Good morning. It sounds unlucky to say this, but welcome to the 13th meeting of the Education Committee this session. Today we continue to hear evidence on the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill. Will people please ensure that their mobile phones, pagers and so on are switched off so that they do not bleep during the meeting.We have a number of different panels of witnesses this morning. I welcome panel number 1, which comprises Ewan Malcolm, the mediation development officer of the Scottish Mediation Network, R John Elliot, chairman of the Scottish committee of the Council on Tribunals and Stephanie Taylor, the policy research officer of the Advocacy Safeguards Agency.I begin by declaring my membership of the Law Society of Scotland and my consultancy with Ross Harper Solicitors, because legal aid issues might come up in this morning's evidence. I invite the witnesses to make their opening statements.
Official Report · Committee
Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Robert Brown LD 55
- R John Elliot 33
- Ken Macintosh Lab 28
- Dinah Aitken Enquire 28
- Kate McGuiness 27
- Dr Lloyd 23
- Rhona Brankin Lab 22
- Adam Gaines Disability Rights Commission 17
- Ewan Malcolm Scottish Mediation Network 13
- Fiona Hyslop SNP 12
- Rosemary Byrne SSP 11
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 10
- Elaine Murray Lab 10
- Stephanie Taylor Advocacy Safeguards Agency 9
- Wendy Alexander Lab 3
- R John Elliot WS Scottish Committee of the Council on Tribunals 1
- Dr Gwynedd Lloyd University of Edinburgh 1
The record
306 contributions · showing 1–200Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. The Scottish committee of the Council on Tribunals is a statutory body that was set up many years ago to oversee the constitution and working of what are loosely termed tribunals. In Scotland, the numbers range from children's hearings at approximately 68,000 hearings a year, through appeals service tribunals at 38,000, down through employment, immigration and General Commissioners of Income Tax tribunals down to such matters as the police appeals tribunal, which has approximately two hearings a year.Apart from going to see the hearings, or at least a number of them, we comment on the rules, regulations and proposals regarding tribunal systems or proposed tribunal systems. My body is concerned solely with appeals mechanisms. As I mentioned, we are involved with numerous tribunals—in fact, more people appear before tribunals than they do before the courts.My particular role this morning is to set out a number of comments and views that the Scottish committee of the Council on Tribunals made on the draft bill and to tell the committee briefly about our areas of concern. The first concern relates to section 14, which deals with jurisdiction. Members might wish to ask me about that. Secondly, we have comments to make about training of panel members—they are not entirely adverse but they are criticisms nonetheless. Our third concern relates to emphasis on efficient and effective performance of the tribunal. Fourthly, we are concerned about the provision that hearings are to be held in private. Our final concern relates to the administration of oaths.We also have some positive comments on the bill. It is not always popular to make positive comments, but we do have some. I would be happy to develop any of the points should the committee wish me to do so.
Although I work with the Scottish Mediation Network, funding arrangements mean that the Scottish Mediation Network is also managed by Mediation UK. I hope to be able to assist the committee with sections 16 and 17, which make specific mention of the provision of mediation services.The purpose of the Scottish Mediation Network is to promote mediation in all its forms. Our concern is that mediation services should meet the needs of the different strands of mediation. I also happen to be a mediation practitioner. I hope that I can also share that perspective with the committee.
The Advocacy Safeguards Agency is a national agency in Scotland that is concerned with the development and improvement of advocacy provision. Our concerns relate to the support that is set out in the bill for parents, families and children. At the moment, as the committee knows, it is proposed that mediation will be used in cases where there is a dispute. We advocate that parents should have representation and support at formal and informal stages because that would foster better relations between children, their parents and schools. We see that provision as being consistent with the other provisions in the bill for mediation and tribunals.
Thank you. I should also have welcomed Brian Adam to the meeting. He is at the committee this morning as the substitute member for Adam Ingram.
Various witnesses have told us of their concerns about the lack of equity at tribunals. They said that some parents might be able to afford legal representation, but others might not. Given that legal aid is not available at tribunals, Children in Scotland suggested that advocacy support should be available at tribunals to support appellants. The committee would be interested to hear the panel's views on that issue.
The general view of the Scottish committee of the Council on Tribunals, which is backed up by evidence, is that advice and representation are helpful to appellants, so we strongly support such provision at any hearing. We find that advice's being available before any hearing is particularly important. The emphasis is often on representation rather than on the pre-hearing advice.
By "representation", do you mean legal representation specifically?
No, we mean representation.
As you would expect, the Advocacy Safeguards Agency also supports the provision of advocacy support to families who go through the procedures. In the early informal stages, before disputes arise, during which a parent might feel unsure about how to communicate with a school or—as is indicated in the policy memorandum—might feel mistrust of schools or education authorities, advocacy is useful in enabling parents to communicate more effectively and to make known their views. Support in the early stages can mean that disputes do not arise. We support the provision of such support at a much earlier stage than is being proposed.
From the point of view of mediation, which is in effect a rigorous process of structured negotiation, people who are supported by effective and well-prepared advocates can use that process very well. In that context, advocacy can be a useful support to the collaborative—rather than adversarial—approach of mediation.
Will you comment on the evidence that some bodies have given us, which suggests that there is inequity in the way in which the tribunals are set up, whereby some parents can afford legal representation while others cannot?
It is difficult to comment on evidence that we have not seen.
I suppose that I am driving at the question of how we can arrive at a situation in which some parents do not perceive themselves to be disadvantaged when the local authority has legal representation but they are not entitled to legal aid for legal representation.
The view of the Scottish committee of the Council on Tribunals is that legal aid is desirable in circumstances in which it will promote a fair hearing. When we talk about the provision of legal aid, the general suggestion is that representation must come from a lawyer but, as I have said, our view is that good-quality representation is what matters. In employment tribunals, for example, there is much good-quality representation that does not come from lawyers, but it is funded by someone.
In the Executive's report on the consultation, it stated that there was broad support for advocacy and conciliation instead of, or in addition to, mediation. Last week, the committee heard from parents' groups, which suggested that advocacy would be a better way of resolving disagreements than would mediation. What are your views on the suggestion on advocacy services?
As I have said, I feel that representation is important. Although, in my particular role, I support advocacy representation, if other forms of representation were proposed for parents—when I say "parents", I mean parents and children—I feel that that would be sufficient to support them through what can be a difficult and traumatic process. The mediation process can work but, as Ewan Malcolm pointed out, it can be difficult for parents to go into that situation if they feel mistrustful—perhaps because they have had bad experiences—or if they do not have all the information that they need beforehand. That is why, in the consultation, many parents and a number of other organisations felt that mediation alone was not enough.As I said, it is a shame that support is not provided to parents—although it cannot really be called support, because the mediator is neutral—until a dispute arises.
It is inevitable that people who go to mediation will have a huge amount of distrust. That is likely to be what drives the comments. The consultation report also said that it was felt that mediation would come into play only when relationships had broken down. In fact, my experience as a mediator is that mediation can be hugely helpful when a breakdown in a relationship is expected. The essence of mediation is structured negotiation with the assistance of an external person.
We view mediation as a helpful part of any dispute resolution process. The suggestion that tribunals should try not to allow an adversarial situation to develop runs throughout the process. The involvement of advocacy suggests some adversarial proceedings, which are, after all, in our legal tradition. However, we observe that a tribunal that tries to have an inquisitorial role has difficulty in doing that and in running a fair hearing.
Should tribunals have a power such as that which the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service has in employment disputes to refer matters to mediation or to encourage mediation as best practice that is to be preferred to going straight to a tribunal hearing?
Breathing space for mediation is often a good idea. Various views are expressed about whether mediation can be truly voluntary if it is forced on parties. I am not an expert on that, but mediation is a good option.
