To ask the First Minister what concerns the Scottish Executive has regarding child poverty. (S1F-2121)
Official Report · Chamber
Child Poverty
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 3
- Christine Grahame SNP 2
- Dennis Canavan Ind 2
- Sir David Steel 2
- Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind 1
The record
10 contributionsI want to live in a Scotland that is full of opportunities and I want those opportunities to be open to all children. That is why we are investing in, among other measures, sure start Scotland, a child care strategy and the new community schools.
Given that one in three children in resources-rich Scotland lives in poverty and that we have the third-highest child poverty rate of 25 countries after five years of Labour rule, is the First Minister not ashamed?
First, I am pleased that the number of children in Scotland in absolute poverty has dropped so dramatically since 1997. I am disappointed that the number in relative poverty has not dropped more quickly and further. However, I acknowledge that that is because family incomes, particularly in middle-income families, have increased and prospered since 1997.
We must get the balance right. We want to ensure that ordinary working families in Scotland have an opportunity to grow their family budget and have the sort of successful family life that most of us would want them to have. We also want to ensure that those who start with disadvantage in whatever community in Scotland—rural or urban—have the opportunity to grow out of that disadvantage, take up opportunities, educational and otherwise, and have good health and a decent job. We are best equipped to succeed in that if we work in close partnership with the United Kingdom Government. If we work together, we will do the job well.
We must get the balance right. We want to ensure that ordinary working families in Scotland have an opportunity to grow their family budget and have the sort of successful family life that most of us would want them to have. We also want to ensure that those who start with disadvantage in whatever community in Scotland—rural or urban—have the opportunity to grow out of that disadvantage, take up opportunities, educational and otherwise, and have good health and a decent job. We are best equipped to succeed in that if we work in close partnership with the United Kingdom Government. If we work together, we will do the job well.
Some areas of the east end of Glasgow have pockets where child poverty goes up to 90 cent, which shames the nation. Some of those children were, with their parents, victims of the 30 July flood. The UK Government was good enough to give £100,000 to the Czech Republic flood victims, particularly because of the children. However, the First Minister's Executive and the UK Government have given nothing to the east end victims. Will he please now think again because of the children of the east end of Glasgow?
First, I am sure that Dorothy-Grace Elder will know that the minister responsible is developing a package of responses that will be of assistance in Glasgow. I also want to say—I hope that this is not misrepresented or taken lightly—that a situation in which people in eastern Europe are dying because of flooding is a serious one and it is right and proper that Britain fulfils its international obligations to help out.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. Standing orders state clearly that the Presiding Officer should treat all members of Parliament equally, but the standing orders seem to be regularly ignored during First Minister's question time. Invariably, John Swinney is number 1 and David McLetchie is number 2. They usually take up at least half or more than half of the time allocated for First Minister's question time.
Today, John Swinney was not here and I noticed that the substitute, number 3 from the SNP benches, was put into the number 1 position. I also note that earlier the Presiding Officer chose Phil Gallie to ask a supplementary question despite the fact that the member was not even in the chamber to ask the question that he had lodged—indeed, he withdrew his question. What is going on?
Today, John Swinney was not here and I noticed that the substitute, number 3 from the SNP benches, was put into the number 1 position. I also note that earlier the Presiding Officer chose Phil Gallie to ask a supplementary question despite the fact that the member was not even in the chamber to ask the question that he had lodged—indeed, he withdrew his question. What is going on?
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
On the second point, I properly called Mr Gallie on an earlier question. He sent me a note explaining why he was withdrawing a later one. I do not have foresight; I was not to know that he was not going to be here later. However, his question was perfectly valid.
On the more general question, it is for the chamber to consider, as we move towards the end of this session of Parliament, whether the existing question time structure is a good one. However, the structure has been operating for three and a half years and I am surprised that Mr Canavan has just discovered that questions 1 and 2 are usually given to the leaders of the Opposition parties. That is the agreement.
I think that the leaders of the Opposition parties will not mind my saying that I have implored them on many occasions to keep their questions short to allow plenty of time for others to get in. In fact, we did well today. Not everyone was called, but nearly everyone who asked was called.
That is my answer at the moment. However, the structure of question time is a matter for the chamber to consider. I have views on how question time might be improved.
On the more general question, it is for the chamber to consider, as we move towards the end of this session of Parliament, whether the existing question time structure is a good one. However, the structure has been operating for three and a half years and I am surprised that Mr Canavan has just discovered that questions 1 and 2 are usually given to the leaders of the Opposition parties. That is the agreement.
I think that the leaders of the Opposition parties will not mind my saying that I have implored them on many occasions to keep their questions short to allow plenty of time for others to get in. In fact, we did well today. Not everyone was called, but nearly everyone who asked was called.
That is my answer at the moment. However, the structure of question time is a matter for the chamber to consider. I have views on how question time might be improved.
With respect, Presiding Officer, it is not a matter for the chamber at this particular time. It is a matter for you to abide by the standing orders that have been agreed by the Parliament. The standing orders state clearly that you should treat all members equally.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
That is true, but there is a well-known saying that, although everyone is equal, some are more equal than others. That has always been the case with party leaders, as Mr Canavan knows from his previous incarnation as well as his present one. I am quite open to suggestions for change, but that is the system that we have used and I am not proposing to change it.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Sep 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 26 September 2002 Debate · 1
- Rural Business (Sustainability) Debate · 126
- Transport (Investment) Debate · 94
- Business Motion Business motions · 44
- Rail Services (Laurencekirk) Questions · 6
- National Health Service (Grampian) Questions · 9
- Criminal Justice (Fingerprint Evidence) Questions · 11
- Child Psychology Services Questions · 7
- Cultural Heritage Questions · 9
- Home Adaptations Questions · 8
- Bus Services (Strikes) Questions · 4
- Homelessness (Priority Need) Questions · 6
- Child Protection Questions · 6
- National Health Service (Low Pay) Questions · 4
- Building Communities Questions · 7
- National Health Service (Winter Pressures) Questions · 7
- Urban Regeneration Questions · 5
- Congestion Charging Questions · 4
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Fluoridation First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Local Government (Proportional Representation) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Economic Growth (Population Change) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Child Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Race Equality Debate · 43
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 21
- Points of Order Procedure · 7
- Decision Time Decision time · 77
- Cancer Services Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.