To ask the Scottish Executive whether public sector workers' wages, conditions and pension rights will be fully protected under any private finance initiative or public-private partnership transfers to the private sector. (S1O-5388)
Official Report · Chamber
Workers' Rights
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Andy Kerr Lab 5
- Tommy Sheridan SSP 2
- Pauline McNeill Lab 1
- Donald Gorrie LD 1
- Andrew Wilson SNP 1
- Sir David Steel 1
The record
11 contributionsThe rights of staff transferring from the public to the private sector in PFI or PPP schemes are protected by the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations—TUPE—which stipulate that, in the event of a transfer of an undertaking, the employees transfer with their existing terms and conditions intact. The regulations are applied comprehensively in all PFI and PPP schemes in Scotland.
Pension provision is not covered in the TUPE regulations, but common practice in Scotland is to provide protection for pensions on what is called a broadly comparable basis. In addition, local government employees are able to retain access to the local government pension scheme by virtue of the Local Government Pension Scheme (Scotland) (Amendment) Regulations 2000 (SSI 2000/199).
Pension provision is not covered in the TUPE regulations, but common practice in Scotland is to provide protection for pensions on what is called a broadly comparable basis. In addition, local government employees are able to retain access to the local government pension scheme by virtue of the Local Government Pension Scheme (Scotland) (Amendment) Regulations 2000 (SSI 2000/199).
Does the minister accept that his answer is misleading? He knows that, under secondary transfers after the commencement of PPP and PFI projects, workers' wages, conditions and pension rights are not protected, which is why the organised trade union movement in this country is opposed to the idea. The fact is that low-paid workers are paying for the profits of the private financiers who are trying to privatise our public services.
Will the minister join me in condemning his Government, which, in 1998, at a meeting of the European Council of Ministers, voted against pension rights being included in the TUPE regulations?
Will the minister join me in condemning his Government, which, in 1998, at a meeting of the European Council of Ministers, voted against pension rights being included in the TUPE regulations?
What I will do is recognise the £2.8 billion of additional investment that has come to Scotland by way of PPP and PFI schemes and which has delivered 80 schools for 64,000 pupils and health services for thousands of people throughout the central belt of Scotland.
In addition, I point out that I listen to and engage with the trade union movement, which is why I have set up a working group with the Scottish Trades Union Congress to deal with the issue of the two-tier work force. I hope that that work will take in some of the concerns that have been expressed by the organised labour and trade union movement, for which I have great respect.
In addition, I point out that I listen to and engage with the trade union movement, which is why I have set up a working group with the Scottish Trades Union Congress to deal with the issue of the two-tier work force. I hope that that work will take in some of the concerns that have been expressed by the organised labour and trade union movement, for which I have great respect.
link
Will the minister confirm that he is making steady progress in his talks with the trade unions to ensure protections for all workers in relation to pension schemes, and that other public sector workers who work in non-private hospitals who had already been subject to a drop in their conditions will also benefit from the talks as the minister is working to ensure that pension schemes and other rights will be applicable to them?
That is the purpose of the talks. Best value means having a well-trained, well-motivated and well-paid work force. Our discussions with the STUC are aimed at delivering that. The matters are complex and we have made a lot of effort to try to seek a solution to the problems. We expect to report to the Parliament on the issue by autumn this year.
Will the minister accept that the private sector workers in the private prison in Kilmarnock have worse pension conditions than similar public sector workers have? Will the minister assure us that no change in the way in which public services are delivered will be based on reducing the quality of life of fairly low-paid employees?
As I said to Mr Sheridan, common practice in Scotland, which is reflected in guidance, is that pension schemes in the private sector should be broadly comparable with those in the public sector. In the discussions on the PPP and PFI schemes that I mentioned, I have to deal with the issue of the two-tier work force, which would include the matters raised by the member.
Does the minister agree that, by hammering workers' rights and conditions, the PPP projects have demotivated people in the public sector? Will he therefore undertake to consider the matter that Mr Sheridan asked about in order to ensure that public service workers are protected and motivated?
The research done by the Amicus trade union shows that many workers expressed the view that, under the changed arrangements, they are well-managed, well-motivated and well-paid. However, that is not always the case, which is why I am engaged in discussions with the STUC. To talk down these matters in the way that Andrew Wilson continues to do only does a disservice to Scottish public servants and, indeed, to his party.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Before we turn to First Minister's question time, I think that the Parliament would like to give a warm welcome to the First Minister and the Deputy First Minister of Northern Ireland, David Trimble and Mark Durkan, who are with us today. [Applause.] I would like to say how much the Presiding Officers and clerks of the three devolved institutions are looking forward to meeting in Belfast next week.
I invite the Parliament to welcome a large group of members of Parliament and mayors from Catalonia, who are also with us today. [Applause.]
I invite the Parliament to welcome a large group of members of Parliament and mayors from Catalonia, who are also with us today. [Applause.]
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Jun 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 20 June 2002 Debate · 1
- Railways Statement · 76
- Public Infrastructure Investment Debate · 111
- Business Motion Business motions · 37
- HCI (Clydebank) Statement · 32
- Schools (Milk) Questions · 6
- Child Prostitution Questions · 8
- Nursery Education (Qualified Teachers) Questions · 8
- Special Educational Needs Questions · 8
- Means Warrants (Strathclyde) Questions · 4
- Methadone Questions · 9
- Occupational Health Services Questions · 4
- Police (Funding) Questions · 8
- Magistrates (ECHR Training) Questions · 9
- Diet and Health (Children) Questions · 8
- Social Inclusion Questions · 8
- Workers' Rights Questions · 11
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Free Personal Care First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Executive (Policy Analysts) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Euro 2008 First Minister’s Questions · 8
- School Meals (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 80
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 12
- Decision Time Decision time · 56
- Foot-and-mouth Recovery Plan (Dumfries and Galloway) Debate · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.