We suggest that the model that is used in family law, which gives sheriffs the option under a rule of court to ask parties to consider mediation without forcing them to participate in it, should be considered.
The jurisdiction of tribunals is limited to education authorities, which the submission from the Scottish committee of the Council on Tribunals says is an anomaly, because"the Tribunal might make an order that a child receives services from … a Health Board".Section 19 of the bill will allow education authorities to request the help of other agencies in fulfilling their functions and says:"An appropriate agency must comply with a request … unless it … is incompatible with its own … duties".What are the panel's views on the jurisdiction of tribunals?
As my committee made the comment, I should speak first. Our response to the consultation and our submission to the committee commented on that issue. The danger is that decisions will become meaningless. We also believe that what we call a joined-up service will not be provided. One notes the inherent contradiction in section 19 between subsection (1), which says:"request the help of that agency",and subsection (3), which says:"An appropriate agency must comply".One can see the many gaps into which efforts might fall.Our work in relation to children's hearings in particular shows that when a tribunal cannot require other agencies to do certain things, children sometimes return to a hearing after an agency has failed to do what the panel thought was necessary. That does not happen frequently, but it happens often enough to make us concerned. We have commented on the matter in several of our annual reports.
I understand that in England, the tribunal system for matters that concern aids and adaptations under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 and the equivalent tribunal to that which the bill proposes have been unified. Are you aware of that? To make the system more effective, can the division be overcome here between services that additional support needs tribunals deal with and the linked issue of aids and adaptations that people might require? Those two tribunals have slightly different jurisdictions and deal with roughly the same subject.
I am aware of that issue, but I am afraid that I cannot give any detail on it. However, I could certainly find out about it and supply the committee with the information, if you would like me to do so.
I would. What are your views on whether having those two tribunals is likely to be a problem? Do you have any views on how we could get round the difficulty of the two tribunals' operating in a reserved-devolved split in Scotland, and on how we could bring their jurisdictions together, as appears to have been done in England?
I would prefer to address that matter in writing.
That would be helpful.
Independent additional support needs tribunals are to be established to hear appeals on matters relating to co-ordinated support plans. Those matters include an education authority's decision to prepare or not to prepare a CSP, the information that is contained within a CSP and an authority's failure to carry out certain actions within the time limits that are prescribed by regulations. What are your views on the establishment of the additional support needs tribunals?
The Scottish committee of the Council on Tribunals views the establishment of the additional support needs tribunal as a positive move, because it will provide the right kind of forum for dispute resolution. Tribunals are introduced when relatively speedy decisions are desired, where informality is desired and, in particular, where expertise is required on the panel. Those seem to me to be the three distinguishing marks of a tribunal.
The Scottish Mediation Network envisages that the availability of mediation would run parallel to the existence of a tribunal, not as a panacea, but simply as an additional option at any stage when people decide to take a consensual, rather than adversarial, approach.
Likewise, the Advocacy Safeguards Agency views advocacy support as being support for children and families at any stage in the process, particularly the informal stage, whether they are in mediation with the schools or education authorities or at a tribunal.
Is the system too adversarial at the outset, rather than being one in which parents feel that their needs will be met without having to go through tribunals and mediation? A number of comments have been made to the effect that we are setting off from the beginning with a confrontational element in the system rather than with a system that assures people that we would go to tribunals or mediation only in extreme cases. Do you have any views on that?
Our view is that this rejigging of how things are done will provide an opportunity. There is no doubt that the words "mediation" and "conciliation" are being used a lot, particularly by local authorities. The bill provides a great opportunity for awareness raising, training in skills and consensus building.
Ultimately, some form of dispute resolution is needed and, in such circumstances, one wants a method that is informal so that parents feel that they can deal with it and it becomes something with which they can cope. That means that parents need to have certain support services to rely upon; however, we must ultimately have a means of resolving disputes. The question is where that is best done.
Do you think that the tribunal will be the best way to do that?
It can be. We have only to watch children's hearings and education authority appeal committees to see that. I have observed education authority appeal committees at which the professional who is representing the council has been beaten into the ground by the parents because the parents have a story to tell. We are dealing with children, and nothing gets parents going more than children do. The tribunals could run well.
The Advocacy Safeguards Agency also feels that it is important that parents have a forum to which they can go if they are unable to resolve their dispute reasonably without formal resolution. Unfortunately, there have been disputes, and many parents—as the committee will know from the responses to its call for evidence—have felt that they have had to fight for provision.We hope that the bill will mean that there will be a more collaborative approach to meeting children's needs, but it is important that there is a fall-back position of an independent forum at which matters can be resolved.
I understand that the Scottish committee of the Council on Tribunals has recently done a report on children's hearings that holds them up as an exemplar of good practice in a number of areas. Are there lessons to be learned from the experience of the children's panels that we can take on board in the context of the bill?
There is no doubt that there are such lessons to learn. One of our comments on the bill relates to the necessity of training for panel members. We think that members of children's panels are extremely well trained and we have observed hearings at which that has been evident. For example, chairing a hearing is not an easy task, but one sees children's hearings at which there are three members on a panel, each of whom chairs a different hearing during a particular session.Children's panel members demonstrate considerable skills and commitment to the process. They run an inquisitorial process in which they try to avoid confrontation as much as possible—their training leads them in that direction. Most tribunal systems can learn an enormous amount from the children's hearings. Although not everything in that system is good, it contains a great deal that is good.
Have you been consulted by the Executive on the number of tribunals it is anticipated that the bill will give rise to?
As far as I am aware, we have not been consulted on that. I do not know whether the Executive has made any such statement, but I do not think that it has asked us how many tribunals it is expected that there will be; we would probably not know that.
I know that that is difficult to anticipate; we are trying to get a feel for the scale of the bill's implications.The Executive has indicated to us that it anticipates that only half of those who have a record of needs will get a CSP. Parents have told us that that could mean—particularly during the transition from the old system to the new system—that many parents who have children who have a record of needs will automatically want to use the tribunal system to ensure that they get a CSP, because they see the CSP as being a better passport to services. That could block the system, particularly in the early years of the bill's implementation. Do you anticipate that that will be a problem?
As you rightly said, that will depend on the numbers. Any new system always has growing pains in areas such as administration and inexperienced panel members can require training.If one considers immigration, there have been times when blocks of cases have come through. Such situations have proved extremely difficult to manage, although the present situation is being managed very well. In past years, there have been significant backlogs of cases, which have caused enormous problems. To some extent, the issue will depend on resources, but I do not imagine that the Executive would want to provide resources for the initial block that were not required later on, as that might be a misuse of resources.
I want to ask about equity in the system. We keep coming back to the fact that not everyone will have access to a tribunal, because of problems about access to legal aid and the fact that so much hinges on the CSP. We have received a lot of evidence in which concern has been expressed about that and it has been suggested that, rather than have separate systems, whereby some people have a CSP, some have an individualised educational programme and some have a personal learning plan, there should be a single system for everyone and everyone should have the same treatment. That would mean that everyone who had concerns about whether they were receiving adequate support from education or health resources would have access to a tribunal.I have mentioned the issue of the volume of tribunals. If Parliament decided that a single system was more appropriate than a fragmented system involving CSPs, IEPs and PLPs, would Scotland be able cope with such a system, which would allow any parent to go to a tribunal if they were not getting adequate resources, or do we need an element of rationing in the system, whereby only a percentage of parents could have access to a tribunal?
You asked whether Scotland could cope: the answer is yes, but someone must know how many cases there could be and how many cases there are. They must also be able to assess what the resource implications would be if all such situations were dealt with in a tribunal. One has only to look at other tribunal systems to understand what resources might be required. The resource implications of listing cases and so on are significant—their administration is quite difficult. I cannot possibly tell you whether that would be right or whether it would be possible. I think that Scotland could probably cope, but it would have to devote considerable resources to that.
