept that point but that we will bring the other parts in? It is fair to say that that is what she said, whether it is right or wrong.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

Can we say that we recognise her concerns but that we want to move forward?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes. Have we dealt with that point? I do not want to make a meal of it.

link

I suggest that it would be helpful to include a paragraph after paragraph 38 about children who have to move by virtue of their way of life, such as the children of travelling people and services personnel. When people in the services are moved from country to country, it is obviously disruptive for their children, who have to move from one school course to another and to fit in at different stages. There is a particular case about the children of travelling people and a paragraph on that would—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

What would be the point of that? Are you drawing attention to the need to have provision for them?

link

Children who move a great deal by virtue of their way of life have additional needs because their education is disrupted constantly.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

We sought reassurance from the minister on those points and we got that reassurance. It might be worth while to state that we understand that these—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Let us move on to the next section—paragraphs 41 to 54—on co-ordinated support plans and integrated working.

link

I have difficulty with the first sentence and particularly with the word "additional". There are different rights—take the child who cannot talk, the child who cannot see, the child who cannot hear, the child who cannot walk unaided, or the child who has cerebral palsy. Those children have severe learning difficulties and I am wholly opposed to anything that infers a diminution of priority or funding for the most vulnerable people in the community. For example, a child with dyspraxia should receive top priority because their needs are particular and considerable. To say that"the system is not designed to elevate a group or give children with CSPs additional rights"implies that the most vulnerable children in the community will not receive the top priority that they have received up to now.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that you are referring to paragraph 54, not to paragraph 41.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am not sure that I disagree with the sentence to which you refer.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I do not disagree with that sentence. Although I agree with what Lord James Douglas-Hamilton says, I do not think that what the minister said means that any youngster's needs will be met any less. For example, a youngster may have complex needs and barriers to learning but no need for inter-agency working. It is important to reassure parents that the question is not whether their child has a CSP. Parents have the right to have their child's needs met.

link

The first sentence of paragraph 54 ought to be reworded so that it is clear that the most vulnerable children in the community will not be disadvantaged.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

It is a way of trying to beef up and improve the situation, but we could meet all children's needs without a two-tier system.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

With respect, Rosemary, let us not have that argument any further. Do you have a particular point to make?

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

The issue is so relevant because we keep on having to pick up on it and look at ways to clarify it. We are trying to make a good job out of a bad premise.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am sorry to cut you short but we are not going to have a discussion about that again. We can come back to that when we discuss the general principles of the bill. We know your views on the subject, but we have to deal with the detail of the co-ordinated support plan now.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

I refer members to paragraph 54, which says:"However, the Committee strongly recommends that parents are given clear assurances that appropriate service provision will be made for all children".How are we going to do that? What are we going to recommend to the Executive?On the whole, this section is good. I would like members to reflect on the minister's explanation of the reasoning behind establishing a CSP, which was that, if the system was going to break down at all, it would be in relation to the co-ordination of many services. However, quite a lot of witnesses, particularly those from the Scottish Dyslexia Association and the National Autistic Society, said that the problem lies with gaining access to the system in the first place because of difficulties in the identification of the fundamental problem that the child is facing. There seems to be a reluctance in the system to commit resources. We have heard evidence to the effect that a lot of head teachers do not want to acknowledge the fact that there are such problems as dyslexia because they have resource implications for their schools. How can we square that particular circle? How do we give parents clear assurances that appropriate service provision will be made available for their children?

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

I thought that that was the area that we should focus on.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

There are three issues involved in that. The first is whether the minister is right to focus on the co-ordination issue; the second is whether co-ordination is defined correctly; and the third relates to the issues that are raised for people who might not qualify for a CSP if that definition is right.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

