To ask the First Minister what the current position is regarding the closure of individual learning accounts. (S1F-1525)
Official Report · Chamber
Individual Learning Accounts
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 4
- Alex Neil SNP 2
- Annabel Goldie Con 1
- Brian Fitzpatrick Lab 1
The record
8 contributionsThe individual learning account scheme was closed on 20 December. The Executive will introduce a new scheme, which will take the best from the old programme while addressing the concerns that have been raised. In the meantime, people who are already learning will continue to do so and those who enrolled before the scheme's closure will be able to proceed if their learning starts before the end of this month.
All 245,000 account holders have been informed directly of the decision to close the scheme, as have members of the Scottish Parliament and learning providers. Learning providers will be paid for valid claims when the ILA member was enrolled by 20 December and the learning will have commenced by 31 January.
All 245,000 account holders have been informed directly of the decision to close the scheme, as have members of the Scottish Parliament and learning providers. Learning providers will be paid for valid claims when the ILA member was enrolled by 20 December and the learning will have commenced by 31 January.
I thank the First Minister for that reply. First, can he clarify the reasons for closing the ILAs? Was it done primarily because of fraud, because the money ran out or for some other reason that we do not know about? Secondly, can he tell us when the new system will be put in place, what criteria will be used and whether there will be carryover to a new ILA for those who have an existing ILA?
The second and third questions will be answered in due course. However, the important thing just now is to ensure that not only those who have an ILA but those who have started learning by using their ILA can continue with that learning. I have said that we will do that. The system was closed down because of the potential for fraud. It was important that that closure happened.
Would it not be appropriate to ensure that, to facilitate the continued operation of ILAs, rigorous investigation is made of the allegations of fraud? Is the First Minister not apprehensive that, as the ILAs were constructed by primary legislation in this Parliament, there is a danger—I think—of legal challenge to the Executive for failing to provide ILAs to applicants?
Many people who have an ILA have not yet begun, or signed up for, a course of learning. It is important that those who have committed themselves to a course of learning can continue with that. We have given that guarantee. It is also important that we investigate any allegations or suspicions about the system. We will do that before we complete payments to any of the learning providers who are claiming payments at the moment. We want to check that those payments are properly due before they are fulfilled.
Will the First Minister give an assurance that the Executive remains committed to keeping learners at the centre of learning? Will he look constructively, with the Minister for Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning, at what measures can be taken—particularly to support collective learning through bodies such as the trade union learning fund and to support workplace learning—to place learners at the centre of the Executive's lifelong learning strategy?
Yes, we will. One of the things that we have done proudly over the past two years is to ensure that those kinds of opportunities begin to exist and develop. In Scotland today we have a large number of adults who require to improve their skills and their availability and competitive position in the local marketplace.
It is important that, when people have perhaps had bad experiences of schools, colleges or learning environments in the past, we offer a variety of different routes into developing new skills. I think that we can do that. I can see in my own home constituency of Motherwell and Wishaw the impact that such learning is having not just through the local college, but through other learning providers. I hope that we can ensure that that happens elsewhere in Scotland.
It is important that, when people have perhaps had bad experiences of schools, colleges or learning environments in the past, we offer a variety of different routes into developing new skills. I think that we can do that. I can see in my own home constituency of Motherwell and Wishaw the impact that such learning is having not just through the local college, but through other learning providers. I hope that we can ensure that that happens elsewhere in Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Jan 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 10 January 2002 Debate · 2
- Hepatitis C Debate · 59
- Education (Looked-after Children) Statement · 26
- Business Motion Business motions · 13
- Courts (Mediation) Questions · 4
- Traffic (Midlothian) Questions · 8
- “Better Behaviour—Better Learning” Questions · 6
- Families (Support) Questions · 4
- Social Inclusion Partnerships (Misapplication of Funds) Questions · 9
- “For Scotland's children” Questions · 6
- Scottish Executive Priorities Questions · 4
- Home Energy Conservation Act 1995 (Local Authorities) Questions · 8
- Small Businesses Questions · 12
- Her Majesty's Government (Partnership) Questions · 4
- Loch Lomond and Trossachs National Park Questions · 6
- Fishing Industry (2002 Quotas) Questions · 10
- Sustainable Development Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Individual Learning Accounts First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Tourist Attractions (Euro) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Economy (West Lothian) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scotland's Economy Debate · 127
- Foot-and-mouth Disease (Public Inquiry) Debate · 11
- Decision Time Decision time · 31
- Strategic Planning (Fife) Members’ business · 31
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.