What type of people do you expect will sit on tribunals and provide mediation and advocacy services?
Going back to the point that I made earlier, I think that the parents whom you have spoken to have expressed concern that fewer people will have a CSP. It is important that, where there is concern, parents should have support and information to enable them to make choices that are based on fact rather than on perception. Representation—whether it be advocacy or another form of representation—should be available to parents at a formal and an informal stage. The people involved need to have an understanding of the system as it will operate. Currently, no one has an understanding of the new system, so there will need to be training, especially because, as was said earlier, there are likely to be hiccups in the system. It will be important to parents in particular that the people who provide support or mediation do not work for the education authority.
I echo that point, although with some amplification. As the committee may know, there are already several pilot schemes, principally the Govan law centre education service and Children in Scotland's Enquire mediation service. On the question about volume and resources, the interesting thing is that, although mediation services have been relatively little used, parents and children have made quite a lot of inquiries about them. The anecdotal perception is that people in local authorities feel that mediation should be part of their responsibilities and duties. I do not for a second diminish what those people are doing—they are using mediation-type skills—but they cannot have the essential independence that leads to the credibility and trust that is required of a mediator. Our ideal would be for services to be separate from local authorities. I am aware that the bill indicates that if those services are to be provided by the local authority, they have to be outwith the decision-making process. I acknowledge that in community mediation—neighbour mediation—some local authorities use that model: council mediation services are provided for council tenants and, in some instances, ratepayers. The sort of people whom we would be looking for are independent, extremely skilled and trained as mediators. They would have an understanding of the geography of the subject matter. There is a pool of people out there. In the consultation, there was concern that not enough mediators would be available. I have lists of people who are available and trained and I am certain that the standards are sufficient to merit an excellent service.
The dilemma that others have pointed to and with which the committee is struggling is how we bring speed to the process but balance that with fairness. On the speed side, there have been many representations for quick intervention, so that resources are not consumed in the dispute resolution process but are left for front-line services. However, although the fairness of the system could be secured or enhanced in a number of ways, the ways that have been suggested seem to risk introducing significant delay into the system. Therefore, I ask you to comment on three things.First, if we addressed your concerns by going for independent mediators who were not linked to local authorities, might it not take longer to acquire those services in parts of Scotland? Secondly, if legal representation were provided as of right, would not the need to have lawyers available typically introduce delay into the mediation, arbitration or tribunal process? Thirdly, if we are concerned with the total education experience of children with learning support needs, might not some liabilities fall on organisations other than the education authority that contribute to the child's education experience? Would that not introduce delay into the mediation process because of the need to have a variety of actors at the table?Our desire to bring speed to the process to allow for early intervention means that we must strike a balance between ensuring that resources are not consumed in dispute resolution and ensuring that there is fairness. Are there any risks associated with requiring independent mediation at every stage, legal representation and involvement from all organisations that might have a responsibility or role in providing the child's education experience? I would be interested in the panel's comments on how we achieve that balance.
Achieving the balance so that there is speed in the selection of independent mediation is about service levels. There are models elsewhere showing how quickly independent services can be provided. The model that springs to mind is the disability conciliation service, a mediation service that is provided under the DDA. Clear time scales are set down for that, so I do not think that that is an issue.
We would be interested to see more information on those time limits.
The disability conciliation service is managed by Mediation UK and is UK-wide.I will skip the second issue, which was about legal representation—although, as I have a legal background, I have some thoughts about it.Convening the appropriate parties is a diary exercise. It is not necessary to have a formal timetable to get the right people in the right room. That comment may give rise to some scepticism but, if all parties are committed to a mediation process and think that it is a good thing to build consensus, a date can be set and people can come together. It is as simple as that.Mediation does not exclude other processes and can often run in parallel with them. As John Elliot mentioned, a breathing space is sometimes required so that dates do not push the process forward. However, if the tribunal is not to be held for three or four months, mediation can be tried while people are waiting.
I agree that striking a balance between speed and fairness is difficult. I reiterate the point that it is essential that support is given to parents, whatever that support or representation might be, from an early, informal stage onwards. That would be a way of reducing the number of cases that come later to mediation or tribunal.There is already advocacy provision across Scotland. I could provide further information on that. There are specific children's and carers' advocacy services that provide support to parents and children who are going through the systems that are currently in operation. In Wales, children's advocacy is particularly well developed and there is support in most local authority areas. Advocacy services are being developed under the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003. Because those services need to be age appropriate, they are being developed for children and people of every age group with a mental disorder, which includes learning disabilities. As the committee will be aware, there will be some overlap between children with additional support needs and children with mental disorders. That means that there will be opportunities for joint funding—for education authorities to put some funding into the development of advocacy that is also being funded under the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003—so that the support is in place for children and families if they wish to use it.
We have drawn attention to paragraph 8(2) of schedule 1 to the bill, which says:"The President must ensure that Tribunal functions are exercised by those Tribunals efficiently and effectively."We have said that that seems to place a lot of emphasis on cost, whereas the emphasis should be on fairness and justice. I have five suggestions for helping with the speed of tribunal decisions. I agree with Ewan Malcolm on time limits, which, when reasonable, are essential for any appeal process. The time limits of the various tribunals differ—one only has to see how fast immigration adjudicators and appeal tribunals must work to realise how far that can be stretched. I take the point about legal representation, but I, too, am a member of the Law Society of Scotland and you have heard me say that legal representation per se is not essential, but that advice is. If good-quality advice is given, that helps to speed up the process enormously and reduces the number of cases that go to a tribunal, which is a good thing. Good panel members must be available—the quality of panel members is important. Training of panel members is also important to ensure that whatever decision is taken is a good one and therefore less likely to go to appeal. There must also be good administration, which does not necessarily need to cost a lot, but is essential for listing cases, for example, which is often important for parents, because they want their case to come up quickly.
That is helpful. I think that we will be able to get information on the mediation procedure under the DDA from the horse's mouth: the next witnesses are sitting at the back of the public gallery, so perhaps we can ask them about it.
We have already touched on concerns about the independence of in-house mediation services. Do you have any concerns about whether, if we have such in-house services, we will achieve uniformity of mediation service throughout the country?
Whether the mediation service is in house or out of house, uniformity is essential. It would be important to avoid some sort of postcode quality mark. The Scottish Mediation Network is working on a minimum standard of practice for mediators in all fields, well beyond the additional support needs sphere, and we are building consensus on a process—I think that I have provided the committee with a copy of that work. Mediation is a young profession. Family mediation in Scotland is celebrating its 20th anniversary this year, so we do not have a great deal of background to draw on and we must acknowledge that we have to work on and develop what has been learned.
I have no view that I can express.
The bill is not prescriptive on mediation services. It suggests two possible models—a national service and an in-house service—for which the financial memorandum gives ranges of possible costs: from £800,000 to £1.8 million for the national service and from £1.2 million to £2.5 million for the in-house service. All of you have stressed the importance of training in producing good mediation. Are the estimates for setting up the mediation services—the figures are supposed to cover training—sufficient to train the number of mediators who might be required, given that there might be a fairly large number of disputes during the transition from records of needs to CSPs? Are the estimates sufficient to cover the costs of setting up the services?
I can honestly say that I do not have a clue.
I am glad that John Elliot is so honest, as I, too, do not know the answer to the question. The issue is relevant and needs to be further researched. Perhaps the disability conciliation service is a good analogy. It operates UK-wide with only around 30 to 35 mediators. The Govan law centre and Enquire already have bodies of mediators who have trained specifically in the area in question. Therefore, there would not be a standing start.
As a matter of interest, how important is knowledge of the subject for mediators? I think that you touched on that issue earlier. I am conscious that there are not many experts in education law and related issues. Do you foresee any difficulties in that respect?