On that last point, paragraphs 61 to 65 specifically deal with the abolition of the record of needs and the views of the committee on the transition. We have all flagged up the fact that the perceived loss of rights is important. We will come back to that point. The point that Adam Ingram raised is addressed, to some extent, by the minister's letter, which says that there is a "spectrum of need" in relation to autism and dyslexia. He is trying to get away from the medical deficit model, which is why he is using complexity as the key definition. That also moves away from resources. That is why, by default, I have come around to thinking that the minister's definition is the best, although it is not perfect. As Rosemary Byrne says, in an ideal world, we would not have a definition but would have a seamless system. However, we do not have an ideal world. We have a difficult world with difficult decisions to make. We have to ask whether this system is an improvement from the point of view of the professionals and the families. We should not pretend that families who have children with dyslexia or autism will not continue to have battles to have their children's condition recognised. The bill will move matters forward, but it will not resolve all the problems because there will still be battles. A case came to me just this week—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Does Adam Ingram want to come back on that?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The words that Adam Ingram highlighted from the middle of paragraph 54 are helpful. We will come back to that issue.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

Paragraph 47 refers to further clarifying the definition of eligibility for a CSP in the code of practice. However, I wonder whether something should be included in the bill as opposed to the code of practice.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

On Lord James's point, we all wish to ensure that the most vulnerable are protected. Perhaps we need to add that to paragraph 54. However, we also need to say that the system is not designed to give those with CSPs additional rights over and above those who have additional support needs. It is important that we say that for those who are not eligible for CSPs.I do not like the wording in paragraph 52, where it says that the committee"is sympathetic to the points made by witnesses that there is a danger that children with complex needs such as autism will not be eligible for a CSP."The danger is not that they might not be eligible, but that their needs might not be met and that they would not have adequate recourse. The issue is not that they might not have a CSP but whether their needs are being met.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I believe that that point was met with nods from around the table.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

We should pursue Adam Ingram's point about identification, because it is crucial.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are coming to the issue of identification under another heading.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

Yes, but I agree with Adam Ingram's point that there must be more assurance about the issue of identification for CSPs. We must keep identification in mind because it is an important aspect for parents and is often a problem.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Not to beat about the bush on the matter, I believe that identification is central. I have two points. Paragraph 48 states Children in Scotland's view that the decision on a CSP must not be based on from where the support is provided but whether co-ordinated support is needed. Capability Scotland said that the definition did not recognise the extent of co-ordination and referred to the example of co-ordination within education authorities. I raise that point partly because of the issue about whether an education department or a health department should provides therapists of one sort or another. To some extent it would be accidental whether a CSP resulted from such co-ordination. There is a definition issue there. We discussed that matter with the minister and others but perhaps it needs further discussion.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

Is the point not about which department provides the service but whether the service is supplied in connection with education duties?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes, but can you argue, for example, that speech therapy is not supplied as part of educational provision?

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

Occasionally, speech and language therapists are attached to education departments, but health boards mainly provide them.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

What I am trying to say is that I believe that we have not fully teased out a definition.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I apologise for leaving the meeting. I had to work elsewhere for 30 minutes.We should be aware that provisions are going through at Westminster that would move some education therapists into being governed by health bodies. For example, I believe that educational psychologists are being discussed from that stance as part of a wider review of health service professionals. Therefore, there is a danger in defining because it would not be clear whether a professional would be regarded as part of the education service or of the health service. I believe that COSLA's evidence was that it would consider, for example, speech therapists as part of the education service, irrespective of whether they were brought in from a health department.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is partly my point. How a service is defined would affect whether a child is eligible for a CSP, which is an important point.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

The minister's evidence was clear: the provision of certain services is part of the problem—services such as speech therapy, physiotherapy and—

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am sorry, but what are those services a part of?

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

I mean the services that are currently provided by the health service.Education authorities might buy in those services, but they are provided by the health service. The problem lies in ensuring that such services are provided. The definition is useful, because it relates to where many of the problems exist.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not challenge that aspect of the definition, but my concern is about whether the definition is sufficiently precise to avoid accidental results that depend on where a therapist or psychologist comes from.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Confusion remains about the interpretation of co-ordination of services, so perhaps that is another matter for the code of practice. When I first saw Children in Scotland's suggestion, I thought that it was a step forward, but it probably leaves the same set of interpretation decisions to be made.I expect the code of practice to make several suggestions. I expect it to say explicitly that speech therapy and physiotherapy are by definition additional services that would require co-ordination alongside teaching, although some authorities, such as my local authority, might be moving towards buying everything in.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

I have difficulty with the concept that a provision that can lead to legal rights, such as the right to go to a tribunal, should not be defined in the bill in a way that the tribunal can get a handle on. It is unsatisfactory to put such a matter in the code of practice. Perhaps we will seek clarification on that, even if we are not unanimous about the solution to that problem. Could we seek clarification?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Perhaps we need legal advice, rather than political or policy-based interpretation.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Could we have guidance from the Scottish Parliament information centre?

