To ask the Scottish Executive what measures are being taken to improve the prosecution service. (S1O-4358)
Official Report · Chamber
Prosecution Service
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- The Solicitor General for Scotland Mrs Elish Angiolini 4
- Dennis Canavan Ind 2
- Paul Martin Lab 1
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 1
The record
8 contributions
The Solicitor General for Scotland
Mrs Elish Angiolini
link
The Lord Advocate and I recognise the pressure under which the Procurator Fiscal Service is working. We are committed to securing public recognition of the excellent work that is already being done and to improving the service that is being delivered.
We have a number of major initiatives under way, including an ambitious information technology strategy, the roll-out of a victim liaison service and a review that will make recommendations on the working practices and systems that are used in serious cases. The reviews of the High Court by Lord Bonomy and of summary procedure by Sheriff Principal McInnes will also provide major opportunities to secure improvement. We have instructed an internal review of the allocation of resources and of the infrastructure for the department to improve the management and support of all staff in the service.
We have a number of major initiatives under way, including an ambitious information technology strategy, the roll-out of a victim liaison service and a review that will make recommendations on the working practices and systems that are used in serious cases. The reviews of the High Court by Lord Bonomy and of summary procedure by Sheriff Principal McInnes will also provide major opportunities to secure improvement. We have instructed an internal review of the allocation of resources and of the infrastructure for the department to improve the management and support of all staff in the service.
I congratulate the Solicitor General on her appointment and on making her first contribution to the Parliament. [Applause.]
Will the Solicitor General tell us what the Crown Office is doing to deal with the problem of institutional racism in the prosecution service, as revealed by Dr Raj Jandoo's inquiry into the Chhokar murder case? Why did the Crown withdraw the charge that the murder of Firsat Dag was racially motivated?
Will the Solicitor General tell us what the Crown Office is doing to deal with the problem of institutional racism in the prosecution service, as revealed by Dr Raj Jandoo's inquiry into the Chhokar murder case? Why did the Crown withdraw the charge that the murder of Firsat Dag was racially motivated?
The Solicitor General for Scotland
Mrs Elish Angiolini
link
I will deal with the second point first. Regarding the Dag trial, the Crown prosecuted a murder that had a racial aggravation. As in many prosecutions, what is manifest at the beginning in terms of the evidence that is available to the prosecution cannot manifest itself in the evidence that is produced before the jury. In that case, the prosecutor rightly took the step of not putting the aggravation before the jury. The presiding judge recognised that that was an entirely appropriate measure to take. That does not detract from the horrifying nature of the murder or its impact on the local community. I hope that the conviction will be seen as some redress for the horrific events surrounding the case.
On Mr Canavan's first point about institutional racism, my predecessor took great strides to ensure that the complacency in relation to institutional racism that can be present in many organisations will not persist in the prosecution service in Scotland. I intend to take that work forward with some energy, to ensure that momentum is not lost. We have a draft action plan, which will be considered by the Lawrence steering group, which I will chair. I will take that major issue forward with expedience.
On Mr Canavan's first point about institutional racism, my predecessor took great strides to ensure that the complacency in relation to institutional racism that can be present in many organisations will not persist in the prosecution service in Scotland. I intend to take that work forward with some energy, to ensure that momentum is not lost. We have a draft action plan, which will be considered by the Lawrence steering group, which I will chair. I will take that major issue forward with expedience.
Will the Solicitor General, with the agreement of Firsat Dag's family, agree to meet the family and me to set out a full account of why those particular charges were not prosecuted further? Does the Solicitor General agree that the life sentence that was served on Scott Burrell should send a clear message that we will not accept such incidents in our society and that they will be met with a life sentence?
The Solicitor General for Scotland
Mrs Elish Angiolini
link
I would be happy to meet the family and the member to discuss the circumstances and to provide more information if that would be helpful.
I accept that the sentence in this case sends out the clear message to those who may indulge in racially aggravated behaviour that such behaviour will be treated with the utmost seriousness by the prosecution service and that such cases will face robust prosecution in the future. I am sure that the Lord Advocate would wish me to convey that assurance to the Parliament.
I accept that the sentence in this case sends out the clear message to those who may indulge in racially aggravated behaviour that such behaviour will be treated with the utmost seriousness by the prosecution service and that such cases will face robust prosecution in the future. I am sure that the Lord Advocate would wish me to convey that assurance to the Parliament.
I, too, congratulate the Solicitor General on her new role, in which I wish her every success. Will she ensure that no cases in Scotland will be abandoned as a result of insufficiency of resources in the Procurator Fiscal Service? Will she make certain that the Procurator Fiscal Service will be properly and adequately funded?
The Solicitor General for Scotland
Mrs Elish Angiolini
link
The Lord Advocate and I recognise the resource issue that has been identified and the pressure that the prosecution service is under. We are in touch with ministerial colleagues on that issue. However, I do not consider that prosecutions have been abandoned on the basis of resources. I assure members that that will not be the case. Every effort will be made to ensure that there is improvement in the use of the resources and their appropriate allocation within the country.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Dec 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 20 December 2001 Debate · 1
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 6
- Scottish Local Government (Elections) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 10
- Scottish Local Government (Elections) Bill Bill debate · 60
- School Education (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 15
- School Education (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 13
- NEC Semiconductors Statement · 20
- Caledonian MacBrayne Debate · 8
- Justice (Sexual Abuse Cases) Questions · 6
- Education (Public-private Partnerships) Questions · 10
- National Health Service (Equipment) Questions · 8
- Dental Practitioners Questions · 8
- Employment (Ex-offenders) Questions · 6
- Languages Questions · 8
- Housing Stock Transfer (Repair and Improvement Grants) Questions · 4
- Prosecution Service Questions · 8
- HM Treasury (Meetings) Questions · 17
- Housing Stock Transfer (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 6
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Rural Economy First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Homelessness (Families) First Minister’s Questions · 28
- Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body Debate · 4
- Motion without Notice Business motions · 20
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 5
- Motion without Notice Business motions · 22
- Decision Time Decision time · 24
- New Lanark Members’ business · 17
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.