The people with specific training whom I mentioned have usually undergone a five-day training course that involves specific training and—more important—experiential learning. Most mediators train by using scenarios and role playing. There are principles and ways of working as a mediator, but working people through the sort of disputes that might occur and having them play the sort of people who might be involved in such conflicts is useful. Such training is necessary.Awareness training for the people who will refer cases to mediation is also essential. As I suggested earlier, people at local authority level who handle such disputes using mediation skills and who are perhaps then a little reluctant to give up disputes to independents, as they might see things, would be useful. Their skills can be used appropriately and strategically.
Before I lose track, I want to return to training tribunal members, which was touched on earlier. What time scales would be involved in getting through the process before the whistle can be blown and things can kick off? Based on your experience of other tribunals, how long would it take for tribunal members to be sufficiently equipped and in place so that a tribunal can be set up?
Of course, that depends on the resources that are thrown at the training. Lawyers and other people who have certain skills will be involved in the process. To deal with the matter seriously, three months might be a reasonable time scale if sufficient resources are made available. Potential members of the children's hearings system have a rigorous training programme that extends over a number of months, but the training is part time—it takes place in the evenings and occasionally at weekends. The time scale also depends on where potential panel members are drawn from, but I reckon that people should be properly trained within three months.
Thank you. That is helpful.
My question is really for Mr Elliot, although I would like to hear any comments that Ewan Malcolm or Stephanie Taylor wants to make. Is it the case that legal aid is not available for representation at most tribunals?
Yes.
Are there any examples of families or others appearing before such tribunals with representation such as a solicitor paid for through legal aid?
Legal aid is available for immigration tribunals, for example, so there is some experience of what you are talking about. However, broadly speaking, legal aid is not available for tribunals.
We are concerned that the tribunal should be fair to both sides. It has been drawn to our attention that, south of the border, the local authorities' solicitors tend to appear before the tribunals. I believe that that is true in more than 50 per cent of cases. That seems to give the authorities an unfair advantage. Is there any way of tackling that? One suggestion, which has been made in discussions with members as opposed to in formal evidence, is that local authorities could be banned from having legal representation. Would that be possible?
That could be done, certainly. The national appeal panel for the entry to the pharmaceutical list, for example, bans representation for the people appearing before it. Slightly absurd situations arise, with people sitting at the panel, listening to someone beside them whispering to them and then mouthing the words that they have just been given. Perhaps you think that that would be an absurd way of proceeding, but I could not comment.
It is like ministers giving evidence.
We have made comments on all these issues publicly. You lay stress on legal representation. Good representation is not necessarily legal representation. I have seen absolutely first-class non-legal representatives appearing before employment tribunals. I have also seen legal representatives who are not good at all. Indeed, I have seen legal representation that is, in my view, not adequate to the circumstances. I am sure that local authority lawyers will generally be of a uniform good standard. However, I have seen tribunals, especially education appeal committees dealing with special educational needs—I am thinking of one case in particular—where the panel was leaning over backwards. Tribunals are not daft. They see a lawyer and sometimes, unconsciously and automatically, they go in the opposite direction. Surprisingly, perhaps, the view that people take of lawyers is not universally one of love. Sometimes tribunals are unfairly critical or hard on the lawyer. That can actually have an effect other than the one that you suggest.
I appreciate that. There is support for advocacy in general, although I would welcome any comments from Ms Taylor about whether the bill should specifically cover advocacy. I am trying to work out whether we could do something to build into the bill a mechanism to ensure equity and fairness so that, for example, when a local authority is represented by a lawyer, the families have equal rights or are assisted in some way in presenting their case. I cannot think of a mechanism that would do that.
To return to some of the points that I made earlier, I think that it is essential for people to obtain good-quality advice before they get to a hearing. We find that people who have had advice focus on what they have to do before a tribunal. Many people who come before a tribunal unrepresented want to tell their story, but they do not appreciate the fact that they must relate their story to the law. The panel therefore has to struggle and sometimes needs to draw the matter out. It can sometimes fall into the trap of doing the appellant's job for them. Good-quality advice and representation are essential and we think that there ought to be equality of arms in that respect.
You have given an example of how the sympathies of a tribunal may be engaged by the parent, rather than by the lawyer. Looking back on how tribunals have operated in general, and on any experience that you might have had of SEN tribunals south of the border—where one side has predominantly been represented by lawyers, to its advantage—would you say that there is any evidence, and have any studies been made, to show whether the outcomes of tribunals are unfairly influenced by such representation?
I am not aware of any such evidence and I suspect that there is none. Our evidence that representation gives the appellant more of a chance is based on a wide variety of tribunals. I do not think that we have any specific evidence on special educational needs. I do not imagine that those tribunals are any different from any other. I am confident that representation is more likely to achieve the result that the appellant wants.
My next question is on jurisdiction. You gave a good example concerning children's hearings where you have had limited or no control or jurisdiction over certain authorities that might be responsible for the outcome. Do you have other examples, perhaps involving SEN tribunals south of the border or anywhere else, where the fact that tribunals are trying to exercise decisions where they do not have any control or authority has or has not been a problem?
At a recent education appeal committee hearing that one of our members attended, the lack of resources in the form of social workers was mentioned and acknowledged. That is another example that I can give you, but I do not have any examples from south of the border.
Is it common for a tribunal to be concerned predominantly with one aspect of service delivery, when the case also involves other aspects of service delivery over which the tribunal has no direct control, with indirect duties being placed on the authority?
Yes. You must remember that tribunals have been set up over many years, during which time agencies have developed. When the system was set up, nobody contemplated quite how things would work together. There is a lack of joined-up justice, if I may use that phrase.
As Fiona Hyslop said, parents will have several different routes. They will be able to go to mediation, which is open to all, and then at different stages they will be able to go to a local authority dispute resolution process, the appeals tribunal, the sheriff court or possibly the DDA appeals tribunal. The worry is that each option will have a different outcome, which would create greater inequity. Is that a concern for you and can we do anything to address it in the bill?
It is a concern. Where people have more than one option, confusion inevitably arises. To some extent, it is like grains of sand running through the hand—people will find their way to the mechanism that is most available or to the one that they have heard anecdotally gives them the best result. That is an important issue and the only way of tackling it is to ensure that people are funnelled into the correct dispute resolution mechanism, which, presumably, you could help to influence.
Ewan Malcolm suggested that evidence that is given in mediation should be inadmissible in a tribunal, to respect confidentiality and to encourage people to use the mediation process. Does that happen in any other situation? Would it be a first? It seems to give special status to mediation and to protect it in a way that I am not sure is necessary.
The situation that I described mirrors what happens in Scotland in respect of family mediation. An act from the 1980s protects privileged information at mediation. I am simply suggesting that that confidentiality be transferred to this scenario. Ideally, it would be available in all mediation scenarios, so that people do not take the privileged mediation discussions outside, regardless of whether the outcome is acceptable and allows people to move forward. In particular, people should not put the mediator on the witness stand.
Mr Elliot, do you have a view on the idea that evidence at mediation should not be admissible and that a mediator should not be asked to give evidence before a tribunal?
Unless that was the case, the mediation would be significantly less effective, even to the point of being impossible.
Should advocacy be referred to in the bill? Evidence to the committee has strongly supported that, but there is no mention of it in the bill. Is that a worry to you?
Yes, advocacy should be mentioned in the bill. When the Scottish Executive consulted on the bill there was a lot of support for advocacy. For reasons that are set out in the policy memorandum, the Executive has indicated that advocacy is inconsistent with the principle of collaboration that the bill is trying to promote. We feel that that is not the case and that advocacy is an effective way of supporting parents and of overcoming difficulties that parents may face. Advocacy makes parents feel more comfortable that they understand the process and supports them through it, which means that they may be less likely to need the formal resolution procedures that you outlined.Your other point was that local authorities may have legal representation, while parents and children do not. Evidence that I have seen—not recently, but I would be happy to look it up—suggests that people who are legally represented in tribunals are more likely to achieve the outcome that they want. A parent who goes into such a situation without representation, legal or otherwise, may feel that the situation is inequitable. I was interested to hear that you are considering ways in which to overcome that imbalance.
