Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Genetic Manipulation Technology

Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 13 June 2002 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link
To ask the Scottish Executive whether it plans to undertake a national debate on genetic manipulation technology similar to that announced by Her Majesty's Government. (S1O-5338)

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Environment and Rural Development · West of Scotland
link
Scottish ministers fully support the Agriculture and Environment Biotechnology Commission's recommendation for a full and informed public debate in advance of decisions on the commercialisation of genetically modified crops. We are working with the United Kingdom Government to ensure that such a debate takes a form that will enable Scottish issues, values and opinions to be heard.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link
I thank the minister for that encouraging response. He will be aware that there was originally a pretence of consultation on GM planting at Roskill farm in Munlochy in my constituency. At the end of the day, after all the civil servants and scientists had come, my constituents never had any chance of preventing the continuation of the trial. What will be the terms of reference of the national consultation on GM technology? If the debate goes against current Executive policy, will the minister give a commitment to abandon the Executive's programme for the promotion of GM?

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Environment and Rural Development · West of Scotland
link
John Farquhar Munro raises two related points. I have never made any pretence of saying that the current regulations occasionally use the word consultation, but I do not think that that has the connotation that members would currently put to it. It is more a question of an information system than of a consultation, whereby members of the public participate actively in a decision. The only decisions that are taken are in Parliament's passing the regulations that give rise to that.

I can assure John Farquhar Munro that the AEBC report has produced a number of helpful and constructive ways in which informed public debate might take place. I am anxious that the recommendations in the report should be adopted throughout the United Kingdom. We should provide ways to ensure that, not just at Roskill or Munlochy but throughout Scotland, there is an adequate opportunity for everyone to participate in the debate. We must also have a means of ensuring that the outcomes of the debate are taken fully into account before any decision is taken on the commercialisation of GM crops.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link
I might have misinterpreted what the minister said at the beginning, because it sounded to me as if he was telling us, in advance, of the decision to plant commercial crops. I would still like him to be absolutely clear. Does he mean that the decision on whether to plant commercial GM crops in Scotland will depend completely on the outcome of the public debate? I ask him to confirm or deny that.

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Environment and Rural Development · West of Scotland
link
I am not quite sure what Robin Harper is driving at. I am saying quite clearly that, as he knows, two issues are involved. We have a regulation problem, which we must address because, as it stands, there is no legal basis for stopping commercialisation. We also have an opportunity. The opportunity that has arisen is the agreement that there shall be no commercialisation until we have finished the present field trial process. It is enormously helpful that the AEBC has recommended that, within that process and informed by its outcome, the amount of public concern should trigger a fully informed public debate. That debate must inform the decision not only of this Parliament but of the United Kingdom Parliament and how we then address the present European regulation. The public debate will have a heavy influence on how we address those issues, because there has not been such a public debate since GM developed 10 or 12 years ago. I hope that everyone welcomes such a debate taking place before we decide on whether to have commercial GM crops.

John Home Robertson Lab East Lothian
link
Will the minister acknowledge the potential for immense environmental as well as economic benefits from GM science in Scotland? There is also the possible development of life-saving medicines from GM science. I urge the minister to stick to the precautionary principle, but to promote an informed debate to balance the scaremongering that is coming from certain quarters.

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Environment and Rural Development · West of Scotland
link
John Home Robertson, if he has done anything, has just started stage 1 of the debate—which is proper and is what is required. Those who have serious and genuine concerns should be able to put their point and those who see a potential advantage in GM crops can also contribute to the debate. That is the whole purpose of my—and, I hope, the Parliament—being supportive of the Executive having such a wide, informed, public debate before a decision is taken on the commercialisation of GM crops.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 13 June 2002 Debate · 1
  2. Youth Justice Debate · 105
  3. Education Debate · 81
  4. Business Motion Business motions · 47
  5. Cities Review Questions · 8
  6. Glasgow Airport Rail Link Questions · 8
  7. Volunteers' Week Questions · 8
  8. Genetic Manipulation Technology Questions · 8
  9. Dental Health (Greater Glasgow) Questions · 5
  10. Anti-social Behaviour Questions · 10
  11. Drug Abuse Questions · 10
  12. Joint Future Group Report (Implementation) Questions · 4
  13. Closed-circuit Television Questions · 10
  14. Less Favoured Areas Questions · 8
  15. Non-trunk Roads (Maintenance) Questions · 8
  16. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  17. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
  18. Education (Public-private Partnerships) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  19. Congestion Charging First Minister’s Questions · 15
  20. Common Fisheries Policy Debate · 72
  21. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 18
  22. Decision Time Decision time · 73
  23. Epilepsy Members’ business · 29

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.