To ask the First Minister when negotiations between the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the independent care homes will be finalised. (S1F-1623)
Official Report · Chamber
Care Homes
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 4
- Mary Scanlon Con 2
- Margaret Jamieson Lab 1
- Shona Robison SNP 1
The record
8 contributionsFinding a long-term solution to the problem of funding care home places is very important and we hope that COSLA and the Scottish care homes reach an agreement soon. Although the duty of care lies with local authorities, ministers are committed to contributing to a lasting settlement that provides long-term stability for those elderly people who need it most.
Given the Executive's recent announcement of £20 million to address bedblocking and the fact that the dispute has been running since last October—despite the agreement reached then between the Scottish Executive, COSLA and Scottish Care—will the First Minister tell me, first, why COSLA is not honouring that agreement and, secondly, whether he thinks that it is acceptable for councils to allocate £400 per person for those staying in their own homes but only £245 for people in independent homes?
This is a serious topic and negotiations are under way. I do not want to undermine those negotiations or to conflict with them. As we have laid money on the table, we share a responsibility with local authorities in the matter and it is important that we reach a proper negotiated settlement. We intend to do that in the best interests of patients. It would be nice if we could have done that last week, the week before or even this week. However, even if it takes time, it is best to do it right in the interests of patients, rather than to take a leap in the dark.
I do not think that those negotiations are helped by those who constantly put forward the case of the private care home owners, rather than that of the patients. I think that the patients should come first, that there should be a proper negotiated settlement and that that should be acted on as quickly as possible. If we can achieve that, we will.
I do not think that those negotiations are helped by those who constantly put forward the case of the private care home owners, rather than that of the patients. I think that the patients should come first, that there should be a proper negotiated settlement and that that should be acted on as quickly as possible. If we can achieve that, we will.
Will the First Minister confirm that any agreement reached will be based on partnership? Will he confirm that both the Scottish Executive and local authorities will make a contribution based on partnership and does he agree that partnership is the only way forward to deliver services for our older people?
I indeed think that that is the way forward. However, I would not want to cut across the negotiations, other than to say that whatever conclusion we come to should be based on an understanding and recognition of our shared responsibility to provide the elderly people who need care home places with the quality of care that they deserve. That is our objective. The local authorities have that duty and we accept our part of that shared responsibility; I am sure that local authorities accept theirs too. I hope that a financial solution is reached as quickly as possible.
Does the First Minister agree that actions speak louder than words and that we need some real action by the Executive to resolve the care home dispute before the fast-approaching 11 February deadline? Will he accept that such action would be a far more effective way of promoting the interests of Scotland's older people than launching yet another glossy report such as the one issued today on health and the older citizen, which, although very worthy, tells us nothing new and is not what the older people of this country actually require from the Executive?
Shona Robison raised a number of interesting issues in that question. First, it is important that the chief medical officer presents a proper report on the future health care needs of Scotland's elderly population that can be considered in the Parliament and elsewhere. Everyone in the Parliament should welcome the availability of such evidence and analysis for our policy making because looking at such evidence before establishing our positions is exactly what we should be doing. Shona Robison may not consider that important, but I am afraid that we do. I hope that others will share that view.
Secondly, I agree that action is more important than words. If we had just taken the decision that I was urged to take by the leader of Shona Robison's party two weeks ago and had handed over as much money as we could as quickly as possible to the care home organisations, we might have had a resolution to the current dispute, but that would not have been in the interests either of Scottish taxpayers or of the elderly people concerned, who deserve to receive the highest quality of care in the care homes.
Action is important and negotiations are important. We will find a solution to this matter, but we will do it properly. We will not respond to deadlines set by other organisations. If this time last year—perhaps 13 months ago—I had established the deal that we reached with Scotland's teacher organisations and local authorities on the basis of a deadline that had been set six months previously by my predecessor, we would not have had a new system for disciplining teachers for poor performance in our schools; we would have handed over a pay rise without winning that concession. It was important to take an extra week then and, if we need to take extra days on this occasion, we will do so to get the right solution for Scotland.
Secondly, I agree that action is more important than words. If we had just taken the decision that I was urged to take by the leader of Shona Robison's party two weeks ago and had handed over as much money as we could as quickly as possible to the care home organisations, we might have had a resolution to the current dispute, but that would not have been in the interests either of Scottish taxpayers or of the elderly people concerned, who deserve to receive the highest quality of care in the care homes.
Action is important and negotiations are important. We will find a solution to this matter, but we will do it properly. We will not respond to deadlines set by other organisations. If this time last year—perhaps 13 months ago—I had established the deal that we reached with Scotland's teacher organisations and local authorities on the basis of a deadline that had been set six months previously by my predecessor, we would not have had a new system for disciplining teachers for poor performance in our schools; we would have handed over a pay rise without winning that concession. It was important to take an extra week then and, if we need to take extra days on this occasion, we will do so to get the right solution for Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 31 Jan 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 31 January 2002 Debate · 1
- Point of Order Procedure · 3
- Scottish Public Sector Ombudsman Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 32
- Scottish Public Sector Ombudsman Bill (Financial Resolution) Bill debate · 3
- Presiding Officer's Ruling Procedure · 1
- Standing Orders (Changes) Debate · 19
- Business Motion Business motions · 47
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Higher Education (Funding) Questions · 6
- Alcohol Misuse Questions · 8
- Teachers' Pay Questions · 11
- National Health Service (Staff Safety) Questions · 11
- Scottish Transport Group Pension Schemes Questions · 10
- Scottish Audit of Gastric and Oesophageal Cancer Questions · 7
- Consignia (Meetings) Questions · 9
- sportscotland (Meetings) Questions · 10
- Rare Birds (Poisoning) Questions · 6
- Nutritional Deficiency Questions · 6
- Accident and Emergency Departments (Specialist Nurses) Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Reshuffle) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Care Homes First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Young Offenders First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Landfill Sites First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2002 Debate · 130
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 23
- Young Runaways Debate · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.