I must say that I am not aware of any such ways, although we would welcome hearing about some.
It might be helpful if you sent the committee any evidence about the differential effects of having legal representation and having none.
Okay.
Do you mean evidence about representation as opposed to non-representation?
Yes. Evidence on that general issue would be useful because it is important that we get a proper feel for it.
I am interested in evidence on how many cases end up at a tribunal in systems that have stages before the tribunal. Is there evidence to say that in a system where there is staged intervention, mediation and dispute resolution followed by a tribunal, more cases are resolved without going to a tribunal?
I ask about a slightly more technical point. In your submission, you mention that the council has statutory supervision over the new tribunal according to the bill. What does that mean in practice?
It means that we observe hearings as of right, including the determination stage, and then report on that. We report in our annual report, which is sent to all MSPs, together with 10,000 other bits of paper, and they have the opportunity to read our views on the tribunals that we see and how they work. We try to say what we think in the report rather than gloss over it. Occasionally, as you mentioned before, we do a special report on any particular system when we believe that that would be advantageous.
Is that triggered by you or by a request from the Scottish Executive or whomever?
It is triggered by our good selves.
Thank you; that was useful and interesting and I am grateful for your contributions. We will come back to one or two matters, but if you have any thoughts after you have reviewed your evidence this morning, feel free to contact the clerk.We move on to the second panel of witnesses. I am slightly bemused because we were expecting two representatives, yet we have three. I welcome Adam Gaines, head of policy and communication at the Disability Rights Commission, and Dinah Aitken, senior information advice manager of Enquire. May I inquire who else we have on the panel?
I have just been told that I am on the next panel.
Do the witnesses want to introduce themselves and say something about the points on which they want us to concentrate?
Good morning and thank you for the opportunity to appear before you this morning. As the committee will be aware, the perspective of the Disability Rights Commission is informed by a rights-based approach. Our remit means that we are concerned with the position of disabled children and students and the enhancement of their rights. As a consequence, there might be some questions on areas to do with additional support needs, which have a wider definition that might go beyond our remit, and I am sure that the committee will understand if we are unable to comment on those.We feel that the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill is a significant development that has genuine potential to enhance the rights of disabled children and young people. We also welcome the many improvements that were made to the draft bill following consultation. I note that there has been some comment on the consultation process. I mention and declare an interest in that respect because we were invited by the Executive to assist in facilitation during the consultation process. The decision to move to a wider and less prescriptive designation of additional support needs is welcome. The current record-of-needs system is in need of reform and the system should be based on need and entitlement. Our concerns about the record-of-needs system arise from the lack of consistency in its application throughout the country and from the absence of a right to appeal against the provision in the record. We also feel that the term "special educational needs" has a stigma attached to it and that "additional support needs" might be a better term to use. The new term is also less based on the deficit model of the child.Beyond those welcome developments, there are a number of points in the bill that need to be clarified, enhanced or improved, particularly with regard to the tribunal system. We welcome the introduction of a tribunal system as something that we have long advocated. It will be helpful and an improvement on the current piecemeal and cumbersome system. We also hope that, in due course, the tribunal system could cover matters to do with the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 and education, as in England and Wales.
The tribunal would need to take into account the position of legal aid for parents and children in representation proceedings. It is also important that children who are aged 12 to 16 should be able to make an appeal to the tribunal.
I, too, thank the committee for the invitation to speak today. Enquire is a service that is funded by the Scottish Executive and it is managed by Children in Scotland. We have a remit to provide independent advice and information on special educational needs throughout Scotland. We do that in a number of ways. We produce written information, we provide training and outreach to parents and professional groups and we provide a telephone helpline.The services are open to parents and carers, to children and young people and to the professionals who work with them. Most of the calls that we get to the helpline are from parents, although a growing number of professionals are also using the service. That gives us an understanding of the issues that are currently causing parents concern and giving difficulties to professionals who are involved in delivering services to children and young people with special educational needs.We are aware that good practice is going on throughout the country, but the reason why we exist and have the knowledge that we do is that there is not a uniform experience for all families.We welcome the bill as an opportunity to improve the existing system and to iron out some of the iniquities that exist. However, it is most important that children and young people who need support in order to have the same educational opportunities as their peers have received that support. It is also important that all children are served by any new legislation, not just those whose parents are able to promote actively their child's rights or to make use of a service such as Enquire. The legislation should be clear so that people can understand easily their rights and obligations and it should provide appropriate forms of accountability and redress where necessary.Given that our client group of parents comes from throughout Scotland, we receive inquiries about all manner of difficulties with the current system, and so we have an interest in all aspects of the bill. In our written submission, we touched on a number of areas that we noted. Those were the need for clarity in the bill about duties within and across authorities; the criteria for opening the proposed co-ordinated support plan and the potential loss of rights of children who are moving from the current system of records of needs; the independence of mediation; the need for clarity about dispute resolution services; and a simplification of the rights of redress. There is concern that transition arrangements, particularly for those moving on from education at age 16 or over, be sufficiently strong and there is concern about the introduction of the reasonable-cost test. We raised issues of jurisdiction, the powers of the tribunal, the absence of availability of legal aid and the unmet need for advocacy, of which we are well aware.
That was a helpful introduction. You both said in various ways that you supported the main principles and approach of the bill. We have had evidence from a number of witnesses that, given that CSPs and additional support would, at one extreme, be stigmatising and would pick out children with special needs or additional support needs, there should be a single system that applies to all children, who are assessed by the same mechanism. Do you have a view on that? There is a resource and targeting issue there, but I have given you a summary of some of the views that we have heard.
It depends which way one approaches the bill. Section 3 sets out a requirement for education authorities to have regard to the additional support needs of children and, in certain cases, to provide CSPs, which provide access to a tribunal service. From our perspective, there is an issue regarding the potential for some disabled students with a single disability, which might not necessarily come under the CSP definition of "complex", to access auxiliary aids and services. Entitlement to auxiliary aids and services does not come under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995, because it is reserved to the special educational needs framework. There might be a question as to whether the auxiliary aids and services entitlement of a few disabled students with a single disability that is not necessarily viewed as complex can be taken forward properly. That is an area where we hope that the code of practice can be more explicit.
The CSP could be helpful for the people who have complex needs in bringing together all the professionals who are required to support the child. It would be unhelpful if people perceived that it was the only way to secure the necessary provision for their child. At the moment, some parents become interested in asking for a record of needs because they are desperate and they think that that is the only way that their child is going to receive the support that they need. Provided that the system is sufficiently strong and well-enough resourced, and provided that all children with additional support needs will be properly identified and will receive the support that they require, the CSP could be a very useful tool.
The DRC has stated concerns about the interface between the bill and the Disability Discrimination Act 1995, to do with the lack of entitlement to auxiliary aids and services. Can you explain your concern a little further?
There is no entitlement under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 to auxiliary aids and services in education. Those have always been seen as matters for the special educational needs framework. As a consequence, it is important that the bill makes it clear that, if there is a requirement for an auxiliary aid or service, the child or disabled student will be able to receive such an aid or service. That is why we have raised the point about the precise definition of "complex". The vast majority of disabled children will probably receive a co-ordinated support plan because they may well receive services from a number of agencies. However, we are concerned about the small number of people who may have a single disability but still require an auxiliary aid or service.
In your representations, you have made it clear that you would welcome exploring"the scope of the Bill to place further duties on health boards and local authority social work departments."