Martin Verity Clerk
link

The Parliament has a directorate of legal services, which can advise us on the point.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Having clarity would help. The clerks have picked up the point about what is included and whether that matches the definition.

link

Section 23 says that the code of practice may, not should, make provision as to many details. That is an enabling power.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That comment is helpful and relevant.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

I will return to what Ken Macintosh said. It is important that although it is clear from the bill that a CSP should be in pursuance of educational objectives, if, for example, a young person who required the involvement of social services was in Dumfries and Galloway, where the council's social services are part of the same department as the education service, there would be no argument about whether they were eligible for a CSP, irrespective of the council's departmental organisation. However, concerns have been expressed, and the code of practice should make such matters clear.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do members have any other issues to raise? I will return to the recommendations in a second.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Did we agree to Elaine Murray's point about paragraph 52?

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We agreed to reword that paragraph. Elaine Murray phrased it well and members nodded.Only paragraph 54 contains a recommendation. I sense that the committee did not accept Lord James Douglas-Hamilton's caveats—particularly that to the first sentence of paragraph 54.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

It might be worth putting in a phrase about taking resources away from the most vulnerable.

link

The committee's view was that the issue should be presented positively and that people who have severe learning difficulties should be properly looked after. Positive wording can be achieved; my point is just that the first sentence has an undesirable implication.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is right. That sentence sets the focus. Adam Ingram asked whether the middle of the paragraph should be firmed up. I am not averse to returning to that if members want to think about it for next week.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So with Lord James Douglas-Hamilton's amendment, the paragraph will say something like, "The committee believes that"—

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I would like to clarify what I think we are saying. The committee is saying that it believes that the bill will ensure that the most vulnerable—I am not sure whether we want to use that word, but we want a word with that meaning.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

The phrase "children with the most significant barriers" could be used.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

That is right. We should say that the committee welcomes the fact that the children who face the most significant barriers will be given the support they need, but the committee also welcomes the assurances that the system is not designed to give children with CSPs additional rights.

link

We should say that the committee supports the policy that the most vulnerable children should receive priority support. There may be a debate as to whether, under the bill, such children will receive such support.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

There are two different points. The main point that you are making is that children with additional needs have barriers in their way. The bill is designed to give them help in surmounting those barriers.

link

With respect, Ken, I have no doubt about the clerks' ability to sort out a suitable form of words to your satisfaction and that of everyone else.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will come back with a final view on that issue next week.I have a slight qualm as to whether it is factually correct to say that the bill will give children with CSPs "additional" rights compared with any other group of young people. The reality is that they will receive additional rights, as they will have the right to go to the tribunal.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

They have different rights rather than additional rights.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

They will have additional rights. I think that there are no two ways about that.

Rhona Brankin Lab Midlothian
link

The issue is that people must be reassured that young people's additional support needs will be met. The bill's intention is that, whether or not young people have a CSP, their needs will be met and the barriers that they face will be dealt with. People need reassuring. The worry for many parents is that they will have what they perceive to be reduced rights.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. We will obviously need to return to the final version of that recommendation. If we are done with that section, let us move on to the next.

Rosemary Byrne SSP South of Scotland
link

I want to make just one point. Basically, the CSP is supposed to co-ordinate things. Consideration needs to be given to ensuring that all children have the same rights, whether or not they have a CSP. We need to talk about that again. I know that we will come to the tribunal system later in the paper, but there just seems to be such a contradiction there.

Robert Brown LD The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is the general point. I appreciate that you want to keep making it, but it does not particularly advance our work for you to do so.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education Committee Wednesday 14 January 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 10
  3. Petition Petitions · 22
  4. School Transport Guidelines Committee business · 26
  5. Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 494

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.