We feel that that would be helpful—particularly in reference to the jurisdiction of the tribunal, an issue that arose earlier. By bringing in a range of agencies and co-ordinating their work, co-ordinated support plans can be very helpful indeed. However, in the event of an appeal to a tribunal, we would hope that the tribunal would also be able to give directions regarding the other agencies.
In your submissions, both of you state concerns about the number of children who currently have records of needs but who may not be eligible for a CSP. You suggest changing the eligibility criteria. Can you say a little bit more about your views, given that there is a duty on education authorities to make provision for additional support needs whether or not there is a CSP?
I am sorry—I am not sure that I quite understood the thrust of your question. Would you repeat it please?
Yes. You have both stated concerns about the number of children who currently have a record of needs but who may not be eligible for a CSP. You suggest changing the eligibility criteria. Can you explain your views further, given that there is a duty on education authorities to make provision for additional support needs?
Our view stems from the experience of listening to parents' concerns. As I have said, parents often feel that they have to push for a record of needs in order to secure the services that they feel that their child needs. Education authorities sometimes struggle to provide support for children who do not have a diagnosis or who have not been through an assessment process and had their special educational needs identified. If the test for the CSP is set very high, there is a concern that parents will try to meet that test in some way because they will see it as a way of accessing services.
I think that you are arguing for a system in which the rights of parents should be strengthened.
Yes.
I want to ask about transition. Enquire's recommendations say:"there is no duty upon any agency receiving information about a young person due to leave school to take any action upon receiving the information."You also state:"there is nothing concrete for the school-leaver in the form of any documentation, nor is there any requirement for follow-up."Do you want much stronger duties to be imposed in that connection?
Yes, I think so. Any transition is difficult and we find that it is when parents anticipate a transition that they come to us with their concerns. Such a transition may be when a young person is entering school or moving between schools, but it may also be when they are moving on from school.While the child is in the education system, it is clearly the education department to whom all the parents' concerns are addressed, but once the child moves out of education, parents have to rely on a patchwork of services. It can be difficult to ensure that the appropriate services are in place and that people know whom to make requests of. The provisions for planning for young people who are leaving education could be strengthened.
The changes that have been made to the bill following consultation to ensure that there is a minimum of 12 months for the development of a future needs assessment are very helpful. However, the issue is that the responsibility will lie with the education authority and it will carry out that work. There needs to be consideration of how the information is used once it is gathered and how it is transmitted to the other agencies that the young person will go on to, whether that is in employment or in further education. We must ensure that that information is passed on and taken on board.
I want to follow up the central issue about whether you are satisfied that the duty that the bill places on education authorities to identify and address the additional support needs of all pupils is sufficient. It seems to me that if you thought that it was sufficient and were happy that the duty would ensure that all pupils who needed support would get it, you would not make the suggestions that you do in your submissions. Enquire states that CSPs should be extended to all children who receive any services that are not provided in the school and the Disability Rights Commission states that it is necessary to bridge the gap between IEPs, PLPs and CSPs so that there is no differentiation between those with and those without CSPs.The issue is fairly fundamental to the bill. The argument put forward by the Executive is that the duty on education authorities means that all support needs for all children will be met, regardless of whether they have a CSP. You do not seem to be satisfied with that because you are pushing for a wider definition of CSPs. We must get to the heart of the issue. Is it wishful thinking that the duty is sufficient? Do you think that we have to strengthen the provisions because the CSP is in effect the tool that young people will need to ensure that they receive co-ordinated services?
We have evidence from the parents who use our services that the existing system for identification and assessment is not working uniformly for all children. There is already a duty to provide adequate and efficient education—that includes making provision for special educational needs. Therefore, a similar system is currently in place and there are some difficulties with it. The difficulty is perhaps the regional variation that has been mentioned. Some local authorities are very good, but others do not have such good systems in place.It seems that the duty in the bill is quite strong and clear, but it is how that duty is implemented that will make a difference. We must wait to see the code of practice in order to know whether it is sufficiently strong to support the duty that is in the bill.
Section 3 places a general duty on all education authorities to assess and take into account the needs of children with additional support needs. If PLPs are being introduced, it might be possible to link them with such an assessment. The detail of how the matter is taken forward depends on how the code of practice is developed, so clearly the code is important.
In England, the tribunal to which appeals on the provision of aids and adaptations are made, which comes under Westminster legislation, deals with both special educational needs and disability. Would it be possible to widen the definitions in the bill slightly to allow what would otherwise go to the disability tribunal to be dealt with by the tribunal in Scotland, thus avoiding a division in this general area?
My understanding is that, under the bill, one would have to apply to the additional support needs tribunal and, in the case of education, under the DDA, the application would be either for conciliation or to the sheriff court. We have suggested that, in the long term, it might make sense, in the case of DDA applications, for there to be an application to a tribunal rather than to the sheriff court, and for that tribunal to be the same one as the tribunal for additional support needs, because that would simplify matters for children and parents.
Would it need Westminster legislation to do that?
Yes, because the application to the sheriff court is part of the DDA, which is a reserved matter.
You say that the code of practice will be central to ensuring that the duty is exercised properly throughout Scotland. Would it be appropriate for members to see the code of practice before they make a final decision about whether to approve or amend the bill?
That is not what I said. I said that the code of practice could be very helpful in the context of implementing the duty and setting it out so that it would overcome some of the current difficulties of differences between authorities.
I want to follow up something that Dinah Aitken said about the concern of parents who have a record of needs and who may not have a co-ordinated support plan. You talked about those parents losing rights. Will you specify which rights they will lose?
It may be more of a perceived than an actual loss of rights. Parents often feel that they have to press for a record of needs because they are not being listened to, and their child's needs are not being properly addressed. It is always difficult to take away a right from somebody. As things are presently framed, without the CSP they would not have access to the tribunal, which they might consider to mean that they have fewer rights.
Can they go to a tribunal to appeal against not being awarded a CSP?
Yes.
You say in your evidence that you think that a significant number of young people will be denied the co-ordination of services because they do not technically meet the criteria for a CSP. Can you tell us a bit more about that?
I do not have any numbers among the statistics that I have brought today, although I could let you have some. However, I think that I said in my submission that more than 30 per cent of the children with records of needs who have come to us have specific learning difficulties or autistic spectrum disorders. It is our guess that those are the ones who are most likely now not to meet the criteria for the CSP, because their needs can be met by an education authority.
But you say in your evidence that you are concerned that those children might be denied the co-ordination of services that they require. Is it not automatic that if they require co-ordination of services, they should get a CSP?
The way the bill is framed, they would get a CSP only if the services were coming from outwith an education authority. I understand that if a child has complex needs that are being met by several services from an education department, the bill will not give them a co-ordinated support plan.
To what services do you refer?
A child may have peripatetic teachers, and specialists such as behaviour management specialists might be involved. Some therapists work in education departments, too. A range of people might provide services under the formal umbrella of an education department.
We understand that when therapists work for an education department, their services are bought in, so therapists do not fall within the scope of an education department.
That may be right.
Do you know of any examples in which that was not the case?
I gave the examples that are within my understanding, but I have no more information.
It would be useful to have any further information that you have. You welcome the fact that children with emotional and behavioural difficulties will come within the scope of the legislation for the first time. You say that, in your work, a significant proportion of calls relate to pupils with emotional and behavioural difficulties. Can you put a figure on that proportion?
I do not have precise figures, but about one third of all callers mention that behaviour is an issue for their child.
Do you know what proportion of those cases involve outside agencies?
I cannot give the figure without looking into the matter, but I am happy to try to provide that.
That would be interesting, as we are trying to get a handle on how many more co-ordinated support plans will be needed for the groups that will become eligible for them and what pressures are likely to occur.
Rhona Brankin covered the points that I planned to make. I will ask Adam Gaines about the number of cases that will go to tribunals, which Rhona Brankin asked the previous panel about. He suggests that rather than having two dispute resolution procedures, all disputes should go to the new tribunals. I do not know whether he knows the expected number of cases. Will tribunals be able to cope? On the face of it, the idea sounds good, but what would it involve?
We do not know how many cases are likely to go to tribunals. We welcome the move to create a dispute resolution service in relation to additional support needs as distinct from CSPs. We await the details, which is why we suggest that it might make sense to have one system in approaching the tribunal, rather than two, but that will depend partly on how the dispute resolution service is developed.
Indeed. We probably need more numbers on that. I had a question for Dinah Aitken about rights, but I think that she has answered it by saying that the matter is more one of perception. Last week, we heard clear evidence that parents have two fears. One fear is that they will lose rights, but we do not think that rights will be lost. One person has used the right to appeal against part IV of a record of needs in relation to matters that would normally be in part V of a record of needs, but that was a way of getting round the system. The new system does not seem to take rights away from most parents. New rights are being given, but rights are not being lost.The other fear is that, in practice rather than in law, local authorities might use the CSP documentation as a rule of thumb for distributing resources. It could become a practical device. If there are limited resources and local authorities use the list of those who have been given a CSP as an easy mechanism for prioritising some children over others, that would not be fair. However, there is no legal right involved; it is just a practical, day-to-day thing. We are trying to evolve a more seamless way of operating, and rights should be applicable across the board rather than being entrenched in a CSP. Perhaps you would care to make other observations on that.
For those who have really been struggling to get a local authority to put services in place, the current record-of-needs system does provide a framework and a regular review mechanism. At the moment, it gives enhanced placing-request rights, but the bill addresses that issue by broadening out those rights. Those things can be important in giving recognition to a child's needs, which may previously have gone unrecognised or not been addressed properly. It might be quite difficult for people who have had a record of needs to move to a system where they do not have the same legally backed-up framework of review and recognition.
There is a particular problem for those who currently have a record of needs and might lose it. We are well aware of that, but we need to find out whether they have any legal rights. All parents will now have the right to ask for an assessment, but we are aware that there is genuine fear and anxiety. We are also aware of how useful the record of needs has been for some parents, but the perception of how useful it has been and the reality is—
Can we be clear about what your question is?
I am trying to pin down what parents fear the bill will do. There is genuine fear that parents will lose out as we move from the old system to the new. The fear is genuine, but will they be losing out? We have yet to pin down what they are losing.
Are you asking whether rights are being lost?
I am asking whether Dinah Aitken can point to anything else that parents will be losing. Enquire's written submission says that parents will be losing rights, but I think that Dinah agrees that that is not actually the case, as there are no legal rights. She has said that there is a loss of legal rights, but now she is saying that there are no legal rights. If there is a legal right that parents are losing, we have yet to see it.
The record of needs brought certain rights of review and appeal against certain provisions of the record of needs. If you do not qualify for the CSP, you will have to rely on the general provisions of the bill, such as the provision of adequate and efficient education to all children with additional support needs, which brings us back to the code of practice. If the code of practice is sufficiently strong, and uniformly applied across the country, some of the difficulties that parents are facing at the moment will be met, because an adequate system will be in place. The system must also meet the needs of those children who do not have parents advocating for them. As Mr Macintosh has pointed out, parents can ask for assessments, but what happens to the child who does not have a parent who is able to ask for an assessment? The system must meet their needs as well.
There is something that I would like to clarify. You said that the record of needs gives parents the right to appeal against an assessment of service, but they will also have that right under the new system, will they not?
If they qualify for the CSP.
My understanding is that all parents will be able to ask for an assessment, but I am not quite sure what they will get. I believe that, under the record-of-needs system, you are able to appeal the record of needs but you are not able to appeal in relation to the provision of services in the record of needs. Provision of services in the record of needs is in the non-appealable part of the record. Last week, we heard about somebody who managed to get the provision of services under a different section, but for most parents who use the record of needs day-to-day, the provision of services part of it is not appealable. That is my understanding, but I am not an expert. That is why I am asking for your view.
That is my understanding as well. However, if you ask for a record of needs, certain assessments will automatically be carried out. If a record of needs is opened, the child's situation and their level of needs will be regularly reviewed and assessed. If the child does not qualify for a CSP, that framework will not be open to the parents, who will then have to rely on the general duty under the bill to meet additional support needs.
And the right to ask for an assessment.
Yes.
Did you have a supplementary question on that point, Elaine?
No. I wanted to discuss a point that arose in last week's evidence, but it has now been covered.
My question is relevant to what has already been asked, but it moves the discussion on slightly. The submissions of both the Disability Rights Commission and Enquire refer to the bill's use of the words "a reasonable cost". Enquire has a concern that parents are worried about that. In some of the evidence that we have received, parents have expressed their concerns about the inclusion of that phrase in the bill being a potential get-out clause for local authorities. I am aware that the DRC is concerned about the broadening out of the definition of additional support needs, and that there might be a diminution of service in some cases—as we have just touched on. Some young people might not get their needs met because the resources will not be sufficient. What are your views on that?
There is a general entitlement to provision under section 3. Obviously, that is very welcome. However, our point is that that entitlement is subject to whether it is "practicable at a reasonable cost."We are concerned that that gives the impression of being based more on cost than it is on reasonableness. The Disability Discrimination Act 1995 works on the principle of reasonableness, so we raised the question whether that would offer a better way forward. Under the 1995 act, reasonableness can and does take issues of cost into account. The need for best value is critical, as is the need to protect public funds. Under the 1995 act, the principle of reasonableness takes into account the needs and circumstances of the situation as well as cost. That is why we posed the question whether the concept of reasonableness might offer a slightly better approach than that of "reasonable cost".
Our experience is that parents are well aware of the facts that resources are finite and that local authorities work within budgetary constraints. They often express concern for other children when they are pushing for services for their own children. The Education (Scotland) Act 1980 does not refer to reasonable cost, although it contains a duty to make "adequate and efficient provision". Parents will be concerned that a cost test is being applied early on in the process of assessing their children.
I wish to move on to assessment and identification. I know that the matter has already been raised, but I am particularly interested in the phone calls that Enquire referred to, from parents of children with social, emotional or behavioural difficulties. Did any of their concerns involve the identification of the difficulties that those young people had or the reasons why they were displaying them?
Yes. Looking again at the content of the calls, I was struck by the fact that there were several cases of children being subjected to the disciplinary procedures that have—quite rightly—been set up by schools when that was perhaps not appropriate. After what can sometimes be quite a lengthy period, an assessment is often eventually carried out after which it is discovered that the child has an underlying condition at the root of their behavioural difficulties. That is quite a difficult area for schools. Some of the conditions that parents say have finally emerged in a diagnosis are quite rare. It is a problem for schools to get to the root of that while trying to manage general discipline. Often the consequence for children is exclusion, so the issue is important.
Will the bill fulfil parents' expectation that if they request a full assessment, it will be carried out? One of you said that many parents might not realise that they can request an assessment or that one is needed. Will the bill allow needs to be identified quickly and accurately or do we need to make changes in order for that to happen?
The bill addresses those issues in that parents can request assessments and there is a duty on local authorities to identify and assess children. We have to be sure that the underlying structures are strong enough to ensure that not so many children slip through the net.
The right of parents to seek an assessment where appropriate is one of the important changes that has been made to the bill. That moves away from the current situation, in which for a child to get a record of needs, there have to be medical and psychological tests, which are not necessarily appropriate for all children. Children with mobility difficulties might not need a psychological test in relation to their provision. It is important that a parent can request an assessment if they feel that one is necessary. It is a helpful step forward.
You have identified a particular problem with children with disciplinary problems and another underlying difficulty. Is there a need for an additional trigger for an assessment, before exclusion, in association with exclusion or at an earlier point? Have you any thoughts on how that might be focused more satisfactorily? Will the code of practice be the proper place to deal with it?
The code of practice is one place where it could be dealt with. My understanding is that some schools could be breaching the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 if they apply disciplinary procedures to children who have an underlying condition. Greater awareness of how the different legislation intersects—there is quite a lot of legislation now—is an important factor as well.
That has to be taken on board in the guidance and pamphlets as well.
Given that we will be dealing with the eventual act as well as the DDA, information and training on the provisions will have to be available for teachers.
Given that there will not be automatic medical assessments, is there a danger that youngsters who display behavioural problems with an underlying cause will be missed out? Will that have to be clear in the code of practice? Is there an issue there?
There could be an issue there. We are getting information from parents that their children are missing out and are not being picked up by the system, so that danger needs to be highlighted. I am not sure whether that could be done in the bill, but it should certainly be in the code of practice. There is already guidance that says that exclusion should be a last resort for schools. That could be examined to see whether schools should be alerted to the fact that when they are thinking about exclusion, they ought to consider whether there are underlying reasons for the child's behaviour.
I know that you have welcomed the extension of the transition period from six months to 12 months, but we are still receiving evidence to suggest that arrangements should be in place by the time the child is 14. Do you feel that 12 months is long enough?
I do not have evidence that would suggest that a precise time scale is appropriate. We felt that a minimum of one year would enable information to be gathered and then taken into account for onward transmission to other agencies. Our priority is not so much to have a time scale of 12 months—although that is welcome—but to ensure that information is used well. The transition period can be absolutely critical to a young person's life chances—they may be moving to an education college or into employment. Their needs during that period must be properly considered.
I notice that you have suggested amendments to section 19(1) and section 19(4). I am sure that we will consider those.
Dinah Aitken's submission states:"There is no provision for the Tribunals to consider the failure of the education authority to actually deliver the provision specified in the CSP, ie there is no right of appeal where the education authority does not carry out its duties".Should there be a right of appeal to the tribunal?
The more that the tribunal can deal with under this legislation the better. There is a gap in the tribunal's powers. From our reading of the bill, it appears that you can have a beautifully written CSP—which says everything that you want it so say—so that there is no reason to appeal to the tribunal, but if the services specified in the CSP are not provided to your child, you cannot go back to the tribunal. It would be very welcome if the tribunal's powers were extended to allow it to oversee that what is in a CSP is what the child receives.
There is a difference between, on the one hand, the position of the tribunal and the CSP, and, on the other, the current situation in which one cannot appeal against the provision in part V of the record of needs. My understanding is that, under the CSP, the provision that is written down can be subject to appeal.
I would like a couple of points to be clarified. I think that reference was made to the Disability Rights Commission's mediation arrangements. Will you give us some information on how those arrangements might work?
I can give you some information today and then follow that up with more detailed information. The Disability Rights Commission's approach is based on advice and conciliation, and then legal enforcement. We feel that, if it is possible and appropriate to overcome difficulties through advice, information and conciliation, so much the better—before matters end up in court or before a tribunal. We have conciliation powers, in the sense that we have set up an independent conciliation service—which is independent of us although contracted by us—that deals with conciliation cases. The service is run for us by Mediation UK. The service has just started for part IV of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995, which covers education, because that has come into effect only in the past year.I am afraid that I cannot give you figures for how many cases have been referred to conciliation in the past year with regard to education, because the provisions have only just come on stream. According to the provisions, if someone wished to raise a case before the sheriff court to do with alleged discrimination, they would have to do so within six months. That time scale can be extended to eight months if the person has asked for conciliation, to enable conciliation to take place.
It might be helpful if you could give us more information about that, just to give us a different perspective on how that all works. My final question is about legal aid or representational support, which was touched on earlier. Does the Disability Rights Commission have specific views based on experience of the equality-of-arms issues that we heard about from the previous witnesses?
We believe that there will be circumstances in which it is likely that an education authority might take a solicitor to a tribunal, so there is an issue to do with parity. Whether that is solved through legal aid or by another mechanism is obviously important. We think that it would be helpful if legal aid were a possibility, particularly for employment tribunals. We understand that, where a person has English as their second language, there are certain circumstances in which they may be entitled to legal aid. For special needs, there may also be certain situations in which people are entitled to legal aid. We wonder whether it might also be possible to apply that in the case of the tribunals that we are discussing today.
We have just learned something useful—that the time limits compel the complainant to raise the action with six months, while there is no obligation on the employer or the authorities to consider how long it takes to process the case. Therefore, the analogy is not particularly helpful, because in it, the complainant would be the parent, and there is no point in placing a time limit on them, because the educational experience of the child will change throughout his or her educational career. At different points, the parent might want to raise an issue, and they would still be left with the issue that we have identified of potentially inexorable delays being built into the consideration of issues.I am just leaving that comment on the table, but I think that the committee would be very interested indeed in details of any tribunal where the time limit was not about compelling the complainant but about compelling the authorities to deal with the issues within a fixed period of time. If members of this panel or previous panels of witnesses can help us in that regard by providing us with written evidence, that would be helpful.
There is one provision in relation to placing requests under which, if a decision is not made within a certain period of time, it is deemed to be a refusal of a placing request. That then opens up the appeal process to the parent. That is one mechanism that already exists.
Thank you for that useful evidence, for which we are grateful. If there are points on which you would like to come back to us once you have reviewed what you have said and heard today, please feel free to do that. If there are specific amendments that you feel we should consider in due course, we will also be grateful for any guidance that you can give us on that.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
We now welcome Kate McGuiness, who is a learning and support co-ordinator in Kilwinning. You have that side of the desk entirely to yourself on this occasion, Kate, and we are very glad to have you here. Perhaps you could introduce yourself and share your perceptions of the bill.
Thank you for the invitation to come along, which has been greeted with consternation in North Ayrshire, because it is rare that ordinary practitioners get a chance to talk about practicalities. I am a depute head teacher at Kilwinning Academy, which is a fairly standard comprehensive with a roll of around 1,000 pupils.For the past seven years, my remit has included an oversight of support for learning, and I am quite well versed in the practicalities of managing the current special needs arrangements. Indeed, all that I can talk about are the practical implications that my colleagues and I see in the proposed legislation. On a positive note, I have not spoken to anyone who does not feel that the philosophy behind the bill is extremely sound. Having said that, there is a great deal of apprehension and fear as to its practical implications. In particular, concern has been expressed about the resource implications. I heard mention made this morning of the number of CSPs that there will be, and whether that will be less or more than the current number of records of needs. I do not think that we at the chalkface have the answer, but the apprehension is that we will not have the resources to do adequately what the legislation sets out. We have particular concerns about the management implications of the right of all additional support needs children to future needs assessment—FNA—procedures. That is admirable, but we know that the system is creaking at the moment, if not bursting at the seams. Those rights are only available to record of needs children at the moment. We are conscious that, unless additional resources are available when those rights expand, some very good practising teachers might become administrators and will no longer work with children. That will not do anything to support their education needs. There is also concern about persons being named as responsible. We know how often staff change, and there will be some fear about that until clarification is made. A further source of fear comes with the link-up between individualised educational programmes, personal learning plans and the co-ordinated support plan. It would be terrific to have all of those joined up, but we do not know how that would work. We hear the term PLPs blithely being used, but no one has yet given us a definitive PLP. There have been some pilots, but everyone is inventing the wheel themselves. If we are to have a joined-up system—and the bill seems to provide an opportunity to make it more joined up—some clarifications and guidelines would be extremely helpful.We all agree that how the bill will work very much depends on the code of practice. The tighter and clearer that code of practice, the more likely it is that we will be able to offer the improved service that we hope to provide.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Dec 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Education Committee Wednesday 10 December 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